REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC PET NO. E165 OF 2026
FRANCIS AWINO…...PETITIONER
VERSUS
THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION….…..1ST RESPONDENT
THE CABINET SECRETARY, THE NATIONAL TREASURY AND ECONOMIC PLANNING…………….2ND RESPONDENT
KENYA REVENUE AUTHORITY,
BOARD OF DIRECTORS…………………….3RD RESPONDENT
AND
ADAN ABDULLA MOHAMED.….……. 1ST INTERESTED PARTY
THE HONOURABLE
ATTORNEY GENERAL….………….2ND INTERESTED PARTY
RULING
The ruling herein relates to the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 27 July 2026 filed by the 3rd Respondent, Kenya Revenue Authority, and Board of Directors, premised on the following grounds:
1. The Petitioner lacks the locus standi to institute and prosecute this Petition in view of the binding decision of the Supreme Court in Petition No. E030 (as consolidated with E033 of 2025), Moi Teaching & Referral Hospital & 3 others vs Dr Magare Gikenyi & 76 others.
2. The Employment and Labour Relations Court lacks the jurisdiction to hear and determine this Petition in view of the provisions of Articles 165(3)(b), (d) and 165 (5)(b) of the Constitution, as read together with Section 12(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and the binding decision of the Supreme Court in Petition No. E030 (as consolidated with E033 of 2025), Moi Teaching & Referral Hospital & 3 others vs Dr Magare Gikenyi & 76 others.
The parties attended and agreed to address the preliminary objection by written submissions.
In support of the preliminary objection, the 3rd Respondent submitted that the Petitioner lacked locus standi to institute and prosecute the Petition before this Court, and that the Court lacked jurisdiction to hear and determine the dispute.
He argued that Article 162(2) (a) of the Constitution, read together with Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act (ELRC Act), identifies the categories of persons and entities entitled to institute claims before the Court. These include employees, employers, trade unions, employers’ organisations, federations, the Registrar of Trade Unions, the Cabinet Secretary and other offices established under written law for that purpose.
The 3rd Respondent further relied on Section 56(8) of the Labour Institutions Act and Sections 5 and 9 of the Employment Act, as well as Section 5(2) of the Labour Relations Act, which extends access to the Court to other specified persons, including persons aggrieved by decisions of the Director of Employment and prospective employees alleging discrimination. It was contended that the Petitioner did not fall within any of the recognised categories and therefore lacked the requisite standing to institute the Petition.
The 3rd Respondent relied on the Supreme Court decision in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR), particularly paragraphs 70–73, where the Court clarified the scope of the jurisdiction of the Employment and Labour Relations Court. The Supreme Court held that the Court’s jurisdiction extends beyond conventional employer-employee disputes to include pre-employment disputes involving persons and entities recognised under Section 12 of the ELRC Act and other relevant written laws. However, disputes falling outside the scope of those specified categories, particularly public law causes involving citizens and State organs over alleged constitutional violations, fall within the jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 165(3)(b) and (d) of the Constitution.
The 3rd Respondent submitted that the Petitioner instituted a public interest cause concerning constitutional violations in the recruitment and appointment of the 1st Interested Party, presenting a public law dispute between a citizen and State organs and that such dispute did not fall within the ambit of the ELRC Act, the Employment Act, the Labour Institutions Act or the Labour Relations Act.
In accordance with the Supreme Court’s decision, the dispute ought to have been instituted before the High Court and not before this Court. The Court lacked jurisdiction to hear and determine the Petition and should strike it out with costs.
In further support of the objection, the 2nd Respondent submitted that the Petition should be struck out for want of jurisdiction, arguing that jurisdiction is a threshold issue which must be determined before the Court considers the merits of the dispute. The Court relied on Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1, which held that without jurisdiction, a court cannot take any further step. In Samuel Kamau Macharia & Another v Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd & 2 Others [2012] eKLR, the Supreme Court affirmed that a court's jurisdiction flows only from the Constitution or statute.
The 2nd Respondent submitted that Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and Section 12 of the ELRC Act limit the jurisdiction of the court to disputes relating to employment and labour relations. At the same time, the High Court retains general constitutional jurisdiction under Article 165(3). In Republic v Karisa Chengo & 2 Others [2017] eKLR, the court held that superior courts of equal status have distinct constitutional mandates, and that the mere presence of constitutional issues does not confer jurisdiction on the ELRC unless those issues arise within a genuine employment dispute.
The Petition is a stand-alone public-law challenge to the appointment of the Commissioner General of the Kenya Revenue Authority and not an employment dispute. The Petitioner claims no status as an employee, employer, applicant for the position, or person asserting any employment right arising from the impugned appointment. According to the 2nd Respondent, the dispute concerns the exercise of public power and compliance with constitutional requirements governing public appointments, matters which fall within the High Court's constitutional jurisdiction.
The 2nd Respondent relied on Moi Teaching & Referral Hospital & 3 Others v Dr Magare Gikenyi & 76 Others, submitting that the Supreme Court distinguished between constitutional questions arising incidentally within employment disputes and public-interest constitutional challenges brought by citizens without an identifiable employment relationship. The Petition falls squarely within the latter category because the Petitioner approaches the Court solely as a public-interest litigant challenging the legality of a public appointment. The fact that the appointment relates to a public institution was said to be insufficient to convert the matter into an employment dispute or enlarge the jurisdiction of the ELRC.
The 2nd Respondent maintained that the Preliminary Objection satisfies the principles in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696 because it raises a pure question of law based entirely on the pleadings and the constitutional and statutory framework governing jurisdiction. Its determination, it was submitted, requires no investigation of disputed facts and can dispose of the entire Petition at the threshold stage.
In response, the Petitioner opposed the Preliminary Objection and submitted that the objection ought to be considered against the constitutional and statutory framework governing the court's jurisdiction. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, the Petitioner acknowledged that a preliminary objection must raise a pure point of law capable of disposing of the proceedings without requiring the Court to ascertain disputed facts. Articles 162(2)(a) and 162(3) of the Constitution, together with Section 12 of the ELRC Act, confer upon the ELRC jurisdiction over disputes relating to employment and labour relations. The Court's jurisdiction is not limited to disputes arising from an existing employer-employee relationship; it also extends to certain pre-employment disputes, including recruitment, selection, and appointment processes. In Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR), the Supreme Court recognised that the ELRC's jurisdiction extends to specified pre-employment disputes and that the Court may determine constitutional questions where they arise within its employment and labour relations jurisdiction. In Kenya Tea Growers Association & 2 Others v National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees & 13 Others [2024] KESC 3 (KLR), the Court upheld the same interpretation.
The Petitioner submitted that the present Petition concerned the legality of appointing the 1st Interested Party as Commissioner General of the Kenya Revenue Authority and was directly connected to public service and employment-related statutory powers. The appointment was made despite the 1st Interested Party having attained the mandatory retirement age, without disclosure of a lawful exemption or justification, and without a transparent, competitive and merit-based recruitment process. The Petitioner maintained that these allegations raised questions concerning compliance with Articles 10, 27, 47, 73, 129 and 232 of the Constitution, particularly the values and principles governing public service appointments under Article 232. The reliefs sought included orders quashing the appointment, prohibiting continued occupation of the office, and directing a fresh, transparent, competitive, and merit-based recruitment process.
The Petitioner submitted that the decision in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR) ought to be read in its entirety and in the context of the facts and statutory framework considered by the Supreme Court. The decision did not establish that every constitutional petition challenging recruitment or appointment to public office necessarily falls outside the ELRC's jurisdiction. The Petitioner distinguished the circumstances in Gikenyi, where the petitioners had approached the Court as public-spirited citizens and human rights activists who did not fall within the categories of persons contemplated under the relevant employment legislation. In the present case, however, the Petitioner argued that the subject matter had a substantial nexus with public employment, recruitment and public-service eligibility.
The Petitioner acknowledged that the Petition was instituted in the public interest pursuant to Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution and that he neither sought appointment to the impugned office nor advanced a personal employment claim. Nevertheless, the Petitioner's capacity alone should not determine jurisdiction. Rather, the Court ought to examine the substance and centre of gravity of the dispute to establish whether it fell within the employment and labour relations jurisdiction conferred by Article 162(2) (a) of the Constitution and Section 12 of the ELRC Act.
The Petitioner further acknowledged the principle in Republic v Karisa Chengo & 2 Others [2017] KESC 15 (KLR) that the High Court, the ELRC and the Environment and Land Court are courts of equal status exercising distinct constitutional and statutory jurisdictions. However, the existence of constitutional questions did not automatically vest exclusive jurisdiction in the High Court, since the ELRC was competent to determine constitutional issues arising within disputes properly falling within its employment and labour relations jurisdiction. The Petitioner maintained that the Court therefore had to examine the nature of the appointment challenged and its relationship to public employment before determining whether the Petition fell within the jurisdiction of the ELRC or the High Court.
The Petitioner submitted that the allegations concerning the legality of the appointment, retirement age, transparency, merit and compliance with Article 232 remained substantive constitutional questions that had not been determined on their merits. The Petitioner acknowledged that, if the Court found that the circumstances fell within the category of public-law disputes reserved for the High Court under Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR), it would be bound to decline jurisdiction. However, such a determination should be confined to jurisdiction and should not be construed as an adjudication of the Petition's merits. The Court should not award costs, since the proceedings were instituted in the public interest to promote constitutional accountability.
Determination
The sole issue for determination is whether the Court has jurisdiction in view of the judgment in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50. The petitioner admitted that he filed the matter in the public interest and sought to distinguish himself vis-à-vis other such petitions. He contends that the petition, filed under Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution, substantively relates to public employment, recruitment, and public-service eligibility. Such matters are different and distinguishable from the petition in the referenced matter.
The Preliminary Objection herein challenges the Petitioner's locus standi and this Court's jurisdiction to hear and determine the Petition. Both grounds raise questions of law that can be determined by reference to the Constitution, applicable statutes, and judgments of superior courts that bind the Court. The Petitioner acknowledges in his pleadings and submissions that the Petition was instituted in the public interest and that he does not assert any personal employment right. The determination of the objection therefore does not require the Court to ascertain disputed facts or evaluate the merits of the allegations concerning the impugned appointment.
Indeed, the jurisdiction of this Court is founded on Article 162(2) (a) of the Constitution, which establishes a court. Article 165(5) (b) further directs that matters addressed under Article 162(2) of the Constitution shall remain within the exclusive jurisdiction of the specialised courts. Previously, I have been guided by these provisions and presided over petitions seeking to address constitutional rights and freedoms by persons acting under Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution.
However, this Court is bound by Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR). The petitioner appreciates that he has no direct or indirect employment relationship with the respondents. His case is purely a public interest case. Therefore, although Article 165(5)(b) expressly excludes the High Court's jurisdiction over matters falling within the jurisdiction of the courts contemplated under Article 162(2) of the Constitution, public interest litigation removed from the court, assuming jurisdiction, would negate the guidance from a superior court.
The Petitioner relies on Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution to justify instituting these proceedings in the public interest. Those provisions confer a broad right to institute proceedings to enforce the Bill of Rights and the Constitution. In the circumstances, having moved this court before the judgment in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR), he shall not be penalised in costs.
Accordingly, objections dated 27 July, 2026 are allowed. The petition is struck out. No orders on costs.
Delivered in open court this 22nd day of October 2026
M. MBARŨ
JUDGE