REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
MISC. APPLICATION NO. E171 OF 2023.
PETER ERICK OKELLO……………………………………………APPLICANT
VERSUS
HUMAN CAPITAL SYNERGIES
LIMITED.……………..……………...RESPONDENT/JUDGMENT DEBTOR
AND
EVOLVING OUTSOURCING SOLUTIONS LIMITED……………………………………INTENDED INTERESTED PARTY
RULING
1. Before the Court is a Notice of Motion application dated 20th May, 2026, brought pursuant to Sections 148 and 787 of the Companies Act (Act No. 17 of 2015), Sections 1A, 1 B, 3A and 34 of the Civil Procedure Act, CAP 21 Laws of Kenya, and Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, wherein the Applicant seeks orders THAT: -
i. Spent
ii. THAT pending the hearing and determination of this motion, leave be granted to the Applicant to enjoin the Intended Interested party herein as the Interested party in this case.
iii. THAT summons be issued directed at NJOKI MARTHA MWIHIA care of P.O. Box 21918 -00505, Ngong Road, requiring her to appear before this court and show cause why she should not be held personally liable for the decree issued in favour of the decree holder/Applicant herein against the Judgement Debtor/Respondent dated 13th November, 2024 which decree (with interest) stood at Kshs.176,631/= as at the said date exclusive of interest and costs.
iv. THAT upon such examination, this Honourable Court be pleased to lift the Corporate Veil of the Judgment Debtor and the Intended Interested Party and the said NJOKI MARTHA MWIHIA be made personally liable and be ordered to settle the decretal sum entered in this suit in the Applicant's favour.
v. THAT the said director does immediately settle the said decretal sum with interest thereof.
vi. THAT in default of the said director complying with the above orders, her personal assets be attached and/or, in the alternative, she be held in contempt and imprisoned and committed to civil jail for a period not exceeding six (6) months.
vii. THAT costs of the Application be provided.
2. The application is supported by grounds on the face thereof and the affidavit of Peter Erick Okello, the Applicant herein, sworn on 20th May, 2026.
3. The Applicant avers that he obtained judgment against the Respondent on 13th November, 2024 for Kshs. 176,631, together with costs and interest, and that despite service and the lapse of time, the Respondent has failed to satisfy the decree.
4. The Applicant states that the Respondent, formerly known as Human Capital Synergies Limited, has changed its name to Evolving Outsourcing Solutions Limited, which operates from the Judgment Debtor’s former premises.
5. The Applicant further contends that Njoki Martha Mwihia, the Respondent's sole director and the Intended Interested Party, orchestrated the name change and transfer of assets to defeat the Applicant's claims.
6. Consequently, the Applicant seeks the attendance and examination of the director regarding the Judgment Debtor’s assets and means of satisfying the decree.
7. The Applicant further seeks the lifting of the Intended Interested Party’s corporate veil and, in default of an adequate explanation, execution against the director personally to satisfy the decree.
8. The Respondent and the Intended Interested Party did not oppose the claim despite proof of service.
Determination
9. The issues for determination are:-
i. Whether the Intended Interested Party should be joined to the proceedings.
ii. Whether the director, Njoki Martha Mwihia, should be summoned for examination.
iii. Whether the circumstances justify lifting the corporate veil of the Judgment Debtor and the Intended Interested Party and imposing personal liability upon the director.
iv. Whether the orders for attachment of the director’s personal assets, contempt, or committal to civil jail are merited.
Whether the Intended Interested Party should be joined to the proceedings.
10. The Applicant seeks to join Evolving Outsourcing Solutions Limited as an Interested Party on the ground that the company is connected to the Judgment Debtor, formerly known as Human Capital Synergies Limited, and is suspected of holding assets transferred to defeat execution of the decree.
11. Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 provides thus on addition of parties: -
"The court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear to the court to be just, order that the name of any party improperly joined be struck out, and that the name of any person who ought to have been joined, or whose presence before the court may be necessary in order to enable the court to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit, be added."
12. The guiding consideration on joinder is whether the proposed party has a direct interest in the subject matter and whether its participation is necessary for the effective determination of the dispute. The Applicant's allegations that the two companies share a director, that the new entity operates from the Judgment Debtor's former premises, and that assets may have been transferred between them provide a sufficient basis to join the proposed party for the limited purpose of investigating and determining the allegations.
13. For the avoidance of doubt, joinder does not establish that the companies are one legal entity, that assets were fraudulently transferred, or that the proposed Interested Party is liable for the decree. Those questions must be determined on evidence and after the affected parties have been afforded an opportunity to be heard.
14. The Court of Appeal in Civicon Limited v Kivuwatt Limited & 2 others [2015] KECA 588 (KLR), affirmed that joinder is intended to bring before the Court all parties whose presence is necessary to resolve the questions in dispute and avoid multiplicity of proceedings.
15. In the circumstances, and noting that the application is unopposed, the prayer for joinder is found to have merit, and the Intended Interested Party is hereby joined to these proceedings.
Whether the director, Njoki Martha Mwihia, should be summoned for examination
16. Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides for the examination of a judgment debtor, or, where the judgment debtor is a corporation, an officer thereof, concerning the corporation's property, debts, and means of satisfying a court decree. The Court may also require the production of books or documents relevant to those matters.
17. The foregoing provision is an enforcement mechanism that is intended to assist a decree-holder to establish what assets are available to satisfy a judgment. The provision does not, by itself, make a director personally liable for the company's debts.
18. The Applicant herein has established that judgment was entered against the Respondent on 13th November,2024 for a sum of Kshs. 176,631, together with costs and interest, and that the decree remains unsatisfied. The Applicant has also raised specific allegations that the Judgment Debtor changed its name, that the same director is associated with the Intended Interested Party, and that the latter operates from the Judgment Debtor's former premises.
19. The Applicant’s foregoing assertions do in my view justify an inquiry into the Judgment Debtor's assets and financial affairs.
20. The prayer for summons requiring Njoki Martha Mwihia to attend Court and be examined on oath is therefore merited, and is allowed as prayed.
Whether the corporate veil should be lifted
21. The Court of Appeal in Victor Mabachi & another v Nurtun Bates Limited [2013] KECA 204 (KLR), affirmed the separate legal personality of a company and the principle that its directors are not, merely by virtue of their office, liable for its obligations.
22. The corporate veil may, however, be lifted in exceptional circumstances where the corporate structure is used to perpetrate fraud, conceal improper conduct, or defeat lawful claims. In Aster Holdings Limited v City Council of Nairobi & 4 Others [2019] KEELC 5045 (KLR), the Court discussed the circumstances in which the corporate veil may be pierced, particularly where fraud or dishonesty is alleged, and the corporate structure is used to conceal the persons responsible for the impugned conduct.
23. In the present case, the common directorship, continued operation from the same premises and suspected transfer of assets to another company are relevant circumstances. Taken together, they raise a legitimate question as to whether the second company/Interested Party is being used to shield assets from execution.
24. In my view, however, the fact that two companies share a director or business premises, or that one has changed its name, does not automatically establish fraud. A change of name ordinarily does not create a new legal person where the same incorporated company continues under a different name.
25. Further, the CR12 produced in evidence herein shows that Evolving Outsourcing Solutions Limited is a separate legal entity, and its liability cannot therefore be inferred merely from the fact that it has the same director as the Judgment Debtor.
26. In the circumstances, and having allowed the prayer for the examination of the director, I will defer the lifting of the corporate veil until the relevant evidence has been produced and evaluated.
Personal liability, attachment and committal to civil jail
27. The Applicant further seeks an order that the director personally satisfy the decree and that, in default, her personal assets be attached, or she be committed to civil jail for a period not exceeding six months.
28. Sections 148 and 787 of the Companies Act, No. 17 of 2015, must be applied in accordance with their respective statutory purposes and the circumstances to which they relate. The mere citation of those provisions does not dispense with the need to establish the legal basis for imposing personal liability.
29. The Applicant's prayer for attachment of the director's personal assets is in my view premature. Such attachment will only be considered after the Court has lawfully established a basis for holding the director personally liable and has afforded her an opportunity to be heard on that question.
30. I also find the prayer for committal to civil jail premature. Failure by a company to satisfy its decree does not, without more, constitute contempt by its director.
31. In conclusion, I find that the application dated 20th May, 2026, is partly merited and grant the following orders:
a) That the prayer to join Evolving Outsourcing Solutions Limited as an Interested Party is allowed.
b) That Njoki Martha Mwihia, being the director of both the Judgment Debtor and the Interested Party, is hereby summoned to attend Court on a date to be fixed by the Court for examination on the Judgment Debtor's assets, liabilities, books of account and means of satisfying the decree.
c) That the said director shall produce relevant books of account, financial statements, bank statements, asset records and documents concerning any transfer of assets between the Judgment Debtor and Evolving Outsourcing Solutions Limited, to the extent that such documents are within her possession, custody or control.
d) That the prayer to lift the corporate veil and impose personal liability upon the director is deferred pending her examination.
e) That the prayer for immediate attachment of the director's personal assets is equally declined at this stage.
f) The prayer for committal to civil jail is similarly declined.
g) I make no orders on costs.
32. It is so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Wanyangu h/b for Mr. Namada for the Claimant/Applicant
N/A for the Respondent/Judgment Debtor
Ms. Esther S - Court Assistant