Small Claims

Mwangi & another v Kinoti [2026] SCC 252 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
T.O. Omono

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling determines the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 21st August 2026 seeking the reinstatement of this claim which was struck out by this court on 24th June 2025 for non-attendance.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

This court has given due regard to the pleadings as well as the written submissions on record in their entirety. The only issue for determination is whether the instant Application is merited.

Paragraph 4 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MILIMANI

SCC COMM NO. E27076 OF 2025

JUDITH WANJIRU MWANGI.……....….…………………1ST CLAIMANT/APPLICANT

JOSEPH NTHALE MUSYOKI……………………………..2ND CLAIMANT/APPLICANT

VERSUS

MARTIN KINOTI………………………...……………….………………….RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling determines the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 21st August 2026 seeking the reinstatement of this claim which was struck out by this court on 24th June 2025 for non-attendance.

2. The instant Application was premised on the ground that the Applicants were not aware that the claim was coming up for mention on the date it was struck out since their then counsel did not inform them about the mention hence their then counsel’s mistakes should not be visited on them.

3. The Respondent opposed the instant Application by averring that the Applicants had not shown sufficient cause for non-attendance when this claim was struck out, they had not explained their inordinate delay in filing the instant Application and their subsequent conduct, and that they have not demonstrated whether the reinstatement of this claim would be consistent with the Small Claims Court framework for expeditious disposal of matters.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

4. This court has given due regard to the pleadings as well as the written submissions on record in their entirety. The only issue for determination is whether the instant Application is merited.

5. It is important to state from the onset to clearly state that this claim was not dismissed on 24th June 2025 as alleged by the Applicants. This claim was actually struck out for non-attendance on that occasion.

6. Angote J in Enock Kirao Muhanji v Hamid Abdalla Mbarak [2013] KEHC 6015 (KLR) gave a distinction between dismissing a suit and striking out a suit in the following words:

“19.The words “dismissed” and struck out” are terms of art and are not supposed to be used interchangeably in a Ruling or Judgment. However, more often than not, the terms are used interchangeably by the litigants and the courts.

20.It is therefore incumbent that when the court is called upon, like in this case, to determine whether a party can file a fresh suit after the first one has been dismissed or struck court, the court should look at the circumstances of each case to arrive at a decision.  The mere fact that the trial court uses the words “dismissed” does not expressly mean that a fresh suit cannot be filed if indeed the court meant that the suit should have been “struck out” so as to allow a party to file a fresh suit.”

7. It is evident from the authority above that this claim having been struck out on 24th June 2025 for non-attendance and bearing in mind the Small Claims Court Act’s overriding objective of expeditious disposal of claims, the Applicants needed not to file the instant Application.

8. They viable option available to them in the circumstances was to file another claim or a civil suit arising from the cause of action herein the claim herein is not yet statute barred.

9. Be that as it may, section 43 of the Small Claims Court Act (“the Act”) grants this court the discretion to set aside or vary its orders. However, that discretion must be exercised judiciously.

10. The foregoing begs the question whether the Applicants have established a case for this court’s exercise of its discretion under section 43 of the Act.

11. The Applicants have blamed their former counsel for failing to inform them about the mention date when this claim was struck out. They urged this court not to visit their then counsel’s mistake on them.

12. However, as correctly submitted by the Respondent, a claim belongs to the Claimant not their counsel. A claimant cannot simply urge a court not to visit their counsel’s mistake on them without stating the steps they took in finding out the status of their case.

13. To this end, this court draws inspiration from Edney Adaka Ismail vs Equity Bank Limited [2014] eKLR where the court held, inter alia, as follows:

“The question then that arises is whether the plaintiff has offered sufficient reason to persuade the court to exercise its discretion in the favour and reinstate the application. It is true that where the justice of the case mandates, mistake of advocate even if they are blunders, should not be visited on the clients when the situation can be remedied by cost .... However, it is not in every case that a mistake committed by an advocate would be a ground for setting aside orders of the court…. It is not enough for a party to simply blame the advocate but must show tangible steps taken by him in following up his matter”.

14. In the same breadth Kimaru J. (as he then was) in Savings and Loans Limited -vs- Susan Wanjiru Muritu Nairobi (Milimani) HCCS No.397 of 2002 expressed himself as follows on this issue: -

“Whereas it would constitute a valid excuse for the Defendant to claim that she had been let down by her former Advocates failure to attend Court on the date the application was fixed for hearing, it is trite that a Case belongs to a litigant and not to her Advocate.  A litigant has a duty to pursue the prosecution of his or her Case.  The Court cannot set aside dismissal of a suit on the sole ground of a mistake by Counsel of the litigant on account of such Advocate's failure to attend Court.  It is the duty of the litigant to constantly check with her advocate the progress of her case.  (Emphasis added)

15. The Applicants have not demonstrated any tangible steps they took in finding out the status of this claim. Clearly they lacked interest in pursuing this claim or finding out the status of this claim. In the circumstances, the Applicants cannot seek to rely on their then counsel’s failure to attend court on the date this claim was struck out to reinstate it.

16. The Applicants also had a duty to file the instant Application without unreasonable delay. The instant Application was filed over one year after the striking out of this claim. The Applicants have not given a satisfactory explanation on why they filed the instant Application too late in the day.

17. This court takes the view the Applicants herein fit the description of the Defendant in the Savings and Loans Limited case where Kimaru J (as he then was) held thus:

“… In the present Case, it is apparent that if the Defendant had been a diligent litigant, she would have been aware of the dismissal of her previous application for want of prosecution soon after the said dismissal.  For the Defendant to be prompted to action by the Plaintiff's determination to execute the decree issued in its favour, is an indictment of the Defendant.  She had been indolent and taking into account her past conduct in the prosecution of the application to set aside the default judgment that was dismissed by the Court, it would be a travesty of justice for the Court to exercise its discretion in favour of such a litigant.  (emphasis added)

18. The foregoing shows that the Applicants are indolent litigants. The Applicants slept on their right to have the orders striking out this claim reinstated under section 43 of the Act, that right must slip away from them.

19. It is against this backdrop that this court declines to reinstate this claim. However, all is not lost to the Applicants given, as earlier explained in this ruling, they can file another claim or suit based on the cause of action herein.

DETERMINATION

20. In sum, the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 21st August 2026 is bereft of merit. The same is dismissed with costs of Kshs. 10,000/= to the Respondent.

21. It is so ordered.

Read, signed, and delivered in open Court at Milimani this 15th day of October 2026

T.O. OMONO

ADJUDICATOR

In the presence of:

C/A: Mr. Rioba

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder