Employment law

Wahome v Kenya Railways Corporation [2026] KEELRC 14712 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Review Application E091 of 2026
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbarũ

Case research

Open case research →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI

JUDICIAL

REVIEW APPLICATION NO. E091 OF 2026

VICTOR KARIUKI WAHOME ……………… APPLICANT

VERSUS

KENYA RAILWAYS CORPORATION ……….. RESPONDENT

RULING

The applicant moved the court by way of judicial review and refers to his application as a petition. He seeks interim orders pending the hearing of his petition.

In response, the respondent filed Notice of Preliminary Objections dated 18 September 2026 on the basis that the petition is an abuse of court process and does not raise any substantive constitutional question that cannot be addressed under an ordinary claim. The rights under the Employment Act and Labour Relations Act can well be addressed through a Memorandum of Claim filed in terms of Rule 7 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules (ELRC Rules)

Other objections are that no special constitutional issue can be ascertained with precision to justify this petition, as required in Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] KLR. The procedure adopted by the petitioner is fundamentally flawed, and the issues raised could have well been addressed under Rule 10(3) of the ELRC Rules.

The court lacks jurisdiction to grant the reliefs sought, which relate to an order seeking to lift the suspension, an order of reinstatement and payment of half-salary withheld during the interdiction. This is not a proper petition and should be struck out.

On the objections, parties filed written submissions and tended to highlight.

The respondent submitted that, on the facts addressed in the petitioner/applicant's application, he was an employee of the respondent until his interdiction on 15 August 2018, following his arrest and arraignment in court in Anti-Corruption Case No. ACCR/33/2018 – Republic v Prof. Abdalla Swazuri Mohammed & 16 others. The charges included neglect of official duty arising from a scandal involving illegal and fraudulent land compensation claims in the Standard Gauge Railway project. The petitioner was acquitted on 26 March 2026.

The respondent submitted that the petitioner grew impatient with the pace at which the respondent was processing his dues and opted to file these proceedings. Instead of filing an ordinary claim, the petitioner chose to move the court by way of a constitutional petition. Such a procedure is unnecessary and an abuse of court process, as held in Muraguri v Principal Secretary, Ministry of Interior [2026] eklr. Under Rule 10(3) of the ELRC Rules, a party may file a Memorandum of Claim and raise a case involving the enforcement of constitutional rights and freedoms. To move the court under a constitutional petition without urging any case of conflict of laws denies the court the inherent constitutional mandate, and the petition should be struck out.

The petitioner submitted that he has established a case of breach of his constitutional rights by the respondent, warranting the filing of the petition. The objections that he should have filed an ordinary suit in a Memorandum of Claim rather than a constitutional petition are not a fatal bar. The court should not look at the technicalities but address the substantive issues addressed in the petition.

The petitioner submitted that, under the respondent's Human Resource Manual, clause 11.16.4 provides that where disciplinary or criminal proceedings have been taken against an officer under interdiction, and there is no dismissal, any salary withheld should be restored to him upon termination of such proceedings. The petitioner was placed on interdiction pending the criminal proceedings made against him by the respondent. He has since been discharged, but the respodnetn has not reinstated him nor paid the back wages.

The test in the Anarita Karimi case has been satisfied. The orders sought in the petition are well outlined with precision. The constitutional violations are particularised and the remedies sought thereof set out. The respondent has violated the rights under Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution. The petition sets out the factual basis upon which the orders sought should be granted. It identifies that the petitioner’s interdiction on 15 August 2018 and criminal proceedings in Anti-Corruption Case No. An acquittal followed CCR/33/2018, and the petitioner is thus entitled to the withheld salary payments and an order of reinstatement.

The nature of wrongs and constitutional violations are identified. In Geoffrey Muthinja & another v Samuel Muguna Henry & others [2015] eKLR, the court held that so long as the facts are sufficiently outlined, the court should hear the substantive issues in the petition on merit. The petition does not merely invoke constitutional provisions; the constitutional rights relied upon have been breached because the respondents failed to undertake their contractual obligations to the petitioner.

Determination

As set out above, the application was moved before the court under Judicial Review Proceedings. The application is indeed registered in the CTS as ELRC Judicial Review Application No. E091 of 2026 and not as a petition.

The applicant has the advantage of legal representation. A layperson would be forgiven for the lapse and allowed the latitude to withdraw the application and move the court appropriately.

Calling the matter a petition or petitioner is not sufficient. A Judicial review application has a contest and purpose. It is regulated under Article 23 of the Constitution and under the ELRC Rules. On the respondent's objections herein, where the applicant noted the lapse, instead of doing the honourable thing and withdrawing these proceedings, he has urged that this is a proper petition.

It is not a petition.

The respondent's objections to this extent are correct.

Even in a case where this was a proper petition, which it is not, under Rule 10(3) of the ELRC Rules, a party is allowed to urge a case of judicial review or constitutional rights violations in a Memorandum of Claim.

Why is this necessary?

Proceedings before this court, unlike those before the other superior courts, are governed by the ELRC Rules, not the Civil Procedure Act and the Rules thereto. The ELRC Rules allow a party to move the court without undue regard to technicalities. However, the choice of how to initiate a suit matters, as it allows the respondent to file a response, a Replying Affidavit, or, in judicial review proceedings, respond as required in terms of the Law Reform Act.

Under a constitutional petition, the rules now require that where the rights addressed are founded on an employment relationship, the Employment Act and the Labour Relations Act rights can well be articulated in a Memorandum of Claim. The rationale is that Article 41 rights are now addressed under these statutes, and unless any provision(s) thereof are insufficient, filing a constitutional petition is unnecessary, as held in Speaker of the National Assembly v Karume [1992] KECA 42 (KLR).

Indeed, in Sumayya Athmani Hassan v Paul Masinde Simidi & another [2019] KECA 107 (KLR), the court struck out a petition which relied directly on constitutional provisions to enforce what were, in substance, Employment Act and Labour Relations Act rights, holding it is not permissible for a litigant to found a cause of action directly on the Constitution without challenging the legislation in question. Hence, the claim did not disclose a cause of action anchored on the Constitution.

The core of the judicial review application herein is what the applicant is seeking:

The applicant has filed an application and Notice of Motion dated 3 September 2026.

No Supporting Affidavit accompanies this application.

The petition is without a Supporting Affidavit.

The application and petition are left bare.

Under the ELRC Rules, an application such as the one dated 3 September 2026 must be supported by the Supporting Affidavit confirming the facts thereto. This is not far removed from the Civil Procedure Act and the Rules thereto.

Without a Supporting Affidavit, the foundation of the application is lost, as held in Achieng t/a Dolhays Knitwear v Kosgei & another [2025] KEHC 10186 (KLR). The defect is fatal and cannot be cured by the court's discretion, as held in Maisitis & another v Ndung'u [2026] KECA 366 (KLR).

The applicant seeks to urge a case for payment of his back salaries and allowances from the date of interdiction on 15 August 2018 to date. He also seeks an order of reinstatement.

Without a proper petition, supported by an affidavit attached to the application, or a Memorandum of Claim, granting the orders sought in the interim would be a travesty of justice. However justified the applicant finds his case, it is settled that every case must be founded on the substantive orders sought in a petition or memorandum of claim supported by an affidavit. The Verifying Affidavit attached to the petition merely confirms the correctness of the record. It does not support the petition.

Even in Judicial Review proceedings as herein done, a Statutory Statement must be filed together with the motion.

The orders sought by the applicant/petitioner have no foundation. The procedure adopted to move the court is an abuse of the process of this Court. Such abuse is not permissible.

The respondent's objections have merit to the extent that this is not a proper petition. As to the abuse of court process, the respondent's objection is allowed; the suit is dismissed with costs to the respondent.

Delivered in open court this 22nd day of October 2026

M. MBARŨ

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder