Employment law

Kyengo v Grainden Millers Limited [2026] KEELRC 14681 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E568 of 2021
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

For determination is the Memorandum of Claim dated 9th July, 2021, in which the Claimant alleges constructive and unlawful termination of employment, discrimination on grounds of pregnancy, and non-payment of employment entitlements, and seeks various remedies against the Respondent.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The principal issues for determination are:-

Paragraph 56 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E568 OF 2021

JENIFFER MULEE KYENGO…………………………….….……………CLAIMANT

VERSUS

GRAINDEN MILLERS LIMITED………….………………………….…RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. For determination is the Memorandum of Claim dated 9th July, 2021, in which the Claimant alleges constructive and unlawful termination of employment, discrimination on grounds of pregnancy, and non-payment of employment entitlements, and seeks various remedies against the Respondent.

2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 4th August, 2021, and subsequently filed a Memorandum of Response and a Counterclaim dated 17th November 2021. The Claimant thereafter filed a Reply to the Memorandum of Response and Counterclaim dated 7th April 2022.

3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 6th March 2025, when the Claimant (CWI) Jennifer Mulee Kyengo testified in support of her case. She adopted her witness statement dated 9th July, 2021 as her evidence in chief and produced her list and bundle of documents of even date as Exhibits No. 1 -31.

4. The Respondent's case was subsequently heard on 8th December 2025, when one Lucy Muthoni Mwangi (RW1), the Respondent’s Director, testified in support of the Respondent’s case. She adopted her witness statement dated 11th April 2022 as her evidence-in-chief and produced her list and bundle of documents of even date as Exhibits Nos. 1-11.

5. The Claimant filed submissions dated 10th March 2026, while the Respondent, with the leave of the Court, filed submissions dated 29th September 2026.

The Claimant’s case

6. The Claimant’s case is that she was employed by the Respondent on 15th January, 2019 and that she rose to the position of General Manager. She states that she resigned on 16th June 2021, but that the Respondent’s conduct induced her resignation and that it was against her will.

7. The Claimant contends that she was subjected to seven show cause letters during pregnancy and maternity leave, that she was asked to leave the company WhatsApp groups, and was further required to hand over her duties while medically unwell. It is her case that her salary was reduced from Kshs. 206,424 to Kshs. 156,000.

8. The Claimant further states that there were no negotiations on signing a new contract, and further denies that there was any criminal investigation against her or Christine. She maintained that the letter dated 22nd November, 2020 reviewing her salary was genuine, and avers that the director held a meeting to review her salary and that she received the increment letter from HR.

9. It is her position that she was never investigated over the letter.

10. She further stated that there was no policy governing WhatsApp groups as a means of communication and none on discrimination. She states that the Respondent told her to leave the WhatsApp group because information was leaking, and that directors removed people from the groups, leaving her alone.

11. The Claimant further states that she had no information that she had employed relatives or unqualified persons.

12. CWI stated that upon leaving employment, she could not follow up on invoices owed to the Respondent because only employees could. Further, she indicated that the Respondent replied to her resignation, but she could not remember whether the response mentioned uncollected dues.

13. It is her case that she could not hand over because she underwent an emergency Cesarean section and that she later handed the laptop and keys to the Respondent’s lawyer.

14. On cross-examination, CW1 stated that she had documents showing commission was owed under clause 2(c) of her contract, and that the company had a system showing how many bags she sold. She averred that Christine Munyoki did not clear, and that she was a General Manager. She further stated that the directors paid terminal dues to Christine and that she had no power to make the payment when Christine resigned in January 2021. It is her assertion that she was instructed to dismiss Christine, pay her January 2021 salary, and write the letter.

15. CW1 confirmed that she received seven show-cause letters while on maternity leave and maintained that they were issued without basis. She produced a medical report showing that she underwent an operation.

16. It is her testimony that when she left the Respondent, her salary was approximately Kshs. 206,424 from November 2020, and that a Director of the Respondent named Lucy issued the letter increasing her salary.

17. On cross-examination, she told the court that she could not recall the date of issuance, but confirmed signing to acknowledge receipt, although she said the letter did not provide for acknowledgment. She also stated that she used to work on Sundays.

18. She avers that issuing the show cause letters while she was on maternity leave amounted to discrimination on grounds of pregnancy.

19. CW1 stated that she did not know the letter referred to in the proceedings as dated “31st November 2020” and had first seen it when filed in court. She avers that she was not aware that she received a Kshs. 150,000 bonus and/or any bonus.

20. Regarding the show cause letter dated 22nd March 2021, she stated that she had not signed a contract and was not away from the office except on compassionate or sick leave.

21. CW1 further testified that she proceeded on maternity leave on 22nd March 2021, and that Christine left in January 2021. She stated that employing Faith Ndinya was not within her mandate. She maintained that she should be paid notice pay and that she was not paid salary for February, March and April 2021. She acknowledged that her advocate received a cheque, but said she did not collect the money.

The Claimant’s Submissions

22. It is the Claimant’s submission that her pay slips for November 2020, December 2020, and January 2021 show a basic salary of Kshs. 206,424, said to have increased from Kshs. 150,000 in October 2020. She submits that the Respondent’s assertion that the increase was forged is unsupported by a police report or criminal proceedings.

23. It is her submission that Sections 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act and the decision in Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] KECA 394 (KLR) support her claim of constructive dismissal. She further cites Mwaniki v Tihan Limited [2025] KEELRC 1208 (KLR) to buttress this assertion.

24. The Claimant submits that the repeated show cause letters during pregnancy and while on maternity leave, her removal from the Respondent’s WhatsApp groups, demands for handover while medically unwell, and the alleged salary reduction cumulatively left her with no reasonable option but to resign.

25. On pregnancy discrimination, counsel invokes Articles 27(5) and 41(1) and (2) of the Constitution and Section 5 of the Employment Act.

26. The Claimant finally argues that the Respondent’s counterclaim is incompetent on the basis that no verifying affidavit or valid authority to swear the counterclaim was filed, and that the alleged loss was not substantiated.

27. The Claimant prays that the Court allow her claim.

The Respondent’s case

28. The Respondent’s case is that the Claimant resigned voluntarily on 16th June 2021, and that her monthly salary at resignation remained Kshs. 156,000. The Respondent disputes the alleged salary increment, maintaining that the letter dated 22nd November, 2020 was a forgery and that the Kshs. 206,424 claimed by the Claimant reflected a Kshs. 150,000 appreciation bonus paid in installments, not an increase in her basic salary.

29. The Respondent further contends that the Claimant failed to hand over her duties before proceeding on maternity leave, that she retained company property and failed to recover payments for goods supplied to customers, thereby occasioning losses to the Respondent.

30. The Respondent further denies discriminating against the Claimant on account of pregnancy, explaining that her removal from the company’s WhatsApp groups was intended to allow her to concentrate on her maternity leave.

31. On cross-examination, the Respondent’s witness (RW1) confirmed that the Respondent was a limited liability company and that she understood the meaning of a special resolution. RW1 testified that she had not filed a resolution authorizing her to swear an affidavit and could not remember signing the verifying affidavit accompanying the counterclaim.

32. RW1 further told the court that she recalls that the Claimant joined the company in 2019 at a monthly salary of Kshs. 156,000 and confirmed that she resigned on 16th June 2021. She disputed the Claimant’s assertion that her salary had increased to Kshs. 206,425, maintaining that it remained Kshs. 156,000.

33. She further stated that the Claimant did not receive a salary increment and that she could not remember the letter dated 22nd November 2020.

34. RW1 admitted that the Respondent did not reported the alleged forgery to the police and that no criminal complaint had been made concerning the letter. She also confirmed that an employee named Anthony Mbaka had left the company around 2019, and stated that the Respondent would not call him as a witness.

35. RW1 further confirmed that the Respondent issued the Claimant with seven notices to show cause between 19th February and 16th June 2021. She acknowledged that no disciplinary hearing was conducted in respect of the notices, and that no warnings or reprimands were issued to the Claimant. She further confirmed that she knew the Claimant was pregnant, that she was the Claimant’s supervisor and that she had instructed someone to prepare the show cause letters.

36. Further, although RW1 stated that the Claimant was not available for disciplinary hearings, she admitted that no written invitation to a disciplinary hearing was sent to her.

37. Regarding the company’s WhatsApp groups, RW1 explained that the Respondent communicated with its employees through those groups and that communication concerning the Claimant’s removal was made through the management WhatsApp group.

38. She stated that the Respondent requested the return of company property and a handover of duties, and that the Claimant was asked through the managers’ group to explain why she had not handed over. RW1 maintained that the communication was not posted in the general WhatsApp group and confirmed that the Claimant responded to all messages.

39. RW1 further testified that the Claimant lacked proper qualifications, but acknowledged that the company employed her. She reiterated that she did not report the alleged forged document to the police.

40. RW1 described the Claimant’s last position as involving sales and oversight of company operations and confirmed that she was a manager. RW1 maintained that the Respondent did not intend to terminate the Claimant’s employment and that she resigned voluntarily.

41. On the alleged unpaid customer invoices, RW1 stated that the Respondent demanded payment for monies owed by customers, but acknowledged that the company still had the debtors’ contacts and could contact them. She also admitted that the Respondent did not file delivery records showing that goods were delivered to the companies in question and that no human resource audit was conducted.

42. RW1 denied that the Respondent caused the Claimant to resign and referred to cheque numbers 3469, 3510 and 3373 in relation to payments made.

43. On re-examination, RW1 stated that the cheques were paid to the Claimant before she resigned and that the show cause letters related to different mistakes allegedly committed by the Claimant. She reiterated that the Respondent did not terminate the Claimant’s employment, and that the Claimant resigned before resuming work after maternity leave.

44. RW1 also maintained that the Claimant did not return company property. She stated that the Claimant was allowed to proceed on maternity leave, but she left about one month earlier than expected, communicating by message that she was proceeding on leave.

45. RW1 denied that the Respondent issued the letter increasing the Claimant’s salary, arguing that the date fell on a Sunday when the company did not work. She maintained that the Kshs.150,000 was an appreciation bonus paid in installments of Kshs. 50,000 and did not constitute a salary increment. She further maintained that the Claimant supplied goods to customers without recovering the corresponding payments, resulting in losses to the Respondent.

The Respondent’s Submissions

46. On whether the Claimant was constructively dismissed, the Respondent sought to rely on the Coca-Cola East & Central Africa Limited case to argue that, to prove constructive dismissal, a party must show that there was a repudiatory breach of an essential term of the employment contract, an objective assessment of the employer’s conduct, a causal link between that conduct and the employee’s resignation, and the employee’s burden to prove constructive dismissal.

47. It is the Respondent's submission that an employer is entitled to issue notices to show cause and that the Claimant’s alleged failure to provide a job description and hand over her duties justified the notices. It submits further that no disciplinary action was ultimately taken against the Claimant and that the issuance of the notices did not amount to constructive dismissal.

48. The Respondent disputes the reduction in the Claimant’s basic salary, maintaining that the Kshs. 206,424 figure reflected a Kshs.150,000 bonus paid in installments rather than an increase in basic salary. It further submits that no salary arrears were outstanding when the Claimant resigned, and that her advocates subsequently accepted and banked the cheques issued to her.

49. On the allegation of pregnancy discrimination, the Respondent submits that there was no evidence linking its conduct to discrimination on account of pregnancy. It maintains that it complied with Section 29 of the Employment Act by allowing the Claimant 90 days’ maternity leave and permitting her to proceed on leave earlier than she had initially requested.

50. The Respondent further submits that the Claimant’s removal from the WhatsApp groups was intended to give her time to care for her child during maternity leave. It further submits that the Claimant retained company tools and failed to hand over her duties before proceeding on leave.

51. The Respondent opposed the Claimant’s prayers for accrued annual leave, salary for February to June 2021, notice pay, unpaid commission, damages for pregnancy discrimination and compensation for constructive dismissal.

52. It submits that the Claimant had admitted receiving the relevant salary payments by cheque, that she took her leave and that she resigned voluntarily without giving the notice required under Section 35 of the Employment Act.

53. It further argued that the Claimant did not adduce evidence establishing the alleged unpaid commission or discrimination.

54. In respect of its counterclaim, the Respondent sought notice pay, the value or refund of tools of trade allegedly not returned, and payment for goods allegedly supplied to customers without recovery of the corresponding sums.

55. It consequently urged the Court to dismiss the Claimant’s claim with costs and allow the counterclaim with costs.

Analysis and determination

56. The principal issues for determination are:-

i. Whether the Claimant was constructively dismissed;

ii. Whether she was discriminated against on account of pregnancy;

iii. Whether she is entitled to the reliefs sought; and

iv. Whether the Respondent has proved its counterclaim.

Whether the Claimant was constructively dismissed

57. Constructive dismissal is not defined under Kenyan law, and its application is tied to the law of contract under the doctrine of discharge by breach.

58. In Osman Eggae Egaal versus John Philip Tilley & Others, Petition No.90 of 2012, and David Potter versus New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, Supreme Court of Canada, 2015 SCC 10, it was held that: -

“The test for constructive dismissal has two branches. The court must first identify an express or implied contract term that has been breached and then determine whether that breach was sufficiently serious to constitute constructive dismissal. … first, the employer’s unilateral change must be found to constitute a breach of the employment contract and, second, if it constitutes such a breach, it must be found to substantively alter an essential term of the contract.…”

59. The Claimant’s case is that she resigned on 16th June 2021 from the service of the Respondent, but argues that her resignation was not voluntary. To determine whether or not an employee was constructively dismissed, the question for the court is whether the employer/Respondent’s conduct amounted to a fundamental breach of the employment contract that entitled the Claimant to treat the contract as terminated.

60. In Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] KECA 394 (KLR), also cited by the parties, the Court of Appeal held that constructive dismissal arises when the employer’s conduct amounts to a fundamental breach of the contract, the breach shows that the employer no longer intends to be bound by the essential terms of the contract, and the employee resigns in response to the breach, and not for other reasons.

61. The Respondent herein confirmed issuing the Claimant with seven show cause letters between 19th February and 16th June 2021. It further confirmed that the Claimant was pregnant at the time, and that no disciplinary hearing was conducted or written invitation to a hearing issued following the seven show cause notices.

62. Although an employer is entitled to raise genuine concerns about an employee’s performance or conduct, that right must by all means be exercised fairly and in good faith. The repeated issuance of disciplinary notices, including during maternity leave, without proceeding to a disciplinary hearing, is in my view material, when considered alongside the Claimant’s removal from the company’s WhatsApp groups and the demands for a handover when she was unwell.

63. Further, the Respondent’s explanation that the removal from the groups was intended to allow the Claimant to concentrate on her child must be assessed against the fact that the groups were also used for official workplace communication within the Respondent’s company.

64. In my considered view, the Respondent’s conduct aforestated supports the Claimant’s assertion that she was constructively dismissed. The Claimant’s resignation letter and the contemporaneous communications adduced before the Court further demonstrate that she resigned in response to this treatment.

65. I therefore have no difficulty finding, and which I hereby do, that the Claimant’s resignation amounts to constructive dismissal.

Whether the Claimant was discriminated against on account of pregnancy

66. Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act prohibits direct or indirect discrimination against an employee on grounds of pregnancy. Further, Article 27(4) of the Constitution similarly prohibits discrimination on grounds including pregnancy, while Article 41 protects employees against unfair labour practices. Section 5(7) of the Employment Act places the burden on the employer to prove that the alleged discrimination did not occur, and that the impugned conduct was not based on a prohibited ground.

67. In Gichuru v Package Insurance Brokers Ltd [2021] KESC 12 (KLR), the Supreme Court addressed the concept of discrimination, including differential treatment on a prohibited ground without objective and reasonable justification.

68. The Court is therefore called upon to examine both the treatment complained of and the explanation offered by the employer.

69. The evidence adduced establishes that the Respondent knew that the Claimant was pregnant and that she received seven show cause letters during the period spanning her pregnancy and maternity leave.

70. It was also confirmed that no disciplinary hearing followed, nor did the Respondent issue any written invitations to a disciplinary hearing pursuant to the notices. The Respondent also acknowledged removing the Claimant from its WhatsApp groups, but contends that it did so to allow her to concentrate on maternity leave.

71. The Respondent, like any other employer, was entitled to require a proper handover and to address genuine performance concerns. However, it was under a duty to demonstrate that its actions were legitimate, proportionate, and unrelated to the Claimant’s pregnancy. In my view, its explanation about the removal from the WhatsApp groups did not adequately explain the repeated disciplinary notices or the lack of a concluded disciplinary process.

72. The reasoning in Janine Buss v Gems Cambridge International School Limited [2016] KEELRC 1550 (KLR) is instructive in that maternity leave is a statutory right, and an employee must not be disadvantaged for exercising that right. Similarly, in Ogayo v China Wu Yi Company Limited [2023] KEELRC 1498 (KLR), the court addressed the protection against pregnancy-related discrimination provided for under Section 5 of the Employment Act.

73. In the circumstances of this case, the timing and the frequency of the show cause letters, the lack of a disciplinary hearing and the Respondent’s knowledge of the Claimant’s pregnancy provide sufficient evidential basis for finding that the Claimant was disadvantaged in connection with her pregnancy and maternity leave. The Respondent’s explanations did not satisfactorily rebut that inference.

74. I therefore find and hold that the Claimant was discriminated against on account of pregnancy contrary to Section 5 of the Employment Act and Article 27 of the Constitution.

Whether she is entitled to the reliefs sought

Damages for constructive dismissal

75. The court has established that the Claimant was constructively dismissed. Under Section 49(1)(c), the Court may award compensation not exceeding twelve months’ gross salary, having regard to the factors in Section 49(4) of the Act.

76. The Claimant served the Respondent from 15th January 2019 until 16th June 2021, a period of approximately two years and five months. She also confirmed that she employed Faith Ndinya when she was not mandated to do so. This points to wrongdoing on her part, even though no disciplinary action was taken against her despite the many show cause notices.

77. Considering the Claimant’s relatively short period of service and her evident contribution to the termination, I deem an award of 6 months’ salary sufficient compensation for the constructive dismissal, which is hereby awarded.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the other monetary claims

Salary arrears

78. The Claimant seeks salary for February, March and April 2021 and other outstanding dues. The Respondent maintains that it made the relevant payments by cheque and that the Claimant’s advocates accepted and banked the cheques.

79. The Claimant confirmed on cross-examination that her advocate received the cheques issued by the Respondent in respect of her salaries, but that she did not collect the money from her advocates.

80. She did not indicate that the amount received by her advocates was less than what she was owed, and therefore her February, March and April salaries are considered fully settled, and the claim therefore fails.

Accrued annual leave

81. The Claimant did not establish the leave entitlement that she claims and the period for which it accrued. It was only upon her stating her leave entitlement that the Respondent would be required to produce the employment and leave records in its possession pursuant to Section 74 of the Employment Act.

82. There is therefore nothing placed before the Court in respect of this claim for the Respondent to respond to, and the claim therefore equally fails.

Damages for Discrimination

83. The Court has held that the Claimant was discriminated against on grounds of pregnancy. This is both a statutory and a constitutional violation which entitles the Claimant to compensation.

84. I thus find the claim merited and hereby award the Claimant Kshs.1,000,000/- on account of discrimination.

Whether the Respondent has proved its counterclaim

85. Under the counterclaim, the Respondent seeks notice pay, the value or refund of company property allegedly retained by the Claimant, and payment for customer invoices said to have remained uncollected.

86. Under sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act, the party asserting a fact bears the burden of proving it. A counterclaim is not established merely because the opposing party disputes or fails to explain an allegation.

87. The claim for notice pay fails on the finding that the Claimant was constructively dismissed.

88. Secondly, although the Respondent alleges that the Claimant retained company property, the Claimant testified that she handed over the laptop and keys to the Respondent’s lawyer.

89. The Respondent was further required to establish what property remained outstanding and its value, which it did not. A general allegation of non-return, without adequate supporting records or valuation, is insufficient to justify a monetary award.

90. On the losses said to have been occasioned by the Claimant by supplying goods to customers without recovering payment, the Respondent’s witness admitted that the company retained the debtors’ contacts and could pursue the outstanding sums. She also acknowledged that the Respondent did not produce delivery records establishing that the goods in question were delivered to the alleged debtors.

91. The Respondent has thus not sufficiently established the alleged deliveries, and the Claimant’s personal responsibility for the debts or the actual loss attributable to her conduct.

92. The counterclaim therefore fails on the foregoing grounds and is hereby dismissed with costs to the Claimant.

93. For the avoidance of doubt, the Claimant’s salary that is applicable to this claim is Kshs. 206, 424, as the pay slips produced in evidence support the amount, and no contrary evidence was led to show that the amounts included bonuses as alleged by the Respondent.

94. In the final analysis, the Claimant’s Claim is determined in terms of the following orders: -

a) That the Claimant was constructively dismissed.

b) That the Respondent discriminated against the Claimant on account of pregnancy.

c) That the Respondent shall pay the Claimant: -

i. Six (6) months’ salary for constructive dismissal at Kshs. 1,238,544/- (@ 206,424).

ii. One Million (Kshs.1,000,000) for discrimination.

iii. Costs of both the Claim and the counterclaim

iv. Interest on i & ii at court rate from the date of judgment until payment in full.

d) That a certificate of service shall be issued within 14 days of this judgment.

e) The counterclaim is dismissed with costs.

95. It is so ordered.

SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Kiluva present for the Claimant

Ms. Mwenja h/b for Mr. Wanjohi for the Respondent

Ms. Faith - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder