Small Claims

Makokha v Wechuli [2026] SCC 254 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Malaba
Case number
Sccomm Case E010 of 2026
Judgment date
28 October 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Judgment Debtor’s application was dismissed. The alleged KSh 87,450 payments were not recognised as proven part-satisfaction of the decree; payment by KSh 20,000 monthly instalments and the broad restraint against execution against relatives’ property were declined. The procedural objection based solely on his acting in person failed. Costs of the application were awarded to the Decree Holder and assessed at KSh 3,000.

Supporting judgment passages

32. The upshot of my findings therefore is that the application is dismissed with costs which I assess at Kshs. 3,000/=.

Paragraph 32 →

11. Accordingly, the prayers seeking a declaration that the said payments constitute part-payment of the decree cannot be granted on the material presented.

Paragraph 11 →

19. I therefore find that the Judgment Debtor has not established a sufficient basis for the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour. The prayer for payment by instalments is consequently declined.

Paragraph 19 →
Issue 1Whether the payments allegedly made by the Judgment Debtor to various persons should be recognized as payments towards satisfaction of the decree.

Held. Declined. The Judgment Debtor did not establish a sufficient basis to treat the entire alleged KSh 87,450 paid to the named persons as money received toward satisfaction of the decree.

Ratio. A judgment debtor asserting part-satisfaction bears the burden of proving both payment and that it was received or authorised by the decree holder toward the decree. Payment to a duly authorised advocate may count, but payment to another third party requires proof of authority, receipt, or later acknowledgement; money changing hands alone does not reduce the decree.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

6. The first concerns whether the payments allegedly made by the Judgment Debtor to various persons should be recognized as payments towards satisfaction of the decree. The second is whether the Judgment Debtor has established sufficient cause to warrant payment of the decretal sum by instalments. The third concerns the prayer seeking to restrain the Decree Holder from attaching or otherwise dealing with property belonging to the Judgment Debtor's parents and/or relatives. Finally, the Court must determine the issue of costs.

Paragraph 6 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

10. In the present application, the Judgment Debtor has not demonstrated a sufficient basis upon which the Court can treat the entire sum of KSh 87,450 allegedly paid to the three persons as money received towards satisfaction of the decree. The Court cannot presume that a payment made to an intermediary necessarily discharged the Judgment Debtor's obligation to the Decree Holder.

Paragraph 10 →

11. Accordingly, the prayers seeking a declaration that the said payments constitute part-payment of the decree cannot be granted on the material presented.

Paragraph 11 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

8. The burden lies upon the Judgment Debtor, who asserts that the decree has been partly satisfied, to demonstrate that the payments were made and that they were received or authorised on behalf of the Decree Holder towards satisfaction of the decree. Proof that money changed hands is not, by itself, proof that the decree was thereby reduced.

Paragraph 8 →

9. There is an important distinction between payments made to an advocate acting on behalf of a litigant in the matter and payments made independently to a broker or another third party. Where payment is made to an advocate duly authorised to receive it, such payment may properly be recognised as payment towards the decree. However, a payment made to a third party cannot automatically be attributed to the Decree Holder merely because the recipient was involved in the transaction or claimed to act on her behalf. The requisite authority, receipt or subsequent acknowledgement must be established.

Paragraph 9 →
Issue 2Whether the Judgment Debtor has established sufficient cause to warrant payment of the decretal sum by instalments.

Held. Declined. The Judgment Debtor failed to demonstrate financial circumstances making KSh 20,000 monthly instalments necessary and reasonable, or why the Decree Holder should be compelled to recover over the extended period proposed.

Ratio. Instalment payment is discretionary, not an automatic entitlement. The court must exercise that discretion judiciously by considering the debtor’s financial position, reasons for the proposal, amount outstanding, and prejudice to the decree holder, balancing the debtor’s opportunity to pay against the holder’s right to enjoy the fruits of judgment.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

6. The first concerns whether the payments allegedly made by the Judgment Debtor to various persons should be recognized as payments towards satisfaction of the decree. The second is whether the Judgment Debtor has established sufficient cause to warrant payment of the decretal sum by instalments. The third concerns the prayer seeking to restrain the Decree Holder from attaching or otherwise dealing with property belonging to the Judgment Debtor's parents and/or relatives. Finally, the Court must determine the issue of costs.

Paragraph 6 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

17. In the present case, the Judgment Debtor has proposed monthly payments of Ksh 20,000 but has not sufficiently demonstrated, on the material before the Court, the financial circumstances that make such an arrangement necessary and reasonable. Nor has he adequately demonstrated why the Decree Holder should be compelled to recover the decretal sum over an extended period on the terms proposed.

Paragraph 17 →

19. I therefore find that the Judgment Debtor has not established a sufficient basis for the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour. The prayer for payment by instalments is consequently declined.

Paragraph 19 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

13. The power of a court to permit payment by instalments is discretionary. The discretion must be exercised judiciously, taking into account the circumstances of the case, the Judgment Debtor's financial position, the reasons advanced for the proposed arrangement, the amount outstanding and the prejudice that the proposed arrangement may occasion the Decree Holder.

Paragraph 13 →

14. A judgment debtor does not acquire an automatic entitlement to instalment payments merely by proposing a monthly amount. Sufficient cause must be demonstrated to justify the departure from the ordinary expectation that a decree, once issued, should be satisfied without undue delay.

Paragraph 14 →

18. The Court must balance the Judgment Debtor's opportunity to satisfy the decree against the Decree Holder's right to enjoy the fruits of her judgment. That balance cannot be achieved by imposing an instalment arrangement unsupported by sufficient cause.

Paragraph 18 →
Issue 3The prayer seeking to restrain the Decree Holder from attaching or otherwise dealing with property belonging to the Judgment Debtor's parents and/or relatives.

Held. Declined without prejudice to any person whose property is wrongfully attached pursuing the appropriate legal remedy. The application did not establish an evidential basis for the broad restraining order.

Ratio. A decree may be enforced against the judgment debtor and property legally available to satisfy it, not merely against third-party property. A general apprehension of attachment, without a demonstrated unlawful execution threat, does not justify an unrestricted restraint; an affected third party may use objection proceedings if property is actually attached.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

6. The first concerns whether the payments allegedly made by the Judgment Debtor to various persons should be recognized as payments towards satisfaction of the decree. The second is whether the Judgment Debtor has established sufficient cause to warrant payment of the decretal sum by instalments. The third concerns the prayer seeking to restrain the Decree Holder from attaching or otherwise dealing with property belonging to the Judgment Debtor's parents and/or relatives. Finally, the Court must determine the issue of costs.

Paragraph 6 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

24. The present application does not establish a sufficient basis for the broad restraining order sought. The prayer is therefore declined, without prejudice to the right of any person whose property is wrongfully attached to pursue the appropriate legal remedy.

Paragraph 24 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

21. A decree is enforceable against the judgment debtor and property legally available to satisfy the decree. It does not, merely by its existence, authorise execution against property belonging to persons who are not judgment debtors.

Paragraph 21 →

22. At the same time, the Court must distinguish between a general apprehension that third-party property may be attached and an actual or sufficiently demonstrated threat of unlawful execution. The Court cannot issue an unrestricted order against the Decree Holder in the absence of a proper evidential foundation for the relief sought.

Paragraph 22 →

23. The appropriate legal remedy is available where property belonging to a third party is actually attached or is otherwise subjected to execution in circumstances warranting an objection. The affected person may invoke the applicable objection proceedings and demonstrate the nature and extent of the proprietary interest claimed. Such proceedings enable the Court to determine the competing claims on the evidence presented.

Paragraph 23 →
Issue 4Whether the application was incompetent because the Judgment Debtor, though represented by an advocate, filed it in his own name.

Held. No. The application could not be struck out merely because the Judgment Debtor acted in person; no specific defect affecting its validity was identified.

Ratio. Representation by an advocate does not itself make a litigant’s personal filing incompetent. The right to act in person must be distinguished from compliance with applicable procedural rules, and a specific validity defect must be identified and assessed on its merits.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

25. On the objection concerning the manner in which the application was filed, I have also considered the objection that the application is incompetent because the applicant is represented by an advocate while he has filed the application in his own name.

Paragraph 25 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

28. To the extent that the objection rests solely on the Judgment Debtor's appearance in person, I find no sufficient basis for striking out the application on that ground.

Paragraph 28 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

26. The mere fact that one party is represented by an advocate does not, in itself, render an application filed by the opposing party in person incompetent. A litigant's right to act in person must be distinguished from compliance with the applicable procedural requirements governing the institution, signing and service of applications.

Paragraph 26 →

27. The Court is enjoined to administer justice without undue regard to procedural technicalities, while ensuring that substantive and mandatory procedural requirements are observed. Accordingly, the objection cannot succeed merely on the ground that the Judgment Debtor has acted in person. Any specific defect affecting the validity of the application must be identified and assessed on its own merits.

Paragraph 27 →
Issue 5The issue of costs.

Held. Costs were awarded to the successful Decree Holder and assessed at KSh 3,000.

Ratio. Costs are discretionary and ordinarily follow the event, subject to the nature of the application, issues raised, and parties’ conduct. As the Judgment Debtor failed on the substantive reliefs and the Decree Holder had to respond, there was no reason to deny her costs.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

6. The first concerns whether the payments allegedly made by the Judgment Debtor to various persons should be recognized as payments towards satisfaction of the decree. The second is whether the Judgment Debtor has established sufficient cause to warrant payment of the decretal sum by instalments. The third concerns the prayer seeking to restrain the Decree Holder from attaching or otherwise dealing with property belonging to the Judgment Debtor's parents and/or relatives. Finally, the Court must determine the issue of costs.

Paragraph 6 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

32. The upshot of my findings therefore is that the application is dismissed with costs which I assess at Kshs. 3,000/=.

Paragraph 32 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

29. On costs, costs remain a matter for the Court's discretion, to be exercised judicially and in accordance with the applicable law. While costs ordinarily follow the event, the Court must consider the nature of the application, the issues raised and the conduct of the parties.

Paragraph 29 →

30. In the present case, the Judgment Debtor has not established an entitlement to the substantive reliefs sought. The Decree Holder has been required to respond to an application seeking to alter the mode of satisfaction of an existing decree and to obtain additional orders concerning payments and execution.

Paragraph 30 →

31. In the circumstances, I find no sufficient reason to deprive the successful party of the costs of the application.

Paragraph 31 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before me for determination is the Applicant’s notice of motion dated 30th September 2026 in which the Applicant seeks the following orders: -

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

The upshot of my findings therefore is that the application is dismissed with costs which I assess at Kshs. 3,000/=.

Paragraph 32 →

Reasoning passage

To the extent that the objection rests solely on the Judgment Debtor's appearance in person, I find no sufficient basis for striking out the application on that ground.

Paragraph 28 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether alleged payments of KSh 87,450 to Pascal Iteba, Lilian Opiyo and the decree holder’s advocates should be credited against the decree; whether the judgment debtor had shown sufficient cause for monthly instalments of KSh 20,000; whether execution…

Material facts

A decree had issued following judgment for KSh 406,000, with costs assessed at KSh 46,400 and interest. Solomon Wechuli sought recognition of alleged payments, an instalment plan, and protection of his parents’ and relatives’ property from execution. He…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MALABA

SCCOMM CASE NO. E010 OF 2026

FAITH NASIMIYU MAKOKHA….……………........CLAIMANT/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

SOLOMON WECHULI………….………………….…RESPONDENT/APPLICANT

RULING.

1. What is before me for determination is the Applicant’s notice of motion dated 30th September 2026 in which the Applicant seeks the following orders: -

a) That the Honorable Court do declare the receiver/account of payments made in satisfaction of the decretal sum in this suit.

b) That the Honorable Court do adopt the payment schedule of Kshs. 20,000/= on every 20th day of each month until full settlement of the decretal sum and make it an order of the court.

c) That the court do declare that all the monies so far paid to Pascal Iteba, Lilian Opiyo and the Decree Holder’s Advocates totaling to Kshs. 84,450/= do form part of the decretal sum in this claim.

d) That an order restraining the Decree holder whether by herself, her agents, servants, employees, advocates or any person acting on her behalf from attaching, advertising for sale, selling, transferring or otherwise dealing with the property belonging to te applicant’s parents and/or relatives in execution of the decree.

e) That costs of the application be provided for.

2. The application is supported by the following grounds and reiterated in the supporting affidavit of Solomon Wechuli Wawire:-

a) That the applicant was adjudged to pay a decretal sum of Kshs. 406,000/= and on instructions of the decree holder has paid a total of Kshs. 87,450/= to one Pascal Oteba, counsel for the decree holder and Lilian Opiyo. That the applicant may fail to keep proper accounts the monies being paid to different people.

b) That Dominion yards auctioneers under the strict directions and guidance of the decree holder have visited, called and/or contacted the parents of the applicant threatening with consequences of attachment of their property in fulfilment of the decree.

3. The application is opposed vide a replying affidavit sworn by the Respondent on 12th October 2026 and whose averments may be summarized as follows: -

a) That the notice of motion is incompetent for having been filed by the Applicant in person yet he is represented by an advocate.

b) That the notice of motion contains falsehood and fails to disclose material facts.

c) That judgment was entered in this matter for the sum of Kshs. 406,000/= together with costs which were assessed at Kshs. 46,400/= and interest and a decree was issued on 11th May 2026.

d) That counsel for the Respondent issued instructions to Dominion Yard Auctioneers after no steps were made to liquidate the decretal sum and which auctioneers issued and served a proclamation notice.

e) That on 2nd June 2026, the applicant through M. K Kimaru Advocates wrote a letter to Dominion Auctioneers requesting for indulgence to clear the decretal sum in ten months by first paying Kshs. 20,000/= per month but increase to Kshs. 30,000/= before July and December 2026 and simultaneously spoke to her advocate for indulgence not to proceed with execution.

f) That he deposited Kshs. 30,000/= with her advocate and she told her advocate to agree to the request by the applicant but she has never instructed any person to take over payments from her advocate.

g) That she is aware that the Applicant has in the past been paid both by Busia County Government and Bungoma County Government in millions and that the court does not have jurisdiction to unilaterally adopt and impose the proposed mode of payment.

4. This matter came up for directions on the notice of motion on 9th October 2026 and subsequently on 13th October 2026 when the court directed that the application be canvassed by way of written submissions. The court reserved the matter for ruling on 28th October 2026. At the time of writing this ruling, only the Respondent had filed submissions.

5. I have considered the Notice of Motion, the supporting affidavit, the response thereto and the rival positions taken by the parties. The application raises several distinct questions which must be considered separately.

6. The first concerns whether the payments allegedly made by the Judgment Debtor to various persons should be recognized as payments towards satisfaction of the decree. The second is whether the Judgment Debtor has established sufficient cause to warrant payment of the decretal sum by instalments. The third concerns the prayer seeking to restrain the Decree Holder from attaching or otherwise dealing with property belonging to the Judgment Debtor's parents and/or relatives. Finally, the Court must determine the issue of costs.

7. On the alleged payments and accounting for the decretal sum, the Judgment Debtor seeks an order declaring that the payments made to Pascal Iteba, Lilian Opiyo and the Decree Holder's advocates, allegedly totaling KSh 87,450, constitute part-payment of the decretal sum.

8. The burden lies upon the Judgment Debtor, who asserts that the decree has been partly satisfied, to demonstrate that the payments were made and that they were received or authorised on behalf of the Decree Holder towards satisfaction of the decree. Proof that money changed hands is not, by itself, proof that the decree was thereby reduced.

9. There is an important distinction between payments made to an advocate acting on behalf of a litigant in the matter and payments made independently to a broker or another third party. Where payment is made to an advocate duly authorised to receive it, such payment may properly be recognised as payment towards the decree. However, a payment made to a third party cannot automatically be attributed to the Decree Holder merely because the recipient was involved in the transaction or claimed to act on her behalf. The requisite authority, receipt or subsequent acknowledgement must be established.

10. In the present application, the Judgment Debtor has not demonstrated a sufficient basis upon which the Court can treat the entire sum of KSh 87,450 allegedly paid to the three persons as money received towards satisfaction of the decree. The Court cannot presume that a payment made to an intermediary necessarily discharged the Judgment Debtor's obligation to the Decree Holder.

11. Accordingly, the prayers seeking a declaration that the said payments constitute part-payment of the decree cannot be granted on the material presented.

12. On the application for payment by instalments, the Judgment Debtor further seeks an order permitting him to pay Kshs 20,000/= on the twentieth day of every month until the decretal sum is fully settled.

13. The power of a court to permit payment by instalments is discretionary. The discretion must be exercised judiciously, taking into account the circumstances of the case, the Judgment Debtor's financial position, the reasons advanced for the proposed arrangement, the amount outstanding and the prejudice that the proposed arrangement may occasion the Decree Holder.

14. A judgment debtor does not acquire an automatic entitlement to instalment payments merely by proposing a monthly amount. Sufficient cause must be demonstrated to justify the departure from the ordinary expectation that a decree, once issued, should be satisfied without undue delay.

15. In opposing this prayer, the Decree Holder relies on M-Pesa statements said to reflect transactions amounting to KSh 14,768,560.94. The significance of that material is that it raises a legitimate question regarding the Judgment Debtor's financial capacity and whether the proposed instalment arrangement is reasonable in the circumstances.

16. I am, however, alive to the distinction between gross transactional turnover and actual disposable income. The amount passing through a mobile money account does not, without more, necessarily represent the account holder's net income or available assets. Nevertheless, where substantial financial activity is demonstrated, the Judgment Debtor is expected to provide a credible explanation of his financial circumstances and establish why the proposed instalments are appropriate.

17. In the present case, the Judgment Debtor has proposed monthly payments of Ksh 20,000 but has not sufficiently demonstrated, on the material before the Court, the financial circumstances that make such an arrangement necessary and reasonable. Nor has he adequately demonstrated why the Decree Holder should be compelled to recover the decretal sum over an extended period on the terms proposed.

18. The Court must balance the Judgment Debtor's opportunity to satisfy the decree against the Decree Holder's right to enjoy the fruits of her judgment. That balance cannot be achieved by imposing an instalment arrangement unsupported by sufficient cause.

19. I therefore find that the Judgment Debtor has not established a sufficient basis for the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour. The prayer for payment by instalments is consequently declined.

20. On the prayer to restrain attachment of property belonging to third parties, The Judgment Debtor also seeks an order restraining the Decree Holder, her agents, employees, advocates or persons acting on her behalf from attaching, advertising for sale, selling, transferring or otherwise dealing with property belonging to his parents and/or relatives in execution of the decree.

21. A decree is enforceable against the judgment debtor and property legally available to satisfy the decree. It does not, merely by its existence, authorise execution against property belonging to persons who are not judgment debtors.

22. At the same time, the Court must distinguish between a general apprehension that third-party property may be attached and an actual or sufficiently demonstrated threat of unlawful execution. The Court cannot issue an unrestricted order against the Decree Holder in the absence of a proper evidential foundation for the relief sought.

23. The appropriate legal remedy is available where property belonging to a third party is actually attached or is otherwise subjected to execution in circumstances warranting an objection. The affected person may invoke the applicable objection proceedings and demonstrate the nature and extent of the proprietary interest claimed. Such proceedings enable the Court to determine the competing claims on the evidence presented.

24. The present application does not establish a sufficient basis for the broad restraining order sought. The prayer is therefore declined, without prejudice to the right of any person whose property is wrongfully attached to pursue the appropriate legal remedy.

25. On the objection concerning the manner in which the application was filed, I have also considered the objection that the application is incompetent because the applicant is represented by an advocate while he has filed the application in his own name.

26. The mere fact that one party is represented by an advocate does not, in itself, render an application filed by the opposing party in person incompetent. A litigant's right to act in person must be distinguished from compliance with the applicable procedural requirements governing the institution, signing and service of applications.

27. The Court is enjoined to administer justice without undue regard to procedural technicalities, while ensuring that substantive and mandatory procedural requirements are observed. Accordingly, the objection cannot succeed merely on the ground that the Judgment Debtor has acted in person. Any specific defect affecting the validity of the application must be identified and assessed on its own merits.

28. To the extent that the objection rests solely on the Judgment Debtor's appearance in person, I find no sufficient basis for striking out the application on that ground.

29. On costs, costs remain a matter for the Court's discretion, to be exercised judicially and in accordance with the applicable law. While costs ordinarily follow the event, the Court must consider the nature of the application, the issues raised and the conduct of the parties.

30. In the present case, the Judgment Debtor has not established an entitlement to the substantive reliefs sought. The Decree Holder has been required to respond to an application seeking to alter the mode of satisfaction of an existing decree and to obtain additional orders concerning payments and execution.

31. In the circumstances, I find no sufficient reason to deprive the successful party of the costs of the application.

32. The upshot of my findings therefore is that the application is dismissed with costs which I assess at Kshs. 3,000/=.

RULING DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MALABA SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS 28TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

In the Presence of

Solomon Wechuli the Applicant and

Faith Nasimiyu the Respondent

Court Assistant: Paul Otieno

A.Z. OGANGE

RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

28.10.2026

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder