Background
This Judgment relates to a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th January 2023, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This Judgment relates to a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th January 2023, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →In the upshot, I find and hold that the Respondent did not comply with the mandatory tenets of procedural fairness enshrined in Section 40 of the Act, as it failed to issue the requisite notices within the timeline provided by law.
Paragraph 45 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI CAUSE NO. E035 OF 2023.
KENYA ENGINEERING WORKERS UNION............................CLAIMANT
VERSUS
M/S GARAGE AND INDUSTRY LIMITED............................RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. This Judgment relates to a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th January 2023, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
a) THAT the Honourable Court deem fit and find the action of the Respondent on redundancy of Mr. Simon Mbogo and Daniel Waweru to be unfair, unlawful and unprocedural and declare the same to be null and void hence reinstating them without loss of any benefit.
b) THAT in the alternative the two grievants be paid their redundancy dues as hereunder: -
Simon Mbogo
i. One month salary pay in lieu of Notice
(9/100 x 39,932) + 39,932 + 5,508 = Kshs. 49,034/=
ii. Salary arrears (10 months)
a. (9/100 x 39,932 x 10) = Kshs. 39,939/=
iii. Severance pay (15 years)
a. 28/30 x 15 x 43,526 = Kshs. 652,890/=
iv. Service gratuity (15 years)
a. 15/30 x 15 x 43,526 = Kshs. 326,445/=
v. 12 months salary as compensation
a. 12 (43,526 + 5,508) = Kshs. 588,408/=
Total Amount = Kshs. 1,656,770/=
Daniel Waweru
i. One month salary pay in lieu of Notice
(9/100 x 26,769) + (26,769 + 3,692) = Kshs. 32,862/=
ii. Salary arrears (10 months)
(9/100 x 26,769 x 10) = Kshs. 24,092/=
iii. Severance pay (15 years)
28/30 x 15 x 29,178 = Kshs. 408,492/=
iv. Service gratuity (15 years)
15/30 x 15 x 29,178 = Kshs. 218,835/=
v. 12 months salary as compensation
12 x (29,178 + 3,692) = Kshs. 394,440/=
Total Amount = Kshs. 1,078,721/=
c) THAT the grievants be issued with certificates of service.
d) THAT the Respondent to pay the Claimant the cost of this suit.
2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 14th September, 2023 and subsequently filed a Memorandum of Response dated 14th November, 2023, together with their supporting documents.
3. The Claimant's case was heard on 11th November, 2025, when CW1, Simon Mbogo Macharia, with the written authority of his co-grievant, testified in support of the Claimant’s Claim. He adopted his witness statement dated 18th January, 2023 as his evidence in chief and produced his list and bundle of documents dated 16th January, 2023 as Exhibits 1-9.
4. The Respondent's case was subsequently heard on 21st April, 2026, when RW1, Patrick Mwamba, the Respondent's director, testified in support of the Respondent’s defense. He adopted his witness statement dated 14th November, 2023 and produced the Respondent’s list and bundle of documents as Exhibits 1-3.
5. Both parties filed their respective submissions.
The Claimant's case.
6. The Claimant states that the parties herein have a Recognition Agreement and had negotiated a CBA governing the terms and conditions of service of the Respondent's unionizable employees.
7. It contends that the Respondent failed to implement the agreed salary increments and instead, sought to reduce employees' salaries. It further states that the Respondent declared the grievants redundant when they declined to accept the proposed salary reductions.
8. The Claimant maintains that the termination was connected to the grievants' union affiliation and activities, particularly because Simon Mbogo Macharia served as the Chief Shop Steward. It is its case that the Respondent failed to comply with the applicable redundancy procedures under Section 40 of the Employment Act, 2007, and acted contrary to the CBA and the Tripartite Agreement.
9. The Claimant further states that Simon Mbogo (CW1) worked as a Supervisor/Sheet Metal fitter, while Daniel Waweru was a welder. It avers further that in the month of April 2019, the grievants and other colleagues voluntarily joined the Claimant's union by signing check-off forms (Form “S”).
10. The Claimant states that both grievants were employed on 3rd November, 2005, and were terminated on 28th May, 2020, for joining the Claimant's union and for the reason that there was insufficient work.
11. It is the Claimant’s case that the parties herein had negotiated CBA No. 5 of 2020, but which was not implemented.
12. On cross-examination, CW1 confirmed that his termination letter cited reduced work as the reason for redundancy and that the termination occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic. He further acknowledged that paragraph 3(c) of the Tripartite Agreement suspended CBA negotiations and implementation, and that CBA No. 5 of 2020 was suspended.
13. CW1 further admitted that he had no proof that the grievants were sent on unpaid leave and that Form S was not before the Court.
14. On re-examination, CW1 maintained that the Respondent agreed to pay employees in accordance with the CBA and that the claimed salary increment arose from the agreed 9% increase.
15. The Claimant urges the court to allow its Claim with costs.
The Claimant’s submissions
16. The Claimant submits that the Respondent failed to comply with the statutory redundancy requirements and did not demonstrate a valid operational reason for terminating the grievants. It further argued that the Respondent failed to consult the union on the redundancy, and that the COVID-19 pandemic did not excuse non-compliance with the law.
17. The Claimant submits that the timing of the termination, coupled with the grievants' union roles and subsequent withdrawal of other employees from the union, supports its allegation of victimization.
The Respondent's case.
18. The Respondent denied that it unlawfully terminated the grievants' employment or discriminated against them on account of their union activities. It maintains that the termination arose from operational difficulties occassioned by the COVID-19 pandemic, which required the Respondent to scale down its business.
19. The Respondent states that CBA No. 5 of 2020 was signed on 5th November, 2020, after the grievants' termination, and therefore could not retrospectively govern their separation. It further maintains that the Tripartite Agreement suspended CBA negotiations and implementation during the relevant period.
20. The Respondent further denies liability for the full claims and sought dismissal of the suit with costs.
21. It is the Respondent’s case that both grievants were her employees and that the business experienced operational difficulties during the COVID-19 pandemic.
22. On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that the grievants were in the service of the Respondent for approximately 15 years. He admitted that one month's salary was paid in lieu of notice, although Clause 11(iii) of the CBA provided for three months' notice or salary in lieu for employees with more than 14 years of service.
23. RW1 further stated that gratuity was paid for two years since the previous years were already paid for, but he could not confirm whether documentary proof of the previous payments were filed.
24. RW1 maintained that the termination was based on operational challenges as well as the Tripartite Agreement. He acknowledged that the union was authorized to negotiate employees' terms and conditions of service and that Simon Mbogo Macharia was the Chief Shop Steward.
25. He testified further that the grievants were declared redundant when they declined the proposed salary reductions. He further indicated that the Respondent engaged the Claimant, but communication was difficult during the pandemic.
26. On re-examination, RW1 reiterated that the Tripartite Agreement suspended CBA negotiations and implementation, and that discussions concerning the separation took place by telephone due to the COVID-19 lockdown.
27. The Respondent prays that the Claimant’s Claim be dismissed with costs.
The Respondent's Submissions.
28. On the applicability of the CBA, the Respondent submits that CBA No. 5 of 2020 was signed after the termination of the grievants and could not retrospectively create entitlements. It relied on Mukiria Farmers Co-operative Society Ltd v Jacob Rukaria & 5 Others [2017] KECA 432 (KLR) on the contractual nature and binding effect of a CBA.
29. On redundancy, the Respondent relied on Section 40 of the Employment Act, 2007, and the case of Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 Others [2014] KECA 403 (KLR), to submit that redundancy must be established by evidence of operational requirements rendering an employee's services superfluous.
30. The Respondent further relied on Thomas De La Rue (K) Ltd v Omutelema [2013] KECA 492 (KLR), on an employer's managerial prerogative to terminate employment for valid operational reasons. It argued that the termination was occasioned by the pandemic rather than the grievants' union activities, and that the Claimant failed to establish victimization or a causal link between union affiliation and termination.
31. Relying on Sections 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007, and Kenfreight (E.A.) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] KECA 409 (KLR), the Respondent submits that the Claimant did not establish unfair termination.
32. The Respondent further disputed the claims for severance pay, salary arrears, gratuity and compensation, and opposed reinstatement on the grounds of the circumstances of the termination and the passage of time.
33. It urged the Court to dismiss the claim with costs.
Analysis and Determination
34. The issues that arise for determination from the pleadings, evidence and submissions are:-
i. Whether the redundancy of the two grievants was substantively justified and procedurally fair.
ii. Whether the grievants are entitled to the reliefs sought.
Whether the redundancy of the two grievants was substantively justified and procedurally fair.
35. Redundancy is generally a legitimate mode of terminating employment where an employer's operational requirements render an employee's position superfluous. The law, however, requires that an employer shows both a genuine operational reason for the declaration of redundancy as well as compliance with the mandatory statutory procedure provided under Section 40 of the Employment Act, 2007.
36. Section 40(1) of the Employment Act specifically requires that an employer gives the prescribed notices to the employee or the employee’s union and the labour officer, that it considers seniority in time and the employee's skill, ability and reliability where applicable, that it pays for the employee’s accrued leave and issues at least one month's notice or pay in lieu, together with a severance pay of not less than fifteen days for each completed year of service.
37. In Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] KECA 403 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed the importance of compliance with Section 40 of the Employment Act, and further held that an employer's operational prerogative does not displace its statutory obligations.
38. Further, Section 43 of the Employment Act requires an employer to prove the reason for termination, while Section 45 demands that the employer further shows that the reasons are valid and fair, and that the termination is carried out in accordance with fair procedure.
39. The Respondent attributed the redundancy to operational difficulties occasioned by the COVID-19 pandemic and a reduced workload. The COVID-19 pandemic notwithstanding, the Respondent had a statutory duty to demonstrate the operational circumstances necessitating the redundancy and to comply with Section 40.
40. CW1 acknowledged in his oral testimony that his termination letter cited reduced work as the reason for redundancy and that the termination occurred during the pandemic. These circumstances no doubt support the Respondent's explanation that the business was experiencing operational challenges.
41. In the circumstances, therefore, I deem the Respondent’s explanation of the operational circumstances and the reduced workload valid and justified, and which leads me to the conclusion that the termination on grounds of redundancy was fair.
42. In respect of procedural fairness, it is evident from the Court record that the Respondent issued the two grievants with termination notices on account of redundancy dated 28th May, 2020, and further indicated that the termination was effective 1st June, 2020. Additionally, the record confirms that the Respondent subsequently notified the Claimant union by letters dated 3rd June, 2020, that it had terminated the grievants’ employment.
43. The record does not carry any evidence showing that the redundancy notice was issued to the Labour Officer or that the Claimant union was given the requisite notice prior to the termination of the grievants.
44. The Claimant was, from the evidence adduced, only notified of the redundancy a few days after the grievants were terminated, and the notice given to the grievants also doubled up as the termination letters, which took effect three days later.
45. In the upshot, I find and hold that the Respondent did not comply with the mandatory tenets of procedural fairness enshrined in Section 40 of the Act, as it failed to issue the requisite notices within the timeline provided by law.
46. The termination of the grievants’ employment is therefore procedurally unfair and therefore unlawful, and so I hold.
Whether the grievants are entitled to the reliefs sought
Notice pay
47. It is not in dispute that the grievants were paid one month's salary in lieu of notice. The Claimant’s position is that the grievants were entitled to three months' salary in lieu of notice under the CBA, while the Respondent argued that the Tripartite agreement suspended the CBA during the Covid pandemic.
48. RW1 further admitted that the grievants were paid one month's salary in lieu of notice, and further acknowledged that Clause 11(iii) of the CBA provided for three months' notice or salary in lieu for employees who had served for more than fourteen years.
51. The Claimant’s claim for an additional two months’ pay is therefore without merit, and is for the reasons foregone dismissed.
Severance pay
52. Section 40(1)(g) of the Employment Act provides for severance pay at the rate of not less than fifteen days' pay for each completed year of service. This statutory entitlement is distinct from any more favourable benefit provided under a binding CBA.
53. The evidence indicates that both grievants served for approximately fifteen years. The Respondent did not lead any evidence that it paid the grievants this statutory entitlement upon their redundancy.
59. I therefore find no legal basis for the Claim and the same fails.
Salary arrears arising from the 9% increment
60. CBA No. 5 of 2020 was signed after the grievants' termination, and CW1 acknowledged the suspension of its negotiations and implementation. The Claimant did not lead any evidence to establish that the increment had already become effective under an earlier binding agreement or that the later CBA expressly operated retrospectively.
61. The claim for salary arrears based on that increment is equally devoid of merit and is dismissed.
Compensation for unfair termination
62. Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act empowers the Court to award compensation of up to twelve months' gross wages for unfair termination. The award is discretionary and must be determined in accordance with the statutory factors, including the circumstances in which the termination occurred, the employee's length of service, the reasonable expectation of continued employment, and the extent to which the employee contributed to the termination.
63. The grievants served the Respondent for approximately fifteen years. The Respondent, on its part, has shown that reduced work and operational challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic occasioned the redundancy. Considering these factors, I deem an award of six months’ salary sufficient compensation for the unfair termination.
Reinstatement
64. The Claimant seeks reinstatement of the grievants without loss of benefits. Section 49(3)(a) of the Employment Act empowers the Court to order reinstatement, subject to the statutory conditions and the circumstances of the case.
65. In Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] KECA 403 (KLR), the Court of Appeal emphasized that reinstatement is discretionary and that its appropriateness must be assessed against the circumstances of the redundancy, the practicability of the remedy and the applicable legal principles.
66. There is no doubt that the grievants served the Respondent for a considerable length of time. However, the termination of their services occurred on 28th May, 2020, and the matter is now being decided in October 2026.
67. Although the passage of time is not by itself an absolute bar to reinstatement, the Court must consider various factors such as whether the positions still exist, and whether reinstatement is practicable and just in the circumstances.
68. On the material before the Court, there is no sufficient information to establish that the positions remain available or that reinstatement is practicable. For this reason, I decline the claim for reinstatement, and it is dismissed.
71. In the final analysis, the Claimant’s Claim succeeds in terms of the following orders: -
a) A declaration that the grievants were unfairly terminated on the ground of redundancy.
b) That the Respondent shall pay the Claimant:
i. Severance pay in respect of both grievants: Grievant 1 -Kshs. 248,700 while Grievant 2 -Kshs. 189,179.40
ii. 6 months’ salary for each grievant for the unfair termination
iii. Issue each grievant a certificate of service within 14 days of this judgment
iv. The Respondent shall equally bear the costs of the suit.
72. It is so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
N/A for the Claimant
Mr. Akanga present for the Respondent
Ms. Esther - C/A