Employment law

Kinuthia v Insta Pumps Engineering Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14714 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 541 of 2019
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application was partly allowed. The respondent’s directors, Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, were summoned for examination regarding the company’s assets and means of satisfying the decree and ordered to produce relevant company records. Automatic personal execution of the decree against them was declined. No order as to costs was made.

Supporting judgment passages

24. In the premise, I find merit in the application dated 9th September, 2025, and allow the same in the following terms:-

Paragraph 24 →

a) An order that summons do issue upon Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, being directors of the Respondent company, to attend Court on a date to be fixed by the Court for examination concerning the Respondent's assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree issued on 3rd October, 2024.

Passage 43 →

c) The prayer for automatic execution of the decree personally against the directors is declined at this point.

Passage 45 →
Issue 1Whether the Claimant has established a basis for summoning the Respondent’s directors for examination.

Held. Yes. The unsatisfied monetary decree and unsuccessful efforts to trace or attach the respondent’s assets established the requirements for examination. The two directors were summoned to be examined on the respondent’s assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree, and required to produce relevant company financial and other records.

Ratio. Under Order 22 Rule 35, a decree-holder may obtain oral examination of an officer of a corporate judgment debtor and production of relevant documents to discover the company’s assets, liabilities and means of satisfying a monetary decree. This is a discovery mechanism in aid of execution, not itself a basis for personal liability. An unsatisfied decree and unsuccessful execution efforts provide a legitimate basis for the examination.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

i. Whether the Claimant has established a basis for summoning the Respondent’s directors for examination.

Passage 23 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

16. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the requirements for an examination under Order 22 Rule 35 have been met, and the directors, Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, are hereby summoned to attend Court and be examined concerning the Respondent's assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree.

Paragraph 16 →

a) An order that summons do issue upon Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, being directors of the Respondent company, to attend Court on a date to be fixed by the Court for examination concerning the Respondent's assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree issued on 3rd October, 2024.

Passage 43 →

b) That the said directors shall produce for inspection the Respondent's books of account, cheque books, audited financial statements and such other relevant company records in the Respondent's possession or control that may assist in establishing its assets and means of satisfying the decree.

Passage 44 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

11. The application is anchored on Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, which provides that where a decree is for the payment of money, the decree-holder may apply for an order that the judgment debtor, an officer of a corporate judgment debtor, or another person be orally examined concerning debts owing to the judgment debtor and its property or other means of satisfying the decree. The Court also has power to order the attendance and examination of the relevant person and the production of books or documents.

Paragraph 11 →

12. The purpose of this provision is to assist a decree-holder to establish the assets, liabilities and financial means of a judgment debtor so that execution may be pursued effectively. It is, in effect, a discovery mechanism in aid of execution and does not, by itself, impose personal liability on the officers of a corporate judgment debtor.

Paragraph 12 →

14. In this case, the Claimant/Applicant has demonstrated that a decree remains unsatisfied and that attempts to execute it through attachment and sale have been unsuccessful. These circumstances provide a legitimate basis for seeking information concerning the Respondent's assets and financial means.

Paragraph 14 →
Issue 2Whether the decree should be executed personally against the directors of the Respondent.

Held. No, at this stage. The court declined the requested automatic personal execution against the directors. The directors had not yet been examined, and there was no evidence that they had fraudulently removed assets, misused the corporate structure, or otherwise acted in a manner justifying personal liability.

Ratio. A company is distinct from its directors and shareholders. Examination under Order 22 Rule 35 identifies the company’s assets and means of payment; it does not itself authorize personal liability. Directors’ failure to attend or produce documents cannot automatically make them liable for the corporate decree. Personal liability through lifting the corporate veil requires examination and evidence of circumstances such as bad faith, concealment or removal of assets, or misuse of the corporate structure.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

ii. Whether the decree should be executed personally against the directors of the Respondent.

Passage 24 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

23. The Court cannot therefore at this stage grant the second prayer in the manner it is sought herein.

Paragraph 23 →

c) The prayer for automatic execution of the decree personally against the directors is declined at this point.

Passage 45 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

18. The law recognizes a company as a legal person distinct from its directors and shareholders. In Victor Mabachi & another v Nurtun Bates Limited [2013] KECA 204 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed that a company has a separate legal identity from its shareholders, directors and agents, unless circumstances warrant lifting the corporate veil.

Paragraph 18 →

19. The examination procedure is in essence intended to identify the company's assets and means of satisfying the decree, and does not, by itself, authorize the Court to impose personal liability on directors.

Paragraph 19 →

20. It then follows that the mere failure by the directors to attend Court or produce the Respondent's documents cannot automatically render them personally liable for the decretal sum.

Paragraph 20 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the application dated 9th September, 2025, by the Claimant herein, brought pursuant to Sections 1A, 18 and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Section 20 of the Companies Act, 2015, Order 22 Rule 35, and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Claimant/Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the application, the grounds and the supporting affidavit, together with the Claimant’s submissions. The issues for determination are:-

Paragraph 8 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the requirements for an examination under Order 22 Rule 35 have been met, and the directors, Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, are hereby summoned to attend Court and be examined concerning the Respondent's assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree.

Paragraph 16 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the claimant had established grounds under Order 22 rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules to summon the respondent company’s directors for examination and production of records; and whether the decree could, upon default in complying with those orders,…

Material facts

The claimant stated that he obtained a monetary decree against Insta Pumps Engineering Limited on 3 October 2024 for Kshs 1,288,000, with costs assessed at Kshs 235,105. He said that execution through M/s Dollar Auctions had failed because the respondent’s…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. 541 OF 2019

SIMON GAKURU KINUTHIA….………................................CLAIMANT

VERSUS

INSTA PUMPS ENGINEERING LIMITED…………………….RESPONDENT

RULING.

1. This ruling relates to the application dated 9th September, 2025, by the Claimant herein, brought pursuant to Sections 1A, 18 and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Section 20 of the Companies Act, 2015, Order 22 Rule 35, and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Claimant/Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -

i. THAT the Directors of the Respondent Company, namely PURITY WANJIRU GICHERE and PAUL KIGETHO GOCHO, be summoned to attend court on a date to be appointed by the Court and:

a) Be directed to produce for inspection of the court all books of accounts, cheque books, audited accounts and all other relevant documents pertaining to the respondent

b) Be examined under oath as to the respondent's/judgment debtor's assets or other means of satisfying the decree issued against the respondent on 31st October 2024.

ii. In default of complying with the orders of the court issued in terms of prayer (1) above the court do direct that the decree issued in favour of the claimant dated 31st October 2024 be executed personally against the directors of the respondent/Judgment debtor.

iii. The court do grant any further orders that it may deem just and fit.

iv. THAT the costs of this application be borne by the respondent.

2. The application is supported by the grounds on the face of the motion and the affidavit of Simon Gakuri Kinuthis, the Applicant/Claimant herein, sworn on 9th September, 2025.

3. The Claimant/Applicant states that he obtained a decree against the Respondent on 3rd October, 2024 for Kshs. 1,288,000/=, together with costs assessed at Kshs. 235,105/=.

4. He states further that he subsequently commenced execution proceedings and instructed M/s Dollar Auctions to execute warrants of attachment and sale, but the execution efforts have been unsuccessful, as the Respondent has no known assets or identifiable physical address. He avers that, despite extensive investigations, he has been unable to trace the Respondent’s assets to satisfy the decree.

5. The Claimant contends that granting the orders sought is fair, just, and necessary to enable him to enjoy the fruits of his valid judgment.

6. The Respondent did not oppose the application despite proof of service.

7. The Court directed the parties to file submissions on the motion. The Claimant/Applicant filed his submissions dated 8th June, 2026. The Respondent did not file its submissions despite being allowed 7 more days to do so.

Analysis and Determination

8. I have considered the application, the grounds and the supporting affidavit, together with the Claimant’s submissions. The issues for determination are:-

i. Whether the Claimant has established a basis for summoning the Respondent’s directors for examination.

ii. Whether the decree should be executed personally against the directors of the Respondent.

Whether the directors should be summoned for examination.

9. It is evident from the record that the Claimant/Applicant obtained a monetary decree against the Respondent dated 3rd October, 2024 for Kshs.1,288,000/=, together with costs assessed at Kshs. 235,105/=.

10. The Claimant avers that attempts to execute the decree through M/s Dollar Auctions have been unsuccessful for the reason that the Respondent’s assets and physical address have not been traced.

11. The application is anchored on Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, which provides that where a decree is for the payment of money, the decree-holder may apply for an order that the judgment debtor, an officer of a corporate judgment debtor, or another person be orally examined concerning debts owing to the judgment debtor and its property or other means of satisfying the decree. The Court also has power to order the attendance and examination of the relevant person and the production of books or documents.

12. The purpose of this provision is to assist a decree-holder to establish the assets, liabilities and financial means of a judgment debtor so that execution may be pursued effectively. It is, in effect, a discovery mechanism in aid of execution and does not, by itself, impose personal liability on the officers of a corporate judgment debtor.

13. In Laborex Kenya Limited v Kileleshwa Pharmaceuticals Limited [2024] KEHC 12934 (KLR), the High Court held that an application for examination of a judgment-debtor company's directors under Order 22 Rule 35 should happen first, and it is upon examination that the court may, if the circumstances warrant, lift the veil of incorporation and hold the directors of the company personally liable to satisfy the amount decreed to be paid.

14. In this case, the Claimant/Applicant has demonstrated that a decree remains unsatisfied and that attempts to execute it through attachment and sale have been unsuccessful. These circumstances provide a legitimate basis for seeking information concerning the Respondent's assets and financial means.

15. It is also not lost on this Court that the Respondent, despite service, did not oppose the application or place before the Court any material to controvert the Claimant's averments.

16. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the requirements for an examination under Order 22 Rule 35 have been met, and the directors, Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, are hereby summoned to attend Court and be examined concerning the Respondent's assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree.

Whether the decree should be executed personally against the directors

17. The second prayer that the Applicant seeks is an order that, in default of compliance with the examination orders, the decree against the Respondent be executed personally against its directors.

18. The law recognizes a company as a legal person distinct from its directors and shareholders. In Victor Mabachi & another v Nurtun Bates Limited [2013] KECA 204 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed that a company has a separate legal identity from its shareholders, directors and agents, unless circumstances warrant lifting the corporate veil.

19. The examination procedure is in essence intended to identify the company's assets and means of satisfying the decree, and does not, by itself, authorize the Court to impose personal liability on directors.

20. It then follows that the mere failure by the directors to attend Court or produce the Respondent's documents cannot automatically render them personally liable for the decretal sum.

21. In Samuel Ojwang Juma v Saphire Collections Limited [2021] KEELRC 1729 (KLR), the Court distinguished the initial examination of directors from the subsequent determination of whether the corporate veil should be lifted. Although the Court ultimately lifted the veil on the evidence before it, that decision followed examination of the directors and consideration of circumstances indicating bad faith and the concealment or removal of company assets.

22. The Claimant herein has no doubt established unsuccessful execution efforts and an inability to trace the Respondent's assets. However, the Court has not examined the directors, and no evidence has been presented establishing that they fraudulently removed assets, misused the corporate structure, or otherwise engaged in conduct sufficient to justify personal liability.

23. The Court cannot therefore at this stage grant the second prayer in the manner it is sought herein.

24. In the premise, I find merit in the application dated 9th September, 2025, and allow the same in the following terms:-

a) An order that summons do issue upon Purity Wanjiru Gichere and Paul Kigetho Gocho, being directors of the Respondent company, to attend Court on a date to be fixed by the Court for examination concerning the Respondent's assets, debts, liabilities and other means of satisfying the decree issued on 3rd October, 2024.

b) That the said directors shall produce for inspection the Respondent's books of account, cheque books, audited financial statements and such other relevant company records in the Respondent's possession or control that may assist in establishing its assets and means of satisfying the decree.

c) The prayer for automatic execution of the decree personally against the directors is declined at this point.

d) I make no orders on costs since the Respondent did not participate in the motion.

25. Orders accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Kabue present for the Claimant/Applicant

Mr. Mukonyi present for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder