Employment law

Kenya Hotels and Allied Workers Union v Nanchang Investment Company Limited t/a Nanchang Hotel [2026] KEELRC 14728 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 1533 of 2018
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment for the claimant concerning Fridah Mmbone. The court declared her dismissal unfair and awarded Kshs.75,166.60: Kshs.20,000 notice pay, Kshs.40,000 compensation, and Kshs.15,166.66 accrued leave. The award is subject to statutory deductions; claimant receives costs and interest at court rate from judgment.

Supporting judgment passages

35. I have found that the termination of the grievant’s employment was unfair and the claimant is entitled to some of the reliefs sought. Consequently, I enter judgment for the claimant as follows:

Paragraph 35 →

Total - Kshs.75,166.60

Passage 81 →

(d) The Claimant is awarded costs plus interest at court rate

Passage 83 →
Issue 1Whether the respondent unfairly/unlawfully dismissed the grievant.

Held. Yes. The dismissal was unfair and unlawful. The respondent did not prove the alleged theft or a basis to suspect it, and did not establish compliance with the mandatory disciplinary procedure. Although paragraph 30 contains an apparent inconsistent reference to a valid reason, the court's express factual finding was that theft was not proved and its final declaration was that dismissal was unfair.

Ratio. Under sections 45 and 41 of the Employment Act, the employer bears the burden of proving a valid reason and a fair procedure. Here, there was no eyewitness, CCTV, accounts, or other evidence supporting theft. The alleged service of disciplinary documents was supported only by hearsay; the documents lacked acknowledgement space, hearing venue and time, and notice of the right to representation.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(a) Whether the respondent unfairly/unlawfully dismissed the grievant.

Passage 45 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

25. In my assessment, the respondent did not prove the alleged theft or any basis to suspect that the claimant committed the offence of theft. No eye witness testified and no other form of evidence including CCTV footages or books of accounts were produced to prove the alleged misconduct. Consequently, I find that the respondent did not prove on a balance of probability that the reason cited for the dismissal of the grievant, was valid.

Paragraph 25 →

30. Having found that the summary dismissal of the grievant was grounded on a valid reason and that fair procedure was not followed, I must hold that the dismissal was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of Section 45 of the Employment Act.

Paragraph 30 →

(a) Declaration that the grievant was unfairly dismissed from employment.

Passage 76 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

22. The above provisions places a heavy burden on the employer to prove that the termination of his employee’s employment was justified by a valid reason and further that a fair procedure was followed. The said legal principles emanate from ILO Convention 158 of 1982 on termination of employment which provides as follows:

Paragraph 22 →

25. In my assessment, the respondent did not prove the alleged theft or any basis to suspect that the claimant committed the offence of theft. No eye witness testified and no other form of evidence including CCTV footages or books of accounts were produced to prove the alleged misconduct. Consequently, I find that the respondent did not prove on a balance of probability that the reason cited for the dismissal of the grievant, was valid.

Paragraph 25 →

29. Secondly, the said letters never provided any space for the grievant to acknowledge receipt by signing and the invitation letters never gave any particulars of the venue and the time for the hearing. It also never gave the grievant the right of being accompanied by a fellow employee or union official to the hearing. Whichever way one looks at the facts of the case, the inevitable inference that naturally flows out is that the dismissal of the claimant for gross misconduct under Section 44(4)(g) of the Employment Act was not in accordance with the mandatory procedure prescribed by Section 41 of the Act.

Paragraph 29 →
Issue 2Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Held. Partly. The claimant was entitled to a declaration, one month's notice pay of Kshs.20,000, two months' compensation of Kshs.40,000, and accrued leave of Kshs.15,166.66. The maximum compensation claim was declined; compensation was limited due to the grievant's short service and warning letter. The underpayment claim failed for want of evidentiary basis. Costs and interest at court rate from judgment were awarded.

Ratio. Following an unfair termination, section 49 relief includes notice pay and compensation. Compensation was assessed at two months rather than the maximum because service lasted one year and one month and the grievant had acknowledged a warning letter. Awards were calculated on the Kshs.20,000 appointment-letter salary because the higher alleged salary was unproved. Leave was allowed because the respondent offered no evidence disputing it; underpayment lacked a shown basis.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(b) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Passage 46 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

31. In view of the foregoing conclusion, the claimant is entitled to the prayer for declaration that the termination of the grievant’s employment was unfair. Accordingly, the Claimant is further entitled to reliefs under Section 49 of the Employment Act being salary in lieu of notice and compensation for unfair termination.

Paragraph 31 →

34. As regards the claim for salary underpayment for 14 months, I have to reiterate that no basis has been shown to support that claim. However, the claim for leave, is granted since RW1 did not adduce evidence to dispute the same. The letter of appointment provided for 21 days each completed years of service. The grievant served for one year one month equaling to 1.75 days per month x 13 months totaling to 22.75 leave days. Hence, 22.75 x 1/30 x Kshs.20,000 = Kshs.15,166.66 for the accrued leave.

Paragraph 34 →

i. Notice - Kshs.20,000.00

Passage 78 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

32. He prayed for one month salary in lieu of notice which I grant. As regards compensation, the awarded of maximum compensation of 12 months’ gross salary is not justified. She only served for one year and one month. She was served with a warning letter dated 26th January 2017 which she acknowledged by signing. Although she disputed the signature and alleged that it was forged, she nevertheless admitted that it resembled her signature in her witness statement filed herein. Considering the short period of service and the said warning letter, I award her 2 months’ gross salary as compensation for the unfair termination.

Paragraph 32 →

33. The Claimant computed the grievant’s claims based on a gross monthly salary of Kshs.33,544 but no evidence was given to support the same. Consequently, I compute the awards above based on the salary in the Appointment letter dated 26th June 2016 being Kshs.20,000.

Paragraph 33 →

34. As regards the claim for salary underpayment for 14 months, I have to reiterate that no basis has been shown to support that claim. However, the claim for leave, is granted since RW1 did not adduce evidence to dispute the same. The letter of appointment provided for 21 days each completed years of service. The grievant served for one year one month equaling to 1.75 days per month x 13 months totaling to 22.75 leave days. Hence, 22.75 x 1/30 x Kshs.20,000 = Kshs.15,166.66 for the accrued leave.

Paragraph 34 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant is a trade union registered to represent unionisable employees in the hospitality industry. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 15th November 2018, the Claimant sued the respondent on behalf of its three members Agnes Ngele Mzae, Millicent Nyanchama and Fridah Mmbone (hereinafter called the grievants). The Claimant accused the respondent of unfair dismissal of the grievants and prayed for the following reliefs:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

After the hearing, both sides filed written submissions. Having considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions, the issues for determination are:

Paragraph 20 →

Decision / orders

He prayed for one month salary in lieu of notice which I grant. As regards compensation, the awarded of maximum compensation of 12 months’ gross salary is not justified. She only served for one year and one month. She was served with a warning letter dated 26th January 2017 which she acknowledged by signing. Although she disputed the signature and alleged that it was forged, she nevertheless admitted that it resembled her signature in…

Paragraph 32 →

Reasoning passage

In my assessment, the respondent did not prove the alleged theft or any basis to suspect that the claimant committed the offence of theft. No eye witness testified and no other form of evidence including CCTV footages or books of accounts were produced to prove the alleged misconduct. Consequently, I find that the respondent did not prove on a balance of probability that the reason cited for the dismissal of the grievant, was valid.

Paragraph 25 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether Fridah Mmbone’s summary dismissal was unfair or unlawful, and whether the claimant union was entitled to the requested remedies on her behalf. Although the original claim concerned three grievants, the claims for Agnes Ngele Mzae and Millicent…

Material facts

Mmbone was employed from 26 June 2016 as a Massage Therapist/Cashier, with an appointment-letter salary of Kshs.20,000 per month. She joined the union on 25 April 2017. The claimant alleged that the respondent intimidated employees to leave the union and…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 22nd October 2026)

CAUSE NO. 1533 OF 2018

KENYA HOTELS AND ALLIED WORKERS UNION .………..…….. CLAIMANT

VERSUS

NANCHANG INVESTMENT COMPANY LIMITED T/A

NANCHANG HOTEL……………………………………………...…..RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. The Claimant is a trade union registered to represent unionisable employees in the hospitality industry. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 15th November 2018, the Claimant sued the respondent on behalf of its three members Agnes Ngele Mzae, Millicent Nyanchama and Fridah Mmbone (hereinafter called the grievants). The Claimant accused the respondent of unfair dismissal of the grievants and prayed for the following reliefs:

(a) That the honourable court be pleased to declare the termination of all the three grievant unfair.

(b) That the honourable court be pleased to order the respondent to pay the grievant all terminal dues and accrued rights as tabulated in the witness statement.

(c) That the honourable court be pleased to award maximum compensation for unfair termination.

(d) That in the alternative, the honourable be pleased to adapt the conciliators’ report as award of the court.

(e) That the cost of this suit be provided for by the respondent.

2. The respondent denied liability through a Memorandum of Response dated 11th December 2018 and later amended it on 6th March 2026. The respondent averred that the grievants were lawfully dismissed for misconduct and poor performance, and prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.

Facts of the Case

3. The grievants were all employed by the respondent on diverse dates in 2016 and in different roles in its hotel. Their problem with the respondent started on 25th April 2017 when the Claimant recruited them into union membership as the respondent declined to deduct union membership subscription for the recruited members.

4. When the respondent learnt that the grievants’ other employees were paying the subscription directly to the union, it started intimidating them and coercing them to withdraw their membership from the union. In the end, eleven (11) employees including the grievants were dismissed from service between 26th July and 28th August 2017.

5. Efforts to resolve the matter amicably failed and the Claimant referred the dispute for conciliation at the Labour Office. After hearing the submissions by the union and the respondent, the conciliator prepared a report in which he found that the respondent had unfairly terminated the grievants and recommended that each grievant be paid salary in lieu of notice, compensation of 6 months for unfair termination plus other accrued benefits. The respondent declined recommendation and the claimant brought this suit.

Evidence

6. During the hearing, the claimant withdrew the claim by Agnes Ngele and Millicent Nyanchama and proceeded with the claim by Fridah Mmbone who testified as CW1.

7. Ms. Mmbone adopted her statement dated 15th November 2018 as her evidence in chief and further produced a bundle of 11 documents in the list dated 15th November 2018 which included documents for the two other grievants. Therefore, it was clarified that only those documents which apply to her case will be considered as her exhibits.

8. Her evidence in brief was that she was employed by the respondent on 26th June 2016 as a Massage Therapist/Cashier. Her basic monthly salary was Kshs.20,000 as at the time of exit.

9. On 25th April 2017, she joined the claimant union membership and the respondent embarked on coercing and intimidating her and other employees to withdraw from the union membership. As a result, she was dismissed from employment together with other ten employees. The matter went for conciliation at the Labour office and the conciliator recommended that the employer pays her compensation plus accrued benefits but the employer declined.

10. She prayed for:

(a) 2 days worked in August 2017 being Kshs.2,602.77.

(b) One month pay in lieu of notice being………………Kshs.33,836.

(c) Accrued leave balance for 32 days………………………Kshs.41,644.31

(d) Under payment for 14 months at Kshs.13,836…….Kshs.193,704

(e) Maximum compensation at Kshs.33,836…..………....Kshs.406,032

Total………………………………………………………………......Kshs.677,819

11. On cross examination, she contended that she holds a certificate in Massage Therapy. She reiterated that her monthly gross salary was Kshs.20,000 but her trade union had documentary evidence that her salary was higher than Kshs.20,000.

12. She admitted that there was no recognition agreement between the respondent and the claimant. She contended that she worked for one year and one month and she never received any warning letter or show cause letter or letter inviting her for disciplinary hearing from the respondent. She disowned the signature acknowledging receipt of the warning letter addressed to her but she admitted that the signature resembled the one in her written statement aforesaid. She maintained that the signature was forged. She contended that she was seeing the said letter for the first time.

13. She reiterated that she was not accorded any disciplinary hearing. She contended that 38 employees joined the union and many resigned from the union for fear of victimization. She contended that the respondent’s hotel was closed for renovation but she was not aware whether it was re-opened.

14. The respondent sent its legal officer Mr. Ephrahim Ndegwa who testified as RW1. He adopted his witness statement dated 6th March 2026 as evidence in chief and produced 9 documents as exhibits.

15. In brief, RW1 stated that the claimant approached the respondent with intent represent its employees and requested further documentation and a follow-up meeting for signing a recognition agreement but the claimant declined the request. He contended that there is no recognition agreement.

16. He stated that CW1 was involved in theft and misconduct leading to issuance of warning letters and subsequently a show cause letter then dismissal. He denied the alleged forgery of the grievant’s signature. He averred that the dismissal of the grievant was procedural, justified and fair and therefore, the suit should be dismissed with costs.

17. On cross examination, RW1 confirmed that he joined the respondent in 2021. He further confirmed that he is a partner in the Law Firm on record for the respondent. He contended that the grievant was served with letters but signed some and declined to sign others. He admitted that the warning letter and invitation to hearing had no place for her to sign. He stated that the warning letter was issued by Li Ruifang but it was not responded to.

18. He admitted that the company policies referred to in paragraph 20(a) of the Amended Response had not been produced as exhibits but clarified that there is no specific number of warning letters that must be issued before termination.

19. He confirmed that the Hotel had CCTV in some places. He further admitted that no criminal records for the grievant were produced. Finally, he confirmed that he had no evidence to prove that the grievant was paid her terminal dues.

20. After the hearing, both sides filed written submissions. Having considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions, the issues for determination are:

(a) Whether the respondent unfairly/unlawfully dismissed the grievant.

(b) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Unfair/Unlarful dismissal

21. Section 45(2) of Employment provide that:

“(1) No employer shall terminate the employment of an employee unfairly.

(2) A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove:

(a) that the reason for the termination is valid;

(b) that the reason for the termination is a fair reason—

(i) related to the employee’s conduct, capacity or compatibility; or

(ii) based on the operational requirements of the employer; and

(c) that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure.”

22. The above provisions places a heavy burden on the employer to prove that the termination of his employee’s employment was justified by a valid reason and further that a fair procedure was followed. The said legal principles emanate from ILO Convention 158 of 1982 on termination of employment which provides as follows:

“Article 4 – the employment of a worker shall not be terminated unless there is a valid reason for such termination connected with the capacity or conduct or the operational requirement requirements of the undertaking, establishment or service.

Article 7 – The employment of a worker shall not be terminated for reason related to the worker’s conduct or performance before he is provided an opportunity to defend himself against the allegations made, unless the employer cannot be expected to provide this opportunity.”

23. In this case, the reason cited by the respondent was theft by the claimant. The claimant on the other hand stated that the reason for termination was membership to the claimant trade union.

24. Section 44(4)(g) of the Employment Act entitles an employer to summarily dismiss his employee for gross misconduct including committing a criminal offence against the employer or employer’s property. The question that begs for answer is whether the respondent has tendered any evidence to prove that the claimant committed or was suspected to have committed the offence of theft.

25. In my assessment, the respondent did not prove the alleged theft or any basis to suspect that the claimant committed the offence of theft. No eye witness testified and no other form of evidence including CCTV footages or books of accounts were produced to prove the alleged misconduct. Consequently, I find that the respondent did not prove on a balance of probability that the reason cited for the dismissal of the grievant, was valid.

26. As regards procedural fairness, Section 41 of the Employment Act provides that:

“(1) Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.

(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) or (4) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1), make.”

27. In this case, the grievant maintained that she was never given any opportunity to defend herself before the dismissal for the alleged theft. RW1 alleged that the claimant was served with a show cause letter and an invitation to attend disciplinary hearing but she declined to acknowledge the same and failed to attend the hearing.

28. Having considered the evidence on record, I find that the evidence by RW1 insufficient to support the alleged fair procedure. To begin with, RW1 admitted that he was not the one who served the grievant with the show cause letter and the invitation to the hearing. It follows that his testimony that the grievant declined service of the said documents amount to hearsay evidence.

29. Secondly, the said letters never provided any space for the grievant to acknowledge receipt by signing and the invitation letters never gave any particulars of the venue and the time for the hearing. It also never gave the grievant the right of being accompanied by a fellow employee or union official to the hearing. Whichever way one looks at the facts of the case, the inevitable inference that naturally flows out is that the dismissal of the claimant for gross misconduct under Section 44(4)(g) of the Employment Act was not in accordance with the mandatory procedure prescribed by Section 41 of the Act.

30. Having found that the summary dismissal of the grievant was grounded on a valid reason and that fair procedure was not followed, I must hold that the dismissal was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of Section 45 of the Employment Act.

Reliefs sought

31. In view of the foregoing conclusion, the claimant is entitled to the prayer for declaration that the termination of the grievant’s employment was unfair. Accordingly, the Claimant is further entitled to reliefs under Section 49 of the Employment Act being salary in lieu of notice and compensation for unfair termination.

32. He prayed for one month salary in lieu of notice which I grant. As regards compensation, the awarded of maximum compensation of 12 months’ gross salary is not justified. She only served for one year and one month. She was served with a warning letter dated 26th January 2017 which she acknowledged by signing. Although she disputed the signature and alleged that it was forged, she nevertheless admitted that it resembled her signature in her witness statement filed herein. Considering the short period of service and the said warning letter, I award her 2 months’ gross salary as compensation for the unfair termination.

33. The Claimant computed the grievant’s claims based on a gross monthly salary of Kshs.33,544 but no evidence was given to support the same. Consequently, I compute the awards above based on the salary in the Appointment letter dated 26th June 2016 being Kshs.20,000.

34. As regards the claim for salary underpayment for 14 months, I have to reiterate that no basis has been shown to support that claim. However, the claim for leave, is granted since RW1 did not adduce evidence to dispute the same. The letter of appointment provided for 21 days each completed years of service. The grievant served for one year one month equaling to 1.75 days per month x 13 months totaling to 22.75 leave days. Hence, 22.75 x 1/30 x Kshs.20,000 = Kshs.15,166.66 for the accrued leave.

Conclusion

35. I have found that the termination of the grievant’s employment was unfair and the claimant is entitled to some of the reliefs sought. Consequently, I enter judgment for the claimant as follows:

(a) Declaration that the grievant was unfairly dismissed from employment.

(b) The Claimant is awarded:

i. Notice - Kshs.20,000.00

ii. Compensation - Kshs.40,000.00

iii. Leave - Kshs.15,166.66

Total - Kshs.75,166.60

(c) The award is subject to statutory deductions.

(d) The Claimant is awarded costs plus interest at court rate

from the date of the judgment.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Ombati for Claimant

Katasi for Ndegwa for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder