Background
For determination is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 31st May, 2021, in which the Claimant seeks judgment as against the Respondent for the following reliefs:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
For determination is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 31st May, 2021, in which the Claimant seeks judgment as against the Respondent for the following reliefs:-
Paragraph 1 →From the pleadings, the evidence adduced and the rival submissions, the issues for determination are:-
Paragraph 71 →In the premises, I find and hold that the Claimant was not constructively dismissed.
Paragraph 92 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E447 OF 2021
ANTHONY KARIUKI CHEGE……………………………………….. CLAIMANT
VERSUS
KENYA WOMEN MICROFINANCE BANK PLC………………….RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. For determination is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 31st May, 2021, in which the Claimant seeks judgment as against the Respondent for the following reliefs:-
a) A declaration that the Claimant was constructively dismissed from employment by the Respondent.
b) A declaration that the resignation by the Claimant was involuntary hence it amounted to wrongful/unfair dismissal of employment by the Respondent.
c) An Award of compensation for unfair termination of employment by reason of constructive dismissal, Kshs. 25,806,000.00 equivalent to Kshs. 2,150,500.00 X 12 months.
d) The difference in value of the ESOP units not awarded amounting to Kshs. 26,467,360.00.
e) An award of compensation for the violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights under Articles 27 (4), 29 (d), (f) and 41 (1) 2 (b) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.
f) Damages for discrimination and harassment.
g) Housing allowance.
h) Certificate of Service.
i) Costs of this suit and interest.
j) Any other relief that the court may deem appropriate to grant.
2. The Respondent entered appearance on 16th June, 2021 and filed a Memorandum of Response dated 7th July, 2021. The Claimant thereafter filed a Reply to the Respondent’s response dated 22nd July 2021.
3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 15th October, 2024, 19th February 2025 and concluded on 17th June 2025. The Claimant called five witnesses in support of his case. CW1, Anthony Kariuki Chege, the Claimant, adopted his witness statement dated 31st May 2021, as his evidence-in-chief and produced his list and bundle of documents of even date as Claimant’s Exhibits 1 - 24. CW2, Edna Joy Musha, adopted her witness statement dated 22nd April, 2022 as her evidence-in-chief. CW3, David Momanyi Gichana, adopted his witness statement dated 22nd April, 2022 as his evidence-in-chief. CW4, Judith Kiragu Wawira, adopted her witness statement dated 21st April, 2022 as her evidence-in-chief. Finally, CW5, Jane Ngaiti Marete, adopted her witness statement dated 21st April, 2022 as her evidence-in-chief.
4. The Respondent’s case was subsequently heard on 21st April, 2026, where RW1, Caroline Wanjiku Mwangi, the Respondent’s General Manager, Human Resource Department, testified in support of the Respondent’s case, adopted her witness statement dated 15th September, 2021 and a supplementary statement dated 20th May, 2022 as her evidence-in-chief, and produced the Respondent’s list and bundle of documents dated 7th July, 2021 as exhibits 1-18, the supplementary list and bundle of documents dated 20th May, 2022 as Exhibit 19-36 and the second supplementary list and bundle of documents dated 21st Nov ember 2022 as Exhibit 37-38.
5. Both parties filed submissions.
The Claimant’s Case
6. The Claimant’s case is that he was employed by the Respondent, which at the time was known as Kenya Women Finance Trust Ltd, as the Operations Director vide a letter dated 31st July, 2008, at a starting gross salary of Kshs. 614,000.
7. It is his case that his responsibilities included Microfinance Lending, SME and Esteem Banking, Research and Innovations, Customer Experience, Digital Lending, Frauds and Investigations, Business Support, Salary Secured Lending and Credit Securities.
8. The Claimant states that he always performed and completed his duties timeously, professionally and with devotion, attention and ability, consistently meeting and exceeding his appraisals until the year 2017. He avers that, as a result of his good performance, his salary was increased in April 2018 to Kshs. 1,642,800.
9. It is his case that around September 2018, the Managing Director of the Respondent stopped consulting him, that he met with his subordinates without him and reassigned his functions to other employees. The Claimant states that the letters dated 7th December 2018, a memorandum dated 17th December 2018, and a memorandum dated 5th February 2019 show that Microfinance and other functions were removed from his portfolio without consultation, written notification, or a revised job description.
10. The Claimant states that he also complained of exclusion from the Procurement Committee meeting of 29th November, 2018, the Credit Committee meeting of 21st November, 2018, the Audit and Compliance meeting of 5th December, 2018, the Insurance Policy Committee meeting of 27th November, 2018, and the Board meeting of 6th December, 2018.
11. It is the Claimant’s further case that the allocation of rooms during a meeting in Machakos in January 2019 at Gilean Hotel further showed his isolation and humiliation by the Respondent. He further avers that the entire head office team was booked on the top floor, which has the presidential suite, but the Managing Director directed that he be booked where all the Junior staff were booked.
12. It is his case that he was informed by the Director Legal Services that the Managing Director convened a meeting and the attendees were told not to give him any space, and he should be put to task until he resigns.
13. The Claimant avers that he felt that he was in a toxic working environment and was constantly frustrated by the Respondent, and there was no sign of better conditions, which made it impossible for him to discharge his duties. He avers that, as a result, he tendered his resignation letter dated 21st January, 2019, which the Respondent accepted by letter dated 28th January, 2019.
14. He contends that his five year contract was renewed on 1st January, 2017, with a 10% salary increase, and that he had an expectation that he would continue working for the bank until the year 2022.
15. On cross-examination, CW1 stated that his expertise was in microfinance, although he has no document specifically proving that he was a microfinance specialist. He acknowledged that the Respondent had performed poorly in the year ending 30th September, 2017, and that the Board discussed non-performing loans at the meeting held on 25th November, 2018.
16. It was his case that he alone was asked to leave the Board meeting of 6th December, 2018, which comprised the CEO and two Directors. He states that the Finance Director remained in the meeting, but he had no minutes proving that the Finance Director actually remained.
17. He denied holding the formal title of Deputy Managing Director or Deputy Chief Executive Officer, though he considered himself second-in-command, relying on memoranda appointing him to act as Managing Director. He could, however, not produce the salary scale said to place him above other directors.
18. CW1 confirmed that the Board approved a new organizational structure, that he had no voting rights and could not amend the Board agenda, and that overall strategy fell within the Managing Director’s mandate. He further confirmed that restructuring was normal business practice, but avers that he was not consulted.
19. It is his testimony that Microfinance, Credit Securities, Research and Innovations and Legal/Corporate Affairs were removed from his docket or reassigned, but he was not issued a revised contract.
20. He acknowledged that his salary and benefits were unchanged, that his department was reorganized rather than abolished, that he received salary until April 2019, and that some terminal benefits were paid. The Claimant did not provide a record of his pending leave days.
21. It is his case that fewer than 100 employees reported to him after restructuring, but he had no document supporting that figure, and further confirmed that the SME portfolio had performed poorly, hence the reason the Board approved a lower budget.
22. As regards the Machakos meeting on 24th January 2019, which happened after his resignation but during his notice period, his evidence was that he was discriminated against in the room allocation.
23. He also referred to an incident on 29th November, 2018, where he was allocated Room 616 while the other directors were on the 7th floor. He testified that he did not write or email a complaint about the alleged unfair treatment, did not inform the Board, and acknowledged that his resignation letter did not particularize each incident.
24. The Claimant testified that he was paid terminal benefits of Kshs. 12,259,888.58, but that he received only Kshs. 106,364 after deduction of company loans and statutory deductions. He stated that he had taken a loan of Kshs. 12,000,000 to finance LR No. 15153/129, and that the aggregate amount was Kshs. 32,000,000, although offsetting had not been provided for. He further testified that his ESOP was valued at Kshs. 52,732,740, against which a total recovery of Kshs. 29,705,217 was made, leaving him with a payment of Kshs. 23,027,422.76.
25. The Claimant further testified that the Managing Director sought approval on paper for the repositioning strategy, the replacement strategy, and a combination of the two strategies. He stated that the changes affected his position as the head of the Operations Division, which was subsequently renamed Banking Operations and placed under the Director of Operations.
26. Referring to page 95(c) of the bundle of internal memoranda on the organizational changes, he maintained that no communication was issued regarding the changes affecting his division. He stated that his duties were redistributed to other officers, citing the elevation of Microfinance into a full division as an example.
27. He testified that he was in charge of Microfinance and that the person appointed to head the division was to report directly to the Managing Director. He added that Credit Securities was also hived off from his division and that Research and Innovation was removed from his department. He avers that although the other changes were communicated through internal memoranda, no such communication was issued regarding the changes affecting his responsibilities.
28. The Claimant acknowledged that the changes were approved by the Board and maintained that he was competent to head the Microfinance Division, having managed it until 2018. He stated that he was not informed of any underperformance in his department.
29. CW2 testified that she shared information within the Respondent’s company as instructed by the Managing Director, and with persons to whom the information related. She confirmed that she was under a duty to maintain confidentiality.
30. It is her testimony that she received an email written to the Managing Director (M. D.) but which was copied to her as his Personal Assistant, and that since the Claimant was out of the office with the M.D., she shared the email with the Claimant and other general managers.
31. She avers that she was falsely accused of leaking information and told to write an apology, which she confirmed she did.
32. CW3, on cross-examination, testified that the General Manager-Legal reported to the Managing Director and that there was no formal Deputy Managing Director position or letter appointing the Claimant to that role. He confirmed the Managing Director delegated duties to the Claimant when absent.
33. CW3, on the organizational hierarchy, acknowledged the existence of the Directors of Finance and Operations, but could not confirm whether they were at the same level. He further testified that, whenever the Managing Director was away, he delegated several of his duties to the Director of Operations.
34. The witness stated that he did not see a letter appointing the Claimant as Deputy Managing Director. He explained that, when he served as Credit Securities Manager, he reported to the Director of Operations, whereas as Director, Legal, he reported to the GM-Legal. He further testified that Marion was to report to the GM-Legal Services while serving as Acting Credit Securities Manager.
35. The witness further testified that the Security Department was moved to Credit Administration in 2018, and confirmed that the division reported to the Managing Director. He explained that he consulted the Director of Operations on matters relating to the collateralization.
36. Regarding the alleged instructions to frustrate the Director of Operations, he clarified that the word “express” did not necessarily mean that instructions had to be in writing. He maintained that he was verbally instructed to frustrate the Director of Operations, but confirmed that no written instructions were issued.
37. On her part, CW4 testified that she left the Respondent’s employment on account of poor performance, which she stated was the reason the Respondent disengaged her. She confirmed that she sued the Respondent, claiming Kshs. 24,000,000 for unfair termination, and that judgment was delivered in the matter, resulting in an award of approximately Kshs.600,000. She further confirmed that she has an appeal pending against the Respondent.
38. Regarding the hotel room allocations, CW4 testified that the Claimant was allocated Room No. 616, while Room No. 614 was allocated to Mr. Kitahu, who was then the Finance Director. She stated that the Managing Director occupied Room No. 611 but could not confirm whether the rooms were on different floors, acknowledging that she had no evidence to establish the same.
39. She further testified that the charge for each room was Kshs. 7,000. She stated that she did not know when the Claimant submitted his resignation, but confirmed that the Claimant was allocated Room No. 616 again on 24th January 2019, and the charge for the room was Kshs. 7,300.
40. CW4 further confirmed that the Claimant resigned on 21st January, 2019 and that, by the time a meeting was convened on 24th January, 2019, the Claimant had already tendered his resignation notice. She also testified that one Kinyanjui was the Director of Microfinance and had been allocated Room No. 618, although she could not confirm whether the rooms were on the same floor. She confirmed that Kinyanjui chaired a meeting on 25th January 2019, after the Claimant tendered his resignation on 21st January 2019.
41. CW5 also testified that she was bound by the confidentiality clause in her appointment letter, and that she reported to the Claimant in his capacity as Director of Finance. She further stated that her terms of engagement, including the confidentiality obligation, remained in force and that she was also governed by the Respondent’s Human Resource Manual, which addressed internal communication.
42. She maintained that publishing official information with the Managing Director’s authority did not constitute misconduct, although the Human Resource Manual prohibited her from publishing official information to an outsider.
43. The witness testified that the Managing Director had expressly instructed her to print a document from a flash disk without obtaining a copy. She acknowledged that she obtained a copy contrary to those instructions. She further confirmed that the document was intended for discussion at a Board meeting, and that she shared it without the Managing Director’s authority.
44. She stated that she resigned on 31st January, 2019, but did not have a copy of her resignation letter in Court. She further explained that she had opted not to extend her contract.
45. She stated that the Respondent had no policy governing who could accompany the Managing Director to meetings.
46. In re-examination, she explained that she shared information with the Claimant because she regarded him as second-in-command, had not previously been told not to do so, and has never been charged with unauthorized disclosure.
The Claimant’s Submissions.
47. It is the Claimant’s submission that he resigned with notice because the Respondent’s conduct had made continued employment untenable and repudiated the employment contract.
48. He submits that giving notice did not, by itself, make the resignation voluntary. He sought to rely on Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] KECA 394 (KLR), to argue that constructive dismissal arises where the employer’s conduct amounts to a fundamental breach, is the effective cause of the employee’s resignation, and the employee resigns within a reasonable time.
49. The Claimant further had reliance on Milton M. Isanya v Aga Khan Hospital [2017] KEELRC 571(KLR), in support of the principles governing constructive dismissal.
The Respondent’s Case.
50. The Respondent’s case is that the Claimant voluntarily resigned from its employment and was not constructively dismissed. It contends that the organizational restructuring implemented on 17th December, 2018 was a legitimate management decision intended to improve the Bank’s efficiency and competitiveness.
51. It avers that the restructuring introduced new divisions, including Microfinance and Credit Administration, and transferred the Microfinance function from the Operations Division. The Respondent maintains that the changes did not abolish the Claimant’s position or reduce his contractual terms and benefits.
52. The Respondent further contends that the Claimant was aware of the restructuring through his participation in Board and committee meetings, as well as the internal memorandum communicating the changes. The Respondent denies excluding the Claimant from Board deliberations, sidelining him or subjecting him to discrimination and harassment.
53. It maintains that the Claimant had not raised a formal grievance under the Bank’s Human Resource Policy before resigning, and that the alleged intolerable working conditions were not established.
54. Regarding the Claimant’s responsibilities, the Respondent states that the principal change to his portfolio was the transfer of Microfinance to a separate division, while a substantial operational portfolio remained under him. It contends that the restructuring served the Bank’s institutional interests and did not breach the Claimant’s employment contract.
55. The Respondent also disputed the allegations concerning the hotel accommodation and room allocation, maintaining that the Claimant was accommodated in a room of a similar standard to those allocated to other senior management personnel and was not deliberately humiliated.
56. The Respondent further states that the Claimant was paid his lawful benefits, subject to deductions for outstanding liabilities, and that the value of his ESOP units had been determined through the applicable valuation process.
57. The Respondent disputes the Claimant’s claim for all the reliefs sought, arguing that he has not established a basis for the said reliefs and urged the Court to dismiss the claim with costs.
58. During cross-examination, RW1 testified that the Claimant resigned on account of changes to the organizational structure and confirmed that she was aware of the changes and that they affected his job description. She stated that the changes were communicated through a Board meeting, a management meeting and a circular to staff.
59. She maintained that the Claimant was notified of the changes and participated in the Board meeting. She admitted that, apart from the meeting, she had no direct communication with the Claimant about the changes and did not issue him a letter about the proposed changes.
60. She further confirmed that the Claimant was requested to step out of a Board meeting held on 6th December, 2018, and that she had not issued him with a revised job description.
61. RW1 testified that the replacement strategy did not specifically refer to the Claimant and maintained that it did not affect his job description. She explained that the strategy involved transferring roles to other dockets, including Microfinance, in order to create a new Director position. She stated that the Claimant was left in charge of SME, while Credit was transferred to the Managing Director’s docket.
62. She confirmed that before the changes, the division was known as the Operations Division and was headed by a Director of Operations, a position the Claimant held under the title Director of Operations/Operations Director. She acknowledged that no letter informed the Claimant of a change in his division, but maintained that his position was not changed. She further stated that she was not present at the Board meeting where the changes were made and that the circulars did not address the Claimant directly.
63. RW1 acknowledged having heard the Claimant testify that he had confronted the Managing Director about the changes and that the Managing Director had informed him that he did not know what role the Claimant would assume.
64. She stated that the Board had recommended the appointment of a new Director, but clarified that she had not personally recommended the appointment. She could not confirm whether the Board consulted the Claimant regarding the changes. She further testified that the Claimant was supervising seven dockets.
65. Regarding the hotel accommodation, RW1 stated that she had not attended the meeting in Machakos, but could see from the records that the Claimant had been booked in Room No. 606. However, she could not confirm whether the room was on the sixth floor. She further testified that the Claimant’s last working day was 20th April, 2019 and that his replacement was appointed on 28th January, 2019.
66. In re-examination, she reiterated that the Claimant resigned on 21st January 2019. She indicated that a deputy was appointed Director to take over the Claimant’s role and that he proceeded on leave from February to the end of April.
67. She explained that the Board meeting of 6th December, 2018 concerned a turnaround strategy and that directors and management were asked to step aside for discussion. She said the Claimant had previously used Room 616, that they did not intend to isolate him, and that the rooms cost Kshs. 7,300 each.
The Respondent’s Submissions.
68. It is the Respondent's submission that the Claimant voluntarily resigned and has not established constructive dismissal. The Respondent argues that the Board approved restructuring was a legitimate managerial decision necessitated by declining financial performance, non-performing loans, and the need to improve operational efficiency.
69. It submits that the restructuring altered departmental functions and reporting lines, but did not reduce the Claimant’s salary, grade, benefits, or job title. It submits further that the Claimant participated in Board and management meetings and did not prove the alleged isolation, humiliation, discrimination, or harassment.
70. The Respondent urged the Court to dismiss the claim.
Analysis and Determination
71. From the pleadings, the evidence adduced and the rival submissions, the issues for determination are:-
i. Whether the Claimant was constructively dismissed.
ii. Whether the Respondent subjected the Claimant to discrimination, harassment or violations of his constitutional rights.
iii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought,
Whether the Claimant was constructively dismissed.
72. The Claimant’s case is that following the Respondent’s organizational restructuring undertaken in December 2018, the Managing Director progressively stripped him of key responsibilities, excluded him from important meetings, reassigned functions within his portfolio and undermined his position in the organization.
73. He contends that the cumulative effect of the Managing Director’s actions rendered his working environment intolerable and compelled him to resign on 21st January, 2019, and thus considers himself constructively dismissed.
74. On its part, the Respondent maintains that the restructuring was a legitimate management decision necessitated by the Bank’s operational and financial circumstances. It argues that the Claimant retained his job title, salary and benefits, and that no fundamental breach of his employment contract occurred.
75. The meaning of constructive dismissal was succinctly articulated by Lord Denning MR in Western Excavating (ECC) Ltd. -v- Sharp [1978] ICR 222 or [1978] QB 761, as follows:-
“If the employer is guilty of conduct which is a significant breach going to the root of the contract of employment or which shows that the employer no longer intends to be bound by one or more of the essential terms of the contract, then the employee is entitled to treat himself as discharged from any further performance. If he does so, then he terminates the contract by reason of the employer’s conduct. He is constructively dismissed.
The employee is entitled in those circumstances to leave at the instant without giving any notice at all, or alternatively, he may give notice and say that he is leaving at the end of the notice. But the conduct must in either case be sufficiently serious to entitle him to leave at once.”
76. Closer home, the now settled governing principles on constructive dismissal are set out in Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] KECA 394 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal recognized constructive dismissal where the employer’s conduct amounts to a fundamental breach of the employment contract, the employee resigns in response to that breach, and the resignation occurs within a reasonable time. The employee must further establish that the employer’s conduct left no reasonable alternative but to resign.
77. The question is therefore not simply whether the Claimant resigned voluntarily in the literal sense, but whether the resignation was the consequence of a fundamental contractual breach attributable to the Respondent.
78. In Milton M Isanya v Aga Khan Hospital Kisumu [2017] KEELRC 571 (KLR), the Court considered the principles applicable to constructive dismissal, including whether the employer’s conduct fundamentally breached the employment relationship and made continued employment intolerable.
79. The evidence before the Court confirms that indeed the restructuring undertaken by the Respondent affected the Claimant’s portfolio. The Respondent’s witness (RW1), who is also the General Manager for Human Resources, acknowledged that functions were transferred from the Claimant’s docket to other dockets, that Microfinance was separated from the Operations Division, that the Claimant was left in charge of SME, and that no individual letter communicating changes to his role was issued. She also confirmed that the employer/Respondent did not issue a revised job description to the Claimant upon restructuring.
80. These admissions by the Respondent are no doubt material. Further, although an employer ordinarily has managerial prerogative to reorganize its business, that prerogative does not confer an unrestricted right to make fundamental changes to an employee’s contractual position without regard to the employment contract and the statutory requirements governing changes to the employment particulars.
81. The Claimant also led evidence showing that Microfinance, Credit Securities, Research and Innovations, and other functions were removed from or reassigned outside his portfolio. RW1 further acknowledged that the restructuring created a new Director position and redistributed some of the Claimant’s responsibilities. These circumstances, in my view, support his contention that the changes materially affected his role.
82. The Respondent produced in evidence minutes of various Board and committee meetings held on different dates including 25/1/2018, 21/11/2018, 27/11/2018, 29/11/2018, 5/12/2028, and 6/12/2028, which show that the Claimant attended all these meetings, contrary to his assertion that he was sidelined when meetings were called. The Respondent’s documents also show that the Central Bank approved the hiring of the Claimant’s replacement on 7th May, 2019, after the Claimant’s notice period had expired, contrary to his contention that his replacement was hired before his notice period lapsed.
83. In a claim of constructive dismissal, however, such as the one before me, the evidence must be assessed as a whole. The Claimant acknowledged that his salary and benefits remained unchanged, that his department was reorganized rather than abolished, and that restructuring was a normal business practice. He also confirmed that the Respondent's Board approved the changes and that the Bank's overall strategy fell within the Managing Director’s mandate.
84. Further, the allegation that he was the Bank’s second-in-command has not been conclusively established. He acknowledged that he did not formally hold the title of Deputy Managing Director or Deputy Chief Executive Officer, and the supporting witnesses did not establish that such a formal position existed.
85. On the allegations of exclusion and humiliation, the Claimant did not produce minutes proving that he alone was required to leave the Board meeting of 6th December, 2018. The evidence on the hotel room allocation was equally inconclusive as to whether the rooms were on different floors or whether the Claimant was deliberately treated less favourably. It is also evident that the 24th January 2019 meeting occurred after his resignation.
86. Further, the testimony concerning the alleged verbal instructions to frustrate the Claimant provides some corroboration of his case, but the witness did not produce written instructions. Its weight must therefore be assessed against the other evidence, including the absence of a contemporaneous written complaint by the Claimant to the Board or through the Respondent’s grievance procedures.
87. The decisive consideration in my view is whether the restructuring, viewed cumulatively and in the context of the employment contract, amounted to a fundamental breach rather than an ordinary managerial reorganization.
88. In Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga (Supra), the Court of Appeal made it clear that an employee may resign with notice and still establish constructive dismissal. The controlling question, therefore, is whether the employer’s conduct constituted a repudiatory breach and was the effective cause of the resignation.
89. From the evidence adduced herein, the removal of substantial functions from the Claimant’s portfolio, the failure to communicate the changes directly to him, and the appointment of another Director to assume responsibilities previously exercised by him raise legitimate concerns about how the restructuring was implemented. However, those matters must be weighed against the absence of any reduction in the Claimant’s salary or benefits, the continuation of his substantial portfolio, the lack of documentary proof of the alleged acts of humiliation, and the absence of a contemporaneous formal grievance against the Respondent's actions.
90. The evidence no doubt establishes that the Claimant was dissatisfied with the restructuring and perceived it as a diminution of his standing. Dissatisfaction, however, is not synonymous with a repudiatory breach of contract. The Court must, in my view, be satisfied that the Respondent’s conduct crossed the legal threshold set in Coca-Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga (supra).
91. Finally, the totality of the evidence before the Court does not sufficiently establish that the Respondent committed a fundamental breach of the Claimant’s contract as to compel his resignation, and on this account, the claim for constructive dismissal cannot be sustained and it fails.
92. In the premises, I find and hold that the Claimant was not constructively dismissed.
Whether the Claimant was discriminated against, harassed or subjected to constitutional violations
93. The Claimant has invoked Articles 27, 28, 29 and 41 of the Constitution, alleging discrimination, harassment, humiliation and violation of his dignity at work.
94. The Claimant has not, from the evidence before the court, identified a sufficiently established discriminatory ground or demonstrated how the restructuring was motivated by such a ground.
95. Further, the evidence concerning room allocation does not establish that he was deliberately assigned inferior accommodation because of a protected characteristic. Similarly, his alleged exclusion from a meeting, without further evidence of the circumstances and purpose of the exclusion, does not automatically establish discrimination or a constitutional violation.
96. Accordingly, the claims of discrimination, harassment and constitutional violations have not been sufficiently proven, and they fail.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought
97. The Court has held that the Claimant’s termination does not constitute a constructive dismissal. On this account, the claims for damages for the termination and violation of constitutional rights fail, and are hereby dismissed.
98. I further note that claims in respect of house allowance and ESOP units were withdrawn, which I then let rest.
99. In the final analysis, I find the Claimant’s Claim devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed in its totality with costs to the Respondent.
100. It is so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Jomo h/b for Mr. Kamotho for the Claimant
Mr. Kigata present for the Respondent
8Ms. Esther - C/A