Background
The Claimant initially commenced this suit via a memorandum of claim dated 9th November 2020 and later filed an amended memorandum of claim dated 2nd April 2024 seeking the following orders as follows:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Claimant initially commenced this suit via a memorandum of claim dated 9th November 2020 and later filed an amended memorandum of claim dated 2nd April 2024 seeking the following orders as follows:
Paragraph 1 →The court has considered the pleadings on record together with the rival submissions; the issues for determination are as follows:
Paragraph 39 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E6455 OF 2020
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Anna Ngibuini Mwaure)
ERICK BINGE OMWENGA…..…………...….…….... CLAIMANT
VERSUS
GOVERNORS’ CAMP MUSIARA LTD………....... RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. The Claimant initially commenced this suit via a memorandum of claim dated 9th November 2020 and later filed an amended memorandum of claim dated 2nd April 2024 seeking the following orders as follows:
a. A declaration that the Claimant’s dismissal from employment was not on good faith, unfair, wrongful, illegal, null and void ab initio.
b. The Claimant be paid sum of Kshs.8,749,180/=
c. Costs of suit and interest on (b) above at court rates from the date of filing suit until payment in full.
Claimant’s case
2. The Claimant avers that he was employed as a Credit Control Assistant by the Respondent through a letter dated 1st February 2006, earning a monthly salary of Kshs.17,500/=.
3. The Claimant avers that he served diligently for fourteen years until his termination on 17th March 2020, which he terms unlawful, unfair, and predetermined, arising from hostility by the Finance Manager and disciplinary proceedings tainted with conflict of interest.
4. The Claimant states that upon returning from his annual leave in February 2020, he was unfairly assigned urgent tasks, harassed by the Finance Manager, and subjected to a hostile work environment culminating in a flawed disciplinary process. The show cause letter and subsequent hearing were riddled with bias and ambiguity, with the Finance Manager and Senior Accountant, both complainants, sitting on the disciplinary panel.
5. The Claimant contends that his dismissal could not lawfully fall under redundancy or poor performance, since redundancy requires notice and payment of benefits, while poor performance requires a performance improvement plan, neither of which was followed. The Claimant cites violations of the Employment Act, 2007, the Fair Administrative Action Act, No. 4 of 2015, and Articles 35, 47, and 50 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, asserting denial of fair hearing and access to information.
Respondent’s memorandum of response
6. The Respondent opposed the amended memorandum of claim dated 4th April 2026.
7. The Respondent admits that they had an employment relationship with the Claimant but denies allegations of unfair dismissal. It asserts that the Claimant’s performance deteriorated over time and that his conduct in March 2020 amounted to gross misconduct under section 44 of the Employment Act, 2007, including neglecting duties, refusing lawful instructions, using insulting language, and absenteeism.
8. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant was issued with a Notice to Show Cause on 6th March 2020, responded on 9th March, 2020, and was invited to a disciplinary hearing on 13th March 2020, after which his employment was lawfully terminated on 17th March 2020.
9. The Respondent further contends that the Claimant voluntarily resigned the same day and later signed a Final Dues Agreement on 15thJune 2022, confirming receipt of all dues and waiving further claims.
10. The Respondent denies claims of bias, conflict of interest, or predetermined dismissal, insisting the process was fair, professional, and in line with its HR Manual.
11. The Respondent also rejects claims for redundancy, poor performance, or extra work compensation, arguing that tasks assigned were within the Claimant’s job description and no agreement for additional pay existed.
12. Consequently, the Respondent prays that the Amended Claim be dismissed with costs, as the Claimant is not entitled to any of the reliefs sought.
Claimant’s evidence in court
13. The Claimant (CW1) adopted his witness statement dated November 2020 together with the accompanying bundle of documents as his evidence in chief.
14. CW1 testified that he was employed by the Respondent as a Credit Control Assistant pursuant to an offer letter dated 1st February 2006 and served until his termination on 17th March 2020.
15. In cross‑examination, CW1 stated that upon returning from leave he was assigned a personal task by the Finance Manager, though the assignment was left on his desk rather than handed to him directly. He explained that the Finance Manager persistently followed up through emails, which he found burdensome, and that the assignment was eventually taken away and handed to a colleague when he was nearly finished. He confirmed receipt of a Notice to Show Cause dated 6th March 2020, to which he responded on 9th March 2020, and that he was invited to a disciplinary hearing but was not informed of his right to representation.
16. At the hearing, CW1 stated that six people were present, including himself, and that he was only asked to explain why he had not completed the assignment. He was accused of laxity, insubordination, and refusal to obey lawful orders, which he described as fabricated charges not presented during the hearing. He further testified that he undertook extra work from 2016, including tasks left after a colleague’s dismissal, for which he was promised an additional Kshs. 20,000/=, though this was never formalized. He maintained that his gross salary of Kshs.17,500/= did not include house allowance, which was absent from his payslip, and that while statutory deductions were made, gratuity and other allowances were not provided.
17. CW1 added that following the disciplinary hearing he was compelled to resign, with the resignation letter backdated to 17th March 2020, and later signed a discharge agreement dated 15th June 2022 to secure payment of his March 2020 salary. He asserted that he was forced into signing the discharge voucher due to financial hardship and that it only covered salary and not final dues, and that he intends to seek the court’s intervention to discharge the agreement.
18. In re‑examination, he reiterated that he never received his final dues and that the discharge was limited to salary arrears.
Respondent’s evidence in court
Respondent’s Witness (RW1)
19. RW1, Alice Kabake, the Respondent’s Human Resource Manager, adopted her witness statement dated 5th August 2025 together with the list of documents dated 4th April 2025 as her evidence in chief.
20. In cross‑examination, she stated that she was not the HR Manager at the time of Claimant’s witness(CW1)’s dismissal and only learned of the matter from office records. She confirmed she had no company resolution authorizing her representation, was not a member of the disciplinary committee, and noted that no minutes of the disciplinary hearing were filed in court. She acknowledged attaching a warning letter dated 2011, which by 2020 was nine years old.
21. RW1 further testified that the contents of the warning letter could be clarified by Mr. Kihara, and that she was unaware whether CW1’s salary was paid upon dismissal. She joined the Respondent in August 2023 and stated that CW1’s employment contract referred to gross pay inclusive of house allowance, though she had not seen his payslip. She emphasized that the contract allowed the employer to assign additional duties from time to time.
22. In re‑examination, RW1 pointed to clause 9 of CW1’s contract, which permitted allocation of extra duties without additional salary, and reiterated that CW1 never lodged a formal claim for future work.
23. RW2, Francis Njuguna Mbure, the Respondent’s Finance Manager, adopted his witness statement dated 11th August 2025 as his evidence in chief.
24. In cross‑examination, RW2 confirmed that he was CW1’s supervisor and sat as a member of the disciplinary committee, though he could not recall the venue of the hearing. He stated that witnesses were present, including Mr. Limo, who appeared as CW1’s representative. RW2 testified that CW1 had complained in the show cause letter of being overburdened with work, but in his view CW1 never formally raised such a complaint. He recalled that six people attended the hearing, where CW1 was given an opportunity to defend himself, and maintained that the process was fair. He emphasized that CW1’s work was marred by underperformance, noting that although the Respondent had no appraisal forms or performance improvement plans, clause 9 of CW1’s contract allowed allocation of additional duties without extra pay.
25. RW2 further stated that there was no redundancy in 2019 and that CW1 was dismissed for poor performance, misconduct, and insubordination. He explained that CW1 failed to finalize credit notes and there were inquiries which were documented in emails from William. He reiterated that although disciplinary hearings were held, he could not trace the minutes. He added that CW1 had a right of appeal by responding to the dismissal letter.
26. In re‑examination, RW2 maintained that the dismissal was based on insubordination, laxity, and wilful refusal to obey lawful orders, stressing that the decision was not predetermined but followed a fair hearing in which negligence was proved.
27. Parties canvassed the claim by way of written submissions.
Claimant’s submissions
28. The Claimant submitted that the Respondent’s defence evidence was fundamentally flawed. The Human Resource Manager admitted that no disciplinary minutes were produced in court and could not confirm whether a proper disciplinary hearing was ever conducted. This absence of records demonstrates that the termination process was procedurally defective, entitling the Claimant to the reliefs sought. The payment of Kshs.34,000/= was merely his March 2020 salary and not service gratuity for his 14 years of service, and the discharge voucher signed did not constitute terminal dues. Clause 9 of the employment contract referred to internal assignments within the Respondent’s company, not outsourced work for separate entities such as Governors Camp Rwanda, Governors Balloon Safaris, and Alfa Lima, thereby justifying his claim for unpaid salaries and allowances from those companies.
29. The Claimant submitted that under section 31 of the Employment Act, 2007, house allowance is a statutory right, and in its absence, an equivalent of one-third of basic salary should be provided. Since no evidence was adduced showing provision of housing or payment of allowance, the Claimant is entitled to house allowance for the entire period of service.
30. In conclusion, both Respondent’s witnesses confirmed that no disciplinary hearing took place, and the alleged engagement team had no minutes of proceedings. This renders the termination unjustified and contrary to Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, the Fair Administrative Action Act, and the Employment Act, 2007. The Claimant therefore seeks maximum compensation to cushion the loss of employment and the hardship suffered due to unlawful dismissal.
Respondent’s submissions
31. The Respondent contended that the Claimant’s termination was justified on several grounds. It was argued that the Claimant wilfully neglected to perform his assigned duties, which were within his contractual obligations, and deliberately failed to comply with lawful instructions to complete and prioritize his section of the assignment. This was evidenced by his emails dated 26th and 27th February 2020, where he declined to commit to the timelines provided. Further, the Respondent alleged that the Claimant used disrespectful language towards his superior, stating in the presence of witnesses that “the same pen that employed me is the same pen that will sack me.” Additionally, the Claimant was accused of absenting himself from work on 11th March 2020 without authorization and habitually leaving the office early, conduct consistent with prior warnings issued in 2011 and 2014. The Respondent relied on sections 43 and 45(2) of the Employment Act which provides for the valid reasons for terminating an employee and Walter Ogal Anuro V Teachers Service Commission [2013] KEELRC 386 (KLR), where the court held that: “However, for a termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for the termination but also procedural fairness.”
32. The Respondent also relied on Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019] KECA 300 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal underscored that the role of the court is not to re-evaluate managerial discretion unless it is exercised unlawfully or unfairly. Similarly, Were v Ketepa Sacco Limited [2026] KEELRC 1518 (KLR) reaffirmed that an employer’s decision must be based on genuine and reasonable belief supported by evidence. In Naivas Limited v Muthoka [2026] KEELRC 1472 (KLR), the court reiterated that judicial intervention is warranted only where the employer’s grounds lack substantive justification or contravene procedural fairness.
33. The Respondent submitted that the Claimant was formally issued with a Notice to Show Cause, which set out the allegations against him, and thereafter the Claimant was invited via the letter dated 12th March 2020 to a disciplinary hearing which was held on 13th March 2020, where a fellow employee of his choice accompanied the Claimant, and he was accorded an opportunity to present his defence and make oral representations before the disciplinary committee. These steps demonstrated adherence to the principles of natural justice by ensuring the Claimant was notified of the charges, given time to respond, and heard before any decision on termination was reached.
34. The Respondent relied on the case of Koyabe v Kenya National Union of Teachers & Another [2025] KEELRC 3202 (KLR), the court reaffirmed that disciplinary and administrative bodies must uphold due process and ensure that affected individuals are accorded a fair hearing before any adverse decision is made. Similarly, Kiarie v UAP Holdings Limited [2026] KEELRC 1255 (KLR) emphasized that an employer’s decision to terminate must be grounded on credible evidence and a genuine, reasonable belief in misconduct, thereby reinforcing the principle of substantive justification. The decision in Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & another v Mule & 3 others [2014] KECA 890 (KLR) extended these principles to public administration, underscoring that decision-makers must act within the bounds of fairness, reasonableness, and legality.
35. The Respondent argued that the Claimant’s assertion that a conflict of interest arose because the Respondent’s Finance Manager and one of the Senior Accountants, both of whom had made accusations against him, sat on the disciplinary panel is unfounded. In Martin Rugenyi Warutere v Open World Limited [2020] KEELRC 1695 (KLR), the court clarified that the Employment Act does not prescribe the composition of a disciplinary committee or the manner in which such hearings should be conducted. What the law requires is that the employee be given a fair opportunity to prepare, be heard, and, if desired, be accompanied by a representative of their choice. Similarly, in Clement Karuri v Kenya Ports Authority [2018] KECA 607 (KLR), the court emphasized that procedural fairness is determined by impartiality and adherence to statutory requirements rather than the identity of those sitting on the panel.
36. The Respondent also maintained that the Claimant voluntarily resigned on 17th March 2020 and later executed a Final Dues Agreement on 15th June 2022, receiving Kshs. 34,239.75/= in full settlement. The Respondent cited the cases of Coastal Bottlers Ltd v Mithika [2018] KECA 523 (KLR) and Trinity Prime Investment Limited v Lion of Kenya Insurance Company Limited [2015] KECA 793 (KLR), they argued that such agreements, if voluntary, bar further claims.
37. The Respondent systematically contested each of the Claimant’s reliefs. It argued that service gratuity had no contractual or statutory foundation, citing the case of Amwata Mutahi Nicolus v Ukwala Supermarket [2016] KEELRC 1427, where the court held that “no contractual or statutory foundation for service pay gratuity was disclosed and the same is denied.” The claim for compensation under section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act was deemed untenable since the termination was fair. The Respondent maintained that house allowance was already included in the gross salary, relying on Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR) and Ngugi & 16 Others v Safaricom PLC [2021] KEELRC 1521. Notice pay was excluded under section 44(1) of the Employment Act, which permits summary dismissal without notice. The claim for March 2020 salary was barred by the Final Dues Agreement, supported by Kamau v Kevian Kenya Ltd [2023] KEELRC 627. Lastly, the claim for special allowances was dismissed as unfounded, since the duties allegedly attracting extra pay fell squarely within the Claimant’s contractual obligations.
38. In conclusion, the Respondent urged the court to find that the Claimant was lawfully terminated hence he is not entitled to the reliefs sought.
Analysis and determination
39. The court has considered the pleadings on record together with the rival submissions; the issues for determination are as follows:
a. Whether the Respondent substantively and procedurally terminated the Claimant;
b. If (a) above is in the negative, whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought; and
c. Who should bear the costs of the suit?
40. The court reiterates the case of Walter Ogal Anuro V Teachers Service Commission (Supra) that termination to be fair, it ought to be both substantive justified and procedural fair. The same is set in the cases of Mary Chemweno Kiptui v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited [2014] KEELRC 905 (KLR) and Loice Otieno V Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd [2013] KEELRC 271 (KLR).
41. In this instant case, the Claimant was employed on 1st February 2006 as a Credit Control Assistant earning Kshs.17,500/=. He argues that his termination on 17th March 2020 was unlawful, unfair, and predetermined, citing hostility from the Finance Manager, bias in the disciplinary process, and violations of constitutional and statutory rights. He maintains redundancy and poor performance procedures were ignored. In contrast, the Respondent insists the dismissal was lawful under section 44 of the Employment Act, 2007, pointing to misconduct including neglect of duty, refusal of instructions, absenteeism, and insulting language. It emphasizes that the Claimant was issued a Notice to Show Cause on 6th March 2020, responded on 9th March, 2020, attended a disciplinary hearing on 13th March 2020, and was terminated on 17th March 2020, before voluntarily resigning and later signing a Final Dues Agreement on 15th June 2022 waiving further claims. Thus, the Claimant relies on alleged procedural flaws, while the Respondent anchors its defence on statutory grounds and the binding effect of the settlement.
42. The Claimant voluntarily resigned by a letter dated 17th March 2020, in which he expressed gratitude for the opportunity to work with the Respondent and anticipated cordial relations thereafter. It is to be noted that the same day he had received a dismissal letter he also signed a discharge voucher acknowledging receipt of Kshs. 34,238.75/= as final dues, yet later filed suit seeking additional reliefs. The Court notes there was no evidence of hostility with the Finance Manager, and employees who resign due to a hostile environment are expected to state their reasons clearly rather than provide unverified grounds for termination. Reliance is placed on Milton M. Isanya v Aga Khan Hospital Kisumu [2017] KEELRC 571 (KLR), where it was held that resignation under such circumstances does not amount to constructive dismissal. The appreciative tone of the Claimant’s resignation is of importance.
43. It is also to be noted as provided in the Court of Appeal PETER CHEGE -VS- TIMSALES LTD APPEAL 79 OF 2020 where the court held: -
“That the Appellants purported retirement notice cannot be allowed to evade lawful disciplinary proceedings which is tantamount to sanitizing gross misconduct.”
Whichever way the Claimant was due for summary dismissal but he opted to resign the same day he was to be dismissed.
44. In any event, the Claimant was put through a disciplinary process which was a legal process and he attended and participated.
The employer cannot be accused of unlawful dismissal when he complied with Sections 41, 43, 45 and 47 of the Employment Act. The respondent complied with the above legal provisions.
45. Having considered the pleadings, submissions and case-laws
the Court finds the claim for wrongful dismissal devoid of merit and accordingly dismisses it, with each party bearing its own costs. However, in compliance with section 51 of the Employment Act, the Court directs the Respondent to issue the Claimant with a certificate of service within 30 days.
It is so ordered.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nakuru this 16th Day of October, 2026.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE
ORDER
In view of the declaration of measures restricting Court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open Court. In permitting this course, this Court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the Court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this Court the duty of the Court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.
A signed copy will be availed to each party upon payment of Court fees.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE