REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MALABA
SCCOMM CASE NO. E103 OF 2026
GILBERT MOPHAT ODILI………..................................................CLAIMANT
-VERSUS-
MIRIAM NANGEKHE WANYONYI…..………….RESPONDENT/APPLICANT
-AND-
MOSES KHISA…………………………………………..1ST PROPOSED THIRD PARTY
BENEDICT WEKESA………………………………..2ND PROPOSED THIRD PARTY
RULING.
1. I have considered the application, the rival submissions by learned counsel for the parties, the procedural history of this matter and the applicable law. The application dated 19th October 2026 principally seeks the Court’s intervention on grounds that include the need for additional time to effect service upon third parties, counsel’s alleged engagement before other courts on the scheduled hearing date, the right to a fair hearing and the possibility of transferring the claim to the Magistrates’ Court.
2. The Court is mindful of the constitutional right to a fair hearing and access to justice. However, those rights must be considered alongside the obligation of parties and their advocates to comply with lawful court directions and the corresponding right of the opposing party to have the dispute determined fairly and expeditiously.
Procedural history and compliance with court directions
3. The procedural history of this matter is material to the determination of the present application.
4. Upon considering the application filed under certificate of urgency, this Court directed that the application be heard today the 23rd October 2026 and that service be affected forthwith. The directions were clear and unambiguous. Notwithstanding the urgency attributed to the application, service was only effected yesterday 22nd October 2026, a day before the scheduled hearing date.
5. The Court observes that this is not the first instance in which the Applicant has failed to comply with its directions, particularly those concerning service upon the third parties.
6. While the Court must remain receptive to genuine procedural difficulties encountered by litigants, judicial discretion cannot be exercised in isolation from the conduct of the party seeking its intervention. A party who invokes the Court’s jurisdiction is equally bound to respect the directions issued in the course of the proceedings.
On the objection to oral submissions
7. At the commencement of the proceedings, learned counsel for the Applicant initially objected to counsel for the Claimant/Respondent making oral submissions. The objection was subsequently abandoned, and counsel conceded to the matter proceeding by way of oral submissions.
8. For completeness, the Court observes that there is no general prohibition against receiving oral submissions on an interlocutory application, particularly where the submissions concern questions of law arising from the application and the record before the Court.
9. Section 17 of the Small Claims Court Act empowers the Court to adopt its own procedure in the conduct of proceedings, subject to the Act and the applicable Rules, where necessary to meet the ends of justice. The Court must, however, ensure that both parties are afforded a fair opportunity to present their respective positions.
10. In the present case, both counsel were afforded that opportunity. The absence of written grounds of opposition does not, of itself, preclude the Court from considering oral arguments on the issues raised.
On service upon the third parties
11. The Applicant contends that additional time is necessary to effect service upon the third parties. The Court has considered this contention against its earlier directions of 15th October 2026.
12. The Court had expressly addressed the question of service through WhatsApp. Service by electronic means is not inherently impermissible. However, where service is contested or requires verification, the party relying upon it must place sufficient material before the Court to establish that the telephone numbers or electronic addresses used are attributable to the intended recipients and that the relevant documents were duly transmitted.
13. In the present matter, what was lacking was evidence establishing that the telephone numbers used belonged to the respective third parties.It was against that background that the Court directed that the matter proceed as against the named Respondent.
14. The present application therefore seeks, in substance, a further opportunity to undertake steps for which the Court had already afforded an opportunity and issued specific directions. The Court is not persuaded that sufficient cause has been demonstrated to warrant a further postponement of the proceedings on that account.
Whether non-service upon the third parties prevents the principal claim from proceeding
15. The Court has considered whether the continued presence of the third parties in the proceedings, notwithstanding the absence of proper service, constitutes an impediment to the hearing of the principal claim.
16. Rule 16 of the Small Claims Court Rules governs third-party proceedings. In particular, Rule 16(5) provides for the consequences of failure to serve a third-party notice in accordance with the Rule, while Rule 16(6) empowers the Court, upon application and after hearing the other parties, to extend time for service and the filing of the requisite certificate of service before the hearing of the claim.
17. The effect of these provisions is that third-party proceedings do not automatically suspend the hearing of the principal claim between the Claimant and the named Respondent.
18. The Court distinguishes between the substantive claim instituted by the Claimant against the Respondent and the ancillary proceedings initiated by the Respondent against the third parties. The failure to effect proper service upon the third parties does not, invalidate the principal proceedings or deprive the Court of jurisdiction to determine the dispute between the parties properly before it.
19. Equally, the mere fact that the third parties remain named in the court record does not establish that they have been properly brought before the Court for purposes of determining liability against them.
20. The Court had already afforded the Applicant an opportunity to comply with the requirements of service. That opportunity was not utilised. The Court finds no sufficient basis for further delaying the principal claim on account of the unserved third-party proceedings.
21. For the avoidance of doubt, the principal claim shall proceed as between the Claimant and the named Respondent. No adverse orders shall issue against the unserved third parties.
On the constitutional provisions invoked by the Applicant
22. Learned counsel for the Applicant has invoked Articles 10, 48 and 159 of the Constitution in support of the application.
23. The Court is fully cognisant of the constitutional principles of access to justice, fairness, the rule of law and the administration of justice without undue regard to procedural technicalities.
24. However, these provisions cannot be considered selectively. The constitutional right to access justice is enjoyed by both the Claimant and the Respondent. Likewise, the obligation to facilitate the expeditious determination of disputes is owed to all parties appearing before the Court.
25. The Applicant has been afforded opportunities to participate in these proceedings, to present his position and to comply with the directions issued by the Court. What emerges from the record is not a denial of the opportunity to be heard, but a failure to utilise the opportunities already afforded.
26. Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution was not intended to render court directions optional or to excuse persistent non-compliance with procedural obligations, particularly where such non-compliance occasions delay and prejudice to another litigant.
27. The Court must balance the Applicant’s right to be heard against the Claimant’s equally protected right to have the dispute determined without unreasonable delay.
On the proposed transfer of the claim
28. Counsel for the Applicant has further submitted that the claim may be transferred to the Magistrates’ Court. The Court finds this argument unpersuasive in the circumstances of the present matter.
29. The Claimant consciously invoked the jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court, a specialised forum established to facilitate the expeditious and affordable resolution of disputes. Section 34 of the Small Claims Court Act contemplates the hearing and determination of claims within sixty days from the date of filing.
30. The Claimant has complied with the directions issued by this Court and has demonstrated readiness to proceed. It would be manifestly unfair to subject the Claimant to further delay merely because the Respondent has failed to comply with procedural directions.
31. The Applicant has not demonstrated any jurisdictional impediment or other sufficient legal basis warranting the proposed transfer. The Court cannot sanction a transfer merely to accommodate procedural defaults where it is otherwise properly seized of the dispute.
On counsel’s alleged engagement before other courts
32. The Applicant further seeks the Court’s indulgence on the basis that counsel has other matters scheduled before different courts on the date fixed for hearing. In support of that contention, counsel has annexed a copy of his diary. The Court has considered that explanation.
33. While the Court appreciates the professional obligations of advocates appearing before different courts, a diary prepared and maintained by counsel is, without independent verification, insufficient to establish that the alleged matters are indeed listed for hearing on the material date,
34. Counsel has not exhibited cause lists, extracts from the Case Tracking System, hearing notices or other objective material demonstrating that the matters referred to are scheduled before the respective courts. The Court is therefore unable to independently ascertain the alleged conflicting engagements.
35. Even assuming that such engagements exist, the Court agrees with counsel for the Claimant that judicial business is conducted over the course of the working day. Counsel could reasonably attend the virtual proceedings, inform the Court of the alleged engagements and seek appropriate directions regarding time allocation.
36. The existence of other professional engagements does not, without sufficient explanation, automatically entitle a party to an adjournment, particularly where the proceedings are subject to statutory timelines.
On the directions for hearing
37. The Applicant has also questioned the fixing of the matter for hearing before directions were taken on whether the claim would proceed by way of oral hearing or written submissions. The Court finds no merit in this contention.
38. Section 28 of the Small Claims Court Act provides for notification of the date, time and place of hearing upon receipt of the Respondent’s written response.
39. Further, Rule 19 of the Small Claims Court Rules contemplates the Court issuing appropriate directions at the hearing, including identifying contested issues, considering settlement and determining the appropriate manner of proceeding.
40. It follows that the fixing of a hearing date does not necessarily presuppose that every procedural direction must have been issued beforehand. The Court was therefore entitled to allocate a hearing date and give such further directions as were necessary for the just and expeditious determination of the claim.
41. On citation of the provisions of the Civil Procedure Act and Rules is not, it ismy considered view that this is not fatal to the application. The Court is concerned with the substance of the relief sought and the applicable legal framework rather than the mere form of the provisions cited. However, the citation of those provisions does not relieve the Applicant of the obligation to establish sufficient grounds for the orders sought.
42. Having considered the application in its entirety, the Court is not satisfied that the Applicant has demonstrated sufficient cause to warrant the exercise of discretion in his favour.
43. I reiterate that directions are issued to facilitate the orderly, fair and expeditious determination of disputes. They are not mere administrative suggestions to be complied with at the convenience of the parties. The Applicant has had adequate opportunity to comply with the directions concerning service upon the third parties and to prepare for the hearing of the claim. The Court must also safeguard the Claimant’s right to the timely determination of a dispute properly instituted before it.
44. In the circumstances, the application is devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed. The matter shall proceed to hearing on 28th October 2026 as previously directed, as between the Claimant and the named Respondent. Costs of the application shall be in the cause.
RULING DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MALABA SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS 23RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
In the Presence of
Mr. R. Wamalwa Counsel the Respondent/Applicant and
Mr. Makokha for the Claimant/Respondent
Court Assistant: Paul Otieno
A.Z. OGANGE
RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR
23.10.2026