Background
This Judgment relates to a Statement of Claim dated 30th September 2024, in which the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This Judgment relates to a Statement of Claim dated 30th September 2024, in which the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →In the premise, I find and hold that the Respondent had a valid, fair and justified reason to terminate the Claimant’s employment.
Paragraph 61 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E821 OF 2024
JAMES MUCHIRI WARINGA .................................................CLAIMANT
VERSUS
NATIONAL OIL CORPORATION OF KENYA LIMITED......RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. This Judgment relates to a Statement of Claim dated 30th September 2024, in which the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
a. A declaration that the Respondent’s termination of the Claimant’s employment was wrongful, unfair, and in breach of the Employment Act.
b. A declaration that the Respondent’s actions violated the Claimant’s constitutional rights to freedom from discrimination, fair hearing, fair administrative action, fair labour practices and inherent dignity.
c. Kshs. 1,752,000 being the equivalent of 12 months’ salary on account of unlawful termination.
d. General and exemplary damages on account of violation of the Claimant’s right to freedom against discrimination, degrading and inhumane treatment.
e. General and exemplary damages on account of violation of the Claimant’s right to fair labour practices.
f. Costs of this Cause.
g. Interest on the sums in prayers (d), (e), (f), (g), (h) and (i) at commercial rates from 12th June 2024 until payment in full.
2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 18th October, 2024 and subsequently filed a Statement of Response dated 15th November, 2024, denying the allegations and maintaining that the termination was lawful and justified.
3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 18th November, 2025, where CW1 James Muchiri Waringa, the Claimant herein, testified in support of his case and adopted his witness statement dated 30th September, 2025 as his evidence in chief and further produced his list and bundle of documents as Exhibits 1-7.
4. The Respondent’s case was subsequently heard on 25th February, 2026, through RW1, Willis Anyango, the Respondent’s Human Resource Manager, who adopted the Statement of Response dated 15th November, 2024, list of witnesses, and his witness statement dated 14th May, 2025 as his evidence in chief. He also produced his list and bundle of documents dated 15th May, 2025 as Exhibit 1-14.
5. Both parties filed their respective submissions in the matter, and have been duly considered.
The Claimant’s case
6. The Claimant states that he is a qualified and experienced Geochemist, and that he initially worked for the Respondent as a Supply Analyst Assistant from July 2012 to 2014, before proceeding abroad for one year of further studies. He states that he returned in 2015 and was employed by the Respondent as a Graduate Geochemist, subsequently transitioning to permanent employment as a Petroleum Geochemist in August 2018.
7. It is his case that by an employment contract dated 1st July, 2020, and executed on 28th July, 2020, the Respondent employed him as a Geochemist, effective from 1st July, 2020. He states that he was entitled to 30 working days of annual leave per calendar year, together with a leave allowance of KShs.30,000.
8. The Claimant avers that he diligently and faithfully performed his contractual duties. He further states that during his employment with the Respondent, he provided the Respondent with his bank account details for payment of his remuneration, but had no control over when or how the Respondent or its officers remitted funds to those accounts. He maintains that his role as a Geochemist was purely technical and did not involve administrative responsibilities.
9. It is his case that despite his dedication and positive performance appraisals, he was interdicted by the Respondent’s Human Resource Department on 12th January, 2024, over allegations of involvement in, intention to commit, or benefiting from fraudulent payments. He contends that the interdiction was imposed before he was issued with a notice to show cause or given an opportunity to respond to the allegations.
10. It is the Claimant’s case that on 14th March, 2024, the Respondent issued him with a show cause letter requiring him to respond within seven days to allegations of fraudulently receiving KShs.510,110 in two payments made on 24th January, 2022 and 14th April, 2022, and failing to account for the funds in accordance with clauses 8.0–9.0 of the Respondent’s Business Travel Policy.
11. The Claimant states that he responded to the show cause letter on 20th March, 2024, denying the allegations of fraud and any involvement in or intention to defraud the Respondent. He maintains that he had no control over the remittances made to his bank accounts, that the funds were unexpected and had not been requested by him, and that he acted in good faith by reversing them to the source. He contends that any discrepancies were beyond his control and did not constitute evidence of fraudulent conduct on his part.
12. The Claimant states that despite his response denying the allegations made against him and explaining that he had reversed the funds to the source, the Respondent maintained his interdiction for over six months before terminating his employment on 12th June, 2024. The Claimant avers that the termination was discriminatory and unjustified, as the Respondent suffered no financial loss.
13. The Claimant further states that the Respondent discriminated against him by taking disciplinary action against him while sparing the accounting and administrative officers responsible for the disputed remittances. He contends that his termination was unlawful and unfair, amounted to degrading and inhumane treatment, and violated Article 50 of the Constitution because he was denied a fair hearing.
14. He further maintains that the Respondent failed to adequately explain the reasons for terminating his employment.
15. The Claimant further states that the Respondent disregarded his defence, failed to consider his lack of control over the remittance process, did not establish his involvement in any collusion, and failed to provide the minutes of the alleged disciplinary hearing.
16. The Claimant contends that the manner in which his employment was terminated was contrary to fair labour practices.
17. The Claimant finally states that the termination of his employment was wrongful, unfair and unjustified, violated the rules of natural justice, and contravened the Constitution, the Employment Act and the principles of fair labour practices.
18. On cross-examination, the Claimant told the court that he provided one bank account to the Respondent at employment, but later gave two more accounts. He testified further that one account was a salary only account, while the second was for both salary and per diems.
19. It was his testimony that he had no control over how much money was received into his account, and that it was normal to receive payments other than salary. He further averred that he received his bank statements but did not review them unless there was an issue.
20. The Claimant stated that he received payments in his Standard Chartered account on 24th January, 2022 and 14th April, 2022, but that he refunded the money in October and December, 2023.
21. It is his assertion that although he sought clarification of what the payments were for, he did not have evidence to show that he sought the verification.
22. The Claimant confirmed on cross-examination that he attended the disciplinary hearing, cleared with the Respondent upon termination, and was paid his final dues.
23. He confirmed that he was informed of his right of appeal, but did not appeal against the termination.
24. The Claimant prays that the Court allow his claim.
The Respondent’s Case.
25. The Respondent’s case is that it employed the Claimant in various capacities since 2013, including as a Supply Analyst Assistant, Graduate Geochemist, Petroleum Geochemist and, ultimately, Geochemist in the Upstream Division, under the contract dated 1st July, 2020. It further contends that, under the appointment letter’s clause on Duties and Code of Conduct, the Claimant was required to comply with the Corporation’s rules, regulations, procedures, manuals and applicable laws.
26. The Respondent avers that its HR policies, Business Travel Policy and Procedures Manual prescribe procedures for accounting for per diem and imprest funds, and further provide for disciplinary action for failure to account.
27. It further relies on Section 328(a) and (b)(ii) of the Penal Code on the criminal implications of fraudulent acts, including making false entries in corporate books or accounts with intent to defraud.
28. The Respondent avers that their Internal Audit Department investigation report established that the Claimant irregularly received per diem payments of KShs.156,800 on 24th January, 2022 through invoice No. ENIP11458013, and KShs.353,310 on 14th April, 2022 through invoice No. EZVIP11544343.
29. The Respondent further avers that the Internal Audit Report revealed that KShs.353,310, recorded as imprest under the account of the Assistant Manager, Geology, Elizabeth Kimburi, was instead paid into the Claimant’s bank account, despite his absence from the Staff Travel Request Schedule for the ENI-drilling-Mlima well. It also states that, when asked by the Acting Manager, Finance, on 29th September, 2023 to provide approvals for the KShs.156,800 payment, the Claimant responded on 4th October, 2023, that no such EMP existed, notwithstanding that the amount had been credited to his account on 25th January, 2022.
30. It is the Respondent’s case that, by an email dated 28th November 2023, the Senior Financial Auditor requested the Claimant to confirm surrender of the disputed payments. It avers that the Claimant subsequently confirmed that he had refunded KShs.353,310 and KShs.156,800 through interbank transfers, which he communicated by emails dated 6th December, 2023 and 13th October 2023, respectively.
31. The Respondent states that following completion of the Internal Audit investigations and submission of the report to the Chief Executive Officer, it interdicted the Claimant by a letter dated 12th January, 2024, to facilitate further investigations and disciplinary proceedings.
32. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant was interdicted following credible information concerning suspected fraudulent transactions involving payments into his bank account. It contends that the interdiction was necessary to facilitate a transparent and thorough investigation.
33. The Respondent states that the interdiction was subsequently extended for one month from 14th May, 2024, by a letter dated 8th May, 2024. The Respondent further states that the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter dated 14th March, 2024, setting out the charges against him and allowing him seven days to respond.
34. The Respondent further avers that the Claimant denied the allegations in his response dated 20th March, 2024, but his explanations remained inconsistent with the available transactional records, warranting disciplinary action.
35. It states that the Chief Executive Officer appointed a six-member Disciplinary Committee under the Respondent’s HR Policies and Procedures Manual to review the investigation findings, conduct hearings and recommend appropriate action.
36. It avers that the Committee subsequently invited the Claimant, by a letter dated 4th April, 2024, to attend a disciplinary hearing on 17th April, 2024, and further informed him of his right to be accompanied and the consequences of failing to attend.
37. The Respondent avers that the Claimant attended the disciplinary hearing on 17th April 2024, was informed of his rights and the charges against him, and given an opportunity to make oral representations. It states that the Claimant acknowledged receiving KShs.156,800 and KShs.353,310 into his Standard Chartered Bank account, but could not account for the two payments, totaling KShs.510,110, which remained unaccounted for over a year in breach of the Respondent’s HR Policies and Procedures Manual.
38. The Respondent further contends that, although the Claimant claimed he was unaware of the payments, he confirmed receiving monthly bank statements for the subject accounts.
39. The Respondent avers that the Disciplinary Committee considered the Claimant’s oral submissions and the applicable HR Policies and Procedures Manual before making its findings and recommendations. It contends that the Claimant declined to provide bank statements for January to June 2022 to clarify the disputed payments and further failed to demonstrate that he promptly alerted management of the unexplained deposits.
40. It is the Respondent’s case that the Claimant was therefore subjected to disciplinary action based solely on the alleged financial irregularities, and not on any discriminatory grounds prohibited under Article 27(4) of the Constitution.
41. It contends that the termination was lawful, fair and consistent with best labour practices, having been based on findings of financial misconduct supported by evidence of irregular payments and the Claimant’s failure to account for the funds promptly.
42. The Respondent consequently urges the Court to dismiss the Claimant’s claim as unfounded and without merit, with costs.
43. On cross-examination, the Respondent’s witness told the Court that only officers in the finance department could initiate payments and that the Claimant was a geologist and not a finance officer.
44. RW1 further testified that the Claimant refunded the full amount in issue to the Respondent and that the Respondent accepted the refund.
45. It is RW1’s evidence that the Respondent reported the issue to the DCI and that some employees were charged, but the Claimant was not among the people charged.
46. RW1 further told the court that the Claimant was issued a show cause letter two months after suspension. He also confirmed that the investigation report was shared with him.
47. The Respondent prays that the Claimant’s Claim be dismissed with costs.
Analysis and Determination.
48. I have considered the pleadings, the witnesses’ oral testimonies and the rival submissions. The following issues arise for determination:-
i. Whether the Claimant’s termination was both procedurally and substantively fair and lawful.
ii. Whether the Respondent discriminated against the Claimant or violated his constitutional rights.
iii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought.
Whether the Claimant’s termination was both procedurally and substantively fair
49. An employee is deemed fairly terminated from service where the employer adheres to the twin tenets of substantive and procedural fairness. On substantive justification, Section 47(5) of the Employment Act places the initial burden of establishing that an unfair termination occurred upon the employee, while the employer bears the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination.
50. Further, Section 43(1) of the Employment Act demands that an employer prove the reason (s) for terminating an employee’s employment, while Section 45(2) further requires that the employer demonstrates that the reason (s) for termination was valid and fair, related to the employee’s conduct, capacity or compatibility, or the employer’s operational requirements.
51. In Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited [2014] KEIC 121 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed the employer’s obligation to prove the reasons for dismissal and demonstrate that they were valid and fair.
52. The Respondent herein told the court that it terminated the Claimant’s employment on allegations of involvement in financial irregularities arising from two payments amounting to KShs.510,110, which were deposited into his bank account on 24th January, 2022, and 14th April 2022. The Respondent further asserted that the payments were irregular because the Claimant was not listed on the relevant travel schedule for the payment of KShs.353,310, and that he failed to promptly account for the funds.
53. The Claimant both in his pleadings and his oral testimony admitted receiving both payments, only arguing that he subsequently refunded the full amount to the Respondent and that the Respondent did not incur any loss on account of the payment.
54. The Claimant further maintained that he neither requested for the payments nor exercised control over the Respondent’s payment processes as he was not a finance officer. RW1 partly supported this position, confirming that the Claimant was a Geochemist, not a finance officer, and that the finance department initiated the payments.
55. In my considered view, the fact that the Claimant was not responsible for initiating payments does not entirely absolve him of responsibility for unexplained funds credited to his personal account. He stated that he received his bank statements, but ordinarily did not review them unless an issue arose. He also did not dispute that the subject payments remained in his account for a considerable period, and that he refunded them only after inquiries by the Respondent’s finance and audit departments.
56. In my view, the subsequent refund of the money, although relevant, does not by itself extinguish the Respondent’s legitimate concern regarding the circumstances in which the payments were received and retained for close to a year.
57. The Court must distinguish between proof of fraudulent intent and proof of misconduct arising from an employee’s failure to exercise reasonable diligence concerning unexplained payments. In my view, the Respondent was not required to secure a criminal conviction before taking disciplinary action. It only needed to demonstrate a valid, fair, justified, and employment related reason for its decision to terminate the Claimant’s employment.
58. In Charles Musungu Odana v Kenya Ports Authority [2019] KEELRC 2206 (KLR), the Court stated:-
“It is now clear that the burden placed on an employer by Section 43 of the Employment Act is to establish a valid reason that would cause a reasonable employer to terminate employment.”
59. Further, in British Leyland v Swift (1981) I. R L.R 91, Lord Denning describes the test of what a reasonable employer could or could not do in the following words:-
“The correct test is: was it reasonable for the employer to dismiss? If no reasonable employer would have dismissed him, then the dismissal was unfair, but if a reasonable employer might reasonably have dismissed him, the dismissal was fair…..”
60. The evidence before the court establishes that the subject payments were credited to the Claimant’s account, that he did not promptly establish or report their purpose, and that he refunded the funds only after the matter was raised and indeed became a subject of criminal investigation by the Respondent. In my view, these circumstances provided a reasonable basis for the Respondent to question the Claimant’s conduct, notwithstanding his lack of responsibility for initiating and effecting the transactions.
61. In the premise, I find and hold that the Respondent had a valid, fair and justified reason to terminate the Claimant’s employment.
62. On procedural fairness, Section 41 of the Employment Act requires that an employer contemplating termination of employment on the ground of misconduct explains the reason for the intended termination in a language the employee understands, and further afford the employee an opportunity to make representations, accompanied by another employee or a shop-floor union representative of the employee’s choice.
63. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR), the Court of Appeal spelled out the minimum elements of a fair hearing, including explanation of the grounds for termination, notification of the reason for the contemplated termination, the employee’s entitlement to be accompanied, and consideration of the employee’s representations.
64. It is not in dispute that the Claimant was interdicted on 12th January, 2024, issued with a show cause letter on 14th March, 2024, and allowed seven days within which to respond to the charges leveled against him. It is also not disputed that the Claimant responded to the show cause vide a letter dated 20th March, 2024, denying the allegations, and was subsequently invited to a disciplinary hearing by a letter dated 4th April, 2024. The Claimant in his evidence confirmed that he attended the hearing on 17th April, 2024, where he was informed of the charges and afforded an opportunity to make oral representations.
65. The Respondent further maintained that the invitation informed the Claimant of his right to be accompanied, and that fact is evident in the letter inviting the Claimant to the disciplinary hearing dated 4th April, 2024, produced in evidence.
66. The Claimant further acknowledged that he was informed of his right of appeal against the decision to terminate his services, but which he did not exercise. The Claimant, however, asserted that the Respondent disregarded his explanation.
67. On the evidence before the court, it is clear that the Claimant’s defense was considered but was not accepted by the Respondent. An employer is not required to accept an employee’s explanation, but is instead required to consider it fairly before reaching a decision to terminate/dismiss. The Claimant’s disagreement with the outcome of the disciplinary hearing therefore does not demonstrate procedural unfairness.
68. Further, the interdiction preceding the issuance of the show cause letter is also not, by itself, proof of unfair procedure. In my view, an employer is at liberty to take reasonable interim measures to facilitate investigations, provided those measures comply with the applicable employment terms and do not predetermine the disciplinary outcome.
69. I therefore find and hold that the Respondent adhered to the tenets of fair process in terminating the Claimant’s employment; hence, the termination is procedurally fair and lawful.
Whether the Respondent discriminated against the Claimant
70. Article 27 of the Constitution guarantees equality and freedom from discrimination, while Section 5(3) and (6) of the Employment Act prohibits discrimination in employment and further places a burden on the employer to disprove an allegation of discrimination once a relevant claim is raised.
71. The Claimant contends that the Respondent singled him out for disciplinary action while failing to take similar action against accounting and administrative officers who processed the disputed payments.
72. For starters, the fact that the Claimant was the recipient of the subject funds, while other officers were responsible for initiating the payments, raises a legitimate question as to whether the Respondent investigated the conduct of all the persons involved. Nevertheless, the court acknowledges that different roles and degrees of responsibility may justify different disciplinary responses. Unequal treatment does not necessarily amount to unlawful discrimination.
73. Further, the Claimant did not, on the evidence before the court, establish that the Respondent’s decision was based on a prohibited ground under Article 27(4) of the Constitution, nor is there sufficient evidence demonstrating that the other officers were similarly situated in all material respects or that their treatment was motivated by a discriminatory consideration.
74. The Respondent’s position is that its action was based on the Claimant’s conduct in relation to the irregular payments. In the absence of evidence linking the decision to discipline and subsequently terminate the Claimant to a prohibited ground, I find that the allegation of unlawful discrimination has not been proven.
Whether the Claimant’s constitutional rights were violated
75. The Claimant has also alleged that his constitutional rights under Articles 28, 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution were violated.
76. The disciplinary process in an employment relationship must comply with the statutory safeguards provided in Section 41 of the Employment Act, as well as the applicable constitutional standards. It is, however, now settled that not every adverse disciplinary decision constitutes a separate constitutional violation.
77. The evidence presented herein does not in any way establish that the Respondent subjected the Claimant to degrading or inhumane treatment, or that the termination was motivated by an intention to undermine his dignity. There is also no evidence that the Respondent violated Article 47 merely because it reached a disciplinary conclusion adverse to him.
78. I therefore find that the Claimant has not established any independent constitutional violations.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought
79. Having found that the Claimant’s termination is both substantively and procedurally fair, all the claims sought by the Claimant fail and are hereby dismissed.
80. In whole, I find the Claimant’s Claim totally devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed with costs to the Respondent.
81. Judgment accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ms. Ateka h/b for Mr. Onyango for the Claimant
Ms. Odongo present for the Respondent
Ms. Esther S - Court Assistant