REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC PETITION NO. E100 OF 2026
BETWEEN
JOYCE NJANGO MWAURA ........................................ 1ST PETITIONER
JOSHUA KOROS KOMEN ......................................... 2ND PETITIONER (Suing on their own behalf and on behalf of other affected employees of the Kenya Institute of Mass Communication)
VERSUS
KENYA INSTITUTE OF MASS COMMUNICATION ........... RESPONDENT
SALARIES AND REMUNERATION
COMMISSION ………………………………………….... INTERESTED PARTY
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner’s case is that in 2018 the Public Service Commission (PSC) issued a circular merging certain job grades including M and N, and as such, the Petitioners were to automatically move to job group N. Consequently, there was to be an upward adjustment in house allowance from Kshs. 28,000/= to Kshs. 35,000/=, in addition to increment in basic salary. That the Respondent has failed to comply with the advisory causing the Petitioners loss of benefits as well as seniority.
2. That in response to a complaint by some of the Petitioners, the PSC invited the Petitioners and addressed the issue on house allowance, explaining that for the Semi-Autonomous Government Agency (SAGA), it was not automatic but it was expected that at some level they would do it.
3. That in addition the Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC) carried out job evaluation at the institute and vide circular Ref. No. SRC/TS/JE/PURT1/3/33/7 VOL. IV (83), placed the Petitioners in job grade KIMC 5, with housing allowance of Kshs. 35,000/=. That the Respondent concealed the information and continued to pay the Petitioners Kshs. 28,000/=. That the Petitioners engaged the Respondent in May 2024, but the engagements were unsuccessful.
4. That the issue at hand is the Petitioners demotion exhibited by the Respondent’s response that described their position as per the 2023/2024 SRC review, which indicated that they would enter the scheme at job grade 6 with Kshs. 116,000/=, yet their pay slip reflected Kshs. 96,000/=. That the matrix named annex 6A place Kshs. 116,000/= on KIMC grade 5. That the Petitioners were not immediately awarded allowances for this grade in June 2025 acknowledgement and promise to adjustment, yet their salaries were reduced to Kshs. 96,000/= from 111,000/=. That the Petitioners are unaware of the 2023/2024 SRC review that demoted them from KIMC 5 to KIMC 6, and neither was the same communicated, until 31st October 2025.
5. On discrimination in promotion, it was averred that the Petitioners, among other staff, have stagnated in the same job for years. That people with similar or less qualifications have been hired on the same or higher levels. That the same has caused the Petitioners loss of seniority, loss of opportunity for economic gain, and low morale. That the issues have been caused by poor scheme of services, a document detailing job descriptions, qualifications, and promotional paths. That the Petition is brought by the Petitioners on their behalf and that of the other affected employees. That the Respondent’s conduct amounts to violation of the Petitioner’s constitutional rights to fair labour practices, equality, fair administrative action and human dignity.
The petitioners pray for:
a. A declaration that the Respondent has violated the Petitioner’s rights under Article 27, 28, 35, 41 and 47 of the Constitution.
b. A declaration that the Respondent’s failure to implement SRC recommendations is unconstitutional, unlawful and amounts to unfair labour practices.
c. An order of mandamus compelling the Respondent to compensate the Petitioners all the unpaid salaries and house allowances from the time evaluation was effected till to date by SRC job evaluation of 2019 which puts the Petitioners in KIMC 5, which is Kshs. 644,000/= for house allowance and Kshs. 1,209,024/= for salaries for each Petitioner.
d. An order of mandamus compelling the Respondent to compensate the Petitioners all the unpaid salaries and house allowances from the time merger was effected till to date based on the merger of job group M and N in the mainstream civil service which took effect from July 2017 for house allowance being Kshs. 168,000/= and salaries being Kshs. 141,256/= totaling Kshs. 309,256/= for each Petitioner.
e. An order of mandamus compelling the Respondent to implement SRC recommendations Ref. No. SRC/TS/JE/PURT1/3/33/7 VOL. IV (83) forthwith.
f. An order of prohibition restraining the Respondent from further arbitrary reduction of salaries and allowances of Petitioners and other employees.
g. An order of compensation for the loss of income occasioned by unlawful salary reduction and failure to implement the SRC recommendations from 2018-to date.
h. General damages for violation of constitutional rights and unfair labour practices.
i. Costs of the Petition and interest thereon.
j. Any other relief this Honourable Court may deem fit and just to grant.
6. The Respondent opposed the Petition vide its Replying affidavit sworn by Peter Wakoli, its Director/CEO on 31st May 2026. In the Affidavit, the affiant relies on his affidavit sworn on 21st April 2026, in opposition of the Petitioners’ application. In the said Affidavit, the affiant deponed that under Article 230(4)(b) of the Constitution, the SRC is mandated to set and review remuneration for public officers, and the Respondent is bound to implement such determinations. He stated that the Respondent had at all material times complied with the SRC's directives. He explained that in its 225th meeting held on 2nd October 2019, the SRC approved a Job Evaluation basic salary structure for the Institute, implemented in two phases effective 1st July 2019, as communicated via a letter dated 3rd October 2019.
7. He deposed that under the 2019 review, the Petitioners, then in Job Grade KIMC 10 - D1, were entitled to a basic salary of between Kshs. 76,850 and Kshs. 111,508 upon full implementation, and that allowances, including house allowance, were to be retained at prevailing rates. He asserted that the SRC did not place the Petitioners at Job Grade KIMC 5 as alleged.
8. He further stated that under the subsequent SRC review (3rd Remuneration Review Cycle, FY 2021/2022–2024/2025), the Petitioners were graded at Job Grade KIMC 6, Job Evaluation Grade D1. He noted that in a letter dated 11th December 2023, the SRC advised that house allowances for KIMC 6 - D1 would remain at Kshs. 28,000 for the period 2021/2022–2024/2025, superseding any other advice. He therefore averred that the Petitioners were not entitled to a house allowance higher than Kshs. 28,000.
9. Regarding the alleged reduction of basic salaries, he explained that under the 3rd Remuneration Review Cycle, the SRC adjusted basic salary bands for KIMC 6 - D1 to a minimum of Kshs. 61,739 and a maximum of Kshs. 92,523 for FY 2023/2024 (Phase I) and to a minimum of Kshs. 64,650 and a maximum of Kshs. 96,885 for FY 2024/2025 (Phase II). He stated that at the time of implementation, the Petitioners' prevailing salaries were above the maximums prescribed, and the Institute adopted a salary protection mechanism in consultation with the SRC. He deposed that the SRC advised the Respondent to pay the Petitioners an increased basic salary of Kshs. 111,058 for Phase I and Kshs. 116,294 for Phase II, as part of the salary protection measure, with any amount exceeding the prescribed band categorized administratively as "special salary" for payroll purposes.
10. He averred that the "special salary" was a technical payroll classification necessitated by system limitations and did not constitute a separate or unlawful benefit. He stated that the Petitioners' remuneration remained within the SRC-approved framework and that the Respondent had not reduced their actual earnings in basic pay at any time. He explained that the salary protection mechanism did not amount to an upgrade to Job Grade KIMC 5, but was a measure applicable only to the Petitioners and other similarly affected employees. He added that the Respondent's Governing Council approved the Petitioners holding their grade and special salaries until communication from the SRC in the expected 4th Remuneration Review Cycle, and that the Respondent had written to the SRC requesting a job evaluation and consideration of a further salary review in that cycle.
11. He denied that the Petitioners had stagnated due to any fault of the Respondent, explaining that National Treasury Circulars directed that salary adjustments and upgrading in SAGAs be done only after SRC recommendations, and subject to funding availability from the National Treasury. He stated that the Petitioners had not exhibited any SRC directive recommending their upgrading which the Respondent failed to implement. He further averred that the Petitioners did not meet the qualifications for promotion to KIMC 5, as the Career Guidelines required a Management Course Certificate, among other qualifications, and that promotion was not automatic but subject to application, merit, vacancy, and budgetary approval. He noted that the Respondent had not received any application for promotion from the Petitioners.
12. He deposed that there could be no unfair labour practice under Article 41 where an employer implements binding directives and safeguards employees from loss of earnings. He added that the Petitioners had not demonstrated discrimination or arbitrary demotion. He asserted that the allegations of violations of Articles 27, 41, 47, and 232 were unfounded and without legal basis.
13. In the latter affidavit, the affiant stated that the Respondent is a Semi-Autonomous Government Agency (SAGA). He deposed that the SRC did not at any time place the Petitioners at PSC Job group N or KIMC 5, and at the time of filing this Petition, they were properly placed in KIMC 6. He stated that the Petitioner’s placement at KIMC 6 following SRC’s 3rd Remuneration Review Cycle for FY 2021/2022-2024/2025, was not a demotion as the Petitioners have never been placed at KIMC 5. He stated that the SRC Recommendation dated 3rd October 2019 (Ref: SRC/TS/JE/PURT1/3/33/7 VOL. IV (83) did not approve any increase in the Petitioner’s house allowance as alleged.
14. He denied the reduction of the Petitioner’s salary from Kshs. 111,000/= to Kshs. 96,000/= in June 2025. He stated that the Respondent had at all times complied with and implemented the remuneration structures and binding directives issued by the SRC and applicable to the Respondent. He added that the Petitioners have not suffered any loss of income arising from an alleged demotion or reduction of salary. He urged that the Petitioners have not demonstrated any violation of their constitutional rights or entitlement to the reliefs sought. He urged the Court to dismiss the Petition as it is devoid of merit.
15. The Interested Party respondent to the Petition vide its Replying Affidavit sworn by CHRP Ali Abdullahi Surraw who stated that pursuant to section 11(e) of its Act, the SRC instituted a four-year remuneration review cycle for remuneration and benefits in the public sector; and is mandated to advise on the remuneration payable upon such review. He further outlined the SRC constitutional and statutory mandates and the guiding principles. He stated that the Respondent is SAGA established under Legal Notice 197 of 2011 under the Ministry of Information, Communication and Technology, and therefore within the SRC’s advisory mandate under Article 230(4b) of the Constitution of Kenya. He deponed that the determination of Respondent’s employees’ remuneration is subject to and must be consistent with the SRC’s advice.
16. He stated that the Second Remuneration Review Cycle (2016/17 to 2020/21), the SRC undertook a job evaluation exercise at the Respondent. that upon completion of the same, it issued the approved job evaluation grading and basic salary structure to the Respondent vide letter dated Ref. No. SRC/TS/JE/PURT1/3/33/7 VOL. IV (83) dated 3rd October 2019. That the advisory advised the grading of positions relevant to this petition to be KIMC Grade 6 and not KIMC 5 alleged by the Petitioners.
17. That following engagement with the Respondent in the third remuneration cycle (2021-22 to 2024/25), the SRC communicated and approved salary structure for the Third Cycle vide Circular Ref: SRC/TS/24/7/196 dated 11th December 2023. That the said circular sets out the current advised salary bands, house allowances and other benefits applicable to each grade for the period, including the specific remuneration structure for KIMC 6. He added that the said circular contains the SRC’s current and authoritative advice on the remuneration and benefits structure available to the Respondent.
18. He stated the SRC confirms that the position held by the Petitioners is KIMC 6; which is consistent with the grading across both the second and third remuneration review cycles. He added that the evaluation of the positions at KIMC 6 reflects grade retention, as the relevant job descriptions did not reflect sufficient change in compensable factors to warrant a grade shift. He added that the SRC’s records do support the allegation that the Petitioners were at KIMC 5 and subsequently demoted to KIMC 6; as its grading results do not reflect any prior grade of KIMC 5 for the positions held by the Petitioners. He added that there was not demotion attributable to it or any of its advice.
19. He stated that all the actions undertaken by the SRC were in strict compliance with the Constitution, the SRC Act and other enabling statutes and were guided by the principles of transparency, accountability, fairness and fiscal responsibility. He stated that the figures claimed by the Petitioners are calculated on an incorrect grade basis and do not accurately reflect the Petitioner’s entitlements under the SRC advised remuneration and benefits structure. He added that any compensation order must be calculated on the advised rates applicable to KIMC 6. He stated that the Petition does not disclose any constitutional or statutory basis for any such relief sought against the SRC. He urged that the Petition be dismissed with costs to the SRC.
Petitioner’s Submissions
20. The Petitioners submitted on:
(i) whether the Petition satisfies the constitutional threshold for enforcement of fundamental rights and freedoms;
(ii) whether the Respondent violated Articles 10, 27, 35, 41, 47, 73 and 232 of the Constitution;
(iii) whether the Respondent acted contrary to the Employment Act 2007, the Fair Administrative Actions Act, 2015 and the Salaries and Remuneration Commission Act;
(iv) whether the Respondent violated the Petitioners legitimate expectation arising from the applicable public service circulars and remuneration framework; and
(v) whether the Petitioners are entitled to the declaratory, mandatory and compensatory reliefs sought in the Petition.
21. On the first issue, in submitting that the Petition satisfied the threshold, reliance was placed on the decision in Mumo Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 others [2013] eKLR. Further reliance was placed on the Communications Commissions of Kenya & 5 others v Royal Media Services Ltd & 5 others [2014] eKLR and Mitu-Bell Welfare Society v Kenya Airports Authority & 2 others [2021] KESC 34 (KLR) among other case law on constitutional scrutiny of decisions by public bodies.
22. On the second issue, it was submitted that the Respondent, being a public institution, was under constitutional obligation to ensure that every employment decision complied with principles of legality, transparency, accountability and fairness.
23. On the third issue, on violation of Article 41, of the Constitution reliance was placed on the decision in Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] eKLR as well as Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei & another [2014] eKLR, to submit that employment decisions by public bodies must conform to constitutional standards of fairness.
24. On violation of Article 47, reliance was placed on Judicial Service Commission v Mbalu Mutava & another [2015] eKLR and Suchan Investment Limited v Ministry of National Heritage & Culture & 3 others [2016] eKLR; in submitting that the Respondent has failed to demonstrate compliance with the constitutional requirements.
25. On violation of Article 27, reliance was placed on the decisions in Ol Pejeta Ranching Limited v David Wanjau Muhoro [2017] eKLR to submit that the Respondent had failed to demonstrate any lawful basis for treating the Petitioners differently from similarly situated employees.
26. On the violation of Article 35, reliance was placed on the decision in Katiba Institute v President’s Delivery Unit & 3 others [2024] KESC in submitting that the Respondent neither demonstrated any exemption under the provisions of the Access to Information Act nor offered any lawful justification for withholding the requested documents.
27. On violation of Articles 10, 73 and 232, it was submitted that the complaint was not directed at the SRC’s mandate, rather, the Respondent’s failure to faithfully implement the Applicable SRC job evaluation recommendations in a lawful and transparent manner. It was argued that public power cannot be exercised arbitrarily or in secrecy.
28. On the fourth issue, it was submitted that the Respondent frustrated the Petitioners’ legitimate expectation, thereby rendering its actions unconstitutional. Support was gathered from the decision in Communications Commission of Kenya Case.
29. On the fifth issue, it was submitted that having established constitutional rights violation, the Petitioners are entitled to the reliefs sought. Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court’s holding in the Mitu-Bell Case. Further support was gathered from Kenya National Examinations Council v Republic ex parte Geoffrey Gathenji Njoroge & 9 others [1997] eKLR.
30. On costs, reliance was placed on Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 others v Tarlochan Singh Rai Estate & 4 others [2014] eKLR.
Respondent’s submissions
31. The Respondent raised the following issues for determination are:
(i) whether the Petitioners were promoted from Job Grade KIMC 6 to KIMC 5;
(ii) whether the Petitioners’ house allowances were increased from Kshs.28,000 to 35,000;
(iii) whether the Respondent violated the Petitioners’ constitutional rights under Articles 10, 27, 28, 35, 41, 47, 73 and 232 of the Constitution;
(iv) whether the Respondent acted contrary to the Employment Act, 2007, the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015 and the SRC Act, 2011;
(v) whether the Petitioners have established a legitimate expectation capable of protection;
(vi) whether the Petitioners are entitled to the reliefs sought in the Petition.
32. On the first issue, it was submitted that the Petitioners were not under the alleged, unidentified PSC Circular of 2018 nor under the subsequent SRC’s 2nd or 3rd Remuneration Review Cycles. It was submitted that advancement between grades is provided for in the Respondent’s Career Guidelines approved by the PSC, and clause 2.7 provides that the same is on: merit, existence of a vacancy; and the approval of the Board of Directors for the purpose of staff promotion. It was submitted that the same Career Guidelines required that for appointment to Principal Lecturer (KIMC Grade 5), a Management Course Certificate as minimum qualification, and an application under Clause 2.7(ii). It was submitted that the Petitioners neither pleaded nor exhibited a completed Management Course Certificate, a formal application for promotion, or a vacancy at KIMC Grade 5 to apply for, and therefore the allegation of placement at Job Grade KIMC 5 is unsupported by any evidence.
33. On the second issue, it was submitted that the Petitioners identified no reference number or date of the alleged circular and exhibited none to the Supporting Affidavit the Petition. It was further submitted added that there was no explanation as to how the alleged circular addressed to mainstream civil service Job Groups M and N could bind the Respondent, a SAGA operating its own independent grading structure under the SRC’s direct advisory mandate, and not the PSC’s job-group structure.
34. On the third issue, it was submitted that the Petitioners' basic salaries were never reduced from Kshs 111,000 to Kshs 96,000 in June 2025, or at all, and no proof of any such reduction had been tendered. Reliance was placed on Section 107 of the Evidence Act. It was argued that the Petitioners produced no pay slip, payroll extract, or comparative pay record proving the reduction. Counsel added that the Petitioners failed to comply with the request to by the Respondent to bring the issue to the attention of its Human Resource Manager, indicating when the deductions occurred and how much has been deducted adding that the Petitioners further failed to adhere to the call for proof of demotion in the 6th November 2025 letter.
35. On discrimination, it was submitted that the Petitioners named no comparator, not one employee of similar qualification, promoted or hired at a higher grade with superior remuneration and benefits. It was urged that discrimination claim could not rest on generalized grievance; it required proof of differential treatment among persons in like circumstances, which proof the Petitioners did not tender. On the right to access Information, it was submitted that there was no evidence of any written request for information that the Respondent failed to address.
36. On the fourth issue, it was submitted that Article 230(4) of the Constitution and section 11 of the SRC Act mandated the SRC to determine and advise on the remuneration and benefits of public officers such as the Petitioners. Counsel added that the Respondent implemented every relevant SRC directive on the Petitioners’ remuneration and benefits to the letter, and, on the SRC’s advice, adopted a salary protection mechanism to prevent any diminution of the Petitioners’ salaries. It was urged that there was no unfair labour practice, or unfair administrative action where the impugned conduct is the faithful implementation of a lawful, binding remuneration directive.
37. On the fifth issue, it was submitted that legitimate expectation must rest on a clear, unambiguous and unqualified representation by a public authority. Reliance was placed on Communications Commission of Kenya & 5 Others v Royal Media Services Limited & 5 Others [2014] eKLR, at paragraph [269]. It was submitted that the Petitioners claim rested on no proof before the Court, and established no breach of legitimate expectation.
38. On the sixth issue, it was submitted that the declaratory relief presupposes a proven violation, and none had been proved, and the relief was unmerited. Reliance was placed on Republic v City Council of Nairobi (Nairobi City County Government) & 2 Others; Wambugu & Another (Ex parte Applicants) [2024] KEHC 9497 (KLR), applying Republic vs KNEC ex parte Gathenji & 9 Others [1997] eKLR, and the eight-factor test in Apotex Inc. v Canada (Attorney General) held that:
“8….an order of mandamus will compel the performance of a public duty which is imposed on a person or body of persons by a statute and where that person or body of persons has failed to perform the duty to the detriment of a party who has a legal right to expect the duty to be performed…”
…
10….The eight factors that the must be resent for the writ [mandamus] to issue are:-
i. There must be a public duty to act;
ii. The duty must be owed to the Applicants;
iii. There must be a clear right to the performance of that duty, meaning..,
a. The applicants have satisfied all the conditions precedent; and …”
39. It was submitted that the underlying duty to pay salaries and house allowances under KIMC 5, for which mandamus was sought had not crystallized, and the figures claimed had no evidential foundation.
40. On the Order of prohibition to restrain further reduction of salaries and allowances, it was submitted that the same was otherwise moot because the salary protection mechanism already in place existed precisely to prevent a reduction in Petitioners’ salaries, and the Respondent’s Governing Council had formally resolved to maintain the Petitioners’ protected position pending the SRC’s 4th Remuneration Review Cycle.
41. On compensation and general damages, it was submitted that the same have not been established, and thus unmerited.
42. On costs reliance was placed on Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 Others v Tarlochan Singh Rai Estate & 4 Others [2014] eKLR relied on by the Petitioners themselves. It was urged that the Petition had not been proved on a balance of probabilities and should be dismissed in its entirety, with costs to the Respondent.
Interested Party’s Submissions
43. The Interested Party submitted on the following:
(i) whether the Interested Party discharged its constitutional and statutory mandate by conducting a participatory job evaluation at the Respondent and issuing binding advisories correctly placing the Petitioners' positions at KIMC Grade 6; and
(ii) (ii) whether the Petitioners have discharged the evidentiary burden of proof in respect of their claims on placement.
44. On the first issue, it was submitted that the Interested Party discharged its constitutional and statutory mandate in full, and that its advisories correctly placed the Petitioners' positions at KIMC Grade 6. Reliance was placed on Teachers Service Commission v Kenya National Union of Teachers & 3 Others [2015] eKLR where the Court of Appeal held that:
"No valid salary and/or benefit of a state or public officer shall ensue from a process that ignores the role of SRC. The advice by SRC under Article 230(4)(b) of the Constitution is binding."
45. To reinforce the submission, further reliance was placed on the Court of Appeal decision in Salaries and Remuneration Commission v National Hospital Insurance Fund, Management Board & 2 Others (Civil Appeal No. 156 of 2016) [2024] KECA 419 (KLR) and the Supreme Court case National Hospital Insurance Fund Management Board v Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers (Petition E024 of 2024) [2025] KESC 37 (KLR)
46. Counsel submitted that the Respondent as the employing institution bore a direct constitutional obligation to implement the Interested Party's advised remuneration and benefits structure. It was submitted that the Respondent could not lawfully determine or alter the Petitioners' remuneration in a manner inconsistent with the Interested Party's Grade 6 advisory without acting in contravention of the Constitution. It was further submitted that upon issuing and communicating Advisories AAS-1, AAS-2, and AAS-3, the Interested Party fully and irrevocably discharged its constitutional and statutory mandate.
47. On the second issue, it was submitted that the Petitioners had not discharged the evidentiary burden of proof in respect of their claim that their positions were placed at KIMC Grade 5 under the Interested Party's advisories. Counsel invoked Sections 107 and 108 of the Evidence Act. Reliance was further placed on Communications Commission of Kenya & 5 Others v Royal Media Services Limited & 5 Others (Petition No. 14 of 2014) [2014] eKLR where it was held that a Petitioner must satisfy the Court that the facts alleged give rise to a constitutional violation, which requires placing sufficient evidence before the Court to establish the foundational facts. Counsel urged that the Interested Party's advisories - AAS-1, AAS-2, and AAS-3 – were thus the primary and authoritative evidence on the question of placement.
48. Counsel submitted that the advisories, as evidenced by the documents marked AAS-1 to AAS-3, placed the petitioners at KIMC Grade 6, not Grade 5. That in the absence of any evidence and given that the Interested Party's own records affirmatively established Grade 6, the Petitioners have not discharged the burden under Sections 107 and 108 of the Evidence Act; and the reliefs sought could not be granted. The Court was urged to find that the Interested Party discharged its constitutional and statutory mandate by conducting a participatory job evaluation at the Respondent and issuing binding advisories correctly placing the Petitioners’ positions at KIMC Grade 6; and that the Petitioners had not discharged the evidentiary burden of proof in respect of their claim of placement at KIMC Grade 5, or that the pleaded compensation figures are accordingly not grounded in the Interested Party’s advice. Accordingly, the Court was urged to dismiss all prayers directed at the Interested Party as devoid of merit, with no adverse order as to costs against the Interested Party.
49. The issues for determination are:
(i) whether the Petitioners have demonstrated that the Respondents violated their constitutional rights; and
(ii) whether the Petition is merited.
50. The Petitioners’ argument is that the Respondent violated their rights by demoting them and not paying them according to the correct job group, KIMC5.
51. After perusing the job evaluation by the SRC the court noted that the position of Senior Lecturer fell under KIMC 6, D1. A perusal of the pay slips availed by the Petitioners, revealed discrepancies in each, which reduced their evidential value though no objection was raised to their production, and neither had their authenticity been questioned. Going by the pay slips, the Petitioners’ are as Senior Lecturers and the Petitioners’ total earning were shown as ranging between Kshs. 150,752/= and Kshs. 334,738/=.
It is trite law that a pay slip is not a contractual document in an employment relationship but a pay statement issued under section 20 of the Employment Act.
52. On discrimination, the Petitioners alleged that there was discriminative pay between them and persons who had recently joined. However, no evidence was adduced to show the differential pay, no persons were named and pay slips of the alleged persons salary or an extract of the payroll was not provided as evidence in support of the allegation.
53. The court is guided by the holding of the Supreme Court in of Samson Gwer & 5 others v Kenya Medical Research Institute & 3 others [2020] eKLR, as follows:
“[51] In the foregoing context, it is clear to us that the petitioners, in the instant case, bore the overriding obligation to lay substantial material before the Court, in discharge of the evidential burden establishing their treatment at the hands of 1st respondent as unconstitutional. Only with this threshold transcended, would the burden fall to 1st respondent to prove the contrary. In the light of the turn of events at both of the Superior Courts below, it is clear to us that, by no means, did the burden of proof shift to 1st respondent.”
It behooved the petitioners to establish a prima facie case of discrimination against the respondent for the burden of proof to shift a burden then failed to discharge.
54. It is the finding of the court that the petitioners failed to prove that they were treated in a discriminatory manner.
55. On human dignity, other than the allegation that the Respondent’s conduct infringed Article 28, no facts or evidence was adduced to show how the right was violated. Consequently, the claim fails.
56. On access to information, the Petitioners contended that the Respondent failed to respond to their complaints and correspondences. It is trite law that the right to information is not absolute and a party cannot wave it without showcasing that the prescribed procedure to obtain the information was invoked but the claim was denied. The procedure for obtaining information is well articulated under section 8 of the Access to Information Act as follows:
8. (1) An application to access information shall be made in writing in English or Kiswahili and the applicant shall provide details and sufficient particulars for the public officer or any other official to understand what information is being requested.
(2) Where an applicant is unable to make a written request for access to information in accordance with subsection (1) because of illiteracy or disability, the information officer shall take the necessary steps to ensure that the applicant makes a request in manner that meets their needs.
(3) The information officer shall reduce to writing, in a prescribed form the request made under subsection (2) and the information officer shall then furnish the applicant with a copy of the written request.
(4) A public entity may prescribe a form for making an application to access information, but any such form shall not be such as to unreasonably delay requests or place an undue burden upon applicants and no application may be rejected on the ground only that the applicant has not used the prescribed form.
57. The foregoing is fortified by the holding of the Supreme Court in Dande & 3 others v Inspector General, National Police Service & 5 others [2023] KESC 40 (KLR), where it held that:
“123. On our part, we are inclined to agree with the Court of Appeal that the appellants did not establish a demonstrable link between the rights they intended to exercise or protected and the information requested. We have reached that conclusion because firstly, the right to access to information is not an absolute right…”
58. Furthermore, it is not clear what information was sought other than the correspondences before this Court. There is also a response from the Respondent dated 31st October 2025, acknowledged by the Petitioners. Other than that, it is unclear what information the Petitioners regularly sought and were denied. The claim lacks supportive evidence to sustain and thus lacks merit.
59. On unfair labour practices, the allegations that would fall within this category would be the alleged demotion and introduction of special pay and job stagnation. The Respondent clarified the allegations, on special pay, stating that the same was a created to cushion the Petitioners, given that they earned higher pay than the advised pay. an explanation the court finds to be plausible. The Petitioner has not led any evidence to prove mischief on the part of the Respondent. On the alleged demotion, the same was clarified by both the Respondent and the SRC, and what emerges is that the Petitioners were well placed within the right job group. The court is guided by the holding of the Court of Appeal in Teachers Service Commission (TSC) & 2 others v Kenya Union of Teachers (KNUT) & 8 others [2015] KECA 239 (KLR) on advice from the SRC as follows:
255.With the foregoing in mind, I hereby restate that the advice given by SRC under Article 230 (4) (b) of the Constitution is binding; that the national value of sustainable development embodied in Article 10 (2) (d) and the constitutional criterion of fiscal sustainability of the total public compensation bill as stipulated in Article 230 (5) (a) of the Constitution are part of the mandatory criteria that must be taken into account in the determination of remuneration and benefits in the public service. The principles of public finance stipulated in Article 201 (c) and (d) of the Constitution are mandatory criteria of relevance in the determination of remuneration in the public service. Remuneration in the public service should not be determined at a level that threatens the sustainability of the national economy to the prejudice of the present and future generations.
60. Regarding the alleged denial of promotion, no evidence was provided to show that the Petitioners are qualified to hold the positions in KIMC 5 and the Respondent has also stated that there were neither vacancies nor had the Petitioners submitted any applications to express interest in those position. To answer this issue, the Court is guided by the decision in Reuben Wamukota Sikulu v Director of Human Resource Management, Ministry of Devolution & Planning & 2 others; Public Service Commission (Interested Party) [2020] KECA 876 (KLR) where the Court observed as follows:
[12] What the employee is required to do is establish a prima facie case, through direct evidence or statistical proof, that he or she was discriminated against on any of the grounds set out in Article 27(4) of the constitution, which include; race, sex, pregnancy, marital status, health status, ethnic or social origin, color, age, disability, religion, conscience, belief, culture, dress, language or birth. To establish a prima facie case, the appellant had a duty to demonstrate he qualified for the position he was denied; show that he suffered an adverse employment action as a result of the discrimination; must provide prima facie proof that other explanations by the employer are not contrived or without basis; that the real reason for denial of promotion was discriminatory and the reasons must bear unreasonableness or other types of malpractices which must be linked to the suffering endured by the employee. Once the employee establishes a prima facie case, the burden shifts to the employer, to show a legitimate explanation for refusing to grant the promotion. Where the employee has demonstrated a prima facie case, a presumption that the employer discriminated against the employee is raised. The employer must then articulate clear, specific, and non-discriminatory reason for denying the promotion.
61. Having failed to demonstrate the alleged demotion, stagnation or discriminatory treatment, the court is not persuaded that the respondent violated the petitioner’s right to fair labour practices.
62. On the alleged violation of Article 47 of the Constitution, it discernible that the claim was specifically pleaded but no particulars were provided and significarilly, no evidence was provided to prove the alleged violation. The allegation fails for want of proof.
63. The upshot is that the Petitioners have failed to prove the alleged constitutional violations. The Petition lacks merit and it is dismissed with no orders as to costs.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI ON THIS 19TH OCTOBER, 2026.
DR. JACOB GAKERI
JUDGE
ORDER
In view of the declaration of measures restricting court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open court. In permitting this course, this court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this court the duty of the court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.
DR. JACOB GAKERI
JUDGE