Employment law

France v Chronicle Group International Limited [2026] KEELRC 14722 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E680 of 2021
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbarũ

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The respondent’s stay application was allowed conditionally. Execution of the 14 August 2026 judgment was stayed only if the respondent deposited Ksh. 2,046,565.57 in court within 14 days, by 30 October 2026; otherwise the stay would lapse. Costs were awarded to the claimant.

Supporting judgment passages

Accordingly, the application dated 2 September 2026 is allowed on the following conditions:

Conclusion and orders →

a) The judgment herein delivered on 14 August 2026 is stayed on condition that the respondent herein shall deposit the sum of Ksh. 2,046,565.57 in court within 14 days lapsing on 30 October 2026, failure to which the stay order shall lapse.

Passage 49 →

b) Costs to the claimant.

Passage 50 →
Issue 1The only issue for determination is whether the respondent has met the threshold for a stay of execution.

Held. Yes, but only on conditions. The application was timely; although the respondent’s general assertion that payment would disrupt its finances was unsupported, the claimant did not disclose evidence of means to refund the decretal amount. Balancing the appeal right against the claimant’s entitlement to the judgment, the court granted a conditional stay requiring deposit of the full judgment sum in court within 14 days. Costs went to the claimant.

Ratio. Under Order 42 rule 6(2), stay pending appeal is discretionary and requires conjunctive proof of substantial loss, timely application, and security. Payment of a money decree alone is not substantial loss, and unsupported assertions of financial disruption are insufficient. Where inability to refund is alleged and the claimant does not disclose financial means within his knowledge, the claimant bears the burden to show ability to repay. Security is mandatory; willingness to provide it is not equivalent to providing it.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

The only issue for determination is whether the respondent has met the threshold for a stay of execution.

Passage 33 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The Court therefore finds that, on a balance of the right of appeal and the claimant’s right to enjoy the fruits of the judgment herein, a conditional stay of execution should issue.

Passage 45 →

A willingness to give security is not the same as giving it. The claimant had requested the respondent for security but declined to address. Employment ceased in March 2021, and to date, the claimant has not secured the fruits of his labour. It is therefore necessary that a stay be granted on condition that the respondent shall deposit the full judgment sum in court within 14 days.

Passage 47 →

a) The judgment herein delivered on 14 August 2026 is stayed on condition that the respondent herein shall deposit the sum of Ksh. 2,046,565.57 in court within 14 days lapsing on 30 October 2026, failure to which the stay order shall lapse.

Passage 49 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

a) substantial loss may result to him unless the order is made;b) the application has been made without unreasonable delay; andc) security for the due performance of the decree has been given by the applicant.

Passage 36 →

Regarding Substantial loss, this is the cornerstone of the jurisdiction to grant a stay. The applicant must show that, if the decree is executed, it will be placed in a position where it cannot recover what it has paid should the appeal succeed. Paying a money decree is not, in itself, a substantial loss, because that is the natural consequence of any judgment against a party.

Passage 42 →

The Respondent's second limb is that the Claimant may not be able to refund the decretal sum. The Claimant has not placed any evidence of his means before the Court. The Court takes the view that where an applicant says the claimant is unable to repay, and the claimant does not disclose his own financial position, which is within his knowledge, the burden falls on him to show that he is in a position to refund.

Passage 44 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Respondent satisfied the requirements for a stay of execution pending its intended appeal from the judgment delivered on 14 August 2026, particularly as to substantial loss, promptness, and security under Order 42 rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure…

Material facts

The judgment of 14 August 2026 found an employment relationship and awarded Stephen John Richard France Ksh. 2,046,565.57, interest at 12% per annum from 31 May 2021 until payment in full, and costs. Chronicle Group International Limited filed a notice of…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. E680 OF 2021

STEPHEN JOHN RICHARD FRANCE……………………....CLAIMANT

VERSUS

CHRONICLE GROUP INTERNATIONAL LIMITED …RESPONDENT

RULING

The Respondent, Chronicles Group International Limited filed an application dated 2nd September, 2026 under the provisions of Section 17 of the Employment and Labour relations Court Act, Rule 73 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court(Procedures) Rules, and Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, seeking:

a) Spent;

b) pending the inter partes hearing of this application, the court be pleased to issue an interim stay of execution of the Judgment delivered on 14th August, 2026 and all consequential orders, decree, proceedings and/ or processes arising therefrom ;

c) pending the hearing and determination of the intended appeal to the Court of Appeal, the court be pleased to stay the execution of the Judgment delivered on 14th August 2026 and any decree arising therefrom;

d) pending the hearing and determination of the intended appeal, the Claimant, his servants, agents and/ or advocates be restrained from commencing, continuing or taking any execution proceedings in respect of the Judgment and/ or decree herein; and

e) The costs of this application abide the outcome of the intended appeal.

The Application is supported by the Supporting Affidavit of Samuel Wakiaga, the Director, who avers that, following the judgment delivered on 14 August 2026, the respondent is aggrieved and wishes to file an appeal. The court held that there existed an employment relationship existed between the parties and awarded the Claimant Ksh. 2,046,565.57, together with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 31 May 2021 until payment in full, and costs of the suit.

Wakiaga avers in his affidavit that the respondent has filed a Notice of Appeal and applied for typed proceedings. The intended appeal raises serious and arguable issues of law and fact and is not intended to delay the Claimant from enjoying the fruits of the Judgment. During the hearing, the respondent disputed the existence of an employment relationship with the Claimant and specifically challenged the authenticity and execution of the alleged employment contract dated 16 March 2015. It further disputed the validity and enforceability of the Deed of Settlement dated 25 March 2021, contending that the same had been procured through material non-disclosure and misrepresentation.

These issues warrant consideration by the Court of Appeal.

Unless the Court grants an order staying execution, the Claimant may proceed with execution of the Judgment and recover the decretal sum, thereby causing substantial loss to the Respondent. The decretal sum, together with accrued interest and costs, continues to increase and execution may disrupt its financial affairs.

Should the Respondent succeed on appeal after payment of the decretal sum, there is no certainty that the Claimant will be in a position to refund the amount paid, together with accrued interest and costs. It is therefore apprehended that the intended appeal may be rendered nugatory unless execution is stayed pending its determination.

Wakiaga further avers that it is willing to provide such security as the Court may direct, including depositing the decretal sum, or a portion thereof, in a joint interest-earning account in the names of the parties' advocates. The application has been made without unreasonable delay, and the Applicant has not filed any other application for a stay of execution before any other court.

In response, the Claimant filed his Replying Affidavit and avers that the decretal sum is an acknowledged debt arising from work performed for the Respondent and which the Respondent failed to pay and that he has waited for over ten years to recover the money owed to him, his employment having ended on 28 February 2016, while the Deed of Settlement was executed over five years ago and the suit has been pending before the Court since 2021.

The Claimant avers that during the trial, the Respondent alleged fraud, non-disclosure and misrepresentation but failed to call any witness or tender evidence in support of those allegations. Consequently, the Court found that the allegations remained unsubstantiated. The Claimant contends that the Respondent is now seeking to challenge the Court’s findings on issues it failed to prove at trial.

The Claimant avers that although the Respondent filed the present application on 2 September 2026, nineteen days after delivery of the Judgment, no record of appeal or memorandum of appeal bearing a Court of Appeal case number had been served upon his advocates as at the time of swearing the Replying Affidavit. He contends that granting a stay in the circumstances would indefinitely delay the enjoyment of the fruits of the Judgment, while interest on the decretal sum continues to accrue.

The Claimant avers that the Respondent has failed to demonstrate that it stands to suffer substantial loss should execution proceed. He contends that the Respondent has merely made general assertions of financial disruption and uncertainty regarding his ability to refund the decretal sum, without producing financial statements, bank statements or any other evidence to substantiate those claims. The Claimant maintains that the obligation to satisfy a monetary decree, without more, does not constitute substantial loss.

The Claimant further avers that although the Respondent expressed willingness to furnish security by depositing the decretal sum or a portion thereof in a joint interest-earning account, it has failed to act on that undertaking. The Claimant states that his advocates, by a letter dated 10 September 2026 received by the Respondent’s advocates on 11 September 2026, requested the deposit of the entire decretal sum in a joint interest-earning account, but the Respondent has neither responded to the letter nor deposited any amount as security.

The Claimant avers that the Respondent’s stated willingness to furnish security is not equivalent to actually providing such security. He maintains that security is a mandatory consideration in an application for stay of execution and that the Respondent has failed to demonstrate its commitment to safeguarding the due performance of the decree.

The Claimant further avers that the Respondent’s affidavit does not establish that the intended appeal will be rendered nugatory if execution proceeds. He contends that the Respondent merely reiterates the allegations it raised during the trial without demonstrating, through evidence from a person with knowledge of the facts, that the employment contract was inauthentic or that the Deed of Settlement was invalid. The Claimant maintains that the Respondent’s complaint is essentially that the Court accepted the documentary evidence he produced, which the Respondent elected not to rebut by calling evidence.

The Claimant avers that the intended appeal should not be used as an opportunity for the Respondent to introduce evidence it chose not to adduce during the trial. He maintains that the Respondent has not demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant depriving him of the fruits of a Judgment lawfully obtained in his favour.

It is the Claimant’s case that he is a successful litigant who has endured prolonged delay in recovering money earned from work performed for the Respondent. He contends that the Respondent’s failure to pay the amount acknowledged in the Deed of Settlement has occasioned financial hardship to him and adversely affected his family, who depend on him.

The Claimant further avers that an unconditional stay of execution would unfairly deny him the benefit of the Judgment for an indefinite period while allowing the Respondent to retain the use of money owed since 2021. He maintains that depositing the decretal sum in a joint interest-earning account would adequately protect the interests of both parties by preserving the funds pending the determination of the intended appeal.

The Claimant urges the court to dismiss the Respondent’s application with costs. In the alternative, should the Court grant a stay, the Claimant prays that the same be conditional upon the Respondent depositing the entire decretal sum in an interest-earning account in the joint names of the advocates for both parties within a period stipulated by the Court, failing which the stay shall automatically lapse and the Claimant shall be at liberty to proceed with execution.

Determination

The only issue for determination is whether the respondent has met the threshold for a stay of execution.

A stay of execution pending an intended appeal is a discretionary relief. The Court exercises that discretion judicially, balancing the appellant's right to pursue an appeal that is not rendered academic against the right of a successful litigant to enjoy the fruits of a judgment obtained in his favour. A successful party should not be kept out of his judgment as a matter of course.

The principles are well settled under Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. An applicant must demonstrate that:


a) substantial loss may result to him unless the order is made;
b) the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and
c) security for the due performance of the decree has been given by the applicant.

These requirements are conjunctive, and the applicant must satisfy each. The Court is also guided by the decisions in Butt v Rent Restriction Tribunal [1982] KLR 417 and Kenya Shell Ltd v Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & another [1986] KLR 410, on the exercise of the discretion.

Under section 17 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, there is a right of appeal from the court's judgment.

Although the orders sought herein seek stay of execution pending an intended appeal, the Respondent has filed a Notice of Appeal and requested typed proceedings to move the Court of Appeal. The intention of filing an appeal is actualised. The Notice of Appeal is what places the intention to appeal on record, and the record of appeal will be filed within the time allowed by the Court of Appeal Rules. However, the Court will take this into account in fashioning the conditions of any stay of execution, so it does not become open-ended.

The Court is not at this stage required to determine whether the intended appeal will succeed, and it will not make findings on the merits of the Judgment which it delivered. At this stage, the arguability of the appeal is not a condition under Order 42 Rule 6(2), and the Court of Appeal will decide it.

On whether there was unreasonable delay in filing this Application, the Judgment was delivered on 14 August 2026, and the application was filed on 2 September 2026, a period of 19 days; there is no delay. The Court finds that the application was filed timeously, and this condition is met.

Regarding Substantial loss, this is the cornerstone of the jurisdiction to grant a stay. The applicant must show that, if the decree is executed, it will be placed in a position where it cannot recover what it has paid should the appeal succeed. Paying a money decree is not, in itself, a substantial loss, because that is the natural consequence of any judgment against a party.

In this case, the Respondent submitted in general terms that execution would disrupt its financial affairs and that it had no certainty the Claimant could refund the money. No financial statements, accounts, or other evidence of the effect of paying the decretal sum on the Respondent's operations was placed before the Court. A bare assertion of disruption does not satisfy the requirement.

The Respondent's second limb is that the Claimant may not be able to refund the decretal sum. The Claimant has not placed any evidence of his means before the Court. The Court takes the view that where an applicant says the claimant is unable to repay, and the claimant does not disclose his own financial position, which is within his knowledge, the burden falls on him to show that he is in a position to refund.

The Court therefore finds that, on a balance of the right of appeal and the claimant’s right to enjoy the fruits of the judgment herein, a conditional stay of execution should issue.

The provision of security is mandatory. It is intended to ensure that a successful party is not left worse off by the grant of a stay, and to balance the competing interests of the parties. The Respondent stated in its affidavit that it is willing to furnish security, including depositing the decretal sum, or a portion of it, in a joint interest-earning account in the names of the parties' advocates.

A willingness to give security is not the same as giving it. The claimant had requested the respondent for security but declined to address. Employment ceased in March 2021, and to date, the claimant has not secured the fruits of his labour. It is therefore necessary that a stay be granted on condition that the respondent shall deposit the full judgment sum in court within 14 days.

Accordingly, the application dated 2 September 2026 is allowed on the following conditions:

a) The judgment herein delivered on 14 August 2026 is stayed on condition that the respondent herein shall deposit the sum of Ksh. 2,046,565.57 in court within 14 days lapsing on 30 October 2026, failure to which the stay order shall lapse.

b) Costs to the claimant.

Delivered in open court this 22nd day of October 2026

M. MBARŨ

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder