Background
Spent
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Spent
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. 503 OF 2019
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)
BONIFACE WAYODI……………………….CLAIMANT/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
ELECTRO RESEARCH LIMITED…………………………RESPONDENT
MAXSIM KADOSH……………………………..OBJECTOR/APPLICANT
RULING
1 The Objector/Applicant filed a Notice of Motion application dated 15th May 2025 seeking orders:-
1. Spent
2. THAT pending the inter parte hearing and determination of this application, this Honorable Court be pleased to grant a stay of execution of the proclamation Notice dated 13th May 2026.
3. THAT pending the hearing and determination of the application herein, this Honourable Court be pleased to grant stay of execution of the Proclamation Notice dated 13th May 2026.
4. THAT upon hearing and determination of the Application herein, the Court the Court be pleased to vacate the proclamation and or attachment of the Objector’s moveable assets listed in the Proclamation Notice dated 13th May 2026.
5. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to permanently restrain the Decree Holder, acting though his agents, Mbusera Auctioneers or any other auctioneers from proclaiming, attaching and or selling the Objector’s properties as listed in the Proclamation Notice dated 13th May 2026, or any other property at all.
6. THAT the Court be pleased to raise, cancel, set aside, recall, lift and/or quash the Proclamation Notice dated 13th May 2026 for listing goods that do not belong to the Judgment Debtor.
Objector/Applicant’s Case
2 The Objector/Applicant seeks to have the proclamation of goods dated 13th May 2026 lifted on the ground that the goods belong to him and not to the Judgment Debtor.
3 It is the Objector's case that the Decree Holder, through Mbusera Auctioneers, commenced execution of the decree issued on 22nd May 2024 against the Respondent/Judgment Debtor, Electro Research Limited, and issued a Proclamation Notice dated 13th May 2026 listing various goods for attachment.
4 He avers that the proclamation was carried out at his private residence, that he is the sole and exclusive owner of all the goods listed, and that the Judgment Debtor has no legal or beneficial interest in them.
5 Nonetheless, the auctioneers proceeded with the proclamation despite knowledge of these facts, so that the intended attachment is unlawful, irregular and contrary to the law governing execution, and amounts to an unlawful interference with the proprietary rights of a third party.
6 The Applicant states that the Proclamation Notice was due to lapse within seven days, exposing his property to imminent attachment and sale, and that unless the Court intervenes he stands to suffer irreparable loss.
7 He further contends that the application raises serious and arguable issues on the legality of attaching a third party's property in execution.
8 In his Further Affidavit sworn on 13th July 2026, in response to the Claimant/Decree Holder's Replying Affidavit, the Objector describes himself as the Managing Director of the Judgment Debtor. He denies that the premises visited by the auctioneers are currently the Judgment Debtor's offices or place of business.
9 While conceding that the company may in the past have operated from the premises and used the address for correspondence, he avers that it has since relocated and no longer maintains offices or conducts business there.
10 It is the Applicant’s case that the premises are now exclusively occupied as the residential home of himself, his wife, Paulina Kadosh, and his family, and are not used for the company's business.
11 The Objector contends that the Decree Holder's reliance on historical correspondence, the termination letter dated 10th June 2019, the certificate of service and other documents issued several years ago does not reflect the present position on the ground and is misleading.
12 He similarly avers that information on the company's website and other records has simply not been updated to reflect its relocation, and cannot be taken as conclusive proof that the company operates from his residence.
13 It is the Objector/Applicant’s case that the auctioneers proceeded on the mistaken assumption, based solely on the outdated address, that the premises were the company's offices.
14 The Objector/Applicant avers that the Decree Holder deliberately failed to disclose that the company no longer operates from the premises, and relied on obsolete documents to justify the proclamation.
15 He further contends that the Decree Holder has produced no evidence that the company presently carries on business from the premises or that the proclaimed goods belong to it rather than being his personal household effects.
16 The Applicant maintains that the application is made in good faith, solely to protect his private residence and personal property from unlawful execution.
Claimant/Decree Holder's Case
17 The Claimant/Decree Holder opposed the application through a Replying Affidavit sworn by Boniface Wayodi on 16th June 2026.
18 The Claimant/Decree Holder avers that the application is misconceived, devoid of merit and brought in bad faith to obstruct or delay the administration of justice, since it raises no reasonable ground in law to stall execution of the decree.
19 It is the Decree Holder's case that the Objector is the Managing Director of the Judgment Debtor, Electro Research Limited, and that the company has operated from the same location as the Objector's residence.
20 In support, he annexed "BW1" a screenshot of the contact page of the company's website, which he states reflects its current contact details. The page gives the company's address as Lavington, James Gichuru/Convent Drive, P.O. Box 78409-00507, Nairobi.
21 He further avers that his termination letter dated 10th June 2019, his certificate of service and the subsequent correspondence on his termination, all on the Judgment Debtor's letterhead, show that the Objector's address and that of the company are one and the same. These are annexed as "BW2", and the letterhead bears the address of the corner of James Gichuru Road and Convent Drive, Lavington. Both the termination letter and the certificate of service are signed by the Objector as Managing Director.
22 The Decree Holder avers that the address on the website remains the same as the premises the auctioneers visited to serve the proclamation, which address is also on the Judgment Debtor's letterhead.
23 He contends that the Objector has deliberately distorted the material facts to avoid satisfying the decretal sum, and that the application is a delay tactic intended to prevent him from realizing the fruits of his judgment without any justifiable reason in law. He thus urged the Court to dismiss the application with costs.
Claimant/Decree Holder's Submissions
24 By way of background, he submitted that judgment was entered in his favour against the Judgment Debtor for Kshs. 1,665,301 together with interest at court rates until payment in full. He then instructed Mbusera Auctioneers, who obtained warrants of attachment from the Court and proclaimed the Judgment Debtor's goods. He argued that the execution was regular and lawful, and that all the proclaimed goods were located at the Judgment Debtor's premises at Lavington, James Gichuru/Convent Drive.
25 The Decree Holder further submitted that the auctioneers acted within their mandate under Rule 12(b) of the Auctioneers Rules, which in his view permits the attachment of goods found within premises associated with the judgment debtor. He relied on Ogembo Ondieki v Samwel Bosire Angwenyi & 2 others [2020] eKLR for the proposition that a decree holder with a valid decree cannot have it defeated by a judgment debtor's attempt to resist attachment by an authorised auctioneer.
26 The Decree Holder's central argument was that the burden lies on the Objector to prove his interest in the attached goods, and that he has not discharged it. He relied on Credit Kenya Ltd v John Ogega Nyangweso & Another, Milimani HCCC No. 559 of 1997, cited in Washington Jalango Okumu v Boffar Ltd [2005] KEHC 1162 (KLR), where Mbaluto J. held:"By virtue of Order XXI, rule 56 the burden is placed upon the objector to establish his claim to the attached property. This is to be established by credible evidence and not by unverifiable pieces of paper which can be collected from anywhere in the streets."
27 He also relied on Precast Portal Structures v Kenya Pencil Company Ltd & 2 others [1993] eKLR, the same authority the Objector cited, where the Court held:"The burden is on the objector to prove and establish his right to have the attached property released from the attachment. On the evidential material before the Court, a release from attachment may be made if the Court is satisfied — (1) that the property was not, when attached, held by the Judgment-debtor for himself, or by some other person in trust for the Judgment-debtor; or (2) that the objector holds that property on his own account."
28 The Decree Holder further cited Awo Shariff Mohamed T/A A.S Mohammed Investments V Abdulkadir Shariff Abdirahim & Another [2006] eKLR where Kasango J. held that the burden of proving a legal or equitable interest rests on the objector.
29 On the land rates receipt relied on by the Objector, the Decree Holder submitted that ownership of the premises is beside the point. He relied on Zingo Investment Limited v Miema Enterprises Limited [2015] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held:"It is our considered view that title documents or ownership of premises is not by itself sufficient in objection proceedings; there must be ample documentation of ownership of attached items. The issue is not ownership of premises but proprietary interest in the attached goods. If this were not the case landlords may well become objectors whenever a tenant's goods are proclaimed and this cannot be the law…"
30 Relying on Research Foundation of Kenya v Patrisio Njiru Njeru; Stephen Njeru Chiengo (Objector/Applicant) [2021] eKLR, where this Court dismissed an objection because the objector merely averred that the goods were his without producing evidence to show why. The Respondent submitted that the Objector's documents do not connect him to the attached goods, are random and are intended to frustrate execution.
31 It is the Respondent’s submission that the Objector has shown no direct, indirect or remote relation to the goods, and his averments are bare.
32 On the location of the Judgment Debtor, the Decree Holder submitted that the Objector produced no evidence that the company's offices are not in the same compound as his residence. He pointed out that the Objector does not deny being the company's Managing Director and has not disclosed where the company is now located.
33 The Decree Holder submitted that the company's current address, as shown on its website, which bears a 2026 date, and in all its correspondence, is the Lavington address where the proclamation was made. In his view, this shows that the auctioneers exercised due diligence in proclaiming at the company's known address.
34 The Decree Holder further asked the Court to disregard paragraphs 13 to 15 of the Objector's submissions. He contended that they rely on facts contained in the Further Affidavit, which has since been expunged from the record.
35 He therefore urged the Court to find that the Objector has produced no proof of purchase or ownership of the proclaimed goods and that the application was filed merely to deny him the fruits of his judgment. He asked that it be dismissed with costs and that execution be directed to proceed until the decree is fully settled.
36 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. The objector has filed this objection averring that the attached goods are his and do not belong to the company. The least this court would expect from the objector is to produce evidence of ownership of the goods to him as opposed to the company which he has not done.
37 The applicant has merely stated the goods belong to him but no evidence of this is attached. Whereas the court appreciates that a company is different from its directors, the objector has failed in producing evidence that the attached goods belong to him and not the company and especially in view of the fact that the attachment was done at the same premises where the company address is. In view of this omission, I find that there is no evidence before this court that the goods attached belong to the objector and therefore this application must fail. Costs in the cause.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 19th Day of October 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE