Employment law

Carolyne K. Muumbo & Co. Advocates v Onchwari [2026] KEELRC 14669 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
16 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC MISC. APPLICATION NO. E368 OF 2025

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

CAROLYNE K. MUUMBO & CO. ADVOCATES................APPLICANT

VS

ENOCH NYAKUNDI ONCHWARI…………….………….RESPONDENT

RULING

1 Before this Court is the Respondent/Applicant's Chamber Summons dated 30th March 2026, brought under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, Articles 50 and 159(2)(d) of the Constitution, Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Rule 33 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules and Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. He seeks the following orders:

1. Spent

2. THAT at the first instance and pending the hearing and determination of this Application. this Honorable Court be pleased to grant a stay of execution of the Certificate of taxation issued herein pursuant to the Ruling delivered on 5th March 2025.

3. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to enlarge time for filing a Reference under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order against the decision of the Taxing Officer delivered on 5th March 2025 and the resultant Certificate of Taxation dated 23rd May 2025.

4. THAT upon enlargement of time. this Honourable Court be pleased to admit the Applicant’s Reference (this Application) herein for determination.

5. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to set aside the Certificate of Taxation dated 23rd May 2025, and remit the Bill of costs dated 14th December 2024 for taxation de novo with full participation of both parties.

6. THAT the cost of this application be provided for.

2 The application is supported by the affidavit of Enoch Onchwari sworn on 30th March 2026 and his Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 27th April 2026.

Respondent/Applicant's Case

3 It is the Respondent/Applicant's case that the Applicant/Advocate filed an Advocate/Client Bill of Costs dated 14th December 2024 and taxed it in his absence. This culminated in the Ruling of 5th March 2025, taxing the Bill at Kshs. 650,325/-, and a Certificate of Taxation issued on 23rd May 2025.

4 He avers that he was never served with the Bill of Costs, Taxation Notice, Mention Notice or Ruling Notice. It is his case that the Advocate filed false affidavits of service, which the Court relied on in proceeding ex parte.

5 He states that the process server swore an affidavit of service dated 24th February 2025, alleging that he served him on 23rd January 2025 outside Kencom House and that he refused to sign. He avers that these contents are total falsehoods, that he does not know the process server and has never met him, and that he was out of Nairobi on the alleged date.

6 He contends that the mere claim that the process server once worked in the Advocate's office does not prove that he knew him. He adds that no call logs have been filed to confirm the telephone calls allegedly made to him.

7 The Respondent/Applicant avers that before the Bill was filed, his then advocates, Abidha & Company Advocates, had demanded a breakdown of the Advocate's fees and subsequently lodged a complaint against her. He contends that it would therefore have been easier to serve the Bill upon the said firm.

8 He further avers that the Advocate had his email address and WhatsApp number, through which they had previously communicated, and could easily have served him by those means.

9 It is his belief that the Advocate deliberately misled the Court on service so that she could clandestinely tax the Bill ex parte, being well aware that he would vigorously challenge it.

10 He avers that he only became aware of the taxation months later, when the Certificate of Costs was annexed to the Advocate's response in a disciplinary matter he had lodged against her before the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal. He states that the Certificate has to date not been served upon him.

11 In response to the Advocate's claim that it was served on Abidha & Company Advocates on 3rd June 2025, he avers that this does not mean he became aware of it on that date, as it was not served on him personally nor brought to his attention immediately.

12 On the delay, he states that upon learning of the taxation he filed a Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 seeking to set it aside. That application was struck out on 12th March 2026 for failing to comply with Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order. He explains that he did not issue a Notice of Objection and request for reasons because his advocate advised that he was not challenging the merits of the taxation, but only seeking to set aside the ex parte proceedings.

13 He therefore contends that the delay in filing the Reference was not deliberate. It was occasioned by lack of service and by the time spent prosecuting the application that was struck out.

14 He asserts that the Court has discretion under Paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates Remuneration Order to enlarge time where sufficient cause is shown, as in this case.

15 On the merits, the Respondent/Applicant avers that he has a credible response to the Bill. Given a chance, he will demonstrate that the Advocate had already been paid for her services from monies she received on his behalf, and that she would be required to refund substantial sums withheld on account of fees. Further, he made several attempts in vain to obtain an account or itemized fees from her.

16 In his Supplementary Affidavit, he avers that the Ruling of 5th March 2025 has an error apparent, as the Taxing Officer applied the wrong principle by increasing the entire amount allowed by one half. It is his case that only instruction fees are subject to that increase, while court attendances, drawings, correspondence and disbursements remain at the prescribed rates.

17 He further disputes items 1 to 79, 84 to 96, 106 to 109 and 123 of the Bill. He avers that the Advocate did not act for him in ELRC Cause No. 1180 of 2012, save to take delivery of the judgment and receive the decretal sum.

18 He also avers that a party and party Bill of Costs in that suit was taxed at Kshs. 339,800 and shared between the Advocate and the firm of Diro & Company Advocates.

19 He states that the Advocate orally confirmed to him that her share was her full and final remuneration in the matter. She knew he would have raised these facts had he been served, hence the false affidavits of service.

20 The Respondent/Applicant avers that he will be highly prejudiced if the ex parte proceedings and the Certificate are not set aside; as he will be condemned unheard, that the amount in issue is substantial, and that the taxation has a bearing on the matter pending before the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal.

21 It is his case that denial of participation in the taxation amounts to a breach of natural justice.

22 He maintains that the application is brought in good faith and without inordinate delay, and urges the Court to stay the Certificate, set aside the taxation and allow the Bill to be taxed afresh on the merits.

Applicant/Advocate's Case

23 The Applicant/Advocate opposed the application through a Replying Affidavit sworn by Carolyn Kalunde Muumbo on 17th April 2026 and an affidavit sworn on the same date by James Mbuvi, the process server.

24 It is the Advocate's case that she commenced these proceedings to recover her legal fees after successfully representing the Respondent/Client in ELRC Cause No. 1180 of 2012, Enoch Nyakundi Onchwari v Rural Electrification Authority, the Client having failed or refused to settle her fees as promised.

25 She denies that the Bill of Costs dated 14th December 2024 was taxed ex parte or that the Client was never served. She avers that there is sufficient and reliable evidence that he was duly served before the Taxing Officer delivered the Ruling on 5th March 2025.

26 It is her case that the Client was personally served with the Bill of Costs and the Taxation/Hearing Notice dated 31st December 2024 on 23rd January 2025, as evidenced by the Affidavit of Service dated 24th February 2025. The said affidavit was sworn by James Mbuvi, a licensed court process server, and denies that it is false.

27 She avers that the process server stated that the Client was well known to him, having met him on several occasions at her offices. The process server reached the Client through telephone number 0722527392, which she had supplied; and the Client has not denied that he frequently visited her office or that the said number belongs to him.

28 The Advocate avers that where service is disputed, the usual procedure is to apply to cross-examine the process server, a path the Client has deliberately chosen not to take. The Respondent/Applicant has tendered no evidence that he was out of Nairobi or engaged elsewhere on 23rd January 2025.

29 She states that the Client was served personally because no firm of advocates or agent had indicated to her that they had instructions to accept court documents on his behalf. Therefore, service was effected in accordance with Order 5 Rule 8(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules.

30 In his affidavit, James Mbuvi avers that the contents of his Affidavit of Service are true and that the Client was duly served on 23rd January 2025, but refused to sign and acknowledge receipt.

31 He states that he works in the Advocate's offices, where he met and spoke with the Client in 2021, 2022 and 2023, and that the Client used to call him to ask whether the Advocate was in the office.

32 He avers that he called the Client on 22nd January 2025 and that they agreed to meet the following day. According to the Affidavit of Service, they met at the Kencom Bus Stop, near the front entrance of Kenya Commercial Bank.

33 He states that the Client took possession of the documents but declined to sign the principal copies, saying he first had to read them. Further, he informed the Client that the matter was coming up before the Deputy Registrar on 13th February 2025.

34 The process server states that he can identify the Client and is ready to avail himself should the Court require clarification. He maintains that the Client's averments on service are absolutely untrue and should be disregarded.

35 On the fees, the Advocate avers that the Client never paid her for the legal services rendered. She terms as absolutely untrue his allegation that she has already been paid and would be required to refund him, contending that no evidence of payment or overpayment has been tendered.

36 It is her case that the Client had promised to settle her costs in three matters, namely ELRC Cause No. 1180 of 2012, ELRC Cause No. 2036 of 2017 and ELRC Misc. Application No. 137 of 2017, immediately upon receiving his award in ELRC Cause No. 2036 of 2017.

37 She avers that he instead demanded, through a letter dated 27th June 2023 from Musyoki Mogaka & Co. Advocates, that she releases the entire monies without deducting her fees. This, she states, was despite an undertaking to pay her fees that he signed on 5th August 2019.

38 She avers that the Client thereafter lodged a complaint against her before the Disciplinary Tribunal, being DT Case No. 96 of 2024. She states that he sought a refund of Kshs. 2,446,990 with interest and her suspension from practice, well knowing that he had not paid her fees. It is her position that it beats logic why he would not want her to rely on the Certificate of Taxation to answer those allegations.

39 On delay, the Advocate avers that the Client admits he learnt of the Certificate of Taxation from her Replying Affidavit in the disciplinary matter. The said affidavit was served upon his advocates, Abidha & Co. Advocates, on 3rd June 2025, as evidenced by their receiving stamp.

40 She contends that the Client nonetheless waited over five months to file the Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025, which was dismissed on 12th March 2026, and that close to ten months had passed by the time the present application was filed.

41 It is her case that the delay is inordinate and has not been substantively explained, therefore, the Respondent/Applicant ought to have sought extension of time to file a Reference immediately upon service on 3rd June 2025.

42 On the merits of the taxation, the Advocate avers that the Bill was drawn at Kshs. 1,478,852.10 and allowed at Kshs. 650,325. The Taxing Officer delivered a detailed and reasoned Ruling in which a significant amount was taxed off, which demonstrates that the Taxing Officer discharged her duty as required.

43 She contends that the Client has not identified the items he takes issue with, nor pointed out the exact errors of principle. He has failed to demonstrate that a different result would be reached were the taxation repeated; and what he seeks is taxation de novo, an exercise that has already been concluded.

44 The Advocate further relies on Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order. She avers that sub-paragraphs (1) and (2) require an objector to give notice of the items of taxation objected to and to set out the grounds of objection in the Chamber Summons.

45 She contends that the present application does not set out the items objected to. Even if time were enlarged, she avers, there would be nothing for the Court to determine, as the application does not meet the requirements of a Reference.

46 It is the Applicant/Advocate’s case that the procedure for challenging a taxing officer's decision is strict and special, requiring precise adherence to both procedural steps and content requirements.

47 She maintains that the application is fatally defective, incompetent, frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the court process, and urges that it be struck out or dismissed with costs.

Respondent/Applicant's Submissions

48 The Respondent/Applicant filed written submissions dated 27th April 2026. He began by submitting that the right to a fair hearing is sacrosanct, and that the twin rules of natural justice, that no man shall be a judge in his own cause and that no man shall be condemned unheard, are an embodiment of the duty to act fairly.

49 He submitted that the main contention in his application is that the taxation proceeded ex parte, as he was not served with the Bill of Costs, the taxation notice, the Ruling or the resultant Certificate of Taxation.

50 On whether time should be enlarged, the Respondent/Applicant relied on Paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, which provides that:"The High Court shall have power in its discretion by order to enlarge the time fixed for sub paragraph (1) or subparagraph (2) for taking of any step; application for such an order may be made by chamber summons upon giving to every other interested party not less than three clear days' notice in writing or as the court may direct, and may be so made notwithstanding that the time sought to be enlarged may have already expired."

51 He submitted that a reference ought to be filed within 14 days of receipt of the taxing officer's reasons. In this case, however, reasons were neither sought nor given, as he only became aware of the taxation long after the 14 days had lapsed. He relied on Kipkorir,Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board [2005] KECA 325 (KLR) for the proposition that time for filing a reference starts running when the reasons for taxation are received, or when the applicant becomes aware that no reasons will be given.

52 It is the Respondent/Applicant's submission that he learnt of the taxation from a response the Advocate filed in the disciplinary matter. He then immediately filed a Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 to set aside the ex parte taxation, which was struck out on 12th March 2026 for non-compliance with Paragraph 11, whereupon he filed the present application. He argued that the delay was therefore not deliberate, but occasioned by lack of knowledge of the taxation proceedings and the time taken to prosecute the earlier application.

53 In support, he cited Thomas K’bahati t/a K’bahati & Co. Advocates v Janendra Raichand Shah [2018] KEELC 1912 (KLR), where the court held that:"Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order is clear that the Court has discretion to extend time for lodging a reference notwithstanding the expiry of the 14 days period prescribed for the reference from the Taxing Master's decision on costs. However, in exercising its discretion in this regard, the Court should consider whether there has been no inexcusable delay in presenting the application."

54 On whether there was inordinate delay, the Respondent/Applicant submitted that even if service of the Advocate's Replying Affidavit upon his former advocates on 3rd June 2025 were taken as proper service, it came long after the 14 days had lapsed, the Ruling having been delivered on 5th March 2025.

55 It is the Respondent/Applicant submission that the Advocate has in essence conceded that she did not serve the Ruling and Certificate of Taxation upon him. He maintained that the application was filed promptly upon his becoming aware of the taxation. He relied on Ivita v Kyumbu [1984] KLR 441 for the principle that justice should not be defeated by technicalities of delay where sufficient explanation is given.

56 On service, the Respondent/Applicant submitted that he was never served with the Bill of Costs or the Taxation Notice. He argued that although the process server, James Mbuvi, alleges that he telephoned him before serving him outside Kencom House, he failed to annex call logs from Safaricom or any independent record of such communication.

57 It was submitted that the affidavits of service are uncorroborated, unreliable and of no assistance to the Court. He urged the Court to disregard the Replying Affidavit, which relies heavily on them, and to find that the ex parte taxation was irregular and unjust.

58 He further submitted that he was at the time represented by Abidha & Company Advocates, who had formally requested summarised bills by letters dated 14th August 2023 and 4th September 2023. He contended that the Advocate neither responded to those requests nor served the Bill of Costs upon the said firm, despite knowing that the complaint against her had been lodged through it.

59 It is his submission that she instead opted for opaque means of service to hoodwink the Court, which demonstrates deliberate concealment and a breach of fair procedure.

60 The Respondent/Applicant also submitted that the Advocate had his email address and WhatsApp number, which they had previously used to communicate and which are recognised and acceptable modes of service. He argued that her choice to rely on contested street service outside Kencom House, rather than these reliable channels, demonstrates bad faith and undermines the credibility of her Replying Affidavit.

61 He invoked Article 50(1) of the Constitution on the right to a fair hearing, and submitted that proceedings undertaken on the basis of contested affidavits of service should be set aside in the interest of justice, failing which he would be condemned unheard. He cited Shadrack Arap Baiywo v Bodi Bach [1987] eKLR for the submission that where service is disputed, the burden lies on the party alleging service.

62 On whether the taxation and the Certificate of Taxation should be set aside, the Respondent/Applicant submitted that Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules empowers the Court to set aside ex parte proceedings where sufficient cause is shown. He maintained that his failure to participate was not deliberate but was occasioned by lack of service.

63 He placed reliance on CMC Holdings Ltd v James Mumo Nzioki [2004] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal emphasised that the discretion to set aside ex parte orders should be exercised to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence or excusable mistake. He further relied on Shah v Mbogo and Another [1967] EA 116, where it was held that:"…the Court's discretion to set aside an ex-parte judgment is intended to be exercised to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence, or excusable mistake or error, but not to assist a person who has deliberately sought (whether by evasion or otherwise) to obstruct or delay the cause by justice…"

64 The Respondent/Applicant submitted that, in the alternative to Order 12 Rule 7, he has invoked Paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, which requires an aggrieved party to identify the items of taxation objected to. He has done so in his Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 27th April 2026, the items being Nos. 1 to 79, 84 to 96, 106 to 109 and 123 of the Bill as taxed.

65 He argued that items 1 to 79, 84 to 96 and 106 to 109 ought to have been taxed off entirely, as the Advocate did not act for him in ELRC Cause No. 1180 of 2012, save to take delivery of the judgment and receive the decretal sum.

66 As regards item 123, he submitted that the Taxing Officer erroneously increased by 50% items that are not subject to that increment.

67 It is the Respondent/Applicant’s submission that only instruction fees can be increased by 50%, while court attendances, drawings, correspondence and disbursements remain at their prescribed rates. He argued that by applying the increase to all items allowed, the Taxing Officer applied wrong principles of law.

68 He again cited Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board (supra) for the submission that substantial irregularity in taxation justifies an order for re-trial, the Court of Appeal having stated:"In our view, such an appeal can only be allowed on any of the three grounds specified in section 72 (1) of the Civil Procedure Act, that is to say, if the decision is contrary to law or some usage having the force of law; or the decision has failed to determine some issue(s) of law or usage having the force of law or where there is a substantial error or defect in the procedure provided by law which may possibly have produced error or defect in the decision on the case upon merits."

69 The Respondent/Applicant further submitted that the Advocate failed to deliver a summarized bill when it was demanded. He relied on Section 46 of the Advocates Act, which requires an advocate to first render an itemized bill to the client before commencing recovery. Thus, the Advocate’s failure to comply renders the taxation premature, and demonstrates that the Bill was filed and taxed with ill motive.

70 On stay of execution and taxation de novo, he submitted that the Certificate of Taxation dated 23rd May 2025 was obtained ex parte without service, and is now being used by the Advocate before the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal. He argued that unless it is stayed and set aside, he will be compelled to pay costs he disputes and will be prejudiced in prosecuting his complaint. He relied on Butt v Rent Restriction Tribunal [1982] KLR 417 for the principle that the Court should exercise its discretion to prevent substantial loss and ensure justice.

71 The Respondent/Applicant submitted that he has a credible defence to the Bill of Costs. The Advocate did not give credit for the amount she received out of the party and party costs taxed at Kshs. 339,800 in ELRC Cause No. 1180 of 2012. Had that amount been taken into account, he submitted, the sum allowed would have been much lower, and she would be required to refund substantial sums once the accounts are properly scrutinized. He contended that taxation de novo with both parties participating will ensure transparency and fairness, especially given the pending disciplinary proceedings.

72 The Respondent/Applicant relied on Article 50(1) of the Constitution, which guarantees every person the right to have a dispute decided in a fair and public hearing, and Article 159(2)(d), which provides that justice shall be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities. He urged the Court to enlarge time, stay execution of the Certificate of Taxation, set aside the ex parte taxation proceedings, remit the Bill of Costs dated 14th December 2024 for taxation de novo, and award him the costs of the application.

Applicant/Advocate’s Submissions

73 The Applicant/Advocate identified four issues for determination, namely: whether the Client was duly served in line with the Affidavit of Service dated 24th February 2025; whether he should have sought to cross-examine the process server; whether the application has been brought timeously; and whether he has established a prima facie case to warrant the orders sought.

74 On service, the Applicant/Advocate submitted that the allegations of non-service have been vehemently denied. In answer to the contention that the Bill of Costs and Taxation Notice ought to have been served upon Abidha & Co. Advocates, she submitted that the said firm has never been on record for the Client in this matter. She argued that this is why he has not annexed any Memorandum of Appearance, Notice of Appointment of Advocates or letter addressed to her indicating that pleadings should be served upon that firm.

75 It is the Applicant/Advocate’s submission that the Client was personally served in line with Order 5 Rule 8(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, and had a duty to deliver the documents to his advocates if he was desirous of challenging the Bill of Costs. She relied on Order 5 Rule 8, which provides that:"8. (1) Wherever it is practicable, service shall be made on the defendant in person, unless he has an agent empowered to accept service, in which case service on the agent shall be sufficient. (2) A Summons may be served upon an advocate who has instructions to accept service and to enter an appearance to the summons and Judgment in default of appearance may be entered after such service."

76 The Applicant/Advocate submitted that personal service is the principal mode of service, which the law has not done away with. She argued that the Client has not demonstrated that there was an agent or advocate with instructions to accept service on his behalf, nor that she was aware of any alternative postal, workplace or home address at which he could be served.

77 The Advocate further submitted that the Client has not denied that telephone number 0722527392, which the process server used to establish contact with him, belongs to him. She contended that he has equally provided no evidence that his phone is linked to WhatsApp or that he previously communicated with her through that medium, so as to justify his contention that he ought to have been served by WhatsApp. Neither has the Respondent/Applicant provided evidence that he was out of Nairobi or engaged elsewhere on 23rd January 2025.

78 It was submitted that the process server, by his affidavit of 17th April 2026, confirmed that he served the Client and clarified the manner of service. The process server works in her law firm, which is how he came to know the Client, and that the Client used to call him on his telephone number in 2021, 2022 and 2023. She urged the Court to find the contents of the Affidavit of Service unchallenged and therefore true.

79 In support, the Advocate relied on Telcom Kenya Limited v EM Communication Limited T/A Popote Wireless, Civil Case No. 375 of 2010, where a defendant sought to set aside a judgment on the allegation that the process server had sworn a false affidavit of service. She submitted that the court there found that the process server had largely met the required standard, having indicated the date and time of service, how he came to know the place of service and the manner in which service was effected.

80 Therefore, she urged the Court to find that the Affidavit of Service herein meets the standard set out in that decision as follows:"A person serving the process must state in a return service the time when the service was effected on the person served; the manner in which the summons were served; the name of the person who identified the person served to him and how he came to know the identifying person; the place where the service was effected and finally whether the person served was required to acknowledge service by signing and whether he complied."

81 She further relied on Jacinta Muthini Kavisi v Mark Macharia, Cause No. 90 of 2012, where the Industrial Court dismissed an application to set aside an award for want of service. The court there found that the process server had established contact with the respondent through his telephone number, and held:"The Court is satisfied that the Claimant served the Respondent at the various times and places indicated in the affidavits of service. The Respondent did not deem it necessary to cross-examine the Process-Server on any of the numerous affidavits of service, or the affidavit sworn in reply to the application by the Process-Server."

82 On the second issue, the Advocate submitted that although the Client accuses the process server of swearing a false affidavit, he has shown no interest in cross-examining him to establish the truthfulness or otherwise of its contents.

83 It was her submission that courts have held that the only way to discount the evidence of a process server is through cross-examination, there being a rebuttable presumption that court process was properly served. She relied on Raphael Ngure Wangunyu v John Gacheru Ndehi & Edward Ndehi Kamau, Civil Appeal E047 of 2021, where the High Court upheld a refusal to set aside an ex parte judgment, stating:"Raphael needed to be reminded that there is a presumption in favour of the process server. Raphael needed to shift that presumption and that would have been done if he successfully discounted the evidence of the process server by cross examining him."

84 She submitted that the court in that case was guided by the Court of Appeal in Dickson Daniel Karaba v John Ngata Kariuki & 2 others (2010) eKLR, which affirmed that there is a presumption that court process was properly served unless rebutted. The court also cited Karatina Garments Ltd v Nyanarua [1976] KLR 94, where it was stated:"Where one party to proceedings denies having been served with a relevant document, it is proper for the court to look into the matter; if the court is faced with conflicting affidavits as to the alleged service of process, it is proper that the deponents should be examined on oath in order to establish the truth."

85 The Applicant/Advocate further relied on Shadrack Arap Baiywo v Bodi Bach, Civil Appeal No. 122 of 1986, where the Court of Appeal cited with approval the following passage from Chitaley and Annaji Rao; The Code of Civil Procedure:"Presumption as to service – There is a presumption of services as stated in the process server's report, and the burden lies on the party questioning it, to show that the return is incorrect. But an affidavit of the process server is admissible in evidence and in the absence of contest it would normally be considered sufficient evidence of the regularity of the proceedings. But if the fact of service is denied, it is desirable that the process server should be put into the witness box and opportunity of cross examination given to those who deny the service."

86 She submitted that the Court of Appeal there concluded that the appellant bore the burden of disproving service, and that the burden was not discharged by mere denials, the process server's affidavit being much the stronger evidence.

87 It is the Applicant/Advocate’s submission that the Client herein has likewise failed to discharge his burden. She argued that it would only be just and equitable for him to do so through cross-examination, as opposed to condemning the process server unheard.

88 On the third issue, the Advocate submitted that the Client admits at paragraphs 4 and 21 of his Supporting Affidavit that he learnt of the Certificate of Taxation from her response before the Disciplinary Tribunal. The said response, being her Replying Affidavit dated 29th May 2025 in Disciplinary Cause No. 96 of 2024, was received by Abidha & Co. Advocates on 3rd June 2025, therefore, the Client became aware of the Certificate on that date.

89 She argued that it beats logic why he then waited over five months to file the Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025, and why the said firm, which he alleges was representing him, took no action upon receiving the Certificate. Therefore, this only goes to prove that the firm had no capacity to represent him herein.

90 She submitted that the inordinate delay has not been explained at all, and that the Certificate has already been acted upon by the Disciplinary Tribunal, which has given final directions in the matter. In support, she relied on Cecilia Wanja Waweru v Jackson Wainaina Muiruri & Another, Civil Appeal No. 49 of 2013, where a delay of 40 days in taking action after knowledge of a dismissal was considered inordinate. The Court of Appeal found the appellant in that case to have been indolent and to have slept on her rights, and declined to interfere with the refusal to reinstate her appeal.

91 On the fourth issue, the Applicant/Advocate submitted that the basic question is whether the Client has shown sufficient reason for the Court to enlarge time under Paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates Remuneration Order. She relied on Paragraph 11(1) and (2), which provide that:"11. (1) Should any party object to the decision of the Taxing Officer, he may within Fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the Taxing Officer of the items of taxation to which he objects.(2) The Taxing Officer shall forthwith record and forward to the Objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the Objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a judge by Chamber Summons, which shall be served on all the parties concerned, setting out the grounds of his objection."

92 It is the Applicant/Advocate’s submission that the Chamber Summons does not set out the items of taxation objected to. She maintained that even if the Court were to enlarge time, there would be nothing for it to determine, as the application does not meet the requirements of a Reference.

93 She further submitted that no draft Notice of Objection to Taxation has been annexed to the application, which makes it very difficult for the Court to determine the Client's claim.

94 The Advocate submitted that Section 51(2) of the Advocates Act recognizes that a Certificate of Taxation is final as to the amount of costs unless set aside or altered. She submitted that this finality does not oust the Court's jurisdiction to intervene under Paragraph 11 where sufficient cause is shown. She argued, however, that the Client deliberately failed to demonstrate sufficient cause and opted to make mere allegations, thereby failing to discharge his burden of proof.

95 The Applicant/Advocate further submitted that the Court should ask itself whether there is any justification in repeating an exercise that was properly conducted by the Taxing Master in accordance with Paragraph 16 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, when the Client has provided no evidence that a different result would be achieved.

96 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. The applicant has sought three prayers from this court:- stay of execution of the certificate of taxation, enlargement of time to file a reference and admission of the reference for determination.

97 It is worth noting that the bill of costs was filed on 14/12/2024 and taxed and a ruling delivered on 5/3/2025. The applicant has averred that he was never served with the said bill as he was out of Nairobi. Despite stating so, the applicant has not demonstrated to court that he was out of Nairobi as no evidence of where he was, was submitted before court.

98 The applicant also seeks enlargement of time within which to file a reference before court over the said taxation. He has contended that the delay was occasioned by lack of service and he knew of the taxed bill when it was attached to her response after he filed a complaint at the advocate’s disciplinary committee. The delay in filing the reference could be explainable on that account but does not explain the delay of filing application for over one year since the taxation in March 2025.

99 It is also true that the applicant avers that he knew of this taxation in November 2025 and he then filed an application to set the ex- parte taxation aside. The same was struck out in March 2026 and he then filed this application.

100 The applicant now wants to file a reference out of time. In order to allow the applicant have his time in court for ends of justice to be met, I would allow the application to enlarge time within which to file a reference and in any case within 14 days from the date of this ruling, in default these orders will be considered spent. Costs in the cause.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 16th Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder