Employment law

Onyango v Mutua & 2 others [2026] KEELRC 14891 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Machakos
Case number
Elrc Cause E026 of 2024
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

Open case research →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT MACHAKOS

ELRC CAUSE NO. E026 OF 2024

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

CELINE ANYANGO ONYANGO……….....………………....CLAIMANT

VS

CHRISTOPHER MUTINDA MUTUA...………………1ST RESPONDENT

LAWRENCE BUNYALI INDAKI..……………………2ND RESPONDENT

JOSEPH KIMANTHI MULI..…………………………3RD RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1 The Claimant filed a Statement of Claim dated 18th July 2019 against the Respondent, and prays for judgment in its favor against the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents jointly and severally for: -

a. An order that the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents be ordered to immediately deposit the sum of Kenya Shillings Ninety-Seven Thousand, One Hundred and Forty (Kshs. 697,140/-), embezzled from the Kenya County Government Workers Union, into the designated Bank Account of Kenya County Government Workers union Bank Account being, ABSA BANK PLC, Kenya Queensway Bank, Account Number: - 0941816029, in accordance with Section 47, 48 and 50 of the Labour Relations Act and Article 13(b) of the Kenyan Constitution.

b. The 1st Respondent be directed to comply with Article 4(2) (v) of the Kenya County Government Workers Union (KCGWU) constitution by resuming regular contributions of union dues.

c. That this Honorable court issues an order directing the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents be suspended from their positions at the Kenya County Government Workers Union- Machakos Branch as per Section 47 of the Labour Relations Act for contravening the union's rules regarding the handling of union funds and property.

d. That the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents be ordered to compensate the Kenya County Government Workers Union damages incurred as a result of their actions, including losses suffered by the union.

e. Costs of this suit.

f. Interest thereof on a, d, and e above.

g. Such further or other relief as the court may deem just and equitable in the circumstances.

Claimant’s Case

2 The Claimant described herself as the Member in charge of Finance at the Kenya County Government Workers Union (KCGWU). She avers that at the time the cause of action arose, the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents were the Union's Branch Secretary, Branch Chairman and Branch Treasurer of the Machakos County Branch respectively.

3 The Claimant avers that on 11th April 2022, after receiving written complaints against the 1st Respondent's conduct as an official of the Machakos County Branch, the Union issued him with a show cause letter citing allegations of embezzlement of union dues.

4 She avers that the Respondents stopped contributing union dues, contrary to Article 4(2)(v) of the KCGWU Constitution, which raises questions about the 1st Respondent's membership status.

5 It is the Claimant’s submission that the Respondents misappropriated union funds amounting to Kshs. 697,140. Under Gazette Notice No. 10968, union dues were to be deposited into the Union's gazetted account, Account No. 0941816029 at Absa Bank PLC, Kenya Queensway branch. Instead, the Respondents channelled the funds into a private account of the Machakos County Branch, Account No. 01136549348300 at Co-operative Bank, to which all three Respondents were signatories, thereby embezzling the sum.

6 The Claimant further avers that following his retirement, the 1st Respondent was issued with a certificate of service, which made him ineligible to continue holding office in the Union under Article 4(2)(i)(b) of the KCGWU Constitution.

7 She states that the 2nd Respondent failed to convene a branch congress as required by Article 5(4)(b) of the KCGWU Constitution, frustrating members' right to participate in the governance of the Union.

8 The Claimant avers that the Respondents called for and withheld union dues and encouraged members to withdraw from the Union.

9 She further avers that the 1st Respondent abused the General Secretary, the National Secretariat, the National Executive Committee and the general membership on social media, incited workers against the General Secretary and other members, prepared and disseminated anti-trade union agendas on social media, and involved himself in the politics of Machakos County to the detriment of the workers.

10 The Claimant states that on 7th March 2022, the General Secretary, exercising his powers under Article 6(2)(3) of the KCGWU Constitution, requested the Respondents to convene a branch conference within 21 days, but they ignored the directive.

11 She avers that on 23rd April 2022, the 1st Respondent was summoned to appear at the Machakos Social Hall to defend himself against the allegations, but he failed or refused to attend. She contends that the Respondents' failure to attend the Branch Congress to defend themselves was presumed to be an admission of guilt.

12 She further states that on 24th April 2023, the Union wrote a follow-up letter to the 1st Respondent reiterating its demand that the Respondents immediately deposit the Kshs. 697,140, but they again failed to comply. Despite demand and notice of intention to sue, the Respondents have refused to compensate the Union.

13 In her Reply to the Respondents' Statement of Response dated 30th October 2025, the Claimant avers that she is a bona fide member of the Kenya County Government Workers Union (now the County Government Workers Union, Kenya) in charge of Finance at its Machakos Branch.

14 She states that her payslip on record shows a monthly deduction of Kshs. 500 in union dues.

15 The Claimant avers that under Article 11.1 of the Union's Constitution, any person above 18 years of age employed in any capacity by any County Government in Kenya is eligible for ordinary membership, and that she is employed by the Machakos County Government as a nursery school teacher.

16 It is the Claimant’s case that as a bona fide member, she is empowered under the Labour Relations Act to bring this suit as a complaint against the misuse of the Union's money or property, and that the Respondents' claim that she lacks locus standi is therefore misconceived.

17 The Claimant further avers that the alleged nullification by the Registrar of Trade Unions of the elections held on 23rd April 2022 has nothing to do with her claims against the Respondents.

18 She denies that the matter is res judicata by reason of Machakos MCCC/E136/2022. She states that she was not a party to that suit, which was a defamation claim filed in the Magistrates' Court, and that the 2nd and 3rd Respondents were not parties to it either.

19 The Claimant states that she is a stranger to the allegation that the Union has failed to remit monthly dues to the Machakos Branch since August 2021.

20 She denies that the Kshs. 697,140 was used for its intended purposes, contending that the Respondents have adduced no evidence of the alleged accounts audited by the Registrar of Trade Unions showing that no money was lost from the Union's account.

21 She further avers that the show cause letter dated 11th April 2022, the demand letter dated 24th April 2022 and the letter on suspension of the branch account dated 9t July 2024 were all duly served on the Respondents.

Respondents’ Case

22 In opposition to the claim, the Respondents filed a Statement of Response dated 30th October 2025.

23 The Respondents aver that the Claimant lacks locus standi to bring this suit, as she is not a member of the Kenya County Government Workers Union. They deny that she has ever been a member of the KCGWU Machakos Branch or the member in charge of Finance at the Union's headquarters in Nairobi.

24 The Respondents aver that she is merely a nursery school teacher working for gain within Machakos County.

25 It is the Respondents' case that on 3rd July 2023, the Registrar of Trade Unions nullified the elections conducted at the special branch congress held on 23rd April 2022.

26 They further aver that the suit is res judicata. They contend that the allegations of diversion of money remitted to the Machakos Branch between June and August 2021 were effectively determined in Machakos Civil Suit No. E136 of 2022.

27 The Respondents state that by a letter dated 16th June 2023, they made a demand to the Union's National Executive Committee over its failure to remit the branch's monthly union dues from August 2021 to date.

28 The Respondents deny that any loss of Kshs. 697,140 occurred at the Machakos Branch; and aver that the funds were lawfully used for their intended purposes, and that the Union's books of account are audited by the Office of the Registrar of Trade Unions at the Ministry of Labour, which has never faulted them or cited them for misappropriation of funds. They further deny receiving the letters dated 11th April 2024, 24th April 2024 and 9th July 2024.

29 The Respondents maintain that the Claimant is not entitled to the reliefs sought, as the matters raised in her pleadings have already been determined. They therefore pray that the claim be dismissed with costs.

Evidence in Court

30 The matter proceeded to hearing on 26th June 2026. The Respondents and their counsel were absent despite service. Counsel for the Claimant informed the Court that the Respondents were served on 24th April 2026 and that an affidavit of service was filed on 18th June 2026. The hearing therefore proceeded ex parte.

31 The Claimant, Celine Onyango, testified as CW1. She stated that she works for the County Government of Machakos as a teacher. She adopted her witness statement dated 18th July 2024 as her evidence in chief, and produced the documents filed on 18th July 2024 as Claimant’s Exhibits 1 to 7, and her supplementary list and bundle of documents dated 20th April 2026 as Claimant’s Exhibit 8.

32 The Respondents did not attend the hearing and called no evidence. Their Statement of Response therefore remains unsupported by any testimony.

Claimant’s Submissions

33 The Claimant submitted on three issues: whether the Claimant herein lacks the locus standi to institute the instant suit against the Respondents herein; whether the instant suit is res judicata; and whether, if the answer to (i) and (ii) above are in the negative, the Claimant herein is entitled to the reliefs sought in her statement of claim dated 18th July, 2024.

34 On locus standi, the Claimant relied on Muutu & 3 others (Suing as the Legal Administrators of the Estate of Simeon Muutu Mutisya) v Amboga & 2 others [2026] KEELC 1034 (KLR), where the Court cited Alfred Njau & Others v City Council of Nairobi (1982) KAR 229 for the holding:" Therefore, locus standi means the right to appear before and be heard in a court of law. Without it, even when a party has a meritorious case, he cannot be heard because of that. Locus standi is so important that in its absence, party has no basis to claim anything before the Court.”

35 She further relied on Khelef Khalifa El-Busaidy v Commissioner of Lands & 2 others [2002] eKLR, where it was held that for an individual to have locus standi, "he must have an interest either vested or contingent in the subject matter before the court, which interest must be a legal one." She relied on Section 47(2) of the Labour Relations Act, which provides that a complaint over the misuse of a trade union's property or money "shall be brought by (a) the Registrar; or (b) a member of a trade union, employers' organisation or federation at the time of bringing the complaint of the trade union or employers' organisation concerned."

36 It is the Claimant’s submission that she has demonstrated her membership through her payslip, produced as Exhibit 7, which shows that she is employed by the Machakos County Government as a nursery school teacher. She also relied on the excerpt of the Union's Constitution in her supplementary bundle, whose Article 11 makes any person employed in any capacity by any county government eligible for membership.

37 She submitted that even if she were not the member in charge of finance at the Machakos Branch, which she maintains she was, Section 47(2)(b) entitles any member to bring such a complaint, so her office in the Union is immaterial.

38 Reliance was placed on Richard Bosire & 4 others (suing as the officials and members of Universities Academic Staff Union, University of Nairobi Chapter) v Universities Academic Staff Union [2017] eKLR, where the Court rejected similar argument mounted against the capacity or /ocus standi of trade union members. Further, in Iloti & 14 others (Acting on their Behalf and on Behalf of the Dock Workers Union of Kenya) v Sang & another; Dock Workers Union of Kenya (Interested Party) [2026] KEELRC 554 (KLR), where this Court held that "the claimants have proper standing in this case. Their interest stems from their union membership," and that Section 47(2) allows a member to move the Court over the misuse of union funds. She urged that she has sufficient interest to sustain her standing, and that the Respondents' challenge is baseless and unsupported by evidence.

39 On res judicata, the Claimant relied on Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, which provides that “no court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such court."

40 She cited John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another v Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure & 3 others [2015] eKLR and Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v. Muiri Coffee Estate Limited & another [2016] eKLR on the rationale of the doctrine of res judicata. She also cited Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that the elements of res judicata must all be satisfied, as they are rendered not in disjunctive, but conjunctive terms. Finally, she cited John Florence Maritime Services Ltd & another v Cabinet Secretary Transport & Infrastructure & 3 others [2021] KESC 39 (KLR), where the Supreme Court required a final judgment on the merits by a court of competent jurisdiction, with identical parties, subject matter and cause of action.

41 Applying this test, the Claimant argued that the plea fails on every limb. She submitted that Machakos MCCC/E136/2022 determined whether the defendants there had defamed the 1st Respondent, whereas this suit concerns the misappropriation of Kshs. 697,140.

42 On the parties, the Claimant submitted that the earlier suit was between the 1st Respondent and Petronilla Mwende Willy and four others, whereas she was not a party to it and only the 1st Respondent features in both suits.

43 On title, she argued that the 1st Respondent sued in that matter as branch secretary, while here she sues as a union member against all three Respondents in their capacities as branch officials.

44 On finality, she submitted that the earlier judgment was final only on the question of defamation and not on misappropriation of funds, non-contribution of dues, ineligibility to hold office or political involvement.

45 On competence, the Claimant submitted that the Magistrates' Court and this Court do not have concurrent jurisdiction.

46 On the reliefs, the Claimant submitted that since the Respondents did not attend the hearing, cross-examine her or call any evidence, her claim and evidence remain unchallenged, and their pleadings are mere unsubstantiated allegations.

47 To support her case, the Claimant cited North End Trading Company Limited (Carrying on the Business under the registered name of Kenya Refuse Handlers Limited v City Council of Nairobi [2019] eKLR:“In Edward Muriga Through Stanley Muriga v. Nathaniel D. Schulter Civil Appeal No.23 of 1997, it was held that where a defendant does not adduce evidence the plaintiff’s evidence is to be believed, as allegations by the defence is not evidence.

19.In the case of Motex Knitwear Limited v. Gopitex Knitwear Mills Limited Nairobi (Milimani) HCCC No.834 of 2002, Lesiit, J. citing the case of Autar Singh Bahra and Another v. Raju Govindji, HCCC No.548 of 1998 appreciated that: “Although the Defendant has denied liability in an amended Defence and counterclaim, no witness was called to give evidence on his behalf. That means that not only does the evidence rendered by the 1st plaintiff’s case stand unchallenged but also that the claims made by the Defendant in his Defence and Counter-claim are unsubstantiated. In the circumstances, the Counter-claim must fail."

20.In the case of Karuru Munyororo v Joseph Ndumia Murage & Another Nyeri HCCC No. 95 of 1988, Makhandia, J held that:“The plaintiff proved on a balance of probability that she was entitled to the orders sought in the plaint and in the absence of the defendants and or their counsel to cross-examine her on the evidence, the plaintiff’s evidence remained unchallenged and uncontroverted. It was thus credible and it is the kind of evidence that a court of law should be able to act upon."

48 The Claimant argued that she has discharged that burden. She submitted that the Union's bank statement for the period from 1st January 2021 to 30th October 2021 shows that union dues were deposited into the Co-operative Bank account operated by the Respondents as joint signatories, rather than the gazetted Barclays account.

49 It is the Claimant’s submission that this is proof that the Respondents misappropriated the funds by channeling them to an account of which they were the only signatories, and to which neither the General Secretary nor the National Treasurer was a signatory. She pointed out that under the Union's Constitution, the National Treasurer is the principal signatory and the only officer mandated to open and maintain the Union's accounts, so the branch account was unlawful and amounted to a misapplication of union funds.

50 She placed reliance on Richard Bosire & 4 others (suing as the officials and members of Universities Academic Staff Union, University of Nairobi Chapter) v Universities Academic Staff Union [2017] KEELRC 323 (KLR), where the Court held:" Section 28 of the LRA requires the union dues to be remitted to the respondent and not its branches. There is a gazetted account and cannot be changed through proceedings such as these…..."

51 She further submitted that she proved her other allegations against the Respondents, particularly the 1st Respondent, by producing show cause letters issued to him, to which he never responded.

52 The Claimant submitted that Section 47(1) of the Labour Relations Act gives this Court jurisdiction to grant the reliefs sought, as it provides that the Court may "(a) order any person who has in his possession or control any property of a trade union… in violation of its rules or who has unlawfully expended or withheld its moneys, to deliver that property or pay that money to its trustees; and (b) suspend any official who contravenes paragraph (a)."

53 It is the Claimant’s submission that costs follow the event and having proved her case, she deserves the exercise of the Court's discretion on costs in her favour.

54 I have examined all the evidence and submissions of the claimant above. The matter proceeded ex-parte after the respondent failed to attend court on the date for hearing. From the evidence, herein, the claimant was able to establish that she is a bonafide member of the County Government Workers Union. She produced her pay slip from June 2024 which shows she is a member of the County Government and serves as a nursery school teacher within the county. She therefore has locus to file this claim accordingly.

55 She avers that the respondents embezzled funds meant for the union (KCGWU) which she demands a refund to the tune of kshs 697,140/-. She also wants the respondents suspended from being officials of the branch union by reason of the said embezzlement.

56 She relied on gazette notice no 10698 which shows the official account of KCGWU which was no. 0941816029 at Barclays Bank Queensway House Branch and KCB Moi Avenue branch account no 1108987486.

57 It is also evident that the respondent held another account at Cooperative Bank Machakos branch where money was deposited and cheques issued to bring out the money in the names of the 3rd respondent. The money was wired in the Co-operative Bank Account from the KCGWU account and the purpose for which the 3rd respondent received the money is not clear. It is therefore evident that the respondents as officials of the branch authorized remittances to another account held by the Machakos branch at co-operative bank and also issued cheques in the names of the 3rd respondent. The issue of impropriety seems evident and which requires further investigation by the investigations authority.

58 I will not delve into the evidence for or against the respondent which I direct be investigated by the DCI Machakos County. I will not go into that province which I find may be criminal in nature and I leave it to the investigations agency.

59 As for the other orders sought, I leave to the action of KCGWU National office for further action. There shall be no order of costs.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 30th Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder