Small Claims

Nandutu v Waneloba & another [2026] SCC 258 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Malaba
Judgment date
4 November 2026

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before me for determination is the Respondents’/Applicants’ application dated 15th October 2026 wherein the Applicants seek the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Accordingly, the Court finds that the execution process, insofar as it seeks to attach the personal property of the individual Applicants in satisfaction of an obligation arising from the company's dealings, cannot be sustained.

Paragraph 23 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the alleged Kshs.56,000 payment to Armok Auctioneers partly satisfied the decree; whether Caleb Waneloba and Joan Wasike could face execution against their personal property for an obligation arising from dealings with Joypeace Unity Limited; and…

Material facts

Lilian Nandutu’s pleaded claim arose from her membership, share deposits, loan application and surrender of a title deed to an organisation trading as Joypeace Unity Limited. The applicants said that personal property had been attached although Joypeace Unity…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MALABA

SCCOMM NO. E024 OF 2026

LILIAN NANDUTU………….….………………………………….. CLAIMANT/RESPONDENT

VERSUS

CALEB WANELOBA AND JOAN WASIKE T/A JOYPEACE UNITY LIMITED………………..………………………………………..RESPONDENT/APPLICANT

RULING.

1. What is before me for determination is the Respondents’/Applicants’ application dated 15th October 2026 wherein the Applicants seek the following orders:-

a) Spent

b) Spent

c) Spent

d) That the Honorable Court does declare that Joypeace Unity Limited is a company capable of being sued in own corporate names and separate from the Respondents Caleb Waneloba and Joan Wasike.

e) That the Honorable Court declares that the Respondents/Applicants have paid part of the decretal sum amounting to Kshs. 56,500/= and thus the balance is Kshs. 43,500/= only.

f) That costs of the application be provided for.

2. The Application is supported by the following grounds and reiterated in the affidavit of Caleb Waneloba:-

a) That the Claimant instructed an auctioneer to attach property of the Respondent pursuant to a decree by this court and the auctioneer has attached personal property not belonging to the Company Joypeace Unity Limited and that the parties Caleb Waneloba and Joan Wasike are independent and separate from the company.

b) That the Claimant had initially instructed one Arnold Ombonya trading as Armok Auctioneers and he subsequently transferred Kshs. 56,000/= to the said auctioneer as part payment of the decree.

c) That the Claimant subsequently instructed the firm of Roban Auctioneers to collect the decretal sum afresh from the Respondents.

3. The application is opposed vide the Claimant’s Replying Affidavit sworn on 19th day of October 2026 on the following grounds:-

a) That on the 12th day of March 2026 the applicants raised a preliminary objection challenging the territorial jurisidiction of the court and further contending that they have been improperly sued as individuals, where the entity in question is alleged to be a corporate body capable of suing and being sued in its own name and it is on record that the preliminary objection was dismissed before parties recorded a consent.

b) That the Auctioneers Armok Auctioneers were not instructed by the Claimant to execute the decree or receive any payment on her behalf and that although the Applicants allege to have paid Kshs. 56,000/=only Kshs. 15,000/= was remitted to her.

c) That following the failure to honor terms of the consent, her advocate instructed Roban Auctioneers to execute the decree and the Applicant Caleb Waneloba signed and stamped the proclamation form using Joypeace Unity Limited Stamp.

d) That the Applicants certificate of incorporation identifies the company Joy peace unity limited while the claim and the execution documents refer to Caleb Waneloba and Joan Wasike trading as Joypeace Unity Limited and the legal effect of that distinction must be determined by reference to the pleadings .

e) That she prays for dismissal of the application and/or execution to proceed.

4. This matter came up for directions on 21st October 2026 when parties agreed to canvass the application by way of written submissions. The court reserved the matter for ruling on 4th November 2026. At the time of writing this ruling, only the Claimant/Respondent had filed submissions, which I have read and considered.

5. I have considered the Notice of Motion dated 15th October 2026, the supporting affidavit, the Claimant's Replying Affidavit sworn on 19th October 2026, the previous ruling on the preliminary objection delivered on 16th March 2026, and the record of the proceedings.

6. The application raises three principal issues for determination:

a) Whether the alleged payment to Armok Auctioneers constitutes part-satisfaction of the decree.

b) Whether the individual Applicants can be subjected to execution in respect of an obligation arising from dealings with Joypeace Unity Limited.

c) Whether the Applicants are entitled to the orders sought.

The alleged payment to Armok Auctioneers

7. The Applicants contend that they paid Kshs.56,000/= to Arnold Omonya trading as Armok Auctioneers in purported execution of the decree. They maintain that the Claimant had instructed the said auctioneer to execute the decree.

8. The Claimant, in her Replying Affidavit, denies having instructed Armok Auctioneers or authorised her advocate to do so. However, at paragraph 8 of the same affidavit, she expressly acknowledges that although the Applicants allege to have paid Kshs.56,000/= to the said auctioneer, only Kshs.15,000/= was remitted to her.

9. This averment is significant. It establishes that the Claimant received Kshs.15,000/= from Armok Auctioneers in connection with the alleged execution process. Her denial of having instructed the auctioneer is therefore to be considered alongside her own admission of having received money remitted by the said auctioneer.

10. The Court cannot overlook an admission made on oath. The acknowledged Kshs.15,000/= must accordingly be credited towards satisfaction of the decree.

11. As regards the balance of Kshs.41,000/=, the Claimant maintains that the same was never remitted to her. The Applicants, on their part, contend that the entire amount was paid to the auctioneer. The Court notes that the material before it does not conclusively establish the authority under which Armok Auctioneers received the money or the circumstances surrounding the non-remittance of the balance.

12. The Court is therefore unable to conclusively pronounce the entire Kshs.56,000/= as having been received by the Claimant. However, the acknowledged Kshs.15,000/= shall be credited against the decretal sum. The question of accountability for the balance paid to the auctioneer is distinct from the question of the Claimant's admitted receipt.

2. Whether the individual Applicants can be subjected to execution in respect of an obligation arising from dealings with Joypeace Unity Limited

13. The Applicants contend that Joypeace Unity Limited is an incorporated company with a legal personality distinct from themselves and that their personal property cannot be attached in satisfaction of an obligation belonging to the company. The Claimant's position must be examined against the circumstances disclosed in her own claim.

14. A perusal of the claim reveals that the Claimant's dealings were with an organisation operating as a deposit-taking and money-lending entity. She states that she joined the Respondents' organisation as a member in June 2025, made deposits towards share savings, subsequently applied for a loan, and surrendered her title deed as security for the intended loan. She further states that the loan application was cancelled and that she was subsequently asked to pay Kshs.70,000/= for valuation.

15. The nature of the transaction as pleaded points to dealings with the organisation trading as Joypeace Unity Limited and not an independent personal transaction with either Caleb Waneloba or Joan Wasike.

16. The Court has also considered the certificate of incorporation exhibited by the Applicants, identifying Joypeace Unity Limited as a limited liability company. The law recognises the separate legal personality of an incorporated company. In Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22, the principle was firmly established that a company is a legal person distinct from its shareholders and directors. Consequently, the company's obligations are not automatically the personal obligations of its directors or members, just as the company's property does not automatically become the personal property of its directors or members.

17. The Court has noted that the Applicants had previously raised a preliminary objection challenging their joinder in the proceedings on the basis that the entity in question was a corporate body capable of being sued in its own name. In its ruling delivered on 16th March 2026, this Court dismissed the preliminary objection on the basis that the issue of the proper parties to the claim required factual interrogation and was therefore unsuitable for determination as a preliminary objection.

18. It is important to clarify that the Court did not make a substantive determination on the separate legal personality issue at that stage. The Court expressly left the matter to be determined upon consideration of the factual circumstances surrounding the claim and the relationship between the parties. However, before that question could be fully investigated and determined, the parties proceeded to record a consent judgment on 31st March 2026.

19. The effect is that the question of whether the liability arose against the company or the individual Applicants was never substantively determined following the dismissal of the preliminary objection.

20. From the Claimant's own pleadings, the transaction giving rise to the claim involved membership contributions, share deposits and a loan application undertaken through the organisation trading as Joypeace Unity Limited. There is no clear demonstration of an independent personal borrowing or transaction undertaken by either Caleb Waneloba or Joan Wasike in their individual capacities.

21. The fact that the Applicants may have been involved in the management or operation of the company does not make them personally liable for the company's obligations. Further, the Court has not been invited to lift the corporate veil on any demonstrated legal grounds, nor has any sufficient basis been established for disregarding the company's separate legal personality.

22. The Court is therefore persuaded that the obligation forming the basis of the Claimant's claim arose from dealings with Joypeace Unity Limited as a corporate entity and not from an established personal obligation of the individual Applicants. It follows that the personal property of the Applicants cannot lawfully be subjected to attachment merely on account of their association with the company.

23. Accordingly, the Court finds that the execution process, insofar as it seeks to attach the personal property of the individual Applicants in satisfaction of an obligation arising from the company's dealings, cannot be sustained.

Whether the Applicants are entitled to the orders sought

24. Having considered the pleadings, the affidavits and the history of the proceedings, I find that the Applicants have demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant intervention by this Court.The Court is particularly persuaded by the fact that the underlying transaction, as disclosed by the Claimant's own claim, was undertaken with Joypeace Unity Limited as an organisation. The separate legal personality of the company is supported by the certificate of incorporation exhibited by the Applicants.

25. In the final analysis, I find merit in the Applicants' application and make the following orders: -

a) The Applicants' application is hereby allowed.

b) The warrants of attachment issued herein and the consequential proclamation against the personal property of the Applicants are hereby set aside.

c) The Court recognises Joypeace Unity Limited as a separate legal entity distinct from the individual Applicants. Its obligations shall not automatically be imposed upon the Applicants in their personal capacities.

d) The Claimant shall give credit for the Kshs.15,000/= expressly acknowledged as having been received towards the decretal sum.

e) The alleged balance of Kshs.41,000/= paid to Armok Auctioneers shall not, in the absence of sufficient proof of its remittance or lawful application towards satisfaction of the decree, be treated as money received by the Claimant. The Applicants remain at liberty to pursue any appropriate remedy in respect thereof.

f) Each party shall bear its own costs of this application.

RULING DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MALABA SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS 4TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026.

In the Presence of

Ms. Wakoli for the Claimant/Respondent

Mr. Owuor for the Applicant

Court Assistant: Paul Otieno

A.Z. OGANGE

RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

04.11.2026

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder