Employment law

Republic v Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health Services & another; Sihaam Ltd (Ex parte Applicant) [2026] KEELRC 14711 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Judicial Review Application E057 of 2026
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbaru

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Court struck out/quashed the enforcement proceedings in Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 for want of jurisdiction, directed the parties to revert to DOSH for an inquiry into the reported work injury under sections 16 and 23 of WIBA, and made no order as to costs.

Supporting judgment passages

On this basis, the orders sought by the ex parte applicant assessed; the proceedings under Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 proceeded before a court without jurisdiction and hence quashed. The parties shall revert to the DOSH under its mandate under sections 16 and 23 of WIBA for an inquiry into the reported work injury on 23 July 2024.

Passage 54 →

No orders on costs.

Passage 55 →
Issue 1Whether the Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 had jurisdiction to enforce or adopt the DOSH award of 1 April 2025.

Held. No. The Kajiado lower-court proceedings lacked the requisite jurisdiction and were struck out/quashed. Enforcement of an unobjected-to, unpaid DOSH award was to be pursued through the Court, not the lower court.

Ratio. Where a DOSH award has not been objected to, appealed, or paid, the employee may seek enforcement through the Court rather than the lower court.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

The ex parte applicant has challenged the award to the interested party by the respondent dated 1 April 2025 on the basis that there was no employment relationship between the parties and that there was no notice of such matter to allow the right and opportunity for a hearing. The ex parte applicant is therefore seeking to stop the proceedings before Kajiado CMELRC Misc Application E001 of 2025, which seeks to enforce the DOSH award.

Passage 40 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The lower court proceedings in Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 are without the requisite jurisdiction. These proceedings are hereby struck out.

Passage 48 →

On this basis, the orders sought by the ex parte applicant assessed; the proceedings under Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 proceeded before a court without jurisdiction and hence quashed. The parties shall revert to the DOSH under its mandate under sections 16 and 23 of WIBA for an inquiry into the reported work injury on 23 July 2024.

Passage 54 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

Where there is no objection, appeal, or payment of the DOSH award, the employee may enforce it through the court, not the lower court, as held in Charles v Cheto [2025] KECA 784 (KLR). This position is reiterated in Anguso v DPL Festive Limited [2025] KEELRC 2524 (KLR) and in Mwambia v Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited [2025] KEELRC 2268 (KLR).

Passage 47 →

An award of DOSH, such as the one herein referenced to 1 April 2025, should commence and be addressed by the court and not the lower court.

Passage 49 →
Issue 2Whether the DOSH work-injury assessment should proceed without an inquiry involving the alleged employer and notice of the assessment sufficient to permit payment, objections, or appeal.

Held. No. The parties were directed to revert to DOSH for an inquiry into the reported injury under sections 16 and 23 of WIBA. The Court held that, particularly where an employee reports an injury because the employer did not, the inquiry should extend to the alleged employer; the employer should also be proactively informed of the assessment before Form 4 demands payment. The Court did not determine as a fact whether an employment relationship existed.

Ratio. WIBA covers work injuries involving persons at the shop floor and permits an injured employee to report where the employer has not done so. But the resulting DOSH inquiry should be comprehensive and include the alleged employer, who should receive proactive notice of the assessment so as to pay, object, or appeal under sections 51 and 52.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

With regard to the right to be heard asserted by the ex parte applicant, indeed, work injury claims should commence with a report from the employer under DOSH Form 1. Where this is not done, the employee and one affected or injured person are allowed the right to move DOSH.

Passage 50 →

For effective management of claim and work injury claims, upon the DOSH being moved under section 16 of WIBA, the inquiry envisaged is therefore to be complete, especially where the employee has moved DOSH in the absence of a report by the employer; such inquiry should cast its net far and wide and cover to the alleged employer. Only then will the inquiry establish why the alleged employer failed to make a report to DOSH and where the subject employer is insured. This would expedite payment and avoid proceedings such as those herein. It would also avoid an employee moving the lower court, now adjudged not to have jurisdiction.

Passage 53 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

On this basis, the orders sought by the ex parte applicant assessed; the proceedings under Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 proceeded before a court without jurisdiction and hence quashed. The parties shall revert to the DOSH under its mandate under sections 16 and 23 of WIBA for an inquiry into the reported work injury on 23 July 2024.

Passage 54 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

Where there is no report, the injured employee has the right to make a report to DOSH and, upon assessment, notice to the subject employer should be issued, and where the employer contests the same, objections or appeal are allowed under sections 51 and 52 of WIBA, as held in Law Society of Kenya v Attorney General & another [2019] KESC 16 (KLR).

Passage 46 →

However, before DOSH Form 4 can issue demanding that the employer pay the assessed award. There is a grey area on the timelines within which the employer should be allowed the right to know the award and offer to pay before the options to file objections or an appeal. DOSH Form 1 is not the end. the employer should be informed of the assessment in a proactive manner t allow for payment or objections.

Passage 51 →

For effective management of claim and work injury claims, upon the DOSH being moved under section 16 of WIBA, the inquiry envisaged is therefore to be complete, especially where the employee has moved DOSH in the absence of a report by the employer; such inquiry should cast its net far and wide and cover to the alleged employer. Only then will the inquiry establish why the alleged employer failed to make a report to DOSH and where the subject employer is insured. This would expedite payment and avoid proceedings such as those herein. It would also avoid an employee moving the lower court, now adjudged not to have jurisdiction.

Passage 53 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the DOSH award of Ksh. 691,200 dated 1 April 2025 should be quashed for want of an employment relationship and lack of notice; whether the Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 enforcement proceedings could continue; and whether the parties should return…

Material facts

Thomas Kioko Mule was injured on 23 July 2024 while at premises associated with Sihaam Limited. DOSH assessed compensation at Ksh. 691,200 and issued a DOSH-4 award on 1 April 2025. Sihaam denied that Mule was its employee, maintained it was not notified or…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI

JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION NO. E057 OF 2026

[Formerly Nairobi High Court JR Application No. E174 of 2026]

REPUBLIC ……………. APPLICANT

VERSUS

DIRECTORATE OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH SERVICES….. RESPONDENT

AND

THOMAS KIOKO MULE …… INTERESTED PARTY

AND

SIHAAM LIMITED ….. EX PARTE APPLICANT

RULING

The genesis of these proceedings is a work injury to the interested party, Thomas Kioko Mule, that occurred on 23 July 2024 while employed by the ex parte applicant, Sihaam Limited. The interested party attended before the respondent, the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services (DOSH); an assessment was conducted, and an award of Ksh. 691,200 issued.

To enforce the award, the interested par filed Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 Thomas Kioko Mule v Sihaam Limited. The Lower court

The ex parte applicant then moved the High Court seeking to stop the lower court from adopting the DOSH award as an order of the court through the application dated 10 March 2026. The ex parte applicant was also seeking to have DOSH re-assess the award on the basis that there was no employer-employee relationship between the interested party and the ex parte applicant.

On 8 June 2026, the High Court directed that the proceedings move to this court.

In the application dated 14 July 2026, the ex parte applicant is seeking the following orders:

a) An order of certiorari be issued to bring into this court and quash the decision of the respondent, the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services, contained in DOSH – 4 award dated 1 April 2025, wherein the respondent assessed compensation in the sum of Ksh. 691,200 against the ex parte applicant and in favour of the interested party.

b) An order of mandamus be issued to compel the respondent to hear the interested party’s claim afresh, upon issuance of proper notice to the ex parte applicant and to conduct a proper inquiry into the existence of an employer-employee relationship and the circumstances of the alleged accident in accordance with the provisions of the Work Injury Benefits Act and the rules of natural justice.

c) Costs of the application be provided for.

Mohamed Adow Adan supports the application through his affidavit, because the ongoing proceedings in Kajiado Misc. Application No. MCELRC E001 of 2025 should be quashed through an order of prohibition to stop the Chief Magistrate from adopting the DOSH award dated 1 April 2025 due to the lack of jurisdiction. The respondent acted illegally and ultra vires its statutory mandate by assuming jurisdiction over a party not in the employment of the ex parte applicant under the Work Injury Benefits Act (WIBA).

Adan avers in his affidavit that DOSH's jurisdiction under WIBA is valid only in an employee-employer relationship. Where such a relationship is contested, DOSH must first establish this fundamental jurisdictional fact before it can assess compensation. The ex parte applicant wrote and denied the existence of an employment relationship, but DOSH went ahead to assess the compensation and award of KShs. 691,200 for the IP. Such a decision is therefore made without jurisdiction and should not be allowed to stand.

The respondent breached its statutory duty and the rules of natural justice under Article 50 of the Constitution by condemning the ex parte applicant before affording it a hearing. Through its letter dated 2 April 2025 denying liability, the ex parte applicant had a legitimate expectation that, in any formal proceedings initiated by the respondent, notice would be issued allowing a contestation of the employment relationship. Without it, the award is irregular, unlawful and without due process and should be set aside.

The respondent should have undertaken an inquiry required under section 23 of the WIBA to confirm the employment relationship before proceeding to assess the compensation due to the IP, as herein done. The same should be recalled and done afresh.

In reply, the respondent filed the Replying Affidavit of Eugene Oduori Anyimi, the Assistant Director of DOSH, Athi River Sub County and avers that he is conversant with the matter and the orders sought by the ex parte applicant are not justified and should be dismissed with costs. He avers that the award of Ksh. 691,200 to the interested partyis lawful under WIB following work injury within the ex parte applicant’s premises.

The ex parte applicant challenges the award on the basis that there was no employment relationship with the interested partyand that the DOSH award issued on 1 April 2025 was not served. However, DOSH acted lawfully because WIBA establishes a statutory framework for compensating employees who suffer occupational injuries or diseases arising out of and in the course of employment. When lodging a WIBA claim, the employer files DOSH-1, and upon receipt, DOSH assesses the injury and determines the appropriate compensation. Notice is issued to the employer to make payment within 90 days, and where this is not adhered to, the judicial process for enforcement is allowed under section 51 or 52 of the WIBA.

Anyimi avers that where the employer fails to report a work accident or injury, under section 22(5) of the WIBA, an employee has the right to report it. Under section 34 of WIBA, it is an offence to fail to report a work injury, and the ex parte applicant's contestations are unjustified.

The ex parte applicant is a construction company dealing in building and construction where the interested party was engaged as a mason. Upon inquiry, the respondent was satisfied that the interested party was an employee of the ex parte applicant and therefore processed the claim prescribed in DOSH-4 and awarded Ksh. 691,200 for work injury. The question of whether there was an employment relationship should have been placed before DOSH for assessment through an appeal or objections, as required under sections 51 and 52 of the WIBA, which the ex parte applicant failed to address.

When the ex parte applicant learnt of the DOSH proceedings, they opted to write instead of invoking he rights under WIBA. Such procedures lawfully followed should have addressed the case now sought through these proceedings, and the instant application should be dismissed with costs.

The parties attended and filed written submissions.

The ex parte applicant submitted that the orders sought should prohibit the lower court in Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 from proceeding to adopt the DOSH award of 1 April 2025 as an order of the court. The proceedings were initiated before the ex parte applicant was notified of the matter and without the DOSH and respondent herein establishing whether an employment relationship existed with the interested party as alleged.

The DOSH moved without jurisdiction under WIBA, which requires the claim for compensation to be based on an employment relationship. In Johnson Waweru Kamau v Safaricom Limited [2020] KEELRC 1713 (KLR), the court held that it has jurisdiction only where an employment relationship exists. The ex parte applicant is not the employer of the interested party, and DOSH lacked the requisite jurisdiction to proceed and process his claim for alleged work injury.

The ex parte applicant submitted that the DOSH decision is irrational and unreasonable in view of its lack of jurisdiction. It also moved with the assessment without notice to the ex parte applicant. In Pastoli v Kabale District Local Government Council and Others [2008] 2 EA, the court held that where a decision-maker moved without notice to the parties affected by the decision, such a decision is irrational and unreasonable, and the award by DOSH should be set aside. In this case, the respondent denied the ex parte applicant the right to be heard as required under Article 50 of the Constitution. Such denial undermines the decision's legitimacy and validity.

The respondent violated the rules of natural justice by failing to issue notice to the ex parte applicant and also failing to address its letter challenging the proceedings as required under Article 47 of the Constitution. In Republic v Director of Occupational Safety & Health Services & another (ELRC Judicial Review E007 of 2024) [2026] keelrc 723 (KLR), the court held that the failure to issue notice and an opportunity to be heard renders a decision void. Despite its letter dated 2 April 2025 denying liability in the alleged work injury, the respondent failed to consider or conduct a proper inquiry, leading to an unlawful award to the IP.

The orders sought should be issued with costs.

The respondent submitted and reiterated the averments in the Replying Affidavit by Anyimi and that under section 10 of WIBA, every employer should insure and secure its employees and persons at the shop floor from injury or disease. The ex parte applicant notified the interested party of the accident but failed to report it, and under section 22 of WIBA, the interested party had the right to report it to DOSH. Dr Kamau assessed the injuries, and upon the medical report, the respondent assessed the same and awarded compensation.

In Mwangi v Transgene Agencies Limited [2026] KEELRC 985 (KLR), the court held that upon a report of work injury, the DOSH has no legal duty to hear the parties. Its duty is to assess compensation based on the tabulation and records filed under section 34 of WIBA.

The respondent acted lawfully and within the provisions of WIBA. Where the ex parte applicant is dissatisfied, sections 51 and 52 of WIBA allow for objections and appeal, which have not been invoked. These proceedings are not justified and should be dismissed.

Determination

The ex parte applicant has challenged the award to the interested party by the respondent dated 1 April 2025 on the basis that there was no employment relationship between the parties and that there was no notice of such matter to allow the right and opportunity for a hearing. The ex parte applicant is therefore seeking to stop the proceedings before Kajiado CMELRC Misc Application E001 of 2025, which seeks to enforce the DOSH award.

As correctly submitted by the respondent, the WIBA outlines the procedures for addressing work injury and disease claims. Under section 10 of the WIBA, the employer must have insurance cover for all persons on the shop floor, including employees and persons attending therefrom.

The WIBA is thus not solely concerned with an employment relationship but with all persons present at the shop floor. One may be a casual employee, contract employee, piece-rate employee, permanent and pensionable employee, or as the case may be.

In such a capacity, the WIBA applies to any injury or disease on the shop floor.

Therefore, the employer must report any injury or disease on the shop floor under section 21 of WIBA. The employer should then proceed and report to DOSH under section 22 of WIBA. This is to allow DOSH to make an inquiry and assessment of compensation.

The objective under WIBA is to ensure that the employer is aware of all work injuries before reporting to DOSH. This ensures that the employer records all injuries and diseases arising from the shop floor as a first resource.

Where there is no report, the injured employee has the right to make a report to DOSH and, upon assessment, notice to the subject employer should be issued, and where the employer contests the same, objections or appeal are allowed under sections 51 and 52 of WIBA, as held in Law Society of Kenya v Attorney General & another [2019] KESC 16 (KLR).

Where there is no objection, appeal, or payment of the DOSH award, the employee may enforce it through the court, not the lower court, as held in Charles v Cheto [2025] KECA 784 (KLR). This position is reiterated in Anguso v DPL Festive Limited [2025] KEELRC 2524 (KLR) and in Mwambia v Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited [2025] KEELRC 2268 (KLR).

The lower court proceedings in Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 are without the requisite jurisdiction. These proceedings are hereby struck out.

An award of DOSH, such as the one herein referenced to 1 April 2025, should commence and be addressed by the court and not the lower court.

With regard to the right to be heard asserted by the ex parte applicant, indeed, work injury claims should commence with a report from the employer under DOSH Form 1. Where this is not done, the employee and one affected or injured person are allowed the right to move DOSH.

However, before DOSH Form 4 can issue demanding that the employer pay the assessed award. There is a grey area on the timelines within which the employer should be allowed the right to know the award and offer to pay before the options to file objections or an appeal. DOSH Form 1 is not the end. the employer should be informed of the assessment in a proactive manner t allow for payment or objections.

A strict reading of sections 51 and 52 of WIBA suggests that time starts running only after DOSH Form 4 is issued.

For effective management of claim and work injury claims, upon the DOSH being moved under section 16 of WIBA, the inquiry envisaged is therefore to be complete, especially where the employee has moved DOSH in the absence of a report by the employer; such inquiry should cast its net far and wide and cover to the alleged employer. Only then will the inquiry establish why the alleged employer failed to make a report to DOSH and where the subject employer is insured. This would expedite payment and avoid proceedings such as those herein. It would also avoid an employee moving the lower court, now adjudged not to have jurisdiction.

On this basis, the orders sought by the ex parte applicant assessed; the proceedings under Kajiado MCELRC Misc. E001 of 2025 proceeded before a court without jurisdiction and hence quashed. The parties shall revert to the DOSH under its mandate under sections 16 and 23 of WIBA for an inquiry into the reported work injury on 23 July 2024.

No orders on costs.

Orders accordingly.

Delivered at Nairobi in open court this 22nd day fo October 2026.

M. Mbaru

Judge.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder