Small Claims

Mburu v Shiranda [2026] SCC 257 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Malaba
Judgment date
4 November 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment for the Claimant: Kshs. 49,800 principal, interest at court rates from filing until payment in full, and assessed costs of Kshs. 4,500. The Respondent’s request to pay in four to five monthly instalments was refused.

Supporting judgment passages

22. Accordingly, judgment is hereby entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows:

Paragraph 22 →

a) Kshs. 49,800/= being the principal sum claimed and proved.

Passage 32 →

b) Interest at court rates from the date of filing suit until payment in full.

Passage 33 →
Issue 1Whether the claim is res judicata.

Held. No. The res judicata objection failed because the Claimant was not a party to the alleged earlier Small Claims Commercial Suit No. E090 of 2026; that suit was between Lucy Wambui and the Respondent.

Ratio. Res judicata requires, among other essential elements, that the former suit involve the same parties or persons claiming under them and have been finally determined by a competent court. Absence of the same-party requirement defeats the objection.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

14. I have considered the pleadings, the evidence of the parties and their respective witnesses. The issues falling for determination are whether the claim is res judicata and whether the Claimant has proved the claim.

Paragraph 14 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

15. On the question of res judicata, Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act sets out the essential elements of the doctrine, including that the former suit must have involved the same parties or persons claiming under them, litigating under the same title, and that the matter must have been heard and finally determined by a competent court. In the present case, the Claimant confirmed that he was not a party to the alleged former suit being Small Claims Commercial Suit No. E090 of 2026. In fact the Respondent filed documents demonstrating that the suit aforementioned was between Lucy Wambui (CW3) and himself. This alone defeats an essential ingredient of the doctrine. The objection on res judicata therefore fails.

Paragraph 15 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

15. On the question of res judicata, Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act sets out the essential elements of the doctrine, including that the former suit must have involved the same parties or persons claiming under them, litigating under the same title, and that the matter must have been heard and finally determined by a competent court. In the present case, the Claimant confirmed that he was not a party to the alleged former suit being Small Claims Commercial Suit No. E090 of 2026. In fact the Respondent filed documents demonstrating that the suit aforementioned was between Lucy Wambui (CW3) and himself. This alone defeats an essential ingredient of the doctrine. The objection on res judicata therefore fails.

Paragraph 15 →
Issue 2Whether the Claimant has proved the claim.

Held. Yes. On a balance of probabilities, the Claimant proved entitlement to recover Kshs. 49,800, which the Respondent admitted receiving. The Respondent did not prove his asserted debt explanation and had neither properly pleaded it as a counterclaim nor advanced it as a set-off. His instalment request was also refused for lack of evidence of inability to pay in a lump sum.

Ratio. A party asserting an affirmative factual defence bears the burden of proving it under sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act. An unsubstantiated debt defence, not properly pleaded as a counterclaim or set-off, cannot defeat an admitted receipt of money. Payment by instalments requires an application supported by evidence of inability to satisfy the decree in a lump sum; a bare request for time is insufficient.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

14. I have considered the pleadings, the evidence of the parties and their respective witnesses. The issues falling for determination are whether the claim is res judicata and whether the Claimant has proved the claim.

Paragraph 14 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

19. I am consequently satisfied, on a balance of probabilities, that the Claimant has established entitlement to recovery of the amount proved to have been received by the Respondent. The Court is concerned not merely with the original purpose of the payment, but also with the Respondent's admitted receipt and failure to demonstrate any lawful basis for retaining the money.

Paragraph 19 →

20. On the Respondent's request to settle the decretal sum in four to five monthly instalments, Rule 27 of the Small Claims Court Rules empowers the Court to order payment by instalments upon an application and evidence demonstrating inability to satisfy the decree in a lump sum. In the absence of evidence of the Respondent's financial position, I find no sufficient basis for granting the request as presently made. The mere request for time to pay does not establish inability to pay.

Paragraph 20 →

a) Kshs. 49,800/= being the principal sum claimed and proved.

Passage 32 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

17. More significantly, the Respondent admitted under cross-examination that he received the money. His explanation, however, was that the money constituted a debt and was not intended for the procurement of a laptop. I find that this explanation raises an affirmative factual defence which required particular pleading and proof. Under Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act, the burden of proving the existence of that alleged debt lay upon the Respondent, being the party asserting it. No sufficient evidence was tendered to establish its existence or basis.

Paragraph 17 →

18. Further, the alleged debt was neither properly pleaded as a counterclaim nor advanced as a set-off in accordance with Rules 9 and 13 of the Small Claims Court Rules. The Court cannot be invited to determine an unsubstantiated debt defence through evidence introduced at the hearing. The Respondent's admission of receipt, therefore, remains unrebutted by any satisfactory explanation capable of defeating the Claimant's claim.

Paragraph 18 →

20. On the Respondent's request to settle the decretal sum in four to five monthly instalments, Rule 27 of the Small Claims Court Rules empowers the Court to order payment by instalments upon an application and evidence demonstrating inability to satisfy the decree in a lump sum. In the absence of evidence of the Respondent's financial position, I find no sufficient basis for granting the request as presently made. The mere request for time to pay does not establish inability to pay.

Paragraph 20 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Vide a statement of claim dated 22nd September 2026 and filed in court on even date the Claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs. 49,800/= together with costs and any other relief that the court may deem fit and just to grant.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

More significantly, the Respondent admitted under cross-examination that he received the money. His explanation, however, was that the money constituted a debt and was not intended for the procurement of a laptop. I find that this explanation raises an affirmative factual defence which required particular pleading and proof. Under Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act, the burden of proving the existence of that alleged debt lay…

Paragraph 17 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the claim was barred by res judicata because of Small Claims Commercial Suit No. E090 of 2026; whether the Claimant proved entitlement to Kshs. 49,800; and whether the Respondent should be permitted to pay the decretal sum in four to five monthly…

Material facts

John Mburu stated that, at his mother Lucy Wambui’s request, he sent Kshs. 20,000 on 31 July 2024 and Kshs. 29,800 on 2 August 2024 to the Respondent through mobile number 0727******. He said the money was for a laptop and charger connected to an employment…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MALABA

SCCCOMM NO. E104 OF 2026

JOHN MBURU..……..……………………...……….................................CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

JOSEPH SHIRANDA……….……………….……….…….……………….RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction and Evidence

1. Vide a statement of claim dated 22nd September 2026 and filed in court on even date the Claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs. 49,800/= together with costs and any other relief that the court may deem fit and just to grant.

2. The circumstances leading to the filing of this claim are that on 31st July 2024, the Claimant sent Kshs. 20,000/= to the Respondent vide mobile phone number 0727****** upon being asked by the Claimant’s mother one Lucy Wambui. That on 2nd August 2024 the Claimant sent another Kshs. 29,800/= upon another request by his mother. That this money was being paid to the Respondent to supply a laptop and laptop charger. That the Respondent neither supplied the electronics nor paid back the money despite numerous reminders.

3. The suit is opposed vide a Statement of Response dated 6th October 2026 on the grounds that the Claim is misleading, misinforming and contradictory as it lacks focus and particularity. That the Respondent has never entered into a contract to supply any electronic to the Claimant and the claim is mentioned in the suit no. E090 of 2026 thus res judicata.

4. This matter was set down for hearing on 21st October 2026 when the Claimant testified on his own behalf and called two other witnesses.

5. He testified as CW1 and relied on his Statement of Claim and Mpesa Statements.

6. On cross-examination he testified that he was not a party to any other suit and the issue of buying a laptop charger and a debt were not contradictory. That the money belonged to one Lucy but it is he who sent it to the Respondent.

7. CW2 was one Ann Wanjiru who testified that the Claimant wanted a job and since she knew the Respondent as an accountant she introduced the two of them and later heard that money had been sent to the Respondent.

8. CW3 was one Lucy Wambui who testified that she knew the Respondent and who she had been introduced to by one Ann Wanjiru. That the Respondent was an accountant and who would assist the Claimant in getting a job in Kitale. The Respondent asked for money to buy a laptop for the job. He neither delivered the laptop nor refunded the money.

9. On cross-examination she testified that she sent the Respondent Kshs. 24,000/= and the Claimant sent Kshs. 29,800/= totaling to Kshs. 49,800/=

10. This marked close of the Claimant’s case. The Respondent also testified on his own behalf and relied on his Statement of Response and one Response Affidavit.

11. On cross-examination he admitted to receiving the money but alleged that it was a debt. Not for procuring any laptop. He also asked the court to allow him to settle the debt in 4 to 5 monthly installments.

12. The court granted the Claimant an opportunity to respond to this request and who indicated that to allow such a prayer would not be justice noting that he has pursued the Claimant for two years for repayment of his money.

13. This marked close of the Respondent’s case and the court reserved the matter for judgment on 4th November 2026.

Analysis and Determination

14. I have considered the pleadings, the evidence of the parties and their respective witnesses. The issues falling for determination are whether the claim is res judicata and whether the Claimant has proved the claim.

15. On the question of res judicata, Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act sets out the essential elements of the doctrine, including that the former suit must have involved the same parties or persons claiming under them, litigating under the same title, and that the matter must have been heard and finally determined by a competent court. In the present case, the Claimant confirmed that he was not a party to the alleged former suit being Small Claims Commercial Suit No. E090 of 2026. In fact the Respondent filed documents demonstrating that the suit aforementioned was between Lucy Wambui (CW3) and himself. This alone defeats an essential ingredient of the doctrine. The objection on res judicata therefore fails.

16. On the merits, the Claimant's case is that the Respondent received Kshs. 49,800/= on the representation that he would procure a laptop and laptop charger to facilitate the Claimant's employment opportunity in Kitale. The Claimant's evidence was corroborated by CW2 and CW3, who explained their respective involvement in the introduction and transmission of the money.

17. More significantly, the Respondent admitted under cross-examination that he received the money. His explanation, however, was that the money constituted a debt and was not intended for the procurement of a laptop. I find that this explanation raises an affirmative factual defence which required particular pleading and proof. Under Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act, the burden of proving the existence of that alleged debt lay upon the Respondent, being the party asserting it. No sufficient evidence was tendered to establish its existence or basis.

18. Further, the alleged debt was neither properly pleaded as a counterclaim nor advanced as a set-off in accordance with Rules 9 and 13 of the Small Claims Court Rules. The Court cannot be invited to determine an unsubstantiated debt defence through evidence introduced at the hearing. The Respondent's admission of receipt, therefore, remains unrebutted by any satisfactory explanation capable of defeating the Claimant's claim.

19. I am consequently satisfied, on a balance of probabilities, that the Claimant has established entitlement to recovery of the amount proved to have been received by the Respondent. The Court is concerned not merely with the original purpose of the payment, but also with the Respondent's admitted receipt and failure to demonstrate any lawful basis for retaining the money.

20. On the Respondent's request to settle the decretal sum in four to five monthly instalments, Rule 27 of the Small Claims Court Rules empowers the Court to order payment by instalments upon an application and evidence demonstrating inability to satisfy the decree in a lump sum. In the absence of evidence of the Respondent's financial position, I find no sufficient basis for granting the request as presently made. The mere request for time to pay does not establish inability to pay.

21. On costs and interest, the Claimant is entitled to costs under Section 33 of the Small Claims Court Act and Rule 37 of the Small Claims Court Rules. I also find it just to award interest on the decretal sum at court rates from the date of filing suit until payment in full.

22. Accordingly, judgment is hereby entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows:

a) Kshs. 49,800/= being the principal sum claimed and proved.

b) Interest at court rates from the date of filing suit until payment in full.

c) Costs of the suit assessed at Kshs. 4,500/=

JUDGMENT DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MALABA SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS 4TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026.

In the Presence of

John Mburu the Claimant and

Joseph Shiranda the Respondent

Court Assistant: Paul Otieno

A.Z. OGANGE

R.M/ADJUDICATOR

04.11.2026

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder