Employment law

Kamanga v Rubis Energy Kenya Plc & another [2026] KEELRC 4683 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Petition E204 of 2026
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbaru

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The 2nd respondent’s application dated 15 July 2026 to strike out and dismiss the petition against him was dismissed as without merit. The petition remains to be determined on its merits, including liability as between the respondents. Costs of the application abide the outcome of the petition.

Supporting judgment passages

The application dated 15 July 2026 is without merit and is hereby dismissed. Costs to abide the outcome of the petition.

Passage 44 →

Fundamentally, a petition should be heard on the merits as framed by the petitioner. The substantive issue must be determined, and in this case, the question of liability between respondents, including the 2nd respondent, should be addressed on the merits. The rationale is that a petition should not be defeated for joinder of any particular party as a respondent.

Passage 40 →
Issue 1Whether the 2nd respondent was improperly joined and should be struck out from the petition because no cause of action or relief was disclosed against him.

Held. No. The court declined to strike out the 2nd respondent and dismissed his application. The petition should proceed as framed and be heard on its merits; the question of liability between the respondents, including the 2nd respondent, is to be determined on the merits.

Ratio. Under the constitutional procedure rules, a petitioner who is uncertain from whom redress should be sought may join multiple respondents so that liability and its extent can be determined between them. A petition is not defeated by misjoinder or non-joinder, and the court should determine the substantive controversy on its merits.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

The 2nd respondent has challenged his joinder, arguing that he is not a proper party. He has no employment relationship with the petitioner, and he is also an employee of the 1st respondent. The 2nd respondent asserts that the petition discloses no cause of action against him and no relief is sought against him.

Passage 31 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Fundamentally, a petition should be heard on the merits as framed by the petitioner. The substantive issue must be determined, and in this case, the question of liability between respondents, including the 2nd respondent, should be addressed on the merits. The rationale is that a petition should not be defeated for joinder of any particular party as a respondent.

Passage 40 →

The application dated 15 July 2026 is without merit and is hereby dismissed. Costs to abide the outcome of the petition.

Passage 44 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

(a) Where the petitioner is in doubt as to the persons from whom redress should be sought, the petitioner may join two or more respondents so that the question as to which of the respondents is liable, and to what extent, may be determined as between all parties.

Passage 38 →

(b) A petition shall not be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the Court may in every proceeding deal with the matter in dispute.

Passage 39 →

No suit shall be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the court may in every suit deal with the matter in controversy so far as regards the rights and interests of the parties actually before it.

Passage 42 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Nairobi ELRC Claim No. E1145 of 2025 - Jeniffer Njeri Rukaru v Rubis Energy Kenya Limited.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the 2nd respondent, an employee and officer of the 1st respondent, was improperly joined in the petition; whether the petition disclosed a cause of action or sought relief against him; and whether the court should strike out and dismiss the petition…

Material facts

The 2nd respondent applied on 15 July 2026 to be struck out of the petition, contending that the petitioner was employed by the 1st respondent and had no employment relationship with him personally. The petitioner alleged that the 2nd respondent, as group…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

PETITION NO. E204 OF 2026

ALEX MUTHII KAMANGA PETITIONER

VERSUS

RUBIS ENERGY KENYA PLC 1ST RESPONDENT

OLIVIER SABRIE 2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

The 2nd respondent filed an application dated 15 July 2026 seeking to strike out and dismiss the petition dated 20 May 2026 against him. The 2nd respondent filed his Supporting Affidavit on the grounds that the petition discloses no reasonable cause of action against him.

The 2nd respondent avers that the petitioner, in response, had advanced arguments that he is a necessary party to the suit but failed to advance the prima facie burden that suing him as a respondent is necessary. The employer was the 1st respondent, and no employment relationship exists between the petitioner and the 2nd respondent to justify joinder in these proceedings. The 2nd respondent is seeking to be removed from these proceedings, and the petition against him dismissed with costs.

In reply, the petitioner filed his Replying Affidavit and avers that the 2nd respondent's application was filed without full disclosure and with misrepresentation of material facts. It is an attempt to scuttle the expeditious hearing and determination of the petition on merit. The respondents are abusing the court process and seek to address substantive issues that should be heard in evidence. A cause of action exists against the 2nd respondent, subject to determination by the court.

The petitioner avers that the 2nd respondent is joined in these proceedings because of his personal involvement in the violations complained of, which is a complex triable issue that cannot be summarily determined at an interlocutory stage.

The 2nd respondent was not a passive corporate officer but was directly and personally malicious, and he orchestrated the unlawful termination of employment of his spouse, Ms Jordina Borrel. On 3 December 2024, during a meeting in the boardroom, the 2nd respondent verbally and derogatorily announced his spouse and partner as the new “Brioche Boss”, a position the petitioner held at the time.

Several employees were present during the meeting, including Nicolas Muriu, head of retail; Nathan Korir, bakery manager; Serge Norman, kitchen chef; Susan Kirubi; and Jordina Borrel. The 2nd respondent incorporated the verbal announcement into a formal memorandum dated 8 January 2025. The petitioner was stripped of his duties at Brioche Riverside and subordinated in operations at Brioche Lavington to the direct supervision of Jordina Borrel.

The petitioner avers that since then, he was subjected to systemic hostility and an unworkable environment engineered by the 2nd respondent's spouse/partner, who exhibited gross operational incompetence and routinely threatened his employment when her directives were corrected.

The 2nd respondent abused his managerial power to engineer a disciplinary process to validate his spouse declarations leading to the petitioner’s termination of employment. Through the authority, control and personal directions of the 2nd respondent as the group managing director/chief executive officer, his joinder herein requires material determination of his liability. The 2nd respondent issued the termination of employment and cannot be absolved of personal liability for discriminatory treatment and irregular actions.

The disciplinary process was characterised by patent irregularities, including unreasonably short notice to respond, denial of access to operational systems, and failure to wait for outstanding investigations. Upon removal from his position, the petitioner was replaced by the 2nd respondent's spouse, raising bona fide issues of nepotism, racism and lack of transparency.

The 2nd respondent’s personal conduct fits into a documented institutional pattern of discriminatory management within the 1st respondent, which is the subject of several ongoing claims before the court, including:

1. Nairobi ELRC Claim No. E1145 of 2025 - Jeniffer Njeri Rukaru v Rubis Energy Kenya Limited.

2. Nairobi ELRC Claim No. E1293 of 2026 - Charles Thuo v Rubis Energy Kenya Limited.

3. Nairobi ELRC Claim No. E096 of 2026 - Joy Nmande Mrima v Rubis Energy Kenya Limited.

The petitioner avers that he does not seek to hold the 2nd respondent vicariously liable for the actions of the 1st respondent; rather, his presence as a party is crucial for the complete, effectual, and fair determination of the constitutional and employment infractions arising from his personal actions. The application seeking to strike out the 2nd respondent from these proceedings should be dismissed with costs.

The 2nd respondent submitted on his application that he is an employee of the 1st respondent, which is a separate entity from his person, as settled in Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC. A company is a legal person distinct from its directors and officers. An officer of the company acting on behalf of the company does not incur personal liability for the acts of the principal, as held in Kolaba Enterprises Ltd v Shamsudin Hussein Varvani & another [2014] eKLR.

The petitioner's allegations are not supported by evidence that he personally and maliciously orchestrated the termination of employment. The allegations that there is racism and nepotism are unsupported. Order 2 Rule 4(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules requires that matters such as fraud or malice be specifically pleaded. Order 2 Rule 10(1) requires particulars of fraud or willful default to be pleaded, which the petitioner has failed to address, as held in Laban Omuhaka Otumbula v Truphosa Okutoyi [2019] KEHC 1352 (KLR). The petitioner was taken through the disciplinary process before termination of employment on 21 July 2025. A panel of five members conducted the disciplinary hearing, and the 2nd respondent was not included.

The cited cases pending before the court in Nairobi ELRC Claim No. E1145 of 2025, E1293 of 2025, and E096 of 2026 to allege an institutional pattern is unjustified. These are separate claims with distinct proceedings and on untested allegations. The petitioner cannot invite the court to assume matters not before it.

The 2nd respondent is an unnecessary party in these proceedings. No relief is sought against him, and the court can determine the petition without him.

The petitioner submitted that the threshold for striking out a party is addressed in D. T. Dobie & Company (Kenya) Limited v Joseph Mbaria Muchina & another [1980] eKLR. The power to strike out a pleading is drastic and must be exercised with caution, and only in plain cases. Unless the matter presented is so hopeless and discloses no reasonable cause of action and is beyond redemption, the pleadings should be as presented.

The question is not whether the 2nd respondent disputes the petitioner’s case, but whether the petition plainly addressed is untenable. The petition discloses a cause of action against the respondents and should be heard on the merits. Order 2 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules allows the court to assume the pleadings as presented. The court should invoke its jurisdiction to strike out a party sparingly.

The petitioner submitted that the 2nd respondent is a necessary party in this case and that his petition should be heard on its merits.

Determination

The 2nd respondent has challenged his joinder, arguing that he is not a proper party. He has no employment relationship with the petitioner, and he is also an employee of the 1st respondent. The 2nd respondent asserts that the petition discloses no cause of action against him and no relief is sought against him.

The Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules govern proceedings before the court. A party filing a suit must identify the respondent against whom there is a cause of action and relief sought.

Under the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, a petitioner is allowed to file suit against a respondent defined as:

“respondent” means a person who is alleged to have denied, violated or infringed, or threatened to deny, violate or infringe a right or fundamental freedom;

Therefore, in determining whether one is a proper respondent or not, the parties and the court are guided under Rule 5 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules:

5. Addition, joinder, substitution and striking out of parties

The following procedure shall apply with respect to addition, joinder, substitution and striking out of parties—

(a) Where the petitioner is in doubt as to the persons from whom redress should be sought, the petitioner may join two or more respondents so that the question as to which of the respondents is liable, and to what extent, may be determined as between all parties.

(b) A petition shall not be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the Court may in every proceeding deal with the matter in dispute.

Fundamentally, a petition should be heard on the merits as framed by the petitioner. The substantive issue must be determined, and in this case, the question of liability between respondents, including the 2nd respondent, should be addressed on the merits. The rationale is that a petition should not be defeated for joinder of any particular party as a respondent.

Order 1 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules is emphatic that:

No suit shall be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the court may in every suit deal with the matter in controversy so far as regards the rights and interests of the parties actually before it.

However, even where the petitioner is allowed to proceed against the respondents as framed, if the case is found to be without merit, costs are payable for good cause.

The application dated 15 July 2026 is without merit and is hereby dismissed. Costs to abide the outcome of the petition.

Dated this 15th Day of October 2026

M. MBARU

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Court Assistant: Mohammed Ali

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder