Employment law

Caboni v CX Services Kenya Ltd & another [2026] KEELRC 14692 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E1219 of 2025
Judgment date
21 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether the claimant had proved an employment relationship with the respondents, whether his resignation amounted to constructive termination arising from an unlawful unilateral transfer from Kenya to Nigeria, and what remedies should…

Material facts

The claimant alleged that he served the Teleperformance group from 2019 and, from 1 October 2022, was CEO of the 1st respondent in Nairobi under a Kenya-governed contract. He said he was directed first to relinquish Ghana duties and then to cease acting as…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. E1219 OF 2025

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

FEDERICO CABONI...........………………..………………...CLAIMANT

VS

CX SERVICES KENYA LIMITED……..…………..…1ST RESPONDENT

TELEPERFORMANCE SE…………………..…………2ND RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1 The Claimant instituted this claim vide a Statement of Claim dated 4th December 2025 and prays for a final award against the Respondents in the following terms:

i. A declaration that the Respondents unfairly, un-procedurally, wrongfully and unlawfully constructively dismissed him from employment contrary to the law and the contract of employment.

ii. Compensation for wrongful, unlawful and unfair termination or breach of contract of employment equivalent to 12 months' salary in the sum of EUR 121,000.

iii. Terminal dues in the sum of EUR 147,014.66, being, against the 1st and 2nd Respondents under the contract dated 20th September 2022, six months' pay in lieu of notice of EUR 60,499 and six accrued and unpaid leave days of EUR 2,016.66, and, against the 2nd Respondent for the informal contract from March 2024 to 31st January 2025, six months' pay in lieu of notice of EUR 60,499 and the bonus or yearly variable gross for 2024 of EUR 24,000.

iv. Costs of the claim.

v. A certificate of service for the period worked for the 1st and 2nd Respondents.

vi. Any other appropriate relief that the Court may deem fit to grant.

Claimant’s Case

2 The Claimant avers that he served the 2nd Respondent through its subsidiaries in Kenya and Nigeria from July 2019 to 31st January 2025 without any adverse disciplinary record, the 1st Respondent being the 2nd Respondent's subsidiary in Kenya.

3 It is his case that by a contract of employment dated 20th September 2022, the 1st Respondent employed him as its Chief Executive Officer, based at its Westlands office in Nairobi, with effect from 1st October 2022 and for an undetermined period.

4 He avers that his gross monthly salary was USD 10,083.33, being a yearly fixed gross salary of USD 121,000. He was also entitled to a yearly variable gross of USD 24,000 payable after the issuing of the company's yearly results, a yearly accommodation allowance of USD 20,000, a company car and related expenses, medical insurance with international coverage and four economy class travels to Europe per year.

5 The Claimant avers that while serving under this contract he was also assigned as Chief Executive Officer in charge of the 2nd Respondent's office in Nigeria, and that he set up and served in the same capacity in its office in Ghana, both under TLS Contact Processing Services Ltd. This was without any separate written contract or commensurate pay, and despite his contract providing that his place of work would be the 1st Respondent's principal offices.

6 It is the Claimant's case that in or about February 2024, the 2nd Respondent directed him to hand over his duties in respect of TP Ghana to its subsidiary, Majorel Ghana, and to cease working as its CEO with immediate effect.

7 He avers that this was done without prior notice, discussion, lawful termination of his contract with the 1st Respondent, payment of terminal dues or a transfer of employment.

8 He further avers that in March 2024, the 2nd Respondent's President, by an oral directive given on a telephone conference, instructed him to cease his role as CEO of the 1st Respondent and hand over immediately to the CEO of Majorel Kenya, a company acquired by the 2nd Respondent which was neither his employer nor his superior.

9 On the same occasion he was verbally instructed to relocate to Lagos and take up the role of CEO of Teleperformance Nigeria Limited, without any formal contract of employment or transfer of duties.

10 The Claimant avers that despite his requests and follow-ups by email and telephone, the Respondents failed to formally terminate his contract with the 1st Respondent, pay the terminal dues flowing from it, comply with the laws of Kenya on transfer of employment to a foreign country, or issue him with a formal contract for the Nigerian role.

11 He states that for over ten months, between March 2024 and January 2025, they failed to discuss or offer him a contract for the transfer or re-assignment of his duties. As a result, he sought and was allowed to undertake the Nigerian assignment from Kenya, and he continued to be paid salary and benefits by the 1st Respondent under the contract of 20th September 2022, with a similar job description and obligations save for the change in place of work and subsidiary.

12 He further avers that the 2nd Respondent only served him with a letter of offer for the Nigerian role on 23rd August 2024, with an effective date of 1st September 2024, and a promise to discuss its terms or align them with the relevant laws, on which it reneged.

13 The Claimant states that this offer was titled as a new position of Country Manager and a transfer of employment without probation, yet he continued to perform the same duties on similar pay.

14 It is the Claimant’s case that on or about 1st September 2025 the Respondents, without notice, removed him from all their Chief Executive Officers' distribution and communication lists in EMEA.

15 He avers that this made the performance of his duties difficult and caused him anxiety and psychological and mental anguish. He raised these concerns with the 2nd Respondent's President, who was his supervisor, but they were not addressed.

16 The Claimant contends that these unfair labour practices and the neglect of his concerns precipitated harsh and untenable conditions which made it difficult for him to continue working for the Respondents. Consequently, he resigned on 18th December 2024, and the 2nd Respondent acknowledged and accepted the resignation with effect from 31st January 2025.

17 He avers that he was paid only his January salary and 22.75 leave days, and that the Respondents refused to pay his terminal dues for his service with the 1st Respondent and with the Nigerian subsidiary between March 2024 and 31st January 2025.

18 It is therefore the Claimant's case that he was constructively and unfairly terminated from his position with the 1st Respondent in Kenya, and constructively dismissed from the same role in the 2nd Respondent's Nigerian subsidiary on 31st January 2025.

19 The Claimant particularized the Respondents' breaches to include terminating his contract with the 1st Respondent without the six months' notice, or pay in lieu, for which it provided, and without paying his yearly variable gross for 2023 and his yearly allowance. He also faults them for failing to provide a work laptop and cell phone, thereby compelling him to use his own resources, and for failing to notify and hear him before terminating his employment with the 1st Respondent and relocating him to Nigeria.

20 He further contends that the restructuring and transfer of his duties breached his right to fair administrative action, that he was removed from the CEO distribution list yet expected to continue discharging his duties without the benefit of management communication, and that the Respondents neglected to discuss his work concerns and contract.

21 The Claimant states that it was a term of his contract that his remuneration was based on a USD/EUR exchange rate of 1:1, to be realigned if the rate varied above 1.05 or below 0.95, and he accordingly claims in Euros.

22 He avers that the contracts were at all material times performed in and from Kenya, within the jurisdiction of this Court, and that a demand and notice of intention to sue were served without response.

Respondents’ Case

23 The Respondents did not enter appearance or file a response to the claim, despite being served with the Summons, the claim documents and hearing notices, as evidenced by the Affidavits of Service sworn by Robert Kinyanjui on 17th February 2026 and Olala Mmeli on 11th March 2026.

Evidence in Court

24 The matter proceeded for formal proof on 18th June 2026. The Court noted on 9th April 2026 that the Respondents were served and were absent, and counsel for the Claimant confirmed that they were served with the hearing notice on 20th April 2026.

25 CW1, Federico Caboni, the Claimant, testified on oath and adopted his witness statement dated 4th December 2025 as his evidence in chief. He also relied on his list and bundle of documents of the same date, which he produced as Claimant’s Exhibits 1 to 7. That was the entirety of his oral evidence. There being no appearance for the Respondents, thus, he was not cross-examined.

Claimants’ Submissions

26 The Claimant identified three issues for determination: whether an employment relationship existed between him and the Respondents, whether his termination was unfair, wrongful and unlawful, and whether he is entitled to the reliefs sought.

27 On the first issue, the Claimant submitted that while it is the employer's responsibility to document the employment relationship, he was not thereby released from proving his case, particularly where no appearance has been entered. He thus contended that he has discharged that burden on a balance of probabilities.

28 The Claimant relied on the definitions of "employee" and "employer" in Section 2 of the Employment Act, the latter being:"any person, public body, firm, corporation or company who or which has entered into a contract of service to employ any individual and includes the agent, foreman, manager or factor of such person, public body, firm, corporation or company."

29 In respect of the 1st Respondent, he placed reliance on the contract of employment dated 20th September 2022 and its Schedule 1 setting out his duties as Chief Executive Officer.

30 In respect of the 2nd Respondent, he submitted that he was first employed on 15th July 2019 as Site Director in its Nigerian subsidiary, under a contract formally issued on 10th March 2020, and was thereafter promoted to Chief Executive Officer. He also relied on the email correspondence of 23rd August to 6th September 2024, the draft contract issued by TP Nigeria in August 2024, and his payslip for October 2024, which was issued under the 1st Respondent's name although he was by then serving the Nigerian subsidiary.

31 It is the Claimant’s submission that both Respondents exercised powers ordinarily reserved to an employer, in that they directed his deployments, assigned his duties across jurisdictions, supervised his performance, determined the terms on which he would continue to serve and accepted his resignation.

32 He submitted that he discharged executive functions for the 2nd Respondent's subsidiaries in Kenya, Ghana and Nigeria under the Respondents' common management and control. Therefore, an employment relationship existed with the 1st Respondent under the contract of 20th September 2022, and with the 2nd Respondent through its Ghanaian and Nigerian subsidiaries.

33 On the second issue, the Claimant submitted that Sections 41, 43 and 45(2) of the Employment Act set out the framework governing unfair termination, and that Section 47(5) apportions the burden of proof as follows:"For any complaint of unfair termination of employment or wrongful dismissal the burden of proving that an unfair termination of employment or wrongful dismissal has occurred shall rest on the employee, while the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination of employment or wrongful dismissal shall rest on the employer."

34 The Claimant cited Josephine M. Ndungu & others v Plan International Inc [2019] KEELRC 663 (KLR) and Ondieki v Vice Chancellor, Maasai Mara University & 2 others; Chairman Audit Committee Maasai Mara University (Interested Party) [2024] KEELRC 254 (KLR) for the proposition that once an employee establishes a prima facie case that the termination did not meet the threshold under Section 45, the burden shifts to the employer, failing which a presumption of fact arises in favour of the unlawfulness of the termination.

35 It was submitted that the Respondents contravened Section 35 by failing to issue notice of termination, Section 36 by failing to pay in lieu of notice, and Sections 41 and 43 by failing to give reasons for the termination or to accord him a hearing. Since the Respondents did not enter appearance to justify the termination, he urged that the presumption operates in his favour.

36 The Claimant further submitted that the Respondents' conduct amounted to constructive dismissal. He relied on Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] KECA 394 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal cited with approval Lord Denning MR in Western Excavating (ECC) Ltd v Sharp [1978] ICR 222 that:"If the employer is guilty of conduct which is a significant breach going to the root of the contract of employment or which shows that the employer no longer intends to be bound by one or more of the essential terms of the contract, then the employee is entitled to treat himself as discharged from any further performance. If he does so, then he terminates the contract by reason of the employer's conduct."

37 He also cited Joseph Aleper & another v Lodwar Water and Sanitation Company Limited [2015] KEELRC 613 (KLR), which adopted the holding in Benuel Mariera v Awand Enterprises Limited, Mombasa Cause No. 191 of 2013 that:"…when an employer by action or omission materially breaches the contract or otherwise makes it impossible for an employee to perform his contract of employment then the contract is deemed to have been constructively terminated by the employer."

38 Applying this test, the Claimant argued that the evidence discloses a continuous and deliberate course of conduct which fundamentally breached his contracts. He pointed to his removal from the Ghana role without consultation, and to the oral directive to cease acting as CEO of the 1st Respondent and hand over to Majorel Kenya, a separate legal entity that was neither his employer nor party to his contract. He also relied on the verbal instruction to relocate to Nigeria without lawful termination or transfer, and the failure for over ten months to formalise his engagement despite the draft offer of August 2024. Lastly, he cited his removal from the CEO distribution and communication lists in EMEA, which impaired his ability to perform and exposed him to professional embarrassment, anxiety and psychological distress.

39 It is the Claimant’s submission that the 2nd Respondent was evasive on this removal, alleging that it was neither aware of nor liable for it, yet failing to direct his reinstatement to the lists. He argued that this conduct amounted to unfair and unlawful constructive dismissal contrary to Sections 35, 41, 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act and the terms of his contract.

40 On the reliefs, the Claimant submitted that the Respondents' actions constitute a repudiatory breach entitling him to the declaration sought.

41 On compensation, he relied on Sections 49 and 50 of the Employment Act and urged the Court to consider the circumstances of the termination, the employer's conduct and his legitimate expectation of continued employment. He submitted that, given his seniority, the Respondents' deliberate disregard of their contractual and statutory obligations and the manner in which the relationship ended, twelve months' salary in the sum of EUR 121,000 is justified and equitable.

42 In justifying the claim in Euros, he relied on the term of the contract aligning his salary to a USD/EUR exchange rate of 1:1, subject to realignment should the rate vary. He submitted that this position is corroborated by the letter dated 2nd April 2025 from the 1st Respondent's advocates, written in reply to his demand letter of 19th March 2025. In the letter, the 1st Respondent did not dispute that the claim was denominated in Euros and offered him an ex gratia payment of EUR 15,000 in consideration of his engaging in clearance procedures.

43 On terminal dues, it was submitted that the only payments made upon resignation were the January 2025 salary and 22.75 accrued leave days. The pay in lieu of notice, the bonus and yearly variable pay for the period March 2024 to 31st January 2025, and six un utilised leave days from the 1st Respondent remain outstanding. As the Respondents neither disputed nor rebutted the computation, he urged the Court to award EUR 147,014.66 as claimed.

44 He further submitted that Section 51 of the Employment Act imposes a mandatory obligation on an employer to issue a certificate of service, and that costs should follow the event, the Respondents having been served with all process and elected not to participate.

45 I have examined all the evidence and submissions of the parties herein. It is indeed true that the respondents though served failed to enter appearance or file their defence.

46 The claimant exhibited the contract dated 10th March 2020 between TLS Contract Processing Services Ltd as site Director (tele performance business unit). It is averred that the 1st respondent CX services Kenya Ltd is a subsidiary of the 2nd respondent in Kenya.

47 This contract was signed in Nigeria and was served in Nigeria. The claimant also exhibited another contract dated 21/9/2022 where he was appointed CEO of CS Services (K) Ltd (1st respondent herein) which was described as the newly opened subsidiary of the 2nd respondent based in Westlands Nairobi. The employment was with effect from 1/10/22.

48 Under the contract, the offer letter was to be covered and confirmed in accordance with the laws of Kenya. It is evident that though the claimant was to serve in Kenya he was moved to Nigeria in circumstances that are not clear. He thereafter resigned. The resignation was accepted by the respondents.

49 The respondents having employed the claimant to serve in Kenya, it was a breach of the employment contract for the respondents to unilaterally move him to Nigeria without consultation and without his concurrence. This is especially so in view of the law at section 10(5) of the Employment Act 2007 which states as follows:

(5) Where any matter stipulated in subsection (1) changes, the employer shall, in consultation with the employee, revise the contract to reflect the change and notify the employee of the change in writing.

50 It is this breach that led the claimant to tender his resignation which is equivalent to a constructive termination. I therefore find that the claimant has established his case on a balance of probabilities. I find the claim thus established and remain uncontroverted. I find for the claimant and will award him as follows:

(1) 6 months’ salary in lieu of notice = 10,083x6=60,499 EUR.

(2) Unpaid leave days as prayed = 2016,66 EUR

(3) Yearly bonus of 24,000 EUR.

(4) Due to the unfairness against the claimant I award him 6 months’ salary as compensation for the unfair termination = 6x10,083.3=60,499 EUR.

TOTAL= 147,014.66 EUR less statutory deductions.

(5) Respondents to issue claimant with a certificate of service.

(6) Respondent will pay costs of this suit plus interest at court rates with effect for the date of judgment.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 21st Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder