Employment law

Masila v Athi Water Works Development Agency & another [2026] KEELRC 14680 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E576 of 2020
Judgment date
19 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Notice of Motion dated 22 May 2026 was dismissed. The requested stay, including of the 26 May 2026 contempt ruling, was spent because that ruling had already been delivered. Recusal was refused because the Claimant did not establish an objectively reasonable apprehension of bias. Costs of the application were awarded against the Claimant.

Supporting judgment passages

I am therefore inclined to dismiss the application and order as follows:

Conclusion and orders →

ii) The Notice of Motion dated 22nd May, 2026 is hereby dismissed.

Passage 32 →

iii) The costs of the application shall be borne by the Claimant.

Passage 33 →
Issue 1Whether the prayer for stay of proceedings, including the ruling of 26th May, 2026 is spent.

Held. Yes. The contempt ruling which the application sought to stay had already been delivered on 26 May 2026, leaving nothing to stay. Complaints about the conduct or outcome of those contempt proceedings, including an alleged denial of a hearing, had to be pursued by appeal or review rather than through recusal.

Ratio. A stay request is spent where the ruling sought to be stayed has already been delivered; challenges to that ruling belong in appeal or review, not a recusal application.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

1. Whether the prayer for stay of proceedings, including the ruling of 26th May, 2026 is spent.

Passage 20 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The 1st issue for determination is whether the prayer for stay is spent. The ruling on contempt which the application sought to stay was delivered on 26th May, 2026. This is deponed to by the 2nd Respondent and is not controverted. There is nothing left to stay, and the first prayer is spent. To the extent that the application takes issue with the conduct and outcome of the contempt proceedings, including the complaint that the Claimant was not heard, those are matters for appeal or review of that ruling and not grounds for the recusal of the court.

Passage 23 →

i) The prayer for stay of proceedings, including the ruling of 26th May, 2026 is spent.

Passage 31 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The 1st issue for determination is whether the prayer for stay is spent. The ruling on contempt which the application sought to stay was delivered on 26th May, 2026. This is deponed to by the 2nd Respondent and is not controverted. There is nothing left to stay, and the first prayer is spent. To the extent that the application takes issue with the conduct and outcome of the contempt proceedings, including the complaint that the Claimant was not heard, those are matters for appeal or review of that ruling and not grounds for the recusal of the court.

Passage 23 →
Issue 2Whether the Claimant has established a reasonable apprehension of bias warranting the recusal of this Court.

Held. No. The Claimant did not establish a reasonable apprehension of bias, and the recusal application failed. The court's enforcement of its in-camera order after the Claimant admitted recording proceedings without leave was not bias; considering possible reallocation did not show a predisposition to prejudice him; and the alleged conflict was unsupported by particulars or evidence. The earlier societal-bias allegation had already been dismissed and could not be relitigated. The Claimant had also recently sought to retain the matter before the same court.

Ratio. Recusal is assessed objectively: the circumstances must create, for a reasonable, fair-minded and informed observer, a real likelihood that the judge would not decide impartially. Mere suspicion is insufficient, and the alleging party bears the burden. A court's enforcement of its own orders and consideration of reallocation options do not, without more, establish bias; grave allegations against a judicial officer require evidence.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

2. Whether the Claimant has established a reasonable apprehension of bias warranting the recusal of this Court.

Passage 21 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The allegation that the Court is conflicted… whether out of compromise or otherwise is a grave one. It is made without a single particular or any evidence in support. An allegation of this nature against a judicial officer must be established by evidence. This has not been done or established here. The Claimant’s further reliance on the court’s supposed societal biases was the subject of his earlier application for recusal, which was dismissed by the ruling of 11th November, 2025. It cannot be re-litigated here.

Passage 27 →

Finally, on 11th February, 2026 less than three months after that ruling, the Claimant applied to have this matter retained before this Court and set down for hearing and determination by it, rather than re-allocated. He cannot in February seek to keep the matter before this court and in May assert that the same court cannot try it fairly. The application does not meet the threshold for recusal and fails in toto.

Passage 28 →

ii) The Notice of Motion dated 22nd May, 2026 is hereby dismissed.

Passage 32 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The 2nd issue for determination is whether a case for recusal has been made out. The test is objective. In Rawal v Judicial Service Commission & another [2016] KECA 717 (KLR), the Court of Appeal adopted the test of whether the circumstances would give rise to a reasonable apprehension, in the mind of a reasonable, fair-minded and informed member of the public, that the judge did not or would not apply his mind to the case impartially. It held that a real likelihood of bias must be demonstrated, that mere suspicion is not enough, and that the onus lies on the party alleging it.

Passage 24 →

The events of 29th April, 2026 arose from the Claimant’s own conduct. He admits that he recorded the proceedings, which the court had directed be held in camera, without the leave of the court. A court that directs a party to surrender a recording of proceedings it has ordered to be held in camera, and declines to hear that party further until he complies, is enforcing its own orders. That is the duty of every court. It is not bias and no fair-minded and informed observer would regard it as such.

Passage 25 →

Neither does the court’s consideration, in the presence of the parties, of the options open to it after the events of 29th April, 2026 disclose bias. The options the Claimant himself lists include referral of the file to the Principal Judge for its re-allocation to another court. A court weighing whether to give up the file is not a court bent on keeping the matter in order to visit prejudice on a party.

Passage 26 →
Issue 3Who bears the costs of the application.

Held. The Claimant/Applicant was ordered to bear the costs of the application. The court exercised its statutory discretion, considering the number of such applications and the Claimant's overall conduct in prosecuting the cause.

Ratio. Under section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, the court may exercise discretion to award costs, taking account of the conduct identified in the proceedings.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

3. Who bears the costs of the application.

Paragraph 3 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

As to costs, this court exercises its discretion Under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act to order that the costs of this application be met by the Claimant/Applicant. This is the fair way to go bearing in mind the numeracy of such applications and overall conduct of the Claimant in the prosecution of this cause.

Passage 29 →

iii) The costs of the application shall be borne by the Claimant.

Passage 33 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

As to costs, this court exercises its discretion Under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act to order that the costs of this application be met by the Claimant/Applicant. This is the fair way to go bearing in mind the numeracy of such applications and overall conduct of the Claimant in the prosecution of this cause.

Passage 29 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to and hereby do issue an Order of stay of further proceedings before the Honourable Mr. Justice D. K Njagi Marete including delivery of the Ruling scheduled for the 26th May, 2026.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the request to stay further proceedings, including delivery of the contempt ruling scheduled for 26 May 2026, was spent; whether the Claimant established an objectively reasonable apprehension of bias requiring the court’s recusal and re-allocation of…

Material facts

During the Claimant’s further cross-examination on 29 April 2026, counsel for the 2nd Respondent raised the presence of a laptop beside the self-represented Claimant. The Claimant admitted recording proceedings, saying it assisted his note-taking. He alleged…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. E576 OF 2020

(Before D. K. N. Marete.)

SAMSON NYAMAI MASILA ……………………………………………………… CLAIMANT

VERSUS

ATHI WATER WORKS DEVELOPMENT AGENCY …………………… 1ST RESPONDENT

EMILY MUTHIO M. KYALO ………………………………..…………… 2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

This is an application by way of a Notice of Motion dated 22nd May, 2026. It seeks the following orders as follows:

1. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to and hereby do issue an Order of stay of further proceedings before the Honourable Mr. Justice D. K Njagi Marete including delivery of the Ruling scheduled for the 26th May, 2026.

2. THAT an Order do hereby issue directing that the file be placed before the Honourable Principal Judge of the Employment and Labour Relations Court for re-allocation to another Court.

3. THAT costs of the Application be in the Cause.

The application is premised on the grounds that on 29th April, 2026 in the course of the Claimant’s further cross-examination, Counsel for the 2nd Respondent raised the presence of a laptop beside the Claimant on the supposition that he was recording the proceedings. The Claimant admitted the recording but describes it as an innocent aid to note-taking, as he acts in person. It is his case that the court took umbrage, directed the seizure of the laptop and the attendance of the Judiciary ICT officer to erase the recording, and denied him audience. He avers that he had reservations about the direction, and that the erasure did not proceed.

The Claimant further avers that at the mention of 14th May, 2026 he was again denied audience while the court debated with Counsel for the Respondents the options open to it, including referral to the Principal Judge, re-allocation of the file, closing the matter for judgment on the record, or pronouncing itself on the events of 29th April, 2026. He says that the matter was reserved for a ruling on contempt on 26th May, 2026 without his ever being told of the conduct alleged against him or heard on it, that the outcome is not in doubt, and that the court is now conflicted… whether out of compromise or otherwise. He invokes his earlier application for recusal and urges that the court relinquish the matter.

The 2nd Respondent opposes the application by her Replying Affidavit. Her case is that the prayer for stay is spent, the ruling on contempt having been delivered on 26th May, 2026 and that the application is an attempt to re-open the contempt proceedings. She avers that the court had directed from the beginning of the trial that the proceedings be held in camera, that the Claimant recorded them without the leave of the court or the consent of the other parties, and that when directed to surrender the recording device to the court’s ICT representative but he refused. She further avers that the Claimant knew at all times why the contempt proceedings were commenced, and that as an advocate he ought to know that his remedy against the contempt ruling lies elsewhere.

The 2nd Respondent further points out that the Claimant’s earlier application for recusal dated 30th September, 2025 was dismissed, and that on 11th February, 2026 when this court directed that the file be placed before the Deputy Registrar for re-allocation, the Claimant himself applied the same day to have that order set aside and the matter retained for hearing before this court. She avers that the present application is forum shopping and that all parties have a legitimate expectation that the matter be concluded expeditiously.

No written submissions were filed on the application. It is determined on the Notice of Motion, its grounds and the affidavits on record.

The issues for determination therefore are;

1. Whether the prayer for stay of proceedings, including the ruling of 26th May, 2026 is spent.

2. Whether the Claimant has established a reasonable apprehension of bias warranting the recusal of this Court.

3. Who bears the costs of the application.

The 1st issue for determination is whether the prayer for stay is spent. The ruling on contempt which the application sought to stay was delivered on 26th May, 2026. This is deponed to by the 2nd Respondent and is not controverted. There is nothing left to stay, and the first prayer is spent. To the extent that the application takes issue with the conduct and outcome of the contempt proceedings, including the complaint that the Claimant was not heard, those are matters for appeal or review of that ruling and not grounds for the recusal of the court.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether a case for recusal has been made out. The test is objective. In Rawal v Judicial Service Commission & another [2016] KECA 717 (KLR), the Court of Appeal adopted the test of whether the circumstances would give rise to a reasonable apprehension, in the mind of a reasonable, fair-minded and informed member of the public, that the judge did not or would not apply his mind to the case impartially. It held that a real likelihood of bias must be demonstrated, that mere suspicion is not enough, and that the onus lies on the party alleging it.

The events of 29th April, 2026 arose from the Claimant’s own conduct. He admits that he recorded the proceedings, which the court had directed be held in camera, without the leave of the court. A court that directs a party to surrender a recording of proceedings it has ordered to be held in camera, and declines to hear that party further until he complies, is enforcing its own orders. That is the duty of every court. It is not bias and no fair-minded and informed observer would regard it as such.

Neither does the court’s consideration, in the presence of the parties, of the options open to it after the events of 29th April, 2026 disclose bias. The options the Claimant himself lists include referral of the file to the Principal Judge for its re-allocation to another court. A court weighing whether to give up the file is not a court bent on keeping the matter in order to visit prejudice on a party.

The allegation that the Court is conflicted… whether out of compromise or otherwise is a grave one. It is made without a single particular or any evidence in support. An allegation of this nature against a judicial officer must be established by evidence. This has not been done or established here. The Claimant’s further reliance on the court’s supposed societal biases was the subject of his earlier application for recusal, which was dismissed by the ruling of 11th November, 2025. It cannot be re-litigated here.

Finally, on 11th February, 2026 less than three months after that ruling, the Claimant applied to have this matter retained before this Court and set down for hearing and determination by it, rather than re-allocated. He cannot in February seek to keep the matter before this court and in May assert that the same court cannot try it fairly. The application does not meet the threshold for recusal and fails in toto.

As to costs, this court exercises its discretion Under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act to order that the costs of this application be met by the Claimant/Applicant. This is the fair way to go bearing in mind the numeracy of such applications and overall conduct of the Claimant in the prosecution of this cause.

I am therefore inclined to dismiss the application and order as follows:

i) The prayer for stay of proceedings, including the ruling of 26th May, 2026 is spent.

ii) The Notice of Motion dated 22nd May, 2026 is hereby dismissed.

iii) The costs of the application shall be borne by the Claimant.

Delivered, dated and signed this 19th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Mr. Masila, Claimant in person.

2. Mr. Kioko instructed by the State Law Office for the 1st Respondent.

3. Mr. Nyamu and Ms. Mwinzi instructed by Keli Mwinzi Advocates for the 2nd Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder