REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO E625 OF 2025
SAMSON KAVITA MWOLOLO…....………………………….CLAIMANT
VERSUS
TELKOM KENYA LIMITED……………………………..1ST RESPONDENT
ESTHER MUTISYA...………………………………....….2ND RESPONDENT
RULING
Background
1. The Claimant instituted the instant proceedings against the Respondents seeking to enforce an award of Ksh. 8,365,633.00 which was made in his favour by the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services (the Director) following the injuries he sustained whilst on duty in the service of the 1st Respondent. It was his case that despite the Director having made the award on 11th October 2024, the 1st Respondent refused to pay the amount.
2. When the Respondents were served with the pleadings, they filed a response in which they denied that the 1st Respondent had refused to pay the amount in question. They averred that the delay in settling the claim was occasioned by the fact that the 1st Respondent’s insurer re-assessed the amount due to the Claimant at Ksh. 6,793,386.00.
3. The Respondents contend that the 1st Respondent’s insurer only released Ksh. 6,793,386.00 which was paid to the Claimant. They aver that they meanwhile informed the Claimant that the 1st Respondent was to pay the difference of Ksh. 1,842,247.00 (later amended to read Ksh. 1,572,247.00) directly.
4. The Respondents thus aver that at the time of filing this case, the only amount which was outstanding to the Claimant was Ksh. 1,572,247.00 which the 1st Respondent had covenanted to pay. As such, they aver that there was no reason for the Claimant to institute the case.
5. The Respondents contend that the 1st Respondent, as a matter of fact, prepared a cheque for the aforesaid balance in favour of the Claimant. However, they contend that the Claimant declined to collect the payments for unexplained reasons and instead moved to court.
6. The Respondents deny the Claimant’s contention that the 1st Respondent declined to settle the claim despite several demands. They deny that the Claimant was subjected to intimidation owing to his demands for the amount in question.
7. In response, the Claimant admits that the 1st Respondent indeed paid him Ksh. 6,793,386.00. However, he states that the Respondents told him that the payment was made on compassionate grounds after the 1st Respondent’s insurer refused to pay what had been assessed by the Director.
8. The Claimant contends that because of this misinformation and the failure by the Respondents to indicate when the award or the balance thereof was going to be paid, he instructed his lawyers to issue a demand for the amount. He says that despite his lawyers’ intervention, the Respondents remained non-committal about the payments prompting the decision to file suit.
Analysis
9. After institution of the suit, the parties appear to have resolved the disagreement between them save for the issue of costs. This is evident from the proceedings of 23rd April 2026 during which they confirmed that the outstanding grievance in the cause related to costs.
10. The parties asked for time to try and finalize the matter. As such, the court adjourned the case to 29th April 2026 for further directions.
11. On 29th April 2026, the parties intimated that no agreement had been reached prompting the court to adjourn the case to 11th June 2026. On 11th June 2026, they informed the court that they had failed to amicably resolve the question of costs. As such, they asked the court to determine the matter.
12. It is apparent from the record and the parties agree that the Claimant was awarded Ksh. 8,365,633.00 following the injury he sustained whilst on duty at the 1st Respondent’s premises. It is also apparent that at the point of filing this suit, the 1st Respondent had paid the Claimant the sum of Ksh. 6,793,386.00 leaving a balance of Ksh. 1,572,247.00.
13. The record shows that on 4th February 2025, the Claimant’s lawyers wrote to the 1st Respondent acknowledging payment of Ksh. 6,793,386.00. According to the letter, this amount was paid on 26th November 2024.
14. The Claimant’s lawyers demanded to know why the 1st Respondent had not remitted the entire amount as assessed by the Director. They asked for a response within seven (7) days but expressed their desire to resolve the dispute amicably. There is no indication that the 1st Respondent responded to this letter within the aforesaid timelines or at all.
15. The Claimant subsequently filed suit on 1st July 2025 claiming for the entire sum of Ksh. 8,365,633.00. It is noteworthy that he did not disclose that he had been paid Ksh. 6,793,386.00.
16. The reality of the matter is that at the time this suit was instituted, the 1st Respondent had only made partial payment of the amount in the award leaving a balance of Ksh. 1,572,247.00. Although the Respondents assert that they prepared a cheque for the balance in favour of the Claimant before he filed suit, there is no evidence to support this contention. As such, the court is unable to arrive at the conclusion that non-settlement of the balance of Ksh. 1,572,247.00 before suit was filed was because of the Claimant’s obstinacy. In the premises, the court finds that the Claimant was entitled to file suit to enforce recovery of the aforesaid balance of Ksh. 1,572,247.00 because the amount was still outstanding at that time.
17. Settlement of the dispute was apparently brokered after suit had been filed. As such, the Claimant is entitled to costs of the suit based on the amount which was outstanding at the time the case was filed.
18. In arriving at this conclusion, the court is guided by the principle that costs follow the event (see section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act). This essentially means that the successful party in litigation should be awarded costs unless there are compelling reasons to order otherwise (see Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 Others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 Others [2014] eKLR).
19. In this case, the Claimant is deemed the successful party because the settlement was in his favour. As such, he is entitled to costs of the suit since there are no compelling reasons to order otherwise.
Determination
20. In the premises, the court awards costs of the suit to the Claimant. However, assessment of the quantum of the costs will be based on the outstanding balance of Ksh. 1,572,247.00 due to the Claimant as at the time suit was filed and will take into account the fact that the dispute between the parties was resolved before it progressed to trial.
Dated, signed and delivered on the 21st day of October, 2026
B. O. M. MANANI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
…………….for the Claimant
…………….for the Respondent
ORDER
In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.
B. O. M MANANI