Background
Vide a statement of claim dated 9th September 2026 and filed in court on 10th September 2026 the Claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs. 245,000/= together with costs of the Claim.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Vide a statement of claim dated 9th September 2026 and filed in court on 10th September 2026 the Claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs. 245,000/= together with costs of the Claim.
Paragraph 1 →The central issue for determination is whether the Respondent received Kshs. 400,000/= from the Claimant for a specific purpose, whether that purpose was fulfilled, and whether the Respondent is liable to refund the outstanding balance.
Paragraph 8 →In the circumstances, I find that the Claimant has proved his claim on a balance of probabilities and is entitled to recovery of the outstanding amount. The appropriate remedy is restitution of the money received, less the amount already refunded.
Paragraph 21 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MALABA
SCCCOMM NO. E103 OF 2026
GILBERT MOPHART ODILI….………...……….................................CLAIMANT
-VERSUS-
MIRIAM NANGEKHE WANYONYI…….……….…….……………….RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. Vide a statement of claim dated 9th September 2026 and filed in court on 10th September 2026 the Claimant prays for judgment in the sum of Kshs. 245,000/= together with costs of the Claim.
2. The circumstances leading to the filing of this claim are that the Claimant and the Respondent agreed on a transactional sum of Kshs. 500,000/= of which the Claimant sent to the Respondent a sum of Kshs. 400,000/= which was supposed to be used for employment of the Claimant’s daughter. That a claim was previously filed before the Small Claims Court at Malaba vide SCCOMM E082/2026 wherein the Respondent admitted the Claim and refunded a total of Kshs. 155,000/= leaving a balance of Kshs. 245,000/= which is the subject of the claim. That the matter was subsequently withdrawn for want of time before hearing and determination on the merits.
3. The suit is opposed vide a Statement of Response dated 29th September 2026 denying liability and contends that Kshs. 400,000/= received from the Claimant was intended for onward transmissions to one Moses Khisa, who had allegedly undertaken to assist the Claimant’s daughter, Abigail Mamai secure employment in the Kenya Police Service during the November 2025 recruitment. She avers that the Claimant had agreed to pay Kshs. 500,000/= but initially provided Kshs. 400,000/=, with the balance payable upon successful recruitment.
4. The Respondent stated that on 18th November 2025, the Claimant transferred Kshs. 400,000/= to her M-pesa Account, which she subsequently transferred to her husband, Ibrahim Riwa, for onward transmission to Moses. She further alleges that Moses requested an additional Kshs. 70,000/= which was paid in cash in the presence of the parties. She maintains that the transaction was undertaken in good faith and she acted merely as an intermediary.
5. The Respondent further avers that she subsequently refunded Kshs. 10,000/= and Kshs. 75,000/= to the Claimant, leaving a balance of Kshs. 245,000, which she contends is recoverable from Moses Khisa and Benedict Wekesa. She therefore urges the court to dismiss the Claim with costs.
6. This matter came up for hearing on 28th October 2026 when the Claimant testified on his own behalf and closed his case. The Respondent on the other hand testified on her own behalf and called her husband Ibrahim Riwa as her witness. Parties reiterated the contents of their pleadings.
7. At the close of the respective cases of the parties, they were granted leave to file their submissions and the matter was reserved for judgment on 9th November 2026.
8. The central issue for determination is whether the Respondent received Kshs. 400,000/= from the Claimant for a specific purpose, whether that purpose was fulfilled, and whether the Respondent is liable to refund the outstanding balance.
9. The Claimant testified that he paid the Respondent Kshs. 400,000/= following an arrangement in which she undertook to facilitate employment for his daughter. Although the Claimant initially referred to employment generally, he subsequently explained that the arrangement involved linking his daughter to an agent and facilitating her travel abroad. He maintained, however, that the Respondent was the person to whom he entrusted the money. The Respondent does not dispute receiving the Kshs. 400,000/=. Indeed, her defence is that the money was intended to facilitate the recruitment of the Claimant's daughter into the National Police Service through third parties, namely Moses Khisa and Benedict Odero.
10. I have considered the rival accounts. The Respondent's explanation that she merely acted as a conduit through which the money was transmitted to third parties does not extinguish her obligation to account to the Claimant. The Claimant did not transact with Moses or Benedict; he entrusted the money to the Respondent. The Respondent voluntarily assumed the responsibility of receiving the money and facilitating the agreed purpose. Her subsequent dealings with third parties were matters between her and those persons and cannot be used to shift the consequences of the transaction to the Claimant.
11. The Respondent's account is further weakened by the absence of independent evidence demonstrating the alleged employment arrangement. There was no correspondence, text message, recruitment communication, official recruitment documentation or other satisfactory evidence showing the nature of the arrangement, the alleged involvement of the named third parties, or the terms upon which the money was to be disbursed. Although RW2 attempted to corroborate the Respondent's account, his testimony does not establish that the Claimant agreed to pay money to procure employment through unlawful influence. The Court cannot simply presume the existence and terms of an arrangement merely because the Respondent asserts that it existed. Equally, the Court cannot infer that the Claimant knowingly participated in a corrupt arrangement without sufficient evidence.
12. Under Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, the burden of proving a fact rests upon the party asserting it. The Respondent was therefore expected to substantiate her explanation concerning the alleged employment arrangement and the subsequent disbursement of the money. Her assertion, without satisfactory supporting evidence, cannot automatically absolve her of accountability.
13. I have also considered the evidence of the repayments. The Respondent and RW2 acknowledge that money was returned to the Claimant. The Claimant puts the total repayment at Kshs. 155,350/=. The Respondent's evidence and that of her husband substantially corroborate the fact of repayment. The fact that the Respondent made repayments is also significant because it demonstrates that the money was not treated as an unconditional payment that she was entitled to retain irrespective of the outcome of the arrangement.
14. The Court must nevertheless address the legal character of the transaction. Section 32 of the Small Claims Court Act, 2016, relaxes the strict rules of evidence but does not dispense with the obligation to prove a claim. Further, Section 12(1)(b) of the Act expressly gives this Court jurisdiction over contracts relating to money held or received.
15. I am alive to the principle in Kenya Airways Limited v Satwant Singh Flora [2013] eKLR and Mureithi v Mwangangi [2024] KEHC 7814 (KLR), that courts will not enforce an agreement founded upon illegality. In Mureithi, the High Court declined to assist a claimant who had knowingly participated in an arrangement to bribe shipping officials. The principle is founded on the maxim ex turpi causa non oritur actio.
16. This court therefore distinguishes an agreement knowingly entered into to procure employment through unlawful influence from a situation in which a claimant may have been induced to part with money through misrepresentation without knowledge of the illegality. The nature of the transaction, the parties' knowledge and their respective intentions must be established from the evidence.
17. In the present matter, the Respondent's allegations of corruption cannot be converted into a finding that the Claimant knowingly participated in bribery. The Respondent was not an authorised recruitment officer, and the alleged involvement of third parties was not satisfactorily established. Equally, the fact that the Claimant was seeking employment for his daughter does not, by itself, prove that he intended to procure employment through bribery. I therefore distinguish this case from Mureithi v Mwangangi, where the claimant's own evidence demonstrated participation in the corrupt arrangement.
18. The more fundamental question is whether the Claimant or his daughter received anything in return for the money paid. The evidence is clear that the daughter was not employed. No appointment letter, recruitment confirmation, communication from an employer or other evidence of successful recruitment was produced. Neither was there evidence that the Respondent rendered any identifiable service to the Claimant or his daughter for which she would be entitled to retain the money.
19. The Court is therefore satisfied that the purpose for which the money was entrusted to the Respondent was not achieved. The Claimant parted with Kshs. 400,000/= but received no corresponding benefit. The Respondent cannot justify retaining the money merely because she alleges that she subsequently transmitted it to other persons. There is no satisfactory evidence that the Claimant authorized her to assume the risk of losing his money through dealings with unidentified or unverified third parties.
20. I am consequently persuaded that there was a total failure of the agreed consideration. The Respondent's liability to account for money received cannot be defeated by her unilateral decision on how to deal with it. What she subsequently did with the money was a matter between her and the persons to whom she allegedly remitted it. The Claimant was not privy to those arrangements and ought not to bear their consequences.
21. In the circumstances, I find that the Claimant has proved his claim on a balance of probabilities and is entitled to recovery of the outstanding amount. The appropriate remedy is restitution of the money received, less the amount already refunded.
22. Accordingly, I find for the Claimant and enter judgment in his favor for the sum of Kshs. 245,000/= together with costs of the suit which I assess at Kshs. 15,000/=.
JUDGMENT DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MALABA SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS 9TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026.
In the Presence of
J.P Makokha Counsel for the Claimant and
Mr. Wamalwa for the Respondent
Court Assistant: Paul Otieno
A.Z. OGANGE
R.M/ADJUDICATOR
09.11.2026