Employment law

John v Crystal Adhesives Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14705 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E587 of 2025
Judgment date
21 October 2026
Judge(s)
Dr. Jacob Gakeri

Case research

SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether Crystal Adhesives Limited unlawfully terminated Projella Mwende John’s employment or whether she deserted/absconded duty; and whether she was entitled to the remedies claimed. The court also considered the individual claims for compensation, leave,…

Material facts

The claimant had worked for the respondent from 2018 as a Sales Representative at a monthly salary of Kshs.100,000. The parties differed on whether their relationship ended in April 2023 or April 2024. The claimant relied on an undated, unsigned notice of…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E587 OF 2025

(Before Hon. Justice Dr. Jacob Gakeri)

PROJELLA MWENDE JOHN……………………………..…. CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

CRYSTAL ADHESIVES LIMITED………………………. RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

The claimant commenced this suit on 26th July 2023 vide a Statement of Claim dated 10th July 2023 alleging that the respondent terminated her employment vide letter dated 11th April 2023 and declined to be reinstated when the employer attempted to do so, after she sought clarification on her employment status.

The claimant averred that no valid reason was provided and no fair hearing was conducted.

The claimant prayed for:

(i) 12 months compensation Kshs.1,200,000.00

(ii) 42 days unutilized leave Kshs.161,000

(iii) Unpaid commission for 2 months Kshs.200,000

(iv) Service/Gratuity Kshs.500,000

(v) Unpaid salary for 3 months Kshs.300,000

(vi) Unpaid salaries as at the date of delivery of judgment Kshs.400,000

(vii) General damages for emotional distress and suffering

(viii) Costs of this suit

(ix) Interest at court rate, one (i) – (vi) at commercial rates till payment in full.

Respondent’s case

The respondent’s counsel file a Notice of Appointment on 19th February 2024 dated 30th November 2023 and a response to the Statement of Claim on 6th May 2024 averring that it employed the claimant as a Sales Representative in January 2018 until April 2024 when she was summoned by the Managing Director and Human Resource Manager to clarify certain things but voluntarily left employment. It did not deny the claim that the claimant’s salary was Kshs.100,000 per month but denied having terminated the claimant’s employment.

According to the respondent, the contract of employment was annual. That the claimant absented herself from work without permission, was treated leniently, but when called upon to explain she opted not to show up from early April 2024.

The respondent averred that commission was payable after all monies were collected from clients.

Claimant’s submissions

Counsel for the claimant submitted on whether termination of the claimant’s employment was fair, reliefs and costs.

On the first issue, reliance was placed on the provisions of Section 45 (2), 43(1) and 41 of the Employment Act and the decisions in Jared Arimba v Fina Bank Ltd (2016) eKLR and Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR, among others, to submit that the claimant had established a prima facie case of unfair termination of her employment and the respondent’s documents had inconsistencies.

Reliance was further placed on the decisions in Joseph Nzioka v Smart Coatings Ltd (2017) eKLR and Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Ltd (2024) KEELRC 917 KLR on the duty of the employer who pleads absconding of duty or desertion by an employee to demonstrate attempts made to contact the employee and issue of notice to show cause, to urge that the respondent did not avail such evidence.

Similarly, counsel submitted that the respondent availed no evidence to controvert the claimant’s evidence that she was not accorded a hearing prior to the termination of employment.

On entitlement to reliefs, counsel submitted that the claimant deserved all the reliefs prayed for.

Reliance was placed on Michael Mugure Nyambura v Kiganjo Bakery Ltd (2017) KEELRC 1644 (KLR) the claim for, and Martin Ireri Ndwiga v Olerai Management Company (2017) eKLR on service pay.

Counsel urged the court to find that termination of claimant’s employment was substantively and procedurally unfair.

Respondent’s submission

On termination of the claimant’s employment counsel submitted that the document dated 11th April 2023 was unsigned and could not be relied upon because a stamp is not a signature was never adopted by the respondent and that respondent had taken only one position namely, disowned the letter in question and denied termination as its pleadings showed.

According to counsel, the claimant refused to report to work after the final warning until paid final dues and declined reinstatement and her fixed term contract lapsed on 30th June 2023, citing the decision in Registered Trustees of the Presbyterian Church of East Africa v Ruth Gathoni Ngotho Kariuki (2017) KECA 194 (KLR) on the nature of fixed term contracts.

Counsel submittedThat the decisions cited by the claimant’s counsel on absconding of duty were distinguishable in that the respondent kept its doors open for the claimant to resume duty and in the Jared Arimbas Case, the Court of Appeal declined to fault the employer to submit that the claimant failed to discharge the burden of proof.

In the alternative, whether any termination of employment was fair, counsel submitted that the respondent had a valid reason to terminate the claimant’s employment under section 44 (4) (a) of the Employment Act and was she not dismissed after the hearing but warned and contributed to the separation by refusing to work.

On entitlement to reliefs, counsel submitted that none was merited because there was no termination of employment, salary is consideration for work and not due unless worked for, commission was not proved, leave days not particularized, claimant was a member of the National Social Security Fund (NSSF), did not establish entitlement to overtime pay as held in Rogoli Ole Manadiegi v General Cargo Services Ltd (2016) KEELRC 1607 (KLR) and claim for general damages was unavailable as held in Kenya Broadcasting Corporation v Geoffrey Wakio (2019) KECA 65 (KLR), but was entitled to a certificate of service.

Analysis and determination

It is common ground that the claimant was an employee of the respondent from 2018 and worked until sometime in April 2023 or April 2024 when the parties separated. It is unclear as to how they separated. However, the claimant provided a copy of a Notice of termination, which strangely was undated and unsigned and had no acknowledgment of receipt by the claimant.

When the claimant queried about it vide letter dated 14th April 2023, the respondent responded vide letter dated 18th April 2023 stating that the claimant’s salary had not been terminated as she had a contract of employment upto June 30th 2023. The letter directed the claimant to report to work immediately and debt collection would be discussed. The respondent undertook to afford the claimant a fair opportunity to discuss any concerns she had. It is unclear how the relationship proceeded thereafter but the respondent admitted having received the claimant’s advocate’s demand letter.

The issues for determination are:

(i) Whether the respondent terminated the claimant’s employment unlawfully or the claimant deserted duty.

(ii) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

On the first issue parties adopted contrasting position, while the claimant asserted that her employment was terminated by the respondent unfairly, the respondent’s case is that the claimant deserted the work place or absconded duty.

It is trite law that an employer who relies on the ground of desertion or absconding of duty by an employee is required to prove the desertion or absconding of duly on a balance of probabilities.

Concerning the terms “desertion” and “absconding duty,” in Kosgei v Metkei Multipurpose Co. Ltd (2021) KECA 140 (KLR) the court stated thus:

“However, from the letter it is made clear that they found that the appellant had deserted his work station. That ground is in line with section 44(4) (a) of the Act which uses the words absents himself from the place appointed for the performance of his work. For that reason, we do not wish to go into the meaning of either term as that is semantics”

In Seabolo v Belgravia Hotel (1997) 6 BLLR 829 (CCMA), the South African Court defined desertion as follows:

“…desertion is distinguishable from absence without leave, in that the employee who deserts his or her post does so with the intention of not returning or, having left his or her post, subsequently formulates the intention not to retain. On the other hand, an employer may deduce the intention not to return to work from the facts of the case and should demonstrate the same. The facts may include lack of communication from the employee, duration of absence, and attempts made to reach out or establish the whereabouts of the employee. Show cause notice to explain the absence may also be a factor to consider.”

In Romageco Kenya Ltd v Kisigwa (2026) KECA 1132 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held:

“The critical consideration is that an employer invoking desertion as a defence to a claim of unlawful termination must demonstrate tangible efforts to reach out to the employee with the objective of notifying them that termination on this ground is under contemplation. It is insufficient for an employer to merely invoke the term desertion without substantiating it through action and evidence.”

See also Felistas Acheha Ikatwa v Charles Peter Otieno (2018) eKLR.

In this case although the respondent averred that the claimant deserted or absented herself from duty without leave, which would have entitled it to terminate her employment under section 44(4) (a) of the Employment Act, it adduced no evidence of the steps or actions it took to reach out to the claimant to ascertain here whereabout or notify her that termination of employment was being considered on account of her absence without permission.

A notice to show cause was essential in this case. This is because, from the letters provided by the claimant in support of her case, it is clear that the respondent created the confusion by the unsigned Notice of termination of the claimant’s employment, which the respondent acknowledged. The respondent could not thereafter allege absence from the workplace without demonstrating the attempts it made to reach out to the claimant.

For the foregoing reason the court finds that the respondent failed to prove the defence of desertion or absconding duty.

It is trite law that for a termination of employment to pass the fairness test, there must have been a valid and fair reason to terminate the employee’s employment and the procedure employed by the employer must have been fair. This is the import of the provisions of section 41, 43, 44, 45, 46 and 47 (5) of the Employment Act.

In Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR, Ndolo J (as she then was) held:

“In light of the foregoing, I find that respondent had a genuine reason for terminating the claimant’s employment as required under Section 43 of the Employment Act. However, for a termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for the termination but also procedural fairness.”

In the instant case, the respondent evidentiary demonstrated neither desertion nor a fair termination of employment. The foregoing finding is fortified by the rendition of Onyango J in Judith, Atieno Owuor v Sameer Agriculture and Livestock Ltd (2020) KEELRC 609 (KLR) as follows:

“Further, even if she had absconded, she is by law entitled to a fair disciplinary process a set out in Section 41 of the Employment Act 2007. No evidence was availed to court to support there having been a disciplinary process or notice issued prior to the termination. It is the duty of the respondent to show this court that it did accord the claimant a fair hearing prior to her termination.”

Appropriate reliefs

(i) 12 months’ salary.

Having found that termination of the claimant’s employment by the respondent was unfair, the claimant qualifies for compensation by dint of section 49 (1) (c) of the Employment Act, subject to the provisions of section 49 (4) of the Act.

Considering that the claimant was an employee of the respondent for about 4 years, which is not long, did not appeal the decision or express her wish to remain in employment and contributed to the termination, the court is satisfied that the equivalent of three (3) months gross salary is fair, Kshs.300,000.

(ii) Unutilized leave days.

The claimant provided no evidence of the relevant particulars as to when the leave days accrued including why leave was not taken. The prayer is disallowed.

(iii) Unpaid commission

The claimant adduced no evidence of entitlement to commission. There was no evidence of the circumstances in which the alleged commission was payable and how much was payable. The prayer is dismissed.

(iv) Service pay/gratuity

This claim lacked relevant particulars and it is disallowed.

(v) Unpaid salaries for three months.

The claimant adduced no evidence of having rendered any service to the respondent after the undated notice of termination of employment and seeking clarification. She is however entitled to the salary for the 14 days worked in April 2023 Kshs.47,000.

(vi) Unpaid salaries due to her as at the date of delivery of judgment accruing at the end of each month at the rate of Kshs.100,000. This is a claim for work not done and it is unmerited. Section 17 of the Employment Act provides.

(1) Subject to this Act, an employer shall pay the entire amount of the wages earned by or payable to an employee in respect of work done by the employee in pursuance of a contract of service directly, in the currency of Kenya-

(a) in cash;

(b) into an account at a bank or building society designated by the employee;

(c) by cheque, postal order or money order in favour of the employee; or

(d) in the absence of an employee, to a person other than the employee if the person is duly authorized by the employee in writing to receive the wages on the employee’s behalf.

The prayer lacks a factual or legal basis and it is dismissed.

(vii) Unpaid overtime.

The claimant adduced no scintilla of evidence to demonstrate entitlement to overtime. The claimant provided no particulars of the overtime by way of the extra/additional hours worked, when, and how the figure of Kshs.400,000 was arrived at.

(viii) General damages for emotional distress and suffering. The claimant tendered no evidence of the emotional distress or suffering for which damages are claimed. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K Tanui (2019) eKLR, the Court of Appeal expressed itself as follows:

“In awarding the compensatory damages, the trial, court reasoned, quite correctly in our view that employees ought to be discouraged from replicating injuries and claiming multiple remedies of what is essentially the same wrong. It stated…

Essentially, general damages and statutory compensation redress the same economic injury occasioned to the employee for the singular act of dismissal. Unless an employee shows exceptional circumstances warranting redress under contract and under the statute one form of remedy is sufficient”

The prayer for general damages is unsustainable and it is dismissed.

In the end, judgment is entered in favour of the claimant against the respondent in the following terms:

(a) Equivalent of three (3) months gross salary, Kshs.300,000

(b) Salary for 14 days Kshs.47,000

(c) Costs of the suit at ½ scale.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI ON THIS 21ST OCTOBER, 2026.

DR. JACOB GAKERI

JUDGE

ORDER

In view of the declaration of measures restricting court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open court. In permitting this course, this court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this court the duty of the court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.

DR. JACOB GAKERI

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder