Employment law

Mutala v Kenya Pipeline Company Scheme Benefits Scheme & 4 others [2026] KEELRC 14698 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E278 of 2026
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Both preliminary objections were dismissed. The suit will proceed to a hearing on the merits; the orders also apply to Causes E279 and E280 of 2026, and costs of the objections are in the cause.

Supporting judgment passages

i. The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 16th April 2026, filed by the 2nd Respondent, is dismissed.

Passage 66 →

iii. The suit shall proceed to hearing on the merits.

Passage 68 →

v. The costs of the preliminary objections shall be in the cause.

Passage 70 →
Issue 1Whether the Court has jurisdiction to determine the claim concerning the suspension of the Claimant’s pension.

Not reached

Held. The Court did not make a final, separate determination of its jurisdiction over the substantive pension-suspension claim at this preliminary stage. It dismissed the jurisdiction-based preliminary objections and directed that the suit proceed to hearing on the merits.

Ratio. This issue was not decided. The ruling did not distinctly resolve the jurisdiction question; its dispositive reasoning addressed the inability to dispose of the claim on non-exhaustion at the preliminary-objection stage.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

i. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to determine the claim concerning the suspension of the Claimant’s pension.

Passage 49 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

i. The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 16th April 2026, filed by the 2nd Respondent, is dismissed.

Passage 66 →

iii. The suit shall proceed to hearing on the merits.

Passage 68 →
Issue 2Whether the Claimant was required to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanisms under Sections 46 and 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act before instituting this suit.

Held. The non-exhaustion objections could not properly dispose of the entire claim at the preliminary-objection stage. The parties disputed material matters concerning processing of the Authority complaint, including additional information and alleged inaction; moreover, whether the statutory mechanism could adequately address compensation for a reversed suspension required examination of the pleaded reliefs and statutory powers. Both objections were dismissed and the suit was left for merits hearing.

Ratio. A preliminary objection may determine jurisdiction or statutory exhaustion only where the material facts are undisputed. Where exhaustion depends on contested facts requiring evidence, and the adequacy of the statutory remedy requires examination of the pleadings and statutory powers, the objection cannot summarily dispose of the claim.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

ii. Whether the Claimant was required to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanisms under Sections 46 and 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act before instituting this suit.

Passage 50 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

35. The Court, in my view, cannot at this point determine those contested matters merely by accepting the Respondents’ assertions that the Claimant failed to cooperate or the Claimant’s assertion that the Authority failed to act. Those matters require examination of the correspondence and the parties’ respective evidence.

Paragraph 35 →

37. Consequently, the Court is not persuaded that the objections can properly dispose of the entire claim on the basis of non-exhaustion.

Paragraph 37 →

i. The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 16th April 2026, filed by the 2nd Respondent, is dismissed.

Passage 66 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

25. The principles governing preliminary objections are now well settled. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, the court held that a preliminary objection raises a pure point of law and cannot be raised where facts must first be ascertained or judicial discretion needs to be exercised.

Paragraph 25 →

26. The objections herein challenge the Court’s jurisdiction and assert non-exhaustion of statutory remedies. These are ordinarily matters capable of determination by way of a preliminary objection where the material facts are undisputed.

Paragraph 26 →

35. The Court, in my view, cannot at this point determine those contested matters merely by accepting the Respondents’ assertions that the Claimant failed to cooperate or the Claimant’s assertion that the Authority failed to act. Those matters require examination of the correspondence and the parties’ respective evidence.

Paragraph 35 →
Issue 3Whether the objections satisfy the legal threshold

Held. No. Although jurisdiction and exhaustion can ordinarily be raised by preliminary objection where material facts are undisputed, these objections depended on contested facts about the Authority complaint and its processing. They were therefore dismissed rather than used to summarily dispose of the suit.

Ratio. A preliminary objection must raise a pure point of law; it cannot be sustained where facts must first be ascertained or judicial discretion exercised. Jurisdiction and exhaustion objections are suitable only where the material facts are undisputed.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the objections satisfy the legal threshold

Passage 51 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

35. The Court, in my view, cannot at this point determine those contested matters merely by accepting the Respondents’ assertions that the Claimant failed to cooperate or the Claimant’s assertion that the Authority failed to act. Those matters require examination of the correspondence and the parties’ respective evidence.

Paragraph 35 →

37. Consequently, the Court is not persuaded that the objections can properly dispose of the entire claim on the basis of non-exhaustion.

Paragraph 37 →

ii. The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 29th April 2026, filed by the 1st and 3rd Respondents, is equally dismissed.

Passage 67 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

25. The principles governing preliminary objections are now well settled. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, the court held that a preliminary objection raises a pure point of law and cannot be raised where facts must first be ascertained or judicial discretion needs to be exercised.

Paragraph 25 →

26. The objections herein challenge the Court’s jurisdiction and assert non-exhaustion of statutory remedies. These are ordinarily matters capable of determination by way of a preliminary objection where the material facts are undisputed.

Paragraph 26 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to two Notices of Preliminary Objections, one by the 1st & 3rd Respondents and the second one by the 2nd Respondent. In the first Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 29th April, 2026, the 1st & 3rd Respondents contend thus:

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In the end, the Court makes the following orders:-

Paragraph 38 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Employment and Labour Relations Court had jurisdiction over a claim arising from suspension of pension payments; whether the claimant was required to exhaust the review and appeal process under sections 46 and 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act…

Material facts

Thomas Kioko Mutala was, according to the respondents’ submissions, employed by Kenya Pipeline Company for 30 years, retired in September 2023, and had belonged to its retirement benefits scheme since 18 October 1993. He allegedly received Kshs. 56,099.85…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E278 OF 2026

THOMAS KIOKO MUTALA…………..………………………….CLAIMANT

VERSUS

KENYA PIPELINE COMPANY RETIREMENT

BENEFITS SCHEME & 2 OTHERS…………………………1ST RESPONDENT

RETIREMENT BENEFITS AUTHORITY…………………2ND RESPONDENT

BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF KENYA PIPELINE

COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFITS SCHEME.............3RD RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling relates to two Notices of Preliminary Objections, one by the 1st & 3rd Respondents and the second one by the 2nd Respondent. In the first Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 29th April, 2026, the 1st & 3rd Respondents contend thus:

i. THAT this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction under Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, as the dispute arises from a Retirement Benefits Scheme.

ii. THAT the Claimant has failed to exhaust the available statutory remedies under Section 46 of the Retirement Benefits Act, having filed this suit before the Chief Executive Officer rendered a decision; the suit is therefore premature, bad in law, vexatious, and an abuse of the court process.

iii. THAT the claim offends those provisions of Section 46 of the Retirement Benefits Act that require disputes arising from a Retirement Benefits Scheme to be referred in the first instance to the Chief Executive Officer of the Retirement Benefits Authority for determination in accordance with the relevant scheme rules and the Act.

iv. THAT claim offends those provisions of Section 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act; any appeal from the decision of the Chief Executive Officer lies with the Retirement Benefits Appeals Tribunal established under Section 47 of the Act.

2. On its part, the 2nd Respondent in the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 16th April, 2026, states:-

i. THAT the present matter has been filed in contravention of Section 46(1) of the Retirement Benefits Act, 1998, the Claimant having approached the High Court before the 2nd Respondent rendered a decision.

ii. THAT the instant matter is premature, bad in law, vexatious and an abuse of the court process.

iii. THAT consequently, this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction to grant the orders sought.

iv. THAT in the premises, the instant matter dated 12th March 2026 be struck off and/or dismissed with costs.

3. The Court directed the parties to canvass both objections by way of written submissions, noting that the two objections, though differently filed, speak to the same issues. All parties filed their respective submissions.

The 2nd Respondent’s Submissions

4. The 2nd Respondent submits that the Claimant lodged a complaint, and that it requested him to provide further information, but he failed to do so. It avers that the issue is whether the statutory dispute resolution mechanism has been exhausted. It sought to rely on the decision in Speaker of the National Assembly v James Njenga Karume [1992] KLR 21, to argue that where legislation prescribes a procedure for addressing a grievance, that procedure must be strictly followed.

5. The 2nd Respondent submits that Section 46(1) of the Retirement Benefits Act, 1997 is couched in mandatory terms, and provides:-

“Any member of a scheme who is dissatisfied with a decision of the manager, administrator, custodian or trustees of the scheme may request, in writing, that such decision be reviewed by the Chief Executive Officer with a view to ensuring that such decision is made in accordance with the provisions of the relevant scheme rules or the Act under which the scheme is established.”

6. The 2nd Respondent further submits that the Claimant failed to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanism as the administrative process before the Chief Executive Officer of the Retirement Benefits Authority remains incomplete due to failure to provide information requested on 10th November, 2025. Relying on Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 others v Maurice Munyao & 148 others [2019] KESC 83 (KLR), it argues that the statutory review under Section 46 and subsequent appeal under Section 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act must be exhausted before approaching the courts.

7. The 2nd Respondent further relies on Nganga v Laptrust (Umbrella) Retirement Fund Board of Trustees & another [2025] KEELRC 1296 (KLR), in which the Court struck out a suit for failure to exhaust the statutory remedies under Section 46 of the Retirement Benefits Act.

8. It is its submission that Sections 46 and 48 establish a comprehensive statutory dispute resolution framework that must be exhausted before the Employment and Labour Relations Court can be approached.

9. It therefore maintains that the claim was filed prematurely.

The 1st & 3rd Respondents’ Submissions

10. The 1st & 3rd Respondents submit that the Claimant was employed by Kenya Pipeline Company for 30 years and that he retired in September 2023, having been a member of the Kenya Pipeline Company Retirement Benefits Scheme since 18th October, 1993.

11. They submit that upon retirement, the Claimant received a monthly pension of Kshs.56,099.85 until May, 2024, when the Scheme suspended payments on allegations of forged academic documents, but payments resumed around July 2025.

12. It is their submission that aggrieved by the suspension, the Claimant lodged a complaint with the Retirement Benefits Authority, seeking, among other reliefs, Kshs. 673,198.20 in compensation, but before the Retirement Benefits Authority determined the complaint and without exhausting the statutory dispute resolution mechanisms, he filed the present suit.

13. The Respondents submit that this Court lacks jurisdiction under Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act on the basis that the dispute concerns the administration of retirement benefits under a registered pension scheme rather than an employer-employee relationship or the terms and conditions of employment. Relying on Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Limited [1989] KLR 1, they contend that jurisdiction is fundamental and that the Court must down its tools the moment it finds that it lacks jurisdiction to entertain the claim.

14. The Respondents further sought to rely on Abdalla Osman & 628 others v Standard Chartered Bank (K) Limited & 11 others [2018] KEELRC 978 (KLR), where the Court upheld the doctrine of exhaustion and referred a pension dispute to the Chief Executive Officer of the Retirement Benefits Authority under Section 46 of the Retirement Benefits Act. They also cite Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 others v Maurice Munyao & 148 others (supra), in support of the position that courts should not assume jurisdiction over pension disputes where a specialized statutory dispute resolution mechanism exists.

15. It is the Respondents’ contention that the present dispute, concerning the suspension and resumption of the Claimant’s pension payments, falls within Sections 46, 47 and 48 of the Act and should therefore be determined through that statutory mechanism before the Court is approached.

16. They further contend that the pending complaint, acknowledged by the Authority and assigned a tracking number, demonstrates that the statutory process remains active, with no evidence of refusal or unreasonable delay warranting intervention by the Court.

17. The Respondents finally submit that the Preliminary Objection dated 29th April, 2026 raises pure points of law on jurisdiction and exhaustion, capable of determining the suit summarily in accordance with Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturers Ltd v Westend Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696.

The Claimants’ Submissions

18. The Claimant submits that the Preliminary Objections do not meet the threshold established in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696. He contends that the objections turn on contested facts about the Authority’s response to his complaint, the documents requested, and the alleged failure to provide them.

19. It is his submission that to determine whether the Authority acted, whether its response reached him, and whether there was unreasonable delay requires evidence. Accordingly, he submits that the exhaustion issue cannot properly be determined through a Preliminary Objection and should instead be resolved upon consideration of the evidence at trial.

20. The Claimant submits that Sections 46 and 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act do not provide an adequate remedy because the Authority and Tribunal lack jurisdiction to award the compensation sought for the wrongful suspension of his pension. Relying on Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 others v Maurice Munyao & 148 others [2019] KESC 83 (KLR), he argues that the claim concerns a completed wrong and alleged violations of Articles 47 and 50 of the Constitution.

21. He further maintains that he lodged a complaint with the Authority on 22nd September 2025 but received no substantive decision, and therefore the Court should dismiss the preliminary objections.

22. The Claimant finally submits that the Authority’s prolonged inaction renders the statutory dispute resolution mechanism ineffective and that the claim for compensation falls outside its remedial powers. He argues that the dispute arises from his employment and falls within this Court’s jurisdiction.

23. The Claimant prays that the Court dismiss the Preliminary Objections or, in the alternative, stay the suit and refer the dispute to the Authority for determination within 60 days, with no order as to costs.

Analysis and Determination

24. The issues that arise from the two Notices of Preliminary Objection are:-

i. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to determine the claim concerning the suspension of the Claimant’s pension.

ii. Whether the Claimant was required to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanisms under Sections 46 and 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act before instituting this suit.

Whether the objections satisfy the legal threshold

25. The principles governing preliminary objections are now well settled. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, the court held that a preliminary objection raises a pure point of law and cannot be raised where facts must first be ascertained or judicial discretion needs to be exercised.

26. The objections herein challenge the Court’s jurisdiction and assert non-exhaustion of statutory remedies. These are ordinarily matters capable of determination by way of a preliminary objection where the material facts are undisputed.

27. The Respondents maintain that the Claimant failed to provide information requested by the Retirement Benefits Authority on 10th November 2025, while the Claimant maintains that the Authority failed to determine his complaint despite its acknowledgment of the same on 22nd September, 2025.

28. The Claimant further argues that the statutory mechanism cannot adequately address his claim for compensation arising from the suspension of his pension.

29. Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution establishes this Court to determine employment and labour relations disputes, while Section 12(1)(a) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act confers jurisdiction over disputes relating to or arising out of employment between an employer and an employee.

30. The Respondents contend that the claim is exclusively a pension dispute governed by the Retirement Benefits Act. They rely principally on Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 others v Maurice Munyao & 148 others [2019] KESC 83 (KLR), where the Supreme Court affirmed the statutory mechanism for resolving disputes between pension scheme members and trustees concerning the administration of retirement benefits.

31. The Claimant, however, distinguishes the present dispute from Chaurembo, maintaining that the suspension arose from allegations concerning his academic qualifications and recruitment approximately thirty years earlier, rather than from the calculation or administration of his pension under the Scheme rules. He also seeks compensation for the period during which his pension was withheld, despite the subsequent resumption of payments.

32. Section 46(1) of the Retirement Benefits Act provides a mechanism through which a member dissatisfied with a decision of a scheme manager, administrator, custodian or trustee may request the Chief Executive Officer of the Retirement Benefits Authority to review that decision. Further, Section 48 provides for appeals to the Retirement Benefits Appeals Tribunal against decisions of the Authority or its Chief Executive Officer.

33. The Claimant’s position is that the pension suspension was reversed in July 2025, and that the present claim seeks compensation for the period during which payments were withheld. He contends that the Authority cannot award the damages sought and that the complaint concerns the alleged unlawful exercise of power based on an employment related accusation.

34. To start with, the Court notes that the Claimant has already lodged a complaint with the Authority. Secondly, the parties disagree about the processing of that complaint, including whether the Claimant complied with the request for additional information and whether the Authority’s inaction has rendered the process ineffective.

35. The Court, in my view, cannot at this point determine those contested matters merely by accepting the Respondents’ assertions that the Claimant failed to cooperate or the Claimant’s assertion that the Authority failed to act. Those matters require examination of the correspondence and the parties’ respective evidence.

36. Further, although the statutory mechanism may be appropriate for reviewing a decision made under the Scheme rules, the question of whether it can adequately determine the Claimant’s claim for compensation arising from a suspension that has already been reversed requires consideration of the precise reliefs pleaded and the powers conferred by the Act.

37. Consequently, the Court is not persuaded that the objections can properly dispose of the entire claim on the basis of non-exhaustion.

38. In the end, the Court makes the following orders:-

i. The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 16th April 2026, filed by the 2nd Respondent, is dismissed.

ii. The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 29th April 2026, filed by the 1st and 3rd Respondents, is equally dismissed.

iii. The suit shall proceed to hearing on the merits.

iv. These orders shall apply to Causes No. E279 and E280 all of 2026.

v. The costs of the preliminary objections shall be in the cause.

39. Orders accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Kitonga present for the Claimants

Mr. Mwenga present for the 1st & 3rd Respondent

Mr. Chebon present for the 2nd Party

Ms. Esther - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder