Employment law

Oduor v Safaricom Ltd [2026] KEELRC 4687 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E965 of 2021
Judgment date
16 October 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant through her Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 7th February, 2025 pleaded inter alia as follows: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

On the issue of discrimination, the same fails as the Claimant has not illustrated how she was discriminated against and on what account apart from stating that other employees were treated different without stating which ones.

Paragraph 96 →

Decision / orders

In conclusion the Claimant’s claim is found without merit is hereby dismissed costs.

Paragraph 107 →

Reasoning passage

Whereas the Claimant alleged that the Respondent did not undertake its own internal investigations this court notes that the insurance’s investigation was enough since the Respondent had delegated this duty of medical cover to it. Whereas the Claimant alleged that the reason for her dismissal was not fair, the evidence on record proves otherwise. In this case the Claimant who was residing in Langata and working in Waiyaki way opted to…

Paragraph 82 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E965 OF 2021

LYNETTE AKINYI ODUOR……..……........................................ CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

SAFARICOM LIMITED………………………………………………..............RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. The Claimant through her Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 7th February, 2025 pleaded inter alia as follows: -

a. At all material times relevant to this suit, the Claimant was in the formal employment of the Respondent, on a permanent and pensionable basis working as a Customer Care Representative on 20th September, 2005.

b. The Claimant diligently worked for the Respondent for 16 years until 23rd September, 2021 when she was summarily dismissed by the Respondent.

c. At the time of termination of her employment, she was earning a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 203 632.79 /= and had been promoted to the rank of a Quality Analyst at the Respondent's offices located along Waiyaki Way in Nairobi.

d. On or about the 29th June, 2021, the Claimant avers that she fell ill and she visited Mater Hospital Buru Buru Clinic to be attended to by a doctor. The Claimant had stomach pains and was accompanied by a cousin known as Lilian Omondi.

e. That on arrival at the above-mentioned medical facility, the Claimant was registered at the reception as is the standard practice and the Claimant used her Medical Insurance Smart Card issued to her by the Respondent on account of the Claimant being an employee of the Respondent. That she filled in her particulars on a MINET Outpatient claim form which the Claimant signed upon filling in the particulars.

f. The Claimant further avers that her medical card was swiped for purposes of consultation and after being duly registered for the day at the clinic, the Claimant was referred to the triage before being allowed to see a doctor for consultation.

g. The Claimant avers that upon being attended to at the triage, she was then requested to see the doctor and the Claimant was accompanied to the consultation room with her cousin.

h. The Claimant further avers that while at the consultation room with the doctor, the said doctor examined and advised her to go for a pelvic ultrasound scan so that the doctor could arrive at a conclusive diagnosis. That she proceeded to the Radiology department of the clinic where she was once again requested by the clinic's administration to swipe her medical card for the radiology service, after which the Claimant went in for the procedure.

i. As the Claimant was waiting for the radiology results, she decided to consult a nutritionist within the same facility/clinic to advise her on diet. For this, the clinic's administration also requested her to swipe her medical card for the service.

j. After the Claimant was attended to by the nutritionist, the clinic kept her waiting for too long and when she made enquiries as to why the radiology report was taking too long, it was at that point that the clinic's administration informed her that her medical account with MINET Insurance had been locked and at the same time her medical card was missing.

k. That she demanded for her medical card to be located and returned to her including the report for radiology but the clinic claimed that the report cannot be availed to her. When she demanded to see the doctor who had attended to her, the clinic administration declined to allow her to see the doctor and claimed that the doctor had already left the hospital and could only be seen the following week as the doctor was a specialist who visits the clinic on a weekly basis being a consultant gynecologist.

l. The Claimant then complained to the administration of Mater Clinic but she was made to pay a bill of Kshs. 8,300/- that was to be also catered for by the Claimant's medical insurance scheme.

m. That upon making payment of the outstanding medical bill of Kshs. 8,300/= the Claimant was then given a radiology report for a stranger by the name Abdiwahab Haji who was examined for prostrate ultrasound dated 30th April, 2021.

n. When the Claimant insisted that she be given her specific radiology report, the administration of the clinic insisted that the report already given was hers.

o. That on or about 6th July, 2021, she was summoned to MINET Insurance offices at Nyerere road regarding a complaint that she had allegedly used her medical card to treat a relative who was not a beneficiary in her medical scheme. That she was shown a medical form which had her particulars but dated 28thJune, 2021 and had a Mater Hospital Stamp on it.

p. The Claimant avers that she did not visit Mater Clinic on 28th June, 2021 but on the 29th June, 2021. The diagnosis on the medical claim form shown to the Claimant indicated that she was allegedly suffering from contact dermatitis which the Claimant denies since she was suffering from abdominal pains that was suspected to be fibroids.

q. The Claimant further avers that on 28th June, 2021 she was attended to at AAR Healthcare in Buru Buru for a skin rash on her neck for which she was treated.

r. The Claimant states that she did not report the loss of the medical card to the employer or the insurance as the administration at Mater Clinic assured her that it would be traced and that they would call her the following day to collect it.

s. On or about the 7th September, 2021, she was invited for an initial virtual disciplinary hearing and a subsequent one held on or about 15th September, 2021, following an allegation by MINET Insurance against the Claimant on a fraudulent use of the Claimant's medical card.

t. The Claimant avers that during the disciplinary hearing; the Respondent did not accord her a fair hearing as the Respondent relied entirely on an investigation report provided by MINET Insurance and insisted that the Claimant was culpable and that the Claimant had used her medical card to accord medical services to her cousin.

u. Upon conclusion of the disciplinary hearing, the Respondent summarily dismissed her on the allegations of fraud with immediate effect.

v. That throughout her employment with the Respondent, she performed her duties faithfully, diligently and with utmost dedication and tremendous candor, and had never been cited for any misconduct at work, or issued with any warning letter of whatsoever nature. That her work assessment through several audits was always satisfactory upon which the Claimant was promoted and/or retained, and her salary re-evaluated from time to time.

w. That her termination of her services was effected maliciously and without any due regard to welfare and rights accruing to her. That the Respondent equally discriminated against her by terminating her services unfairly.

x. The Claimant avers that upon dismissal, the Respondent withheld her final dues with a promise that the same would be paid to her on or about 30th September, 2021 after clearance with the Respondent's payroll section. At the time of filing of this claim, the Respondent was still withholding her dues beyond the deadline of 30th September 2021 and this has caused her anguish as she is unable to make ends meet.

y. That she has duly complied with the Respondent's request for a return of all property belonging to the Respondent.

z. As a result of the matters aforesaid, the Claimant has suffered great financial loss and damage.

PARTICULARS OF SPECIAL LOSS AND DAMAGE

i) 12 months compensation @ Kshs.203,632.00/= Kshs 2,443,593.48/=.

ii) Staff benefit phone after 18 months@ Kshs. 35,000.00/=.

iii) Balance of September 2021 salary@ Kshs. 54,204.30/=.

TOTAL Kshs 2,532,797.78/=

2. The Claimant in the upshot prayed for the following against the Respondent: -

a. Claim for unpaid dues from the date of wrongful termination of the Claimant's services till date of retirement (14 years were left until retirement at 60 years Kshs.34,210,308.72/=.

b. Service pay for 16 years of service worked Kshs. 1,629,062.40/=

c. Dues from Safaricom Employees’ Pension Scheme as per the provisions of Clause 5.2 of the Respondent's Staff Manual.

d. Special damages as per paragraph 32A of the Memorandum of Claim.

e. Damages for wrongful dismissal from employment.

f. Certificate of Service.

g. Interest on a), b) c) and d) hereinabove at court rates.

h. Costs of this suit.

i. Any other and/or further relief as thi Honorable Court may deem just and fit to grant.

j. Damages for discrimination.

k. Pecuniary damages

3. The Respondent filed their Amended statement of response dated 24th March, 2025 and averred inter alia as follows: -

a. By an appointment letter dated 19th September, 2005, the Claimant was employed by the Respondent to serve in the capacity of Customer Care Representative, effective 20th February, 2005 and at a starting monthly gross salary of Kshs. 35,000/= to be reviewed on 1st July, 2006 and on 1st July each year thereafter.

b. The letter of appointment provided for other terms including benefits which, entitled the Claimant to join the Respondent’s medical scheme wherein she would be covered together with her family.

c. Other terms of the contract included the fact that the Respondent’s Staff Handbook would form part of the Claimant’s terms and conditions of employment. The same was provided to the Claimant and she was asked to read it carefully before accepting the terms of the contract.

d. The Claimant served the Respondent until on or about 23rd September, 2021 when her employment was terminated for gross misconduct in that she fraudulently sought medical treatment for an ineligible member on 29th June, 2021 at Mater Hospital Buruburu, in violation of the Respondent’s Medical Scheme Policy, her terms and conditions of employment as well as the Respondent’s Code of Conduct. At the time of the aforesaid dismissal, the Claimant was earning a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 203,632.79/= and serving in the position of Analyst–Experience Assurance Officer, within the Respondent’s Distribution Division.

e. The dismissal was substantially justified and procedurally fair as outlined below:

f. The Respondent had engaged the services of Minet Insurance Brokers to provide medical insurance cover for its employees in line with the Respondent’s medical scheme policy. Minet Insurance Brokers was sourced by the Respondent to provide medical insurance to its employees as per the terms of the Respondent’s medical insurance policy.

g. On or about 29th June, 2021, while seeking medical services at Mater Hospital Buru Buru, the Respondent suspected the Claimant:

i. To have fraudulently used her medical card which is a benefit given to her by the Respondent, to seek treatment for an ineligible member who was confirmed after investigations to be the Claimant’s cousin; and

ii. Further her acts may have led to loss of the Respondent’s funds.

h. The scope of the Respondent’s Medical Scheme policy provided who was to be covered and the Claimant’s cousin falls out of the scope of the policy hence was ineligible to benefit from the Respondent’s medical scheme. The Claimant’s actions were therefore in contravention of this policy.

i. Additionally, clause 2.4 of the Respondent’s Employees Code of Conduct

provides thus:

The Company’s Code of conduct provides employees with guidance in maintaining the ethical and cultural standards that help protect and enhance its reputation. The Code applies to every company employee.

j. The Claimant’s actions were in direct breach of the Respondent’s Code of Conduct in that it was unethical of the Claimant to use the Respondent’s medical card for the benefit of her cousin who was ineligible for the same.

k. The Claimant’s actions and omissions being in direct breach of the terms and conditions of her employment with the Respondent as well as applicable policies and the Respondent’s medical scheme policy, prompted the Respondent to conduct investigations. The investigation was carried out by the Respondent’s medical cover provider, Minet Insurance Brokers.

l. To effectively investigate the issues and determine whether the Claimant used her medical card scheme to treat an ineligible member, in the course of investigations, Minet did the following:

i. Visited Mater Hospital Buruburu special clinic and interviewed the relevant personnel who were present on 29th June, 2021.

ii. Visited Mater Main hospital to review the CCTV footage;

iii. Interviewed and recorded a statement of the Claimant being the principal member.

iv. Interviewed the Claimant’s alleged cousin on phone;

v. Reviewed the smart report for the alleged day of 29th June, 2021.

m. The investigations observed and established the following findings:

i. The Claimant was present at the Mater Buruburu specialist clinic and swiped her smart card as illustrated in the smart report extract at page 13 of the investigations report Respondent’s bundle. This is not disputed;

ii. Analysis and review of the Claimant’s medical history revealed that it was the very first time the Claimant was visiting the Mater Hospital facility as she had not been treated there for the last 2 scheme years;

iii. Review of the CCTV footage established that the Claimant and Lillian Omondi (the Claimant’s cousin) were both present at the Mater Hospital Buruburu on the 29th June,2021. Many movements were seen by the two going to the officer in charge office after they were discovered cheating. The movements were explained by the sister in-charge that the two were trying to buy their way out without being reported to the insurance;

iv. The Claimant attempted to use her medical card to treat her cousin who was ineligible for the same. The Claimant was thus involved in fraud. It was noted that the Claimant chose Mater hospital Buruburu where she was not known so that she could be able to conceal her identity.

n. Based on the foregoing findings, the investigations made the following recommendations:

i. The Claimant be subjected to a medical examination by a Doctor appointed by Minet;

ii. Based on the medical report by Minet appointed doctor, a disciplinary action was recommended;

iii. Suspend the Claimant’s benefit pending the disciplinary action/process.

o. Relying on the findings of the investigation report, the Claimant was asked to show cause in writing as to why disciplinary action could not be taken against her for having fraudulently used her medical card which is a benefit given to her by the Respondent, to seek treatment for an ineligible member, vide a letter dated 17th August, 2021. She was required to submit her written comprehensive submissions to the allegations by close of business on 19th August, 2021. The Show cause letter also enclosed therewith a copy of a confidential investigations report from Minet Insurance Brokers.

p. By a letter dated 6th July, 2021, the Claimant responded to the Notice to show cause letter in which she denied all the allegations that had been raised against her.

q. The Respondent considered the Claimant’s response to the show cause notice and found the same not be satisfactory in answer to the issues that had been raised against her in the show cause letter. The Respondent, thus vide a letter dated 2nd September, 2021 invited the Claimant to a disciplinary hearing on 7th September, 2021. The Claimant was advised to be accompanied by a colleague employee of her choice.

r. On 7th September, 2021, the Claimant attended the disciplinary hearing wherein the issues that had been raised in her show cause letter were again presented to her and she was given opportunity to make verbal representations on the issues therein.

s. The Claimant was again invited for a further disciplinary hearing vide an invitation letter dated 10th September, 2021 which hearing took place on 15th September, 2021. The hearing was meant to enable the Claimant provide more details on the following issues which the Respondent had obtained from its investigators:

i. The medical claim form that the Claimant had submitted as evidence during the first hearing of 7th September, 2021 indicating that she was seen by Dr. R.K. Bor on the 29th June, 2021 was fraudulent and not genuine;

ii. Dr. Wanjema who served the Claimant at AAR was on full day coverage shift at AAR Buruburu outpatient center on 28th and 29th June, 2021 therefore he could not have served the Claimant at Mater Hospital at the same time he was at AAR;

iii. Further, it was alleged that the Claimant had on 28th June, 2021 while at AAR Buruburu requested Dr. Wanjema to attend to and treat the Claimant’s cousin under the Claimant’s medical cover to which Dr. Wanjema declined.

t. The disciplinary hearings were held following a further escalation by Minet Insurance Brokers team into alleged fraudulent use of the Respondent’s medical scheme benefit by an ineligible member.

u. The following are some of the deliberations and observations made in the disciplinary hearing meetings:

i. During the initial disciplinary hearing of 7th September, 2021, it was established that the Claimant was at Mater hospital Buruburu with her cousin and that she used her medical card to enable her cousin get medical services for which she was ineligible. When this was discovered, the Claimant’s card was confiscated by Mater Hospital management and that the Claimant was made to pay cash for the services which were rendered;

ii. This [(a) above) was contrary to the Claimant’s allegation that the Mater hospital had lost her card hence forcing her to pay cash.

iii. The Claimant did not report the loss of the medical card nor the incident at the Mater hospital to the Respondent’s health safety and welfare team for assistance, and neither did she seek reimbursement for the cash as is provided for in the Medical scheme policy. The Claimant nevertheless went ahead and applied for a replacement medical card;

iv. After the hearing of 7th September, 2021, the Claimant presented by email, a AON Minet claim form purporting to have been attended to by Dr. Bor on 29th June, 2021 at Mater Hospital. The same form was also found to be fraudulent and not genuine form at the hearing.

v. The Respondent having given the Claimant a fair hearing and having reviewed all the facts of the matter established that:

i. The Claimant’s actions constituted gross misconduct and that she fraudulently sought medical treatment for an ineligible member on 29th June, 2021 at Mater Hospital Buruburu;

ii. The Claimant in addition to the above, presented to the Respondent fraudulent documents in her defence.

w. The Respondent’s disciplinary panel in considering the Claimant’s presentations (both written and oral) and also based on its findings during the Disciplinary hearing made recommendations to terminate the Claimant’s employment.

x. In line with the recommendations of the disciplinary hearing committee, the Respondent subsequently terminated the Claimant’s employment with immediate effect, vide a letter dated 23rd September, 2021 for gross misconduct for violating the terms and conditions of her employment as well as the Respondent’s Medical Scheme policy and Code of Conduct.

y. By the same letter of dismissal, the Claimant was also informed of the right to appeal against the decision of the Respondent by lodging her appeal through email to appeals@safaricom.co.ke within 10 days from the date of receipt of the termination letter.

z. The termination letter also indicated that the Claimant would be paid her terminal dues (net of all statutory deductions and taxes taking into account recovery of any monies owed to the Respondent) upon clearance with the Respondent by or on 30th September, 2021. The terminal dues comprised of:

a) Salary for the days worked in the month of termination paid out by way of a cheques;

b) Any leave balance accrued and not taken paid out by way of cheques;

c) Any allowance accruing as approved by the Claimant’s line manager before the Claimant’s last day.

aa. The Claimant, however, did not appeal against the decision by the Respondent terminating her employment. The Claimant was paid her full terminal dues in October, 2021, totaling to Kshs. 76,362.30/= less statutory deductions and as captured in her letter of dismissal.

ab. The Respondent denies the allegations contained in paragraphs 8 to 23 of the statement of claim and avers that the Respondent relied on extensive investigations report which established that the Claimant had gross misconducted herself hence was liable for summary dismissal.

ac. Contrary to the Claimant’s allegations in paragraphs 24 and 25 of the Statement of Claim, the Respondent maintains that the Claimant’s employment contract was terminated for valid and fair reasons and that the same was strictly done in accordance with the provisions of Section 41 of the Employment Act as well as principles of natural justice. In line with section 43 of the Employment Act, the Respondent had reasons to genuinely believe that the Claimant’s actions were in contravention of the Respondent’s Code of Conduct, medical scheme policy as well as her own terms and conditions of employment.

ad. The Respondent, as an employer to the Claimant, had the prerogative to determine grounds for dismissal/termination of the Claimant so long as they met the validity, reasonableness and fairness test as required by the Employment Act, 2007. The reasons given for the Claimant’s termination were valid and reasonable in the circumstances.

ae. Further, the Claimant did not object to the contents and findings of the investigations report which was shared with her together with the show cause letter. In her response to the show cause letter, the Claimant did not object to any of the issues/findings therein.

af. The Respondent denies the allegations under paragraph 26 and avers that the dismissal of the Claimant was fair and lawful in that there was substantive justification for the dismissal and also that the Respondent strictly adhered to the procedural requirements as well as principles of natural justice. Absence of records of the Claimant’s previous misconduct could not be a shield to the Respondent’s decision of taking a disciplinary action against the Claimant. In any event, the dismissal was not on account of poor performance but misconduct. The issues of performance as raised by the Claimant are therefore irrelevant in the circumstance.

ag. The Respondent denies the particulars of malice and discrimination alleged by the Claimant.

ah. The Respondent denies all the allegations in paragraphs 27 to 31 of the statement of claim and avers that the Claimant was duly paid all her terminal dues upon clearance with the Respondent as was required of her through the dismissal letter. The allegations of malice are therefore unfounded and without basis.

ai. The Respondent denies the allegations in paragraphs 32 to 33 of the statement of claim and avers that the Claimant is not entitled to the claims, orders and prayers sought in the Statement of Claim in that:

a. The Claimant is not entitled to damages as sought and claimed since her employment was terminated on valid and fair reasons and that the termination was in line with the provisions of Sections 41, 43, and 45 of the Employment Act.

b. There is no legal basis to award the claimant pay up until retirement;

c. The claim for 16 years’ service pay is not tenable because the Claimant was a contributing member of the National Social Security Service Fund and is therefore not eligible for service pay in accordance with section 35 (6) (d) of the Employment Act.

d. Damages cannot be granted since the Claimant has not demonstrated valid grounds on which the damages claimed can be granted. The dismissal was substantively justified and procedurally fair;

e. Claim for dues from the Respondent’s employees’ pension scheme is without basis and cannot be granted. The Claimant should be directed to seek payment from the Respondent’s pension scheme service provider as per the guidelines.

f. Staff benefit phone of Kshs. 35,000/= per month is without basis and justification hence should fail; her employment ended and there is no basis for such a claim.

g. The Claimant was paid her full September 2021 salary and there is no basis for balance of unpaid salary in the month of September 2021;

h. The Claimant was issued with a Certificate of Service.

i. The Claimant is not entitled to an award of damages for discrimination.

aj. The Respondent prayed that the Claimant’s suit be dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

EVIDENCE

4. The Claimant’s case was heard on 30th September, 2025 and the Claimant herein CW1 testified. CW1 relied on her witness statement dated 19th November, 2021 and the bundle of documents as her evidence in chief. She stated that the Respondent was her former employer.

5. In cross-examination she stated that she was not currently employed and she was summarily dismissed. That this was after investigations where she was found that she was using her medical cover for ineligible person. That she had two dependants, her spouse and her child. That they were covered by Minet Insurance.

6. She stated that the smart report showed the record of visits to medical facilities. According to her, on visiting the hospital, one is given claim form to fill and proceed to triage then sees the doctor to prescribe medication after consultation. That biometrics were also taken.

7. CW1 stated that on 28/6/2021 she was treated at AAR Buruburu where she was having a skin issue. That she raised no other issue and she was done. That on 29th June, 2021 she visited Mater Hospital accompanied by her cousin. That it was in the morning. She stated that as per her statements she was having stomach ache and had been bleeding for long and she was suspecting she could be having fibroids. That the diagnosis on the other hand was contact dermatitis.

8. She stated that she entered the triage with her cousin as well as the consultation room where she was attended to by a gynecologist. That the doctor recommended a scan. That she went to the nutritionist first then radiologist. That the radiologist was busy at first. She stated that when she went to the radiologist she found her card had been locked and that her card had been lost that is why her account was locked. That she was to follow up with the doctor but this did not happen because her card was lost by the Hospital.

9. She stated that the medical cover had been swiped before it was lost. That she paid for the services by swiping her debit card. That she was to receive a radiology report as soon as possible but received a report for someone else.

10. That she saw the report while at home and reported the incident to the insurance agent, Mr. Mbae and that he called her earlier. That she never returned the report or return for follow up consultation. That the hospital never gave her the report on the lost card. That she informed Mr. Mbae and the HR about the lost card.

11. She stated that she was given a replacement and sought medical treatment elsewhere from Mater hospital. Mr. Mbae informed her why he was raising concerns about transactions on her card.

12. CW1 stated that at her response to show cause letter she stated that she asked if there was a gynecologist available but she was told none was available and she went to Agha Khan where she was told the same thing then she went to Mater Hospital. That her cousin was with her all the time. She further stated that she paid by cash when she was told her card was lost and she was talking with the lady at the reception and was informed the hospital would call her once the card was found since she was residing nearby. That there was no confrontation but she was annoyed when she was told her card was lost.

13. CW1 stated that the CCTV report showed she was in hospital with her cousin and she did not bring her to impersonate her. That in the show cause letter she was accused of fraud/ impersonation and she responded to it. That she was invited to disciplinary hearing on September 2021.

14. She stated that she went alone to the disciplinary hearing. That she was invited for a second hearing where the claim forms were presented and she was accused of using her medical card to access treatment for ineligible person. She stated that she was advised of her right of appeal in the dismissal letter and that she did not appeal and that she was paid her terminal dues but not everything as she was not paid the month she worked for and all her leave days. That she was not paid her pension. She further stated that she received her payslip and but she was underpaid. The bank statements covered her payments and she did not receive the amount stated therein. She could not remember how much.

15. In re-examination CW1 stated that she was pensionable and she disputed mode of calculation at the dismissal. That on 7/9/2021 she appeared before the disciplinary hearing but she was not provided with charge sheet or documents. That there was no report from mater on the incident. That there was no report from Dr. RK Bor.

16. She stated that item on the 8 invoice from Mater was signed by Dr. Bor and it was in respect of her. That it was not wrong to appear in hospital with anyone. That Mater hospital had not disowned the invoice. That she was issued with a wrong report of one Abdiwahab. It was her evidence that there was mishandling of her account at Mater hospital. That the lady she appeared with was her cousin and she never recorded any statement.

17. The Respondent’s case on the other hand heard on 29th October, 2025 and 26th November, 2025 where the Respondent called two witnesses and the first was Odhiambo Ooko herein RW1 the Senior Manager Employee and Labour Relations for the Respondent. He relied on his witness statement and bundle of documents filed with the Respondent’s defence as his evidence in chief.

18. In cross-examination he stated that he was employed in 2016 hence he was present at the material time but not in the hospital. That his evidence was based on investigation report from Minet. That they did not carry out independent investigations but adopted the Minet’s report. He stated that they did not interview the concerned doctors and that the investigator would testify on the report and further that they did not find it necessary to call the doctors during disciplinary hearing. They relied on the Minet report.

19. He stated that there was a CCTV footage presented at the disciplinary hearing. That the Claimant was accorded a fair hearing. She was supplied with Minet report and allowed to call witness. Regarding her service to the respondent, he stated that the claimant had worked for 16 years without any disciplinary issues and no warning was issued before the disciplinary hearing. That the termination was based on the Minet report and the recommendations of the disciplinary panel.

20. In re-examination RW1 stated that Minet was their medical service provider for all their employees. That they had no reason to doubt their report. That the Claimant was informed of her right to be accompanied by a colleague to the hearing.

21. The second Respondent’s witness was Mr. Mbae who worked for Minet Insurance Brokers as the head of security and investigations. He relied on his witness statement dated 4th May, 2023, the bundle of documents as well as the supplementary bundle of documents as his evidence in chief.

22. In cross-examination RW2 stated that he was employed by Minet and his role was to investigate claims and allegations of fraud. That on 29th June, 2021 he was not present at Mater Hospital. That what is stated was from his investigations. That he never received a written statement from Dr. Wanjema and that he did not work at Mater and he did not see the Claimant and the cousin at Mater as alleged. He further stated that Dr. Wanjema was at the material time at AAR Hospital and he established Dr. Bor was present at Mater but did not record his statement. That Dr. Sitonik was corresponding with Minet. That he requested to confirm if Dr. Wanjema was at AAR Buruburu. That the claim forms had AAR stamp.

23. He stated that others had stamp from Mater. That Dr. Wanjema was on duty at AAR Buruburu. That he suspected that the doctor was colluding with the Claimant because one claim form had a stamp for Mater while the claim for 28th June, 2021 had AAR stamp. That they received confirmation that Dr. Wanjema was on both days on full coverage at AAR Buruburu.

24. He stated that it was Dr. Bor who saw the patient. The hospital administration confirmed. That the person who did the ultrasound confirmed. That he did not see the Doctor’s recommendation for ultrasound. That none of Mater Hospital staff recorded statement. That he took notes.

25. He stated that he received the CCTV footages but it was not before the court. That he knew how to review CCTV but did not have certificate on photography and CCTV review. That he recommended the Claimant to be reexamined by a doctor appointed by Minet and he was not aware if Safaricom followed his recommendation.

26. RW2 stated that his report was complete. That he did not furnish the Claimant with the report as it was a report to the management for administrative actions. That he furnished the Claimant with claim forms purported to have been signed by her.

27. He stated that he confirmed that it was the Claimant who swiped the card at Mater and once she swiped the card she was the one to be treated.

28. In re-examination he stated that the email was part of investigations to verify the claim forms. That he interviewed the Claimant and recorded a statement. That the person who accompanied her to Mater did not appear before him. That he called her through. That there was report from Mater of what happened.

CLAIMANTS’ SUBMISSIONS

29. The Claimant’s advocates Gregory Ndege & Associates Advocates filed written submissions dated 16th December, 2025 and on the issue of procedural fairness relied on section 41 of the Employment Act. That the Respondent failed to:-

a. Issue a proper and detailed show-cause letter.

b. Provide the Claimant with the Minet report or alleged CCTV footage.

c. Allow the Claimant to question witnesses.

d. Produce any hospital personnel or doctor for verification.

30. Counsel submitted that this was a breach of natural justice and statutory fairness as was in the case of Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] eKLR.

31. On the issue of substantive justification counsel relied on Sections 43 & 45 of the Employment Act. That the Respondent must prove the reasons for termination were valid and fair. The alleged reason of fraudulent use of medical card was based solely on the Minet investigation report. That the report was hearsay, inconclusive, contradictory and unverified. That the same internally recommended further medical examination, proving it was not complete. Counsel relied on the cases of Kenfreight (E.A) Ltd v Benson Nguti [2016] eKLR and Loice Otieno v KCB Ltd [2013] eKLR to submit that the Respondent therefore failed the test under Sections 43 & 45 of the Employment Act.

32. Counsel further relied on Article 41 which guarantees fair labour practices. That the Claimant had 16 years of clean, exemplary service. Dismissing her abruptly, without conclusive evidence and without due process, was disproportionate, unfair and contrary to the principle of progressive discipline as was held in the case Kenya Revenue Authority v Menginya Salim Murgani [2010] eKLR.

33. It was submitted that the Claimant was subjected to harsher treatment than other employees with similar medical card issues and this amounted to selective discipline, unequal treatment and discrimination. Counsel relied on the case of GMV v Bank of Africa [2013] eKLR. The Respondent relied almost entirely on the testimony and report of Mr. Genson Ngare, investigator from Minet Insurance.

34. Counsel submitted that cross-examination exposed several fatal weaknesses:

a. He never met or interviewed Dr. Wanjema.

b. The CCTV footage was never produced.

c. No hospital witness testified.

d. AAR Healthcare admitted an administrative error.

e. His report was inconclusive and recommended further medical review.

35. Counsel submitted further that the Respondent’s own witness, Mr. Genson Ngare, made critical admissions that completely undermine the Respondent’s case:

a. He confirmed that his own recommendations were not followed, including the recommendation for further medical examination, demonstrating the investigation was incomplete and inconclusive.

b. Mr. Ngare admitted that the Radiologist acted in his own volition, without proper verification of the Claimant’s identity or card usage, showing irregularity and lack of procedural integrity.

c. Most importantly, the witness confirmed that Dr. Wanjema was NOT at Mater Hospital on 28th or 29th June 2021, as evidenced by the email dated 31st August 2021 produced by the Respondent.

36. It was submitted that this fact:

a. Completely destroys the Respondent’s allegation,

b. Shows the medical form relied on is unreliable

c. Proves the Claimant did NOT facilitate any fraudulent treatment.

37. That these admissions demonstrate:

a. The reason for termination was false,

b. The investigation was defective,

c. The dismissal was substantively unfair,

d. And the process was procedurally unlawful.

38. The Respondent’s own witness confirmed the Claimant’s innocence. This makes the Respondent’s evidence unreliable. That the Respondent dismissed the Claimant unfairly, unlawfully, without proof, and in violation of constitutional and statutory safeguards. In lieu of this, the Claimant, under Section 49 and as relied upon in the case of Banking, Insurance & Finance Union v Barclays Bank [2014] eKLR and urged the court to allow the claimant’s prayers in her statement of claim.

RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

39. The Respondent’s Advocates Munyao Muthama & Kashindi Advocates filed written submissions dated 20th March, 2026 and on the issue of whether there was a valid reason for termination, counsel submitted that in 2021, the Respondent’s medical scheme provider was Minet Kenya Insurance Brokers Limited and that sometime in June 2021, the Respondent received a report from Minet alleging that the Claimant had misused her medical card at a hospital to extend benefits to an ineligible individual. Minet indicated that it would conduct investigations and advise the Respondent on the appropriate course of action.

40. That Minet’s investigation was handled by Genson Mbae, the Investigations Manager, who submitted a report dated 12th July 2021 summarizing the investigation process, the outcome and recommendations. On 29th June 2021, Minet’s case management team was alerted by Mater Hospital Buruburu that there was a suspected case of fraud involving the Claimant. The Claimant had arrived at the hospital at about 9.55 a.m. accompanied by a woman who was later identified to be her cousin, Lilian Omondi. The Claimant presented her benefits card at the registration desk and was referred to the triage section.

41. That she entered the triage area with her cousin, and while there, Lilian Omondi falsely identified herself as the Claimant to the triage nurse. Following triage, the Claimant’s cousin, acting as an impostor, presented herself to the gynecologist for examination, after which she was referred to the radiology department for an ultrasound scan.

42. That the women disappeared from the hospital at around 11:00 a.m. and returned at 3:00 pm. When they returned, they went into the radiology room for the ultrasound scan where Lilian Omondi was scanned and after that, the Claimant went for a nutrition consultation. That when the Claimant returned to the registration area with her benefits card for billing, the radiologist who had earlier conducted the ultrasound scan came to the desk to print the scan report. He noticed that the card being swiped bore the same name as the patient he had just examined, yet it was not the same individual. This discrepancy immediately raised suspicion of fraud.

43. That the radiologist reported the matter to the hospital administration immediately. The hospital acted by confiscating the Claimant’s medical card for fraud and demanded for payment of the services administered by cash. The Claimant tried to plead with the hospital administration to be pardoned and for the hospital not to report the incident but this was refused. The Claimant paid the bill of Kshs. 8,300 using her debit card and left. The medical card was forwarded to Minet for further action.

44. It was submitted that in his investigation, Mr. Mbae visited the hospital in question and interviewed the personnel present on 29th June 2021. He also reviewed documentary records, CCTV footage and the Claimant’s Smart report (the medical card record which tracks utilization of benefits).

45. That Mr. Mbae obtained a statement from N. Kimeu of Mater Hospital. The statement provides an account of the events that occurred and were observed at the hospital during the Claimant’s visit with her cousin, Lilian Omondi:

a. Both women proceeded together to the triage room, with the Claimant dressed in a yellow top and her cousin in a black and white trench coat.

b. Lilian Omondi was examined by the gynecologist and referred for a laboratory test and ultrasound scan.

c. The nurse began the billing process and requested the patient to place her finger on the reader. Lilian hesitated, prompting both women to leave the room.

d. When the nurse returned to the triage room after searching for them, she found that a finger had been placed on the finger reader and the ultrasound scan had been authorized on the system. She did not see which patient’s finger had been used.

e. The two ladies disappeared from the hospital around 11am and returned at 3pm. It was at this time that they proceeded for the ultrasound exam.

f. Both ladies went into the radiography room but the person on whom the scan was performed was Lilian Omondi.

g. While waiting for the ultrasound report, the Claimant asked to consult a nutritionist. She placed her finger on the card reader and was charged for the nutritional service and proceeded for the consultation.

h. There was suspicion of fraud when the radiologist came to the desk to print the ultrasound report and saw that it was the Claimant whose card was being charged yet the person he had administered the ultrasound scan on was Lilian Omondi.

i. The triage nurse confirmed that she had attended to the Claimant’s cousin. Other hospital staff similarly confirmed that at the registration, triage, and radiography stages, the services provided were rendered to Lilian Omondi. Only the nutritionist indicated that he had attended to the Claimant. The staff were able to distinguish between the two ladies using the colours of the clothing they wore.

j. The Claimant, as the principal member, improperly used her medical card to obtain benefits for her cousin. After the fraud was uncovered, the Claimant’s card was confiscated and she was asked to pay for the services rendered in cash. The investigator also examined the Claimant’s Smart report. The Claimant was interviewed by Mr. Genson Mbae during the investigation. Mr. Mbae intended to interview Lilian Omondi to corroborate the Claimant’s version of events. Lilian however declined to give a statement. Mr. Mbae confirmed this in testimony. That Minet’s investigation concluded that the Claimant had attempted to use her medical benefits card improperly and recommended suspension of the Claimant’s medical card and disciplinary action. This report was submitted to the Respondent for action.

46. It was submitted that the Claimant challenged the submission of Minet’s report to the Respondent as improper and contended that, for purposes of these proceedings, the report amounted to hearsay. This position was untenable given that Minet was the Respondent’s appointed medical scheme provider and therefore had direct access to detailed information on the utilisation of medical benefits by staff, it was the most appropriate entity to investigate and determine whether any fraudulent use had occurred. The Respondent did not itself have access to this information, and having delegated this responsibility to Minet, it was justified in relying on Minet’s investigation and the findings arising from it.

47. Counsel submitted that moreover, the report could not be considered hearsay because its author, Mr. Genson Mbae, testified in court and formally produced it. It therefore constitutes a firsthand account of his findings and observations. Counsel relied on the case of Tafiri v James Finlays Mombasa Limited (Cause E097 of 2024) 2025 KEELR, where the court affirmed that a report submitted by an external investigator to an employer regarding fraud by the employee was proper and could be relied on.

48. It was submitted that on the strength of the report from Minet, the Respondent issued the Claimant with a notice to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against her. In the Claimant’s written response, she explained the events of 29th June 2021 and revealed new details which had previously not been disclosed to the investigator.

49. Counsel submitted that the Claimant’s account to her employer materially contradicted the version she provided to the investigator, giving rise to questions that cast doubt on her credibility. Regarding her explanation that she was called to school to attend to her sick son, the Claimant could not explain in her testimony why this important detail was not disclosed to the investigator.

50. It was submitted that she claimed that the gynecologist who attended to her had already left for the day and was therefore unable to interpret her scan results. This account was not supported by any information from the hospital staff. Moreover, it is implausible that if the gynecologist had indeed left, the hospital would not have had a back‑up doctor available or, at the very least, advised her on when to return for a follow‑up consultation to complete the required cycle of care. Given that she had already paid for both the ultrasound scan and the gynecologist’s fees, one would reasonably expect her to follow up on the treatment she had paid for. That this explanation was not truthful.

51. Further she alleged that her medical card had been lost by the hospital and she was forced to pay by cash. If this were true, it is unclear why she has never applied for reimbursement for expenses that were covered under her insurance benefits, as required by the Medical Cover Policy. She confirmed in her testimony before this court that she had not sought reimbursement to date. That the card was not lost but was instead confiscated due to fraud.

52. The Claimant alleged that she was in a dire medical condition and in significant pain, which she claimed necessitated her visit to Mater Hospital. However, the evidence showed that she left the hospital not because her treatment had been completed, but because the fraud had been uncovered.

53. If her condition were truly urgent, one would reasonably expect her to seek immediate medical attention elsewhere, even if her card had allegedly been lost, in order to alleviate her symptoms. Instead, the Claimant testified that after leaving Mater Hospital without completing treatment, she did not seek further medical care until 2nd September 2021, almost two months later.

54. It was submitted that the Claimant alleges that she was issued with a scan report belonging to another patient. If that were the case, nothing prevented her from returning the incorrect report to the hospital and requesting the correct one, particularly since she had paid for the service. She could also have reported such a serious lapse to the insurer for appropriate action. She did neither. This raises the question: if her account were true, why did she not return to the hospital to obtain the correct report?

55. It was submitted that during cross‑examination, the Claimant acknowledged that she resided in Lang’ata. It was unclear why she opted to seek treatment at facilities located more than 20 kilometers from her residence. It was the investigator’s belief that the Claimant deliberately chose an area where she was not known in order to carry out the fraud. The inconsistencies in the Claimant’s explanations raised serious doubts about her account of events.

56. It was submitted that the Claimant presented evidence of claim forms that she alleged had been used for her treatment at AAR in Buruburu and Mater Hospital as part of her written response to the show cause. These forms showed that she was treated by Dr. Wanjema in both facilities. These forms were subjected to further investigation by the Minet team.

57. Counsel submitted that this evidence demonstrated that the Claimant had attempted to use her medical benefits at a different facility and when her efforts were thwarted, she went to Mater Hospital where the fraud was discovered later. That it remained unclear why, during both the disciplinary proceedings and the hearing before this court, the Claimant did not call her cousin or Dr. Bor who she alleges examined her to give evidence that could corroborate her version and confirm that it was the Claimant who received treatment. This was especially serious given that her employment and livelihood hung in the balance, and she should have done everything necessary to support her story.

58. It was submitted that the Claimant withheld this evidence because she knew that her cousin or the doctor could not truthfully support her account. Counsel urged the court to draw an adverse inference on this issue. That fraud intended to misuse medical benefits for an ineligible person is a serious offence. Insurance fraud is a fundamental violation of workplace ethics and the Medical Cover Policy, and the Respondent was entitled to treat it with the utmost seriousness. That this was a valid reason to terminate the Claimant’s employment.

59. On the issue of whether the Claimant was terminated in accordance with fair procedure counsel relied on section 45(2) of the Employment Act on what amounted to unfair termination. The Respondent followed due process in taking disciplinary action against the Claimant and duly complied with the provisions of the Employment Act and its own internal policy.

60. That investigation was carried out by Minet, the medical scheme provider. The Claimant was interviewed as part of the investigation to obtain her version of events. Relying on the findings of the investigation report, the Claimant was asked to show cause in writing as to why disciplinary action should not be taken against her by letter dated 17th August 2021 for fraudulently using her medical card to pay for treatment for an ineligible member. Attached to the letter was the report from Minet which was intended to assist the Claimant respond to the allegation against her.

61. That the Claimant submitted her written response in which she denied all the allegations that had been raised against her. The Respondent found the response unsatisfactory and by a letter dated 2nd September 2021 invited the Claimant to a disciplinary hearing on 7th September 2021. The Claimant was advised to be accompanied by a colleague of her choice.

62. That on 7th September 2021, the Claimant attended the disciplinary hearing wherein the issues that had been raised in her show cause letter were again presented to her and she was given opportunity to make verbal representation. This session was postponed for further investigation after the Claimant presented evidence of claim forms which necessitated further investigation by Minet. That Minet carried out further investigation and submitted further evidence to the Respondent.

63. That the Claimant was invited for a further disciplinary hearing by an invitation letter dated 10th September 2021. The hearing took place on 15th September 2021. That in both sessions, despite being aware of her right to be accompanied, the Claimant did not have a representative and was comfortable to continue without one.

64. That the disciplinary panel considered the Claimant’s representations (both written and oral) and found that the Claimant had committed fraud. It was therefore recommended that her employment be terminated.

65. That in line with these recommendations, the Respondent summarily dismissed the Claimant’s employment by a letter dated 23rd September, 2021 for gross misconduct for violating the terms and conditions of her employment as well as the Respondent’s Medical Cover Policy and Code of Conduct. That the letter indicated that the Claimant had a right to appeal the decision. The letter further indicated that the Claimant would be paid her terminal dues and issued with a certificate of service.

66. It was submitted that the Claimant’s dues were computed and paid to her in October 2021 and she was issued with a certificate of service. That the Claimant’s employment was terminated in accordance with due process.

67. On the issue of whether there was discrimination against the Claimant counsel submitted that the Claimant alleges that the Respondent discriminated against her by terminating her services unfairly, but she failed to meet the legal threshold required to prove discrimination. Counsel relied on among another the case of Machungo v Stanbic Bank Kenya Limited (Cause E304 of 2021) [2025] KEELRC 2145 (KLR) (18 July 2025) (Judgment), on definition of discrimination and further stated that the Claimant did not explain how her termination was based on any prohibited ground such as race, sex, religion, ethnic or social origin, or any other ground under Article 27 of the Constitution, section 5(3) of the Employment Act or Article 1 of ILO’s Convention No.111.

68. It was submitted that the Claimant claims that the Respondent completely disregarded the Claimant’s explanation and went ahead to terminate her services unlike other employees. The Claimant failed to identify any employee who was treated more favourably under similar circumstances and no evidence of unequal or selective treatment was adduced. Counsel relied on the case of Tafiri v James Finlay's Mombasa Limited (Cause E097 of 2024) [2025] KEELRC 3569 (KLR) (15 December 2025) (Judgment) where the court observed that the fact that the employer applies different sanctions to other employees is not, in itself, discriminatory.

69. It was submitted that the termination of the Claimant was strictly based on the findings from the investigation report and the subsequent disciplinary hearing where the Claimant was determined to be guilty of fraud. The Claimant claimed that the Respondent violated her constitutional rights to fair labour practices. That this had not been particularized or proven in accordance with Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic (Miscellaneous Criminal Application 4 of 1979) [1979] KEHC 30 (KLR) (Crim) (29 January 1979) (Judgment) and in any case, any alleged violations can be adequately dealt with under the Employment Act.

70. On the issue of whether the Claimant was entitled to the reliefs sought on the claim for unpaid dues from the date of wrongful termination of the Claimant's services till date of retirement (14 years left until retirement at 60 years) counsel relied on among others the case of Ngokonyo & 2 others v Telkom Kenya Limited (Petition E009 of 2025)[2025] KESC75 (KLR) (11 December 2025) (Judgment), where the Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal’s finding that anticipatory salaries are speculative and amount to unjust enrichment. The court stated that permanent and pensionable employment contracts do not create a life employment or a non-terminable employment till retirement. That such an award, even if merited, would be against the common law principle that the purpose of damages was not to enrich a party but to remedy and restore a party. See Patrick Nyoike v People Limited [2013] eKLR.

71. On the claim for Service pay for 16 years of service worked counsel relied on Section 35(6) of the Employment Act which provides the categories of employees who are exempt from service pay upon termination of employment contract. Section 35(6)(d) includes members of the National Social Security Fund (NSSF). That the Claimant's pay slip as seen in both the Respondent’s and Claimant’s bundle of documents highlight that the Respondent was making contributions on behalf of the Claimant towards the NSSF. The Claimant is thus a member exempt from the benefit of service pay as per Section 35(6). Counsel relied on the case of Mary Help the Sick Mission Hospital & another v Ngung’u (Employment and Labour Relations Appeal E198 of 2022) [2025] KEELRC 1938 (KLR) (30 June 2025) (Judgment), on this assertion.

72. On the claim for special damages counsel submitted that in the Claimant’s particulars of special loss and damage, she claims a staff benefit phone after 18 months of Kshs. 35,000. That the letter of appointment as seen in the Claimant’s bundle of documents. These are benefits which were provided by the Respondent to its employees during the period of service and based on actual performance of the contract. Counsel relied on the case of Andrew Maina Githinji & another [2016] eKLR, the Court held that the act of terminating employment ends the enjoyment of any employment benefit.

73. On the claim for Certificate of Service, it was submitted that the Respondent acknowledges its statutory obligation under Section 51 of the Employment Act to issue a certificate of service upon termination of employment. The Claimant was issued her certificate of service which was at page 30 of the Respondent’s bundle.

74. On the claim for damages for discrimination, it was submitted that it was denied that the Respondent discriminated against the Claimant in the termination of her employment as alleged or at all, and no evidence has been adduced to support this claim. The court ought to decline this award.

75. On the damages for wrongful dismissal it was submitted as submitted above, the Respondent had valid and reasonable grounds to terminate the Claimant’s employment. The Court should therefore dismiss this claim in its entirety.

76. On the claim for pecuniary damages it was submitted that the Claimant prays for an award of pecuniary damages in her submissions. That there were valid and reasonable grounds for the Claimant’s dismissal and she has not established any clear basis to justify the award.

77. On the claim for dues from Safaricom Employees’ Pension Scheme it was submitted that the Pension Scheme was a separate entity from the Respondent and has its own rules and regulations on how funds are to be withdrawn or transferred. The Claimant ought to apply to the scheme to access her funds. The Respondent has no control over the scheme.

DETERMINATION

78. This court albeit the long pleadings by parties has reviewed and considered the pleadings, testimonies, submissions and authorities relied on by all parties and has I have come up with three main issues: -Aa. aa.

a. WhetherWhether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful.

b. Whether the Claimant was discriminated against by the Respondent.

c. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWheWhether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful

79. The courts have always held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court is guided by the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others. On the substantive test the employer must give a fair and valid reason as per section 43 of the Employment Act. Section 45 of the Employment was clear that where there was no valid and fair reasons such termination was unfair. Section 44 of the Employment Act ,2007 stipulated when summary dismissal could occur in particular under Section 44(4) (g) of the Employment Act, warranted summary dismissal on grounds of gross misconduct and especially in a case where an employee commits, or on reasonable and sufficient grounds was suspected of having committed, a criminal offence against or to the substantial detriment of his employer or his employer's property.

80. It was not in dispute that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent in 2005 as a customer care representative and rose in ranks to Quality Analyst and her last gross salary was Kshs 203,632.79/=. In this case the Claimant was suspected of using her medical card to treat her cousin one Lilian Omondi which is fraud and a criminal offence as per the Act which is a gross misconduct and a ground for summary dismissal.

81. In this case the Claimant received a show cause letter dated 17th August, 2021 which stipulated the charge as fraudulent use of her medical cover to treat ineligible member on 29th June, 2021 at Mater Hospital BuruBuru. This was after investigations by the Minet Insurance Brokers which was the insurance engaged by the Respondent to offer medical cover for its employees.

82. Whereas the Claimant alleged that the Respondent did not undertake its own internal investigations this court notes that the insurance’s investigation was enough since the Respondent had delegated this duty of medical cover to it. Whereas the Claimant alleged that the reason for her dismissal was not fair, the evidence on record proves otherwise. In this case the Claimant who was residing in Langata and working in Waiyaki way opted to seek medical attention at Mater hospital in BuruBuru. She had attempted to seek medical attention at AAR BuruBuru the previous day on 28th June, 2021 where she was treated for contact Dermatitis. This court finds it suspicious why the Claimant would seek medical attention far away if at all she was sick as alleged.

83. The court also notes that it was the first time in two scheme years she attended the Mater Hospital on 29th June, 2021. This only leads to the finding that the Claimant was looking for a hospital she was not known to hide her identity and treat her cousin. The claimant’s evidence was also contradictory. In her claim she stated that after the triage she went and saw the radiologist and as she was waiting for the results, she went to see the nutritionist. In her evidence on oath in court, she stated that she first went and saw the nutritionist because the radiologist was busy.

84. The Claimant also alleges that her card was lost at Mater hospital but did not report to the insurance or her employer but applied for replacement. She also alleged that she was made to pay for the services rendered by swiping her debit card of Kshs 8,300/=but never requested for reimbursement as per the insurance policy. She also indicated that she never followed up with the gynaecologist after this day and if at all she was sick as alleged, it becomes difficult to understand why she visited hospital two months after in September but a different hospital whereas she had paid for the services in Mater hospital. She also alleged that she was given someone else ultrasound but she never returned the same to the facility for her right one and one wonders why she did not confirm the same while in the facility.

85. This court also notes that the claim forms were also contradictory in that the one dated 28th June, 2021 had the Mater Hospital stamp yet she claimed she went to AAR BuruBuru where she was attended to by Dr. Wanjema. The one for 29th June, 2021 where again she is said to have been seen at Mater Hospital had AAR stamp but again she was seen by Dr. Wanjema with contact dermatitis again. These forms illustrate she was seen by the same doctor different hospitals when it was confirmed that Dr. Wanjema on 28thand 29th June, 2021 was the resident doctor at AAR Buru Buru therefore he could not have treated the Claimant at Mater Hospital.

86. The court notes that from the invoice, the Claimant was seen by Dr. Bor and this was confirmed but the claim forms showed otherwise. The happenings at Mater Hospital by one Kimeu although he did not testify in this court and the CCTV footage used in preparation of the Insurance investigation leads to the finding that the Claimant used her medical card to treat her cousin one Lilian Omondi. It is suspicious why the said cousin was accompanying her in all rooms including the triage, consultation room and radiology room. Just as found by the investigative team the Claimant used her medical card to treat ineligible member. All the nurses apart from the nutritionist confirmed that they attended to the cousin since they could differentiate the two by the clothes they wore.

87. The Claimant was bound by section 47(5) to illustrate that her termination was unfair before the Respondent could be called upon to justify the grounds of termination. In this respect, the court will be guided by the case of Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited [2017] eKLR, the Court of Appeal stated:

“There can be no doubt that the Act, which was enacted in 2007, places a heavy obligation on the employers in matters of summary dismissal (Emphasis mine) for breach of employment contract and unfair termination involving breach of statutory law.  The employer must prove the reasons for terminating (section 43) – prove that the grounds are justified (section 47 (5), among other provisions.  A mandatory and elaborate process is then set up under section 41 requiring notification and hearing before termination.”

88. The Claimant was summarily dismissed as per her dismissal letter dated 23rd September, 2021 and the Respondent on the other hand was bound by section 47(5) to justify the reasons to summarily dismiss the Claimant. Section 43 of the Employment Act states that for termination or dismissal of employment to be held valid, an employer must have genuinely believed the reasons existed which caused termination of the employee’s service. Justice Professor Ojwang’ in the case of Kenya Revenue Authority Vs Menginya Salim Murgani, Civil Appeal No. 108 of 2009 as cited in Republic Vs National Police Service Commission Exparte Daniel Chacha Chacha JR 36 of 2016 (2016) eKLR observed as follows:

“There is ample authority that decision making bodies other than courts and bodies whose procedures are laid down by statute are masters of their own procedures. Provided that they achieve the degree of fairness appropriate to their tasks. It is for them to decide how they will proceed”

89. The Court of Appeal in Civil Appeal No 66A of 2017, Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019) eKLR held as follows on the standard of proof: -

“The trial court applied a skewed standard of proof, and, certainly, not the one provided for under section 43 (1) of the Act. It is improper for a court to expect that an employer would have to undertake a near forensic examination of the facts and seek proof beyond reasonable doubt as in a criminal trial before it can take appropriate action subject to the requirements of procedural fairness that are statutorily required. The standard of proof is on a balance of probability, not beyond reasonable doubt, and all the employer is required to prove are the reasons that it "genuinely believed to exist," causing it to terminate the employee's services."

90. From the above, it was clear the Respondent genuinely believed the Claimant to have fraudulently used her medical cover to treat ineligible member which was unethical and against its code of conduct under clause 2.4 and relying on the investigations carried out by the insurance the Claimant had committed a gross misconduct warranting a summary dismissal. The court notes that any reasonable employer in the same position as the Respondent would have lost trust in the Claimant where trust and honesty was paramount. The test is always whether a reasonable employer would terminate an employee based on the same facts as was held by Lord Denning in the often-cited case of British Leyland UK Ltd v. Swift [1981] IRLR 91 stated:

‘The correct test is: Was it reasonable for the employers to dismiss him? If no reasonable employer would have dismissed him, then the dismissal was unfair, but if a reasonable employer might reasonably have dismissed him, the dismissal was fair. It must be remembered that in all these cases there is a band of reasonableness, within which an employer might reasonably take one view: another quite reasonably take a different view. One would quite reasonably dismiss the man. The other quite reasonably keep him on. Both views may be quite reasonable. If it was quite reasonable to dismiss him, then the dismissal must be upheld as fair even though some other employers may not have dismissed him”

91. The Claimant who never denied her involvement in the activities only stated that she was the one treated and by carrying along her cousin, she did not bring her to impersonate her yet the evidence on record shows otherwise. This court notes that even though the Claimant had a clean history of disciplinary issues and a good performer, her gross misconduct was not so trivial to cause any reasonable employer not to doubt her integrity. The court is therefore inevitably driven to find and hold that the Respondent had valid and reasonable grounds to terminate the services of the Claimant as it did.

92. Regarding procedural fairness section 41 is the guiding law on the procedural fairness which must be adhered to by an employer. It is the Respondent’s case that the disciplinary process against the Claimant was procedural and fair.

93. This court notes that the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter of 17th September, 2021 which had the investigation report by the insurance attached which she responded to. She was invited to disciplinary hearing where she was heard first on 7th September, 2021 and 15th September, 2021. She chose to attend the hearing alone despite been informed to attend with a colleague of choice. She never came with her cousin who caused her all these troubles to corroborate her evidence when her butter was at stake.

94. The disciplinary hearing recommended her dismissal and she was issued with dismissal letter dated 23rd September, 2021 where she was again informed of her right to appeal but she did appeal. This court notes that she was given all the necessary documents to prepare her defence and given all the time to prepare for the hearing.

95. The court is therefore convinced that the Respondent followed the due process in terminating the Claimant’s services. In the above regard the court further finds and holds that in terminating the Claimant’s service the Respondent followed a fair procedure and had valid reasons hence the dismissal was fair.

Whether the Claimant was discriminated against by the Respondent

96. On the issue of discrimination, the same fails as the Claimant has not illustrated how she was discriminated against and on what account apart from stating that other employees were treated different without stating which ones.

97. In the case of Gichuru v Package Insurance Brokers Ltd (Petition 36 of 2019) [2021] KESC 12 (KLR) (22 October 2021) Discrimination was explained as follows:

“Discrimination was failure to treat all persons equally when no reasonable distinction could be found between those favoured and those not favoured. Not all cases of distinction amounted to discrimination. Discrimination could be said to have occurred where a person was treated differently from other persons who were in similar positions on the basis of one of the prohibited grounds like race, sex disability or due to unfair practice and without any objective and reasonable justification.”

98. Equally, in Francis Njeru Kariuki v Crown Paints Kenya Limited [2022] eKLR it was held that:

“According to the Court of Appeal in Barclays Bank of Kenya Ltd & another v Gladys Muthoni & 20 others [2018] eKLR –“…Discrimination means affording different treatment to different persons attributable wholly or mainly to their descriptions … whereby persons of one such description are subjected to … restrictions to which persons of another description are not made subject or are accorded privileges or advantages which are not accorded to persons of another such description…”

99. In the instant case, apart from stating that she was discriminated, the Claimant provided no factual basis for the allegation. It is the finding of the court that the Claimant has not on a balance of probabilities established that she was discriminated.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to reliefs sought.

100. On the issue whether the claimant was entitled to the reliefs sought, the court takes that view that after finding the summary dismissal was fair and lawful the Claimant is not entitled to compensation for unfair termination as per section 49 of the Act. The Claimant was paid her final dues as per the dismissal letter at Kshs 76,362.30/= after statutory deductions hence the Respondent owes her nothing.

101. On the claim for payment of her salary until retirement for 14 years this court notes that the same is untenable since employment relationships are not lifetime engagements and have termination clauses. Apart from termination there are other factors of life like death, redundancy, ill-heath etc which can cause the employment relationship to end.

102. On the claim for service pay the Claimant was a member of NSSF and NHIF hence within the exemptions under section 35(6) of the Employment Act.

103. On the claim for staff benefit phone at Kshs 35,000/= the same was a benefit once she was an employee and the same benefit can not accrue when she is not an employee.

104. On the claim for employees’ pension scheme the same should be followed up with the pension scheme which different from the Respondent.

105. On the claim for general damages/pecuniary damages for breach of constitutional rights and for pain and suffering the same also fail for there being no established breach of the constitutional rights or any harm suffered during employment relationship. Any harm suffered after the end of employment relationship cannot be attributed to the Respondent.

106. The Claimant was issued with certificate of service hence the claim for the same fails.

107. In conclusion the Claimant’s claim is found without merit is hereby dismissed costs.

108. It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi this 16TH day of OCTOBER 2026

Delivered virtually this 16TH day of OCTOBER 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-Appeals Division

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder