REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E818 OF 2019
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)
NANCY KAGURE WACHIRA.........……………………….…CLAIMANT
VS
THE STANDARD GROUP LIMITED……....................RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1 The Claimant instituted this claim vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 3rd December 2019 and prays that this Court grants him an award as follows:
a. The letter dated 10th September 2018 be declared Null and Void ab initio and be withdrawn in toto in all respects.
b. The Claimant continue serving in office without any let or hindrance.
c. In the alternative general damages for unlawful dismissal amounting to a year’s wages in the sum of Kshs. 3,768,000.88
d. Three months’ salary in lieu of notice in the sum of Kshs. 942,000.72
AND the Claimant claims compensatory general damages for
a. Violation of constitutional and fundamental rights, freedoms and protections;
b. Loss of Office Unfairly, Illegally, Unconstitutionally and without following Due Process or the dictates of Natural Justice
c. Career compromise and stagnation after distinguished service at the highest levels
d. Injury to reputation and
e. Loss of future income.
f. Cost and interest
g. Any other award, order and relief as may be directed by this Honourable
Claimant’s Case
2 The Claimant avers that she served the Respondent, a media company, for more than five years. She was employed on 26th August 2013 as Procurement Manager and rose through the ranks to the position of Procurement and Supply Chain Manager.
3 It is her case that by a letter dated 10th August 2018, served on 14th August 2018, the Respondent suspended her from work. The letter accused her of, among other things, the unauthorized release of newsprint, failure to post records and exposing the Respondent's assets to possible loss. The Respondent thereafter terminated her services by a letter dated 10th September 2018.
4 The Claimant avers that the allegations were false and were a mere excuse by a Respondent which had already decided to terminate her.
5 She contends that the decision was not supported by particulars of any regulation or policy she allegedly breached, and that she was found in breach of a non-existent regulation or policy. She further contends that she was blamed for matters handled by other employees, some of whom had acted without her authority. In her view the Respondent discriminated against her, as no action was taken against those employees.
6 It is the Claimant’s case that the Respondent suffered no loss attributable to her, that it disregarded its own well-known previous practices, and that her performance was on any objective assessment exemplary, yet she was denied the benefit of her positive performance appraisals.
7 On procedure, the Claimant avers that the disciplinary process was a smokescreen intended to cover up the Respondent's illegalities, and that it fell short of the Respondent's own internal standards, the Bill of Rights and employment law.
8 She contends that the charges against her were never clear and mutated at different stages of the process, which in her view shows that the Respondent was on a fishing expedition aimed at terminating her by all means.
9 She further avers that she was not accorded representation or a fair hearing before the decision was made, and that the termination letter was final in its terms, allowing no appeal or review.
10 It is her case that the Respondent acted as prosecutor, judge and executioner all at once, in breach of the rules of natural justice embodied in nemo judex in causa sua and audi alteram partem, and of her constitutional right to a fair hearing and due process.
11 The Claimant asserts that she was specifically targeted, that the Respondent acted under ulterior motives and treated her with contempt and high-handedness, and that the termination was therefore unfair, illegal, arbitrary and unlawful.
12 The Claimant avers that despite a demand and notice of intention to sue, the Respondent refused to withdraw the termination letter, make amends or admit liability. She states that she stands to suffer irreparable loss should the termination be allowed to stand.
Respondent’s Case
13 In opposition to the claim, the Respondent filed a Statement of Response dated 3rd February 2020.
14 The Respondent avers that by a contract dated 26th August 2013, it offered the Claimant the post of Procurement Manager with effect from 4th November 2013, which offer she accepted. It admits that it terminated her services by a letter dated 10th September 2018.
15 It is the Respondent's case that by a letter dated 24th July 2018, it required the Claimant to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against her for authorizing, without proper authority, the release to Nation Media Group of newsprint that should have been delivered to the Respondent.
16 The letter stated that her actions were tantamount to negligence in the performance of her duties and gave her until close of business on 25th July 2018 to respond. This followed Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 and clause 5.3 of its Disciplinary Policy.
17 The Respondent avers that the Claimant responded by a letter dated 26th July 2018. In it she explained that on 22nd February 2018 the Head of Production, Mr. George Okoth, informed her that Nation Media Group had requested a loan of 750 metric tonnes of newsprint, and that on the same day Nation Media Group's Group Head of Operations, Mr. George Aswani, wrote asking the Respondent to consider selling it 500 to 1,000 metric tonnes owing to logistical challenges.
18 It further avers that the Claimant further explained that after confirming the stock levels she discussed the loan with Mr. Aswani on 26th February 2018, and on 27th February 2018 Mr. Okoth wrote to her that the then Acting CEO had inquired about the expected return date. She then began the logistics of delivery. She admitted that she instructed her colleague, Mr. Hezekiah Gitau, to divert trucks already en route to Nairobi to Nation Media Group to avoid double handling, and to ensure that a warehouse representative supervised the offloading and retrieved the reel barcodes for entry into the SAP system.
19 The Respondent avers that according to her response, a total of 288.254 metric tonnes was delivered and reflected in the monthly critical stock reports.
20 The Respondent thus avers that she finally admitted that she had put it at risk in the loan process and that the process needed to be formalized.
21 The Respondent avers that by a letter dated 10th August 2018 it suspended the Claimant for 30 days on full salary to allow an in-depth investigation, in compliance with clause 7.1 of its Disciplinary Policy. The suspension letter set out the risks identified in its Audit Department's report. The loan of 481 reels, being 288.254 metric tonnes valued at Kshs. 21.3 million, had not been posted in the SAP system as at 30th June 2018, either as inventory or as a loan, exposing the Respondent to understatement of its assets and misleading accounting records. The audit also noted the absence of clear authorization and documentation for the loan, which exposed the Respondent to unauthorized transfer of assets.
22 Further, although Nation Media Group was to return the same quantity and quality of newsprint by May 2018, it had not done so by 30th June 2018, exposing the Respondent to the risk of running out of stock and tying up its working capital.
23 Lastly, a stock take of 28th May 2018 revealed newsprint moved from the bonded warehouse to the free warehouse without being posted in SAP. While total physical stock matched system stock, the variance per warehouse exposed the Respondent to penalties for consuming bonded stock without KRA clearance, possible closure of the bonded warehouse and increased financing costs.
24 It is the Respondent's case that by a letter dated 20th August 2018 it invited the Claimant to a disciplinary hearing on 22nd August 2018 and asked her to attend with an employee representative, in compliance with Section 41(1) of the Act and clause 5.6.2 of the Disciplinary Policy.
25 It avers that at the hearing the charges were explained to her in a language she understood, she was given adequate opportunity to respond orally, and she was accompanied by Mr. George Okoth as her witness.
26 The Respondent avers that at the hearing the Claimant admitted that about 288 tonnes were released to Nation Media Group, which had initially sought 500 tonnes, and that the physical movement of newsprint stock was among her responsibilities. She also admitted that in or about May 2018 the Group Chief Executive Officer told her she had released the newsprint without his approval.
27 The Respondent contends that the Claimant further admitted that while Nation Media Group's Group CEO was copied in the correspondence, the Respondent's Group CEO was not. As at the date of the hearing, she stated, only about 170 of the 288 tonnes had been returned, and the barcodes of the newsprint were never retrieved and scanned into SAP.
28 The Respondent denies that the allegations against the Claimant were false or a pretext. It avers that upon considering her presentation it found that her conduct amounted to gross misconduct, in breach of Section 44(4)(c) of the Employment Act, 2007 and clause 19.6 of its Human Resource Policy Manual, and it summarily dismissed her.
29 It avers that the Claimant was heard on the allegations in the show cause letter and that it followed a fair, transparent and proper procedure and dismissed her on valid reasons.
30 It further avers that in or about September 2018 the Claimant appealed under clause 5.7 of the Disciplinary Policy. An Independent Appeal Committee constituted by the CEO met on 11th October 2018, found that she had been negligent in performing her duties, and upheld the decision of the Disciplinary Committee. The Respondent puts the Claimant to strict proof of her averment that her performance was exemplary.
31 On the reliefs, the Respondent avers that reinstatement would not be practical. It contends that the position of Procurement Manager is critical to its performance and is a fiduciary position requiring the trust and confidence of the Board in the holder's competence and integrity, and that it has lost such trust and confidence in the Claimant.
32 The Respondent further avers that the role did not involve any specialized skill usable only in its service, so that the Claimant can secure similar alternative employment.
33 The Respondent denies that the Claimant is entitled to any of the prayers sought and urges that the claim be dismissed with costs.
Evidence in Court
34 CW1, Nancy Kagure Wachira, the Claimant, adopted her witness statement dated 3rd December 2019 as her evidence in chief and produced her list of documents dated the same date as her exhibits 1 to 6.
35 On cross-examination, she stated that the newsprint in issue was the Respondent's asset. She denied personally releasing it to Nation Media Group, testifying that the release was done by the department as a whole.
36 She testified that she participated in it but that it was not the first time the Respondent had loaned newsprint to Nation Media Group.
37 CW1 conceded that she received no authorization from the Acting Managing Director to release the newsprint. However, she maintained that there was communication with the Head of Production, who was the one who sought the loan. In particular, she pointed to the email of 22nd February 2018 addressed to her and the response at page 24 of her bundle.
38 CW1 admitted that there were no written instructions from the Respondent to Nation Media Group, and that apart from the emails there was no written agreement for the loan.
39 She testified that she had asked for a policy to govern such transactions but was dismissed. She accepted that, as a procurement professional, she recognized the need for proper authorization.
40 In re-examination, CW1 clarified that while she was responsible for safeguarding the Respondent's inventory, the release was made at the request of the Head of Production and was supported by proper email communication, including the email of 27th February 2018 at page 28 of her bundle.
41 She testified that she released the newsprint only after receiving written confirmation from Nation Media Group, referring to the communication of 25th February 2018.
42 She maintained that the reasons given in her suspension letter were not based on any written policy of the Respondent.
43 CW1 further testified that she was not given a chance to be heard, although on cross-examination she had stated that she attended the disciplinary hearing, gave her version and appealed the dismissal.
44 RW1, Sharon Tomian, the Respondent's Human Resource Manager, adopted her witness statement dated 27th October 2024 as her evidence in chief and produced the Respondent's documents dated 26th December 2023 as her Exhibits 1 to 18.
45 On cross-examination, RW1 conceded that the Respondent has no procedure for the release of newsprint reels, and that this was not the first time it had released reels to Nation Media Group.
46 She confirmed that Mr. George Okoth wrote the email of 22nd February 2018 in the course of the Respondent's business relationship with Nation Media Group, and that the newsprint loaned was a significant surplus. The email of Mr. George Aswani indicates this.
47 RW1 testified that she knows Mr. Olando, the Head of Production, and acknowledged the emails of 26th and 27th February 2018. She testified that both the Head of Production and the Claimant were fully aware of the transaction. However, she did not know whether the Respondent ran out of stock as a result of the loan.
48 RW1 further conceded that the Respondent's own audit report proposed, as remedies, a SAP module to capture sold and loaned assets and clear approval procedures. She could not confirm that the Respondent had a policy on such loans. She also accepted that under the audit's remedial plan Nation Media Group had agreed to return the newsprint by the end of June 2018.
49 RW1 admitted that the disciplinary process and the show cause letter were founded on the release of the newsprint and were not pegged on any policy. She further conceded that under clause 10 of her contract the Claimant was bound to obey orders issued by the company.
50 RW1 testified that the Head of Production, who is part of the company, issued the instruction to loan the reels to Nation Media Group, and when the Claimant asked whether they could do so, he told her that the CEO required formal communication from Nation Media Group.
51 In re-examination, RW1 maintained that the Claimant's conduct exposed the Respondent to a real threat of sanctions by KRA. She pointed out that the newsprint audit at pages 26 and 27 names the Claimant.
52 She testified that the Claimant was taken through a proper disciplinary process under the Respondent's Disciplinary Policy. That policy states at page 6 that its purpose is to set strict procedures in the company, and clause 5 requires staff to familiarize themselves with it.
53 RW1 testified that although the newsprint was surplus, its release was irregular, and that as head of procurement, the Claimant was responsible for ensuring that the Respondent's stock tallied.
Claimants’ Submissions
54 The Claimant identified three issues for determination: whether her dismissal was based on valid and justifiable reasons, whether it was procedurally fair, and whether she is entitled to the remedies sought.
55 On the first issue, the Claimant submitted that Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act give effect to the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution. Under Section 43(1), the employer is required to prove the reason for termination, failing which the termination is deemed unfair within the meaning of Section 45. Section 45(2) in turn provides that a termination is unfair if the employer fails to prove that the reason is valid and fair, and related to the employee's conduct, capacity or compatibility or based on its operational requirements.
56 In support thereof, she cited National Bank of Kenya v Anthony Njue John [2019] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal reiterated the holding in Janet Nyandiko v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2017] eKLR that:"…a termination of an employee is deemed to be unfair if the employer fails to prove that the reason for the termination was valid; that the reason for the termination was a fair reason and that the same was related to the employee's conduct, capacity, compatibility…"
57 It is the Claimant's submission that the Respondent failed to discharge this burden. The show cause and suspension letters charged her with breaching clause 10(a) of her letter of appointment, which required her to abide by the company's orders.
58 She submitted that the email trail shows she acted on the Respondent's own instructions. On 22nd February 2018, Nation Media Group asked to buy newsprint, and the Head of Production, after confirming with procurement, replied that it was possible to loan rather than sell it, given the two companies' business relationship. Nation Media Group was thereafter put in touch with her.
59 The Claimant contended that the Respondent's own personnel set the transaction in motion, the Respondent was aware of it, and she complied with the instructions of its agents. She argued that the Respondent's witness pointed to no document or rule requiring the CEO's prior written approval, and that there was no evidence the CEO ever reprimanded her for breaching any policy.
60 Absent any policy on the release of newsprint, she submitted, the Respondent had no yardstick against which to prove that the loan was irregular.
61 The Claimant further submitted that the CEO's requirement of his express approval arose from a management meeting of 27th February 2018 which she did not attend. She pointed out that the minutes of that meeting were never produced, and that the person tasked with informing her of its resolutions never did so, as the disciplinary minutes themselves reveal.
62 It is the Claimant’s submission that failure to capture the newsprint in the SAP system was not her fault. The asset accountant, Mr. Dickson Changkwony, explained at the disciplinary hearing that he was responsible for SAP entries and that the system does not allow partial entries.
63 She also contended that in May 2018, before the show cause letter, she and other departments had identified the gaps and risks in loaning newsprint and proposed remedial measures with deadlines, as shown at pages 24 to 27 of the Respondent's bundle. These recommendations were never acted upon.
64 The Claimant submitted that in effect, she was punished for institutional shortcomings: the failure to communicate management resolutions, the absence of a clear policy and an outdated SAP system. Additionally, the dismissal letter itself betrays this by faulting her for not personally seeking the CEO's approval and placing on her alone the consequences of the lack of a policy.
65 The Claimant also submitted that the charge, framed under clause 19.6(III) of the Respondent's Human Resource Manual as gross misconduct by way of negligence or failure to perform duties as expected, is in substance an allegation of poor performance. Such an allegation, she submitted, must be measured against an established policy or practice.
66 Reliance was placed on Ngila v Kenya Breweries Ltd [2025] KEELRC 455 (KLR), where the Court held:"The employer must also show that in arriving at the decision of noting the poor performance of an employee they had put in place an employment policy or practice on how to measure good performance as against poor performance…"
67 She submitted that the Respondent placed no such policy before the Court. The Head of Production's remarks in the disciplinary minutes confirm that loans between the Respondent and Nation Media Group were a longstanding practice, and her averments on that practice remain uncontroverted. Moreover, Nation Media Group had begun returning the newsprint before the disciplinary hearing. The reason for her dismissal was therefore, baseless and unfair.
68 On procedural fairness, the Claimant submitted that she was not accorded a fair hearing. Although she was suspended expressly to allow investigations, no investigation report was ever shared with her or produced in Court, and the disciplinary panel itself lacked the necessary documents, its recommendations largely calling for investigations to be done.
69 She cited Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal held: "The Board had in its possession the very document that formed the basis of the charges framed against the respondent but kept it away from him. Even in criminal trials, which are more serious in nature, an accused is entitled to the statements that support the charges laid against him."
70 The Claimant further cited Munyite v Harambee Sacco Society [2024] KEELRC 1287 (KLR) for the precept that an accused must be supplied with the evidence and documents the accuser will rely on so as to prepare for the hearing. She thus submitted that out that the Respondent's own post-hearing report at page 44 of its bundle shows that 142,603 kilograms of newsprint had already been returned by the date of the hearing. She maintained that this information ought to have formed part of an investigation preceding the hearing.
71 The Claimant further submitted that she was ambushed on the charge. The show cause letter, her response and the suspension letter were all premised on clause 10(a) of her letter of appointment, yet at the outset of the hearing the Chairman announced that the clause did not exist and would be expunged. According to her, she learnt only while before the panel that she was charged with gross misconduct under clause 19.6(III).
72 It is the Claimant’s submission that this substitution shifted her defence from the alleged disobedience of orders, which she had answered in full, to gross misconduct, violated her right to be informed of the charges, and denied her time to prepare, so that the hearing ought to have been adjourned. She added that the panel's question whether she found the process fair did not cure these defects.
73 On the appeal, the Claimant submitted that it was fatally tainted by bias, since Joy Kagiri and Millicent Ngetich sat both on the disciplinary panel and on the appeal. She relied on Mutisya v G4S Kenya Limited [2025] KEELRC 2474 (KLR), where the Court held: "Procedural fairness goes beyond issuing a Notice to Show Cause and inviting an employee to a disciplinary hearing. One of the fundamental principles of natural justice is that the decision makers ought to be impartial and free from bias. The bias can be actual, imputed, or apparent."
74 She also relied on Barmao v G4S Kenya Limited [2024] KEELRC 1141 (KLR), where the Court observed: "The principle with regards to bias prohibits a person from deciding any case in which he or she may be, or may fairly be suspected to be, biased."
75 The Claimant further submitted that, if the release was indeed irregular, the whole team involved ought to have been called to show cause. That team included the Head of Production, the asset accountant responsible for SAP and the officer in charge of the warehouses.
76 It is the Claimant’s submission that singling her out was discriminatory. This unfairness was compounded by allowing the very officer who received the request and instructed her to accompany her as her witness at the hearing.
77 The Claimant therefore submitted that her dismissal was neither substantively justified nor procedurally fair, that she is entitled to the prayers sought, and that her claim should be allowed with costs.
Respondent’s Submissions
78 The Respondent submitted on five issues: whether the Respondent had a valid and fair reason to summarily dismiss the Claimant from employment; whether the Respondent complied with the procedural fairness requirements under the Employment Act, 2007 before summarily dismissing the Claimant; whether the Claimant has established any violation of her constitutional rights and fundamental freedoms; whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought in the Memorandum of Claim; and who should bear the costs of this suit.
79 On the first issue, the Respondent submitted that Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act require the employer to prove reasons for termination that are valid, fair and related to the employee's conduct, capacity, compatibility or its operational requirements.
80 It relied on Kenya Revenue Authority v Gitahi & 2 others [2019] KECA 300 (KLR) and Walter Ogal Anuro V Teachers Service Commission [2013] eKLR for the proposition that a termination must be both substantively justified and procedurally fair.
81 Citing Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi, it argued that an employer need not prove misconduct beyond reasonable doubt or conduct a criminal trial; it suffices that, on the material before it, the employer genuinely and reasonably believed the employee had committed the misconduct.
82 The question for the Court, it submitted, is therefore not whether it would itself have dismissed the Claimant, but whether the Respondent acted reasonably in concluding that she had committed gross misconduct.
83 On the second issue, the Respondent submitted that as Procurement and Supply Chain Manager, a senior management office charged with procurement, inventory management and the movement of its assets, the Claimant was bound to ensure strict compliance with its approval procedures and inventory controls. Given that the transaction involved about 288.254 metric tonnes of newsprint valued at Kshs. 21.3 million, it was entitled to expect that none would be released without the requisite approvals and documentation.
84 The Respondent placed reliance on Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei & another [2014] eKLR for the principle that employees in positions of trust are held to a higher standard of accountability. It further relied on CMC Aviation Limited v Mohammed Noor [2015] eKLR for the principle that an employer may terminate where an employee's conduct fundamentally undermines the confidence essential to the relationship.
85 It is the Respondent's submission that its decision rested not on suspicion but on the Claimant's own admissions, contemporaneous documents and its internal investigations. The Claimant in her response to the show cause letter and at the disciplinary hearing the Claimant admitted facilitating the release, directing the diversion of trucks to Nation Media Group, and that the transaction was neither formally documented, approved nor captured in the SAP system.
86 It further submitted that the audit revealed discrepancies in the inventory records, the absence of documented approvals, delays in the return of the newsprint and irregular movement of bonded stock, which exposed it to financial, accounting and regulatory risk, and that the Claimant did not materially dispute these findings.
87 The Respondent submitted that faced with an admitted unauthorized release of assets worth over Kshs. 21 million, no reasonable employer could be faulted for finding gross misconduct within the meaning of Section 44 of the Employment Act. The reasons were communicated in the show cause letter, maintained consistently through the process and set out in the dismissal letter of 10th September 2018.
88 The Respondent contended that the Claimant's assertions that she was blamed for others' actions, that no loss was suffered, or that it relied on non-existent policies are unsupported by evidence, the real question being whether she discharged the obligations entrusted to her as the responsible senior officer.
89 On procedural fairness, the Respondent submitted that Section 41 of the Employment Act requires an employer contemplating termination for misconduct to explain the allegations and the reasons for the contemplated termination, give the employee an opportunity to respond, and permit her to be accompanied by a fellow employee or shop floor union representative.
90 It relied on Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal held: “Four elements must thus be discernible for the procedure to pass muster: (i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee; (ii) the reason for which the employer is considering termination; (iii) entitlement of an employee to the presence of another employee or shop floor union representative when the explanation of grounds of termination is made; and (iv) hearing and considering any representations made by the employee and the person chosen by the employee."
91 The Respondent submitted that each of these elements was met. The Claimant received a detailed show cause letter and responded comprehensively, which demonstrates that she understood the allegations. She was suspended on full pay, a measure it described as investigative rather than punitive given the magnitude of the transaction. She was then invited to a disciplinary hearing, informed of the allegations and of her right to be accompanied, attended with Mr. George Okoth, the Head of Production, as her chosen representative, and was given a full opportunity to explain herself and answer questions.
92 It is the Respondent’s submission that the minutes show the panel considered her written and oral explanations and the investigation findings, therefore, the process was deliberative rather than predetermined. Further, the Claimant was informed of her right of appeal and exercised it, the appeal being considered and dismissed by a letter dated 22nd October 2018, which shows that it subjected its own decision to internal review.
93 On the alleged constitutional violations, the Respondent submitted that such violations are not presumed merely because an employee is dissatisfied with the outcome, and that a party alleging them must plead them with precision. It relied on Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] eKLR, where the Court held:"…if a person is seeking redress from the High Court on a matter which involves a reference to the Constitution, it is important that he should set out with a reasonable degree of precision that of which he complains, the provisions said to be infringed and the manner in which they are alleged to be infringed."
94 Relying on Mumo Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 others [2013] eKLR, which reaffirmed that principle; the Respondent submitted that the claim makes only broad references to fair hearing and due process without identifying the provisions infringed or how. Therefore, the complaint that it acted as prosecutor, judge and executioner is untenable, since internal disciplinary proceedings are by nature conducted by the employer, and the law requires only that they be conducted fairly.
95 It further submitted that the dispute is an ordinary employment dispute fully governed by the Employment Act, that no exceptional circumstances justify constitutional remedies, and that awarding constitutional damages alongside statutory remedies would amount to double recovery.
96 On the reliefs, the Respondent submitted that the dismissal letter being lawful, there is no basis to declare it null and void.
97 On reinstatement, it relied on Section 12(3)(vii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, Sections 49(3)(a) and 49(4) of the Employment Act, and Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] eKLR. In the case, the Court of Appeal held that reinstatement should be granted sparingly and only where it is practicable to restore a relationship founded on mutual trust.
98 It is the Respondent’s submission that reinstatement is inappropriate here, given that the Claimant held a senior office over assets worth millions, that the trust and confidence it requires has been eroded, and that more than seven years have elapsed during which its structures have changed.
99 The Respondent submitted that notice pay is not due because Section 44 permits summary dismissal without notice for gross misconduct, and that compensation under Section 49 arises only upon a finding of unfair termination. In any event, it argued, the Claimant's admitted role in the unauthorized release, her failure to ensure proper documentation and the resulting risks are factors under Section 49(4) weighing heavily against any award.
100 It further submitted that damages for injury to reputation, career stagnation and loss of future income are speculative, unpleaded and unproved, and generally not recoverable in an ordinary employment dispute.
101 On costs, it relied on Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 others [2014] eKLR for the principle that costs follow the event.
102 In response to the Claimant's submissions, the Respondent argued that the authorities on poor performance are inapplicable, since she was dismissed for gross misconduct and not for poor performance. It contended that the existence of prior loans is beside the point, the misconduct lying in her failure to comply with its approval procedures and accountability controls rather than in the practice of loaning itself.
103 It submitted that neither the Employment Act nor its policies require a formal investigation report before disciplinary proceedings, a genuine basis for action and compliance with Section 41 being sufficient.
104 The Respondent distinguished Tanui on the ground that, unlike in that case, the Claimant was informed of the allegations, responded, attended with a representative and appealed. It characterized the correction of the contractual clause at the hearing as a rectification of an erroneous reference that left the factual allegations unchanged and occasioned no prejudice.
105 On bias, the Respondent submitted that the participation of certain management personnel at different stages of an internal process does not, without more, establish actual or apparent bias.
106 On discrimination, it submitted that the Claimant neither pleaded nor proved that the other employees held comparable positions or engaged in similar misconduct. It urged that the Court's mandate is to determine the legality of the process rather than the commercial wisdom of its decisions, and that submissions cannot cure evidentiary gaps or introduce matters not proved at trial.
107 The Respondent therefore urged the Court to find that the summary dismissal was substantively justified, procedurally fair and lawful, and to dismiss the claim with costs.
108 I have examined all the evidence and submissions of the parties herein. The claimant was dismissed vide a letter of summary dismissal dated 10th September 2018 which indicate that the reason for dismissal was lending Nation Media Group (NMG) newsprint without authority which act amounted to gross misconduct under clause 9(a) of her letter of appointment.
109 Prior to this dismissal, the claimant was subjected to a disciplinary process and minutes of the disciplinary hearing have been exhibited before the court. The claimant admitted that she had not received any authorization from the acting MD to release the newsprint. She referred court to the record of 22/2/2018 which was a question addressed to her. She admitted that there was no written invitation from respondent and NMG on release of the newsprint.
110 From this communication, it is an admission by the claimant that she had no written authority to release the materials. The claimant thus acted without authority. It is also true from the record that the claimant was subjected to a fair disciplinary process as per section 41 of the Employment Act 2007 and was even accompanied by a colleague of her choice.
111 It is therefore my finding that there were valid reasons for the claimant’s dismissal and due process was followed. I therefore find the claim unwarranted and is dismissed accordingly. There shall be no order of costs.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 22nd Day of October 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE