Employment law

Maluvu v Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT) East Africa Limited [2026] KEELRC 14727 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E045 of 2024
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before the Court is a Memorandum of Claim dated 4th December, 2023, in which the Claimant seeks judgment against the Respondent for the following remedies:-

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In light of the foregoing, I find and hold that the Respondent has demonstrated a substantive basis for its decision, and it then follows that the Claimant’s termination is substantively fair and lawful.

Paragraph 55 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Respondent proved a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment for poor performance; whether it complied with procedural fairness under section 41 of the Employment Act; and whether the Claimant was entitled to the requested…

Material facts

Alois Makau Maluvu was employed as Senior Commercial Manager, Financial Crime and Compliance from 1 December 2017, at a stated gross monthly salary of KShs.842,000. The Respondent placed him on a three-month PIP from 31 October 2022 to 31 January 2023,…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E045 OF 2024

ALOIS MAKAU MALUVU..................................................................CLAIMANT

VERSUS

SOCIETY FOR WORLDWIDE INTERBANK FINANCIAL

TELECOMMUNICATION (SWIFT) EAST AFRICA LIMITED............RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. Before the Court is a Memorandum of Claim dated 4th December, 2023, in which the Claimant seeks judgment against the Respondent for the following remedies:-

a. A declaration that the decision by the Respondent to terminate the Claimant's employment was procedurally unfair and substantively unjustified.

b. A declaration that the termination of the Claimant's employment was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.

c. An Order for payment of damages of up to 12 months’ salary of Kshs. 10,104,000/= to be paid to the Claimant for wrongful and unfair termination;

d. Exemplary and aggravated damages of Kshs. 10,000,000/=.

e. Costs and interest of this suit.

2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 11th March, 2024 and filed a Memorandum of Response dated 2nd April, 2024. The Claimant equally filed a Reply to the Respondent’s Response dated 8th October, 2024.

3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 19th May, 2025, when CW1, Alois Makau Maluvu, testified in support of his case. He adopted his witness statement dated 4th December, 2023, as his evidence-in-chief and produced his list and bundle of documents of even date as Claimant’s Exhibits 1-9.

4. The Respondent’s case was subsequently heard on 2nd March 2026, when RW1, Avalon Roxanne Ingram, adopted her witness statement dated 23rd July, 2024 as her evidence-in-chief and produced the list and bundle of documents dated 15th July, 2024 as Exhibits 1-2. RW2, Laure Fondu, Head of Social Relations at the Respondent, also adopted his witness statement dated 23rd July, 2024 as his evidence-in-chief and produced the list and bundle of documents dated 15th July, 2024 and a supplementary list and bundle of documents dated 26th November, 2025.

5. Both parties filed submissions in the matter.

The Claimant’s case

6. The Claimant’s case is that he was employed by the Respondent as Senior Commercial Manager, Financial Crime and Compliance, with effect from 1st December, 2017 under a contract dated 21st November, 2017. He avers that he was initially placed on a six-month probationary period, and that his gross monthly salary was Kshs. 842,000, equivalent to Kshs.10,104,000 per annum.

7. It is his case that he successfully completed the probation and that his earlier appraisals were satisfactory. The Claimant contends that in early November 2022, his supervisor, Avalon Ingram, informed him that he would be placed on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), without a supporting appraisal.

8. He avers that the PIP was not completed before his dismissal and that the Respondent conducted the 2022 annual appraisal in February 2023, after the disciplinary hearing, and informed him that he had partially met the standards.

9. It is the Claimant’s case that he did not receive a formal warning or notice to show cause, that there were no regular meetings to review his performance, and that he was not afforded a fair opportunity to improve.

10. The Claimant states that he challenged the termination letter dated 7th March, 2023, which cited failure to demonstrate independent initiative in FCC related opportunities, insufficient product knowledge at expert level, inability to deliver customer presentations independently and effectively, insufficient effort to improve product knowledge, and failure to improve communication with clients and colleagues.

11. He denies that client complaints about his presentations were previously brought to his attention. He avers that the disciplinary hearing of 24th February, 2023 was unfair because he was not afforded a proper opportunity to defend himself or call witnesses.

12. On cross-examination, the Claimant confirmed that he knew the Respondent’s disciplinary rules, participated in annual appraisals and mid-year reviews, and that he identified the document at page 11 of the Respondent’s bundle as an assessment of both the mid-year and full-year reviews.

13. It is the Claimant’s case that he was placed on a PIP in November 2022, before the 2022 review period ended, and that by December 2022 he had achieved 12 accounts against a target of 18. He further avers that the mid-year review recorded only 3 of 18 target accounts.

14. It is his testimony that an employee could be placed on a PIP at any time and not necessarily at the end of a review period, and he further states that no review took place in November 2022. He confirmed that the PIP ran for three months, that he had one review meeting each month, and that the outcome was not communicated to him before his services were terminated.

15. It is the Claimant’s case that the disciplinary hearing concerned issues similar to those in the PIP. He averred that the invitation dated 15th February, 2023 identified the issues, included explanations and supporting documents, and informed him of his rights to representation, to call evidence, and to appeal.

16. It is his evidence that he did not object to the said hearing, and further confirmed that he presented his case, did not appeal against the outcome, and accepted that the hearing minutes were a true record, while disputing the PIP outcome.

17. On client engagements, he explained that he joined a call on 23rd August 2023 fifteen minutes late because he was attending to another account; acknowledged client requests for assistance; stated that the expected turnaround time was 24 - 48 hours; and accepted that he responded to an email request sent on 11th August 2022 only on 5th December 2022, describing the delay as inordinate and confirming that he apologized to the customer. He also acknowledged a delay between correspondence of 23rd November 2022 and 6th December 2022.

18. The Claimant further testified that he had previously worked at Barclays and Citi Bank, where he was a Compliance Manager from 2002 to 2012, and further confirmed that his separation from Citi Bank was on account of performance issues and litigation in ELRC Cause No. 95 of 2015. He acknowledged that he did not inform the Respondent of that case, and gave no reason for failing to appeal the termination decision.

19. It is his testimony that he was dissatisfied with the outcome, and confirmed that he was paid terminal dues.

20. It is his case that the disciplinary minutes were unsigned and that he lost access to his email after surrendering his laptop. He maintained that he resolved the issue when it came to his attention.

The Claimant’s submissions

21. It is the Claimant’s submission that the Respondent did not prove poor performance or show that a fair and credible appraisal process was undertaken. He submits that the PIP was not supported by an adequate prior appraisal, that the performance standards and allegations were insufficiently specific, and that he was not given sufficient time to prepare for the disciplinary hearing.

22. He submits further that an invitation dated 15th February, 2023 was received by him on 22nd February, 2023, shortly before the hearing on 24th February 2023.

23. The Claimant relied on Mukala v Ol Tukai Lodge Limited [2013] KEIC 634 (KLR) and Machira v Mugo Waweru and Associates [2012] KEIC 1 (KLR), for the proposition that termination on account of poor performance should be preceded by a credible performance assessment, clear performance standards and reasonable measures to address the employee’s shortcomings.

The Respondent’s case.

24. The Respondent states that the Claimant was employed between 1st December 2017 and 7th March 2023, but denies that the termination was unfair or unlawful. It maintains that the Claimant failed to meet the minimum competencies expected of a Commercial Manager, leading to his placement on a three month PIP from 31st October, 2022 to 31st January 2023.

25. It states that the PIP identified three areas for improvement, including generating opportunities independently, improving product knowledge to support account managers, and meeting the transparency and performance expectations of an expert.

26. The Respondent avers that the Claimant’s performance concerns were reflected in his 2021 end-year and 2022 mid-year appraisals, and in client correspondence. It cited delays or inadequate responses involving international investment bank S.A. (ibb), BCI, Faulu Microfinance Bank, BancABC, Commercial International Bank and CRDB Bank.

27. It maintains that the PIP set measurable objectives, support measures and a measurement matrix, and that five checkpoint meetings were held approximately fortnightly. The Respondent further states that the Claimant did not meet the required deliverables and that his product knowledge, client communication and opportunity tracking remained inadequate.

28. The Respondent further pleaded that the Claimant was issued with a disciplinary hearing notice dated 15th February, 2023 for a hearing that was scheduled for 24th February 2023, together with particulars of the allegations and supporting documents. It maintains that he was informed of his right to be accompanied by a colleague, call witnesses, present evidence, prepare his defence and appeal against the outcome.

29. It is the Respondent’s case that following the hearing, the panel recommended termination and the Respondent issued a termination letter dated 7th March, 2023.

30. It states that the Claimant received salary up to termination, three months’ salary in lieu of notice and payment for 19 accrued leave days, and was also issued with a certificate of service.

31. RW1, testified that she was the Claimant’s line manager from the beginning of 2022, and that she reviewed his mid-year and end-year performance for that year. She stated that the Claimant’s performance fell below the requirements of his role, prompting his placement on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) from 31st October, 2022 to 31st January, 2023.

32. It was her further case that the PIP set targets relating to business opportunities, product knowledge and performance expectations. She maintained that the Claimant received support and participated in regular check-in meetings, but failed to achieve the required improvement. She further indicated that she was given full access to his inbox, which showed that he was not managing his role.

33. He testified on cross-examination that no performance appraisal report prior to 2022 was placed before the Court and further clarified that his responsibility for assessing the Claimant’s performance was limited to the year 2022. He stated that he initially asked the Claimant to copy him on all communications, and that he subsequently trained and coached him.

34. It is RW1’s testimony that the Claimant failed to consult the recommended documents and was unaware of where to access them. He further referred to emails from clients raising concerns about delays in receiving information, and maintained that he and the Human Resources representative were present when the PIP was thoroughly explained, that the targets were mutually agreed upon, and that the PIP matrix was produced before the Court.

35. On re-examination, he reiterated that the PIP indicated that it ran from 31st October 2022 to 31st January 2023. He clarified that the status the Claimant entered was, “I have read and understood the PIP.” He further testified that he had accounted for the outcomes of every engagement with the Claimant in the documents produced before the Court. He stated that there were five engagements in total, and only two matrices showed that the Claimant was on track.

36. RW2 confirmed that he was a member of the disciplinary panel and that, after considering the Claimant’s case, the panel supported the decision to terminate his employment. He stated that the panel communicated its conclusion to Human Resources on 28th February, 2023 to proceed with termination. He testified that the Respondent communicated the termination decision to Human Resources.

37. On cross-examination, she stated that the minutes are not signed since they proceeded virtually and that the HR team informed the Claimant of the decision to terminate.

The Respondent’s submissions.

38. It is the Respondent’s submission that the Claimant’s termination was substantively justified and procedurally fair. The Respondent relied on Sections 41, 43, 45, 47(5), and 49 of the Employment Act, 2007, to submit that the Claimant’s performance appraisals, PIP records, and client correspondence demonstrated valid reasons for termination.

39. It submits further that the Claimant was given clear performance targets, support and a reasonable opportunity to improve, but he failed to meet the required standards. The Respondent relied on Kwale International Sugar Company Ltd v Mbaya [2024] KECA 795 (KLR) and Mukala v Ol Tukai Lodge Limited [2013] KEIC 634 (KLR), on the requirements for termination on grounds of poor performance.

40. On procedural fairness, the Respondent submitted that the Claimant was informed of the allegations, provided with supporting documents, notified of his rights and afforded an opportunity to respond at the disciplinary hearing.

41. The Respondent submits that Section 41 of the Employment Act did not make a separate notice to show cause mandatory in every case, provided the employee was adequately informed of the allegations and heard in response to those allegations. It relied on Lydia Moraa Obara v Tusker Mattresses Limited [2021] KEELRC 1055 (KLR) and Kenya Plantation and Agricultural Workers Union v Eastern Produce (K) Limited [2022] KEELRC 1302 (KLR) to support its assertion.

42. The Respondent further submitted that the absence of signatures on the disciplinary minutes did not invalidate them, particularly because the minutes were circulated for comments and the Claimant acknowledged them as a true record of the hearing. It relied on Godfrey Meso Komba v Inter Beauty Products Limited [2021] KEELRC 464 (KLR).

43. The Respondent urged the Court to dismiss the Claimant’s claim with costs.

Analysis and Determination

44. Having considered the pleadings, the witnesses’ oral testimonies and the rival submissions, the issues that present for determination are:-

i. Whether the Respondent has demonstrated a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment.

ii. Whether the Respondent complied with the statutory requirements of procedural fairness.

iii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought.

Whether the Respondent has demonstrated a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment

45. Section 43(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 places the burden on an employer to prove the reason or reasons for termination, while Section 45(2) requires the employer to demonstrate that the reason was valid and fair, and that the employee’s termination was undertaken in accordance with fair procedure. Further, Section 47(5) places the initial burden on the employee to show that the termination was unfair or wrongful, while the employer bears the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination of employment.

46. The Respondent’s contention is that the Claimant was terminated from service on account of poor performance. In Jane Samba Mukala v Ol Tukai Lodge Limited [2013] KEIC 634 (KLR), the Court emphasized that an employer relying on poor performance must demonstrate the existence of an objective performance evaluation system, the standards against which the employee was assessed, and the measures taken to address the employee’s shortcomings. In the Court’s opinion, merely asserting that an employee performed poorly is not sufficient.

47. The Respondent specifically attributes the Claimant’s termination to his failure to demonstrate independent initiative in generating financial crime and compliance related business opportunities, inadequate product knowledge, inability to conduct customer presentations independently, and inadequate communication with clients and colleagues.

48. Further, the Respondent relied on the Claimant’s 2021 end-year and 2022 mid-year appraisals, client correspondence, and a three-month Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) running from 31st October, 2022 to 31st January, 2023. It contends that the PIP identified specific areas requiring improvement, set measurable targets, and provided for support and periodic review meetings. RW1 testified that five checkpoint meetings were held, while the Claimant acknowledged that the PIP ran for three months and that he attended monthly review meetings.

49. The evidence adduced also includes client correspondence concerning delayed or inadequate responses. The Claimant acknowledged that he responded to an email request dated 11th August, 2022, on 5th December, 2022, and further described the delay as inordinate, and confirmed that he apologized to the customer. He also acknowledged a delay in responding to correspondence exchanged between 23rd November and 6th December, 2022.

50. The foregoing admissions by the Claimant support the Respondent’s contention that the concerns about the Claimant’s responsiveness and client management were not merely subjective allegations, but they provide an evidential basis upon which the Respondent could assess his performance against the demands of his position.

51. The Respondent presented the PIP matrix and evidence of five review engagements. RW1 testified that only two matrices showed that the Claimant was on track. This evidence supports the Respondent’s position that the Claimant’s performance was monitored during the improvement period, and that the concerns persisted. The Claimant, for his part, confirmed that the PIP ran for three months and that he participated in review meetings, although he disputed the outcome.

52. The Claimant also contended that the 2022 annual appraisal was conducted in February 2023, after the disciplinary hearing, and that he was informed that he had partially met the required standards.

53. In my considered view, a finding that an employee has only partially met performance standards does not establish that the employee met all the requirements of the position. The Respondent needed only to demonstrate that the outstanding deficiencies were material to the Claimant’s role and remained uncorrected despite the support and opportunity provided.

54. On the evidence before the court, it is clear that the Respondent identified the required competencies, set targets, provided coaching and review meetings, and presented the PIP records and the client correspondence. Further, the Claimant’s own admissions corroborated some of the concerns raised by the Respondent regarding delayed client responses.

55. In light of the foregoing, I find and hold that the Respondent has demonstrated a substantive basis for its decision, and it then follows that the Claimant’s termination is substantively fair and lawful.

Whether the Respondent complied with the statutory requirements of procedural fairness

56. Section 41 of the Employment Act provides that an employer contemplating termination on account of poor performance must explain the contemplated grounds to the employee in a language the employee understands, and further inform the employee of their right to be accompanied by another employee or a shop-floor union representative of their choice.

57. The Court of Appeal in National Bank of Kenya v Mutonya [2019] KECA 404 (KLR), adopted its earlier decision in Jane Samba Mukala vs. Ol Tukai Lodge Limited Industrial (supra), where it held:-

“a……………………

b…………………….

c. Beyond having such an evaluation measure, and before termination on the ground of poor performance, an employee must be called and explanation on their poor performance shared where they would in essence be allowed to defend themselves or given an opportunity to address their weaknesses.

d. In the event a decision is made to terminate an employee on the reasons for poor performance, the employee must be called again and in the presence of an employee of their choice, the reasons for termination shared with the employee.”

58. Further, in Kwale International Sugar Company Ltd v Mbaya [2024] KECA 795 (KLR), the Court of Appeal reaffirmed that the statutory requirements governing procedural fairness apply to termination for poor performance.

59. The Claimant’s contention is that he was not issued with a formal warning or notice to show cause and that the disciplinary invitation dated 15th February 2023, was received on 22nd February 2023, only two days before the hearing. He further asserts that he was not afforded a proper opportunity to defend himself or call witnesses.

60. The Respondent, on the other hand, maintains that the invitation to the Claimant identified the allegations against him, supplied supporting documents and expressly informed him of his rights to representation, to call witnesses, to present evidence and to appeal against the decision.

61. The Court notes that the Claimant acknowledged that he received the invitation to attend the disciplinary hearing, understood the allegations leveled against him, participated in the disciplinary hearing of 24th February, 2023, presented his case and accepted the minutes as a true record of the proceedings. It is also noteworthy that he did not appeal against the decision, even when he disputed the PIP outcome.

62. The absence of a separate notice to show cause is, in my view, not, in itself, necessarily fatal where the employer has otherwise complied with Section 41. The decisive question is whether the employee was adequately informed of the contemplated termination and afforded a genuine opportunity to answer to the allegations.

63. Further, although the period between receipt of the invitation and the hearing was short, the Claimant acknowledged that the invitation contained the allegations and supporting documents and that he participated in the hearing without raising an objection to the process.

64. On the evidence presented, therefore, I do not find a demonstrated basis for concluding that the short notice materially prevented the Claimant from presenting his defense.

65. In the upshot, I find and hold that the Respondent substantially complied with Section 41 of the Employment Act, which renders the termination procedurally fair and lawful.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought

66. The Claimant seeks declarations of unfair termination, compensation equivalent to twelve months’ salary amounting to KShs.10,104,000, exemplary and aggravated damages of KShs.10,000,000, costs of the suit and interest thereon.

67. Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act provides for compensation of up to twelve months’ gross wages where an employee’s employment has been unfairly terminated.

68. The court has found the Claimant’s termination on the ground of poor performance both substantively and procedurally fair and lawful, and for this reason, he is not entitled to an award of compensation.

69. The claim for compensation is therefore devoid of merit, and it fails.

70. The claim for exemplary and aggravated damages equally fails for similar reasons as the Claimant has not demonstrated a separate legal basis or sufficient evidence of conduct warranting such an award. In Alois Makau Maluvu v Cititrust Kenya Limited & another [2018] KEELRC 1285 (KLR), the Court declined a claim for aggravated damages where the claim was not supported by evidence.

71. In whole, I find the Claimant’s Claim lacking in merit and is hereby dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

72. Judgment accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Gakuiya present for the Claimant

Ms. Salim h/b for Mr. Nkonge for the Respondent

Ms. Esther - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder