Background
This suit was lodged through a Memorandum of Claim dated 28th September, 2023 and filed in court on 29th September, 2023. Under the claim, the Claimant seeks the following reliefs as against the Respondent: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This suit was lodged through a Memorandum of Claim dated 28th September, 2023 and filed in court on 29th September, 2023. Under the claim, the Claimant seeks the following reliefs as against the Respondent: -
Paragraph 1 →The issues for determination are: -
Paragraph 25 →In the upshot, I find and hold that the Claimant’s services were unfairly and unlawfully terminated.
Paragraph 36 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI.
CAUSE NO. E782 OF 2023
GEOFFREY MUCHOKI IRUNGU.……………………………..…CLAIMANT
VERSUS
VICTORIA JUICE COMPANY LIMITED.…………………….RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. This suit was lodged through a Memorandum of Claim dated 28th September, 2023 and filed in court on 29th September, 2023. Under the claim, the Claimant seeks the following reliefs as against the Respondent: -
a) 12 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination
b) One month pay in lieu of Notice
c) Overtime 3 hours for 45 days in Mombasa
d) Unpaid travel Allowance to Mombasa for 45 days
e) Certificate of service
f) Costs and Interest
2. The Respondent did not initially defend the suit despite proof of service, leading to the same proceeding undefended. The matter proceeded for formal proof hearing on 2nd April, 2025, and the Court reserved judgment for 9th October, 2025.
3. The Respondent lodged an application to arrest the delivery of the ex parte judgment, and the Court did arrest the judgment pending interparties hearing of that motion.
4. On the date set for the hearing of the motion, the Respondent did not appear, and neither did their counsel, leading to the dismissal of the motion for non-attendance. The court then again reserved judgment for delivery on 6th November, 2025.
5. The Respondent, yet again, filed another application dated 7th October, 2025, seeking reinstatement of the motion that was earlier dismissed, and the same was allowed, and the motion was reinstated with the consent of the parties. The Claimant further conceded to the application allowing the Respondent to defend the suit, and the judgment was once again stayed, allowing the Respondent to comply.
6. The Respondent failed to comply within the period allowed, but was again allowed a day to comply, and the suit was set down for hearing.
7. The suit was heard afresh on 20th April, 2026, when the Claimant testified in support of his case, adopted his witness statement and produced the documents filed as exhibits. The Respondent’s Counsel cross-examined him, whereupon he closed his case.
8. The Respondent did not call his witness on this date and was allowed an adjournment and given another hearing date. On 5th October, 2026, when the matter came up for defense hearing, neither the Respondent nor their counsel attended court, and on this account, the court declared the Respondent’s case closed and set a judgment date for 15th October, 2026.
9. The Claimant filed submissions in the matter.
The Claimant’s Case
10. The Claimant’s case is that he was in the service of the Respondent from 1st April 2023, as a Sales and Marketing Manager. He avers that he earned a basic salary of Kshs.114,000/= per month and a travel allowance of Kshs. 2,500/ =.
11. It is the Claimant’s case that he served the Respondent diligently and with loyalty until 8th August 2023, when the Respondent decided to unilaterally terminate his services.
12. The Claimant states that after his unlawful termination, he kept demanding to be paid his terminal dues, but the Respondent refused/failed and/or neglected to pay him.
13. The Claimant states that he was asked to give back the company car keys and to further discuss his salary which had been reduced to half the amount the parties had earlier negotiated. He further avers that his June salary was never paid in full, and that he realized later that he was demoted and his terms of engagement varied without consultations.
14. The Claimant further states that he was not allowed to take out some of his personal items from the company car.
15. The Claimant avers that the termination letter was handed over to him on the morning of 8th August, 2023, when he reported to work and did not have prior notice of the Respondent's intention to terminate his services.
16. The Claimant further states that the Respondent did not invite him to a meeting to discuss and/or explain to him the reasons why it was intending on terminating his services and neither was he heard prior to the termination.
17. The Claimant states that termination of his services was made casually despite his position in the Company, and was done without any justifiable reason, capriciously, maliciously and without being afforded a chance to be heard. He avers that the termination letter dated 8/8/2023 issued to him did not give any valid reason that could cause termination of his services, hence the termination was unfair.
18. The Claimant states that it was the prerogative of the Respondent to ensure that he was paid the entire number of wages earned and payable to him and all the allowances, but which have not been paid to date.
19. The Claimant prays that his claim be allowed, and he be awarded the reliefs sought.
The Claimant’s Submissions
20. It is submitted for the Claimant that though the termination letter based the termination on poor performance, the said letter did not refer to an existing employment policy on performance which the Claimant was said to have breached. Reliance was heard to the Court of Appeal decision in Jane Samba Mukala v OZ Tukai Lodge Limited, Industrial Cause No. 823 of 2010(201O)LLR255 (ICK), where the court observed: -
"The employer must show that in arriving at the decision of noting the poor performance of an employee, they had put in place an employment policy or practice on how to measure good performance as against poor performance ... It will not suffice to say that one has been terminated for poor performance as the effort leading to this decision must be established."
21. It is the Claimant’s submission that the Respondent did not follow procedure on fair hearing in its decision to terminate him, and that the Respondent simply accused him of poor performance which they did not prove. He submits that the Respondent cannot rely on the accusation of poor performance to justify the unfair termination. He placed reliance in Kenfreight (E.A.) Limited v Benson K.Nguti [2016] KECA 688 (KLR), to buttress this position.
22. The Claimant submits that having been the head of marketing at the Respondent, and having subordinate staff under him, the Respondent ought to have exercised some level of prudence in handling his termination. He submits that the treatment he received on the day of his termination was uncalled for and that it caused him embarrassment, shame and trauma. He submits that he was humiliated and, as such, is entitled to the maximum compensation.
23. The Claimant submits further that he is entitled to one month’s pay in lieu of notice on the premise that the termination letter was categorical that the Respondent was willing to pay him for the 8 days he worked in the month of August, and nothing more, despite the fact that he was let go summarily and without notice of termination.
24. The Claimant submits that he worked overtime for the 45 days he was posted in Mombasa, a fact the Respondent is well aware of and should pay him his overtime allowance.
Analysis and Determination
25. The issues for determination are: -
a) Whether the Claimant’s services were unlawfully terminated.
b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the prayers sought.
Whether the Claimant’s services were unlawfully terminated
26. The Claimant’s case is that the Respondent unilaterally terminated his services on the morning of 8th August 2023, without notice, reason or a prior hearing on the reasons for which the Respondent was considering termination as envisaged under Section 41 of the Employment Act.
27. It is his assertion that the Respondent simply asked him to surrender the company car keys, and to further discuss his salary, which had earlier been reduced to half the amount the parties had negotiated and agreed upon.
28. The Claimant further states that the Respondent did not invite him to a meeting to discuss and/ or explain to him the reasons why it was intending to terminate his services and that neither was he heard prior to the termination.
29. The Claimant has placed before this Court a letter of termination dated 8th August, 2023, which indicates that the termination was to take effect immediately. Further, the said letter lists four grounds for the termination of the Claimant’s service, including failure to meet performance targets, failure to close clients’ accounts, losses incurred by the company owing to the Claimant’s failure to collect money from customers, and previous warnings issued for failure to meet targets and the objectives of the company.
30. From the termination letter, it is evident that the reasons the Claimant’s employment was terminated revolved around performance. These reasons/grounds were, however, not put to the Claimant in the form of a show cause notice to allow him to respond, as envisaged under Section 41 of the Employment Act.
31. In Machira v Mugo Waweru and Associates [2012] KEIC 1 (KLR), the court opined:-
"The proper procedure once poor performance of an employee is noted is to point out the shortcomings to the employee and give the employee an opportunity to improve over a reasonable length of time. In our view, 2-3 months would be reasonable."
32. The Court of Appeal equally addressed the handling of poor performance in Jane Samba Mukala v OZ Tukai Lodge Limited, Industrial Cause No. 823 of 2010(201O)LLR255 (ICK) as follows:-
"The employer must show that in arriving at the decision of noting the poor performance of an employee, they had put in place an employment policy or practice on how to measure good performance as against poor performance ... It will not suffice to say that one has been terminated for poor performance as the effort leading to this decision must be established."
33. For the reason that this suit was undefended, no evidence was placed before this Court to show that the Respondent tried to address the Claimant’s purported poor performance before proceeding to terminate his services.
34. Further, the letter terminating the Claimant’s services, having taken effect immediately, confirms the Claimant’s assertion that he was neither issued notice to show cause nor heard prior to the termination of his services. In the case of Matsesho v Newton [2022] KEELRC 1554 (KLR) the Court opined: -
“That the law on termination of employment is codified in the Employment Act as read with the Constitution of Kenya 2010. Article 41 of the Constitution provides for the right to fair labour practices. In my view, this right is wide enough to cover the right of an employee to require that a proposed termination of his employment is informed by valid reasons and is processed in a manner that observes the dictates of due process. Under section 41 of the Employment Act, if an employer proposes to terminate services of an employee on the grounds of gross misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity, the employer must notify the employee of the ground for termination in a language that the employee understands. This information should be given to the employee in the presence of another employee of his choice or a trade union official if he elects. In addition, the employer is obligated to hear the employee’s representations in response to the accusations against him.”
35. Further, in Geoffrey Gikonyo Mathu v Intex Construction Company Ltd [2017] KECA 688 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that even if the reasons for termination were valid, the employee was still subject to a hearing in accordance with Section 41 (2) of the Employment Act.
36. In the upshot, I find and hold that the Claimant’s services were unfairly and unlawfully terminated.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the prayers sought
Compensation
37. The Claimant served the Respondent for a period of 4 months. Considering the duration he worked for the Respondent and the abrupt, demeaning manner in which he was terminated, I deem an award of 7 months’ salary sufficient compensation for the unfair termination, which is hereby awarded.
Pay in lieu of notice
38. The Claimant was evidently not given the statutory 30 days' termination notice, and there is no proof that he was paid in lieu of notice.
39. I find the claim merited and award one month's pay in lieu of notice.
Overtime
40. The Claimant did not lead any evidence to prove this claim, and the same fails and is dismissed.
Travel Allowance
41. Similar to overtime, the documents before the court do not support this allowance. Further, no travel records were produced, nor were previous payments of this allowance placed before the court to prove this claim. None of the pay slips produced show that the Claimant was ever paid this allowance during his time of service with the Respondent.
42. The claim is not proven, and it fails.
Conclusion
43. In whole, the Claimant’s claim succeeds and orders issued as follows:
a) 7 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination at Kshs. 798,000/=
b) One month's pay in lieu of notice at Kshs.114,000/-
c) A certificate of service be issued within 14 days of this judgment.
d) Costs of the suit.
44. Orders accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ms. Nduta present for the Claimant
N/A for the Respondent
Ms. Faith - C/A