Employment law

Abdullahi alias Abdikadir Mohamed v Royal Saudi Arabia Embassy [2026] KEELRC 14717 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause 135 of 2015
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

THAT for the reasons to be recorded, this Application be certified as urgent, service be dispensed with in the first instance and the matter be heard on a priority basis.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the court should summon Khalid bin Abdullah Al-Salman, the Saudi Arabian Ambassador, to show cause and punish him for contempt for non-compliance with the decree arising from the 19 July 2019 judgment; whether diplomatic immunity precluded committal…

Material facts

The Claimant stated that his employment was terminated in 2014 and that, in the judgment of 19 July 2019, the court found the termination unfair and ordered payment of USD 310,282, SAR 54,000, interest if unpaid by 19 September 2019, and costs. He said costs…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. 135 OF 2015

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

ABDIKADIR MOHAMED ABDULLAHI ALIAS

ABDIKADIR MOHAMED............................CLAIMANT/APPLICANT

VS

ROYAL SAUDI ARABIA EMBASSY….........................RESPONDENT

RULING

1 By a Notice of Motion dated 26th September 2025, brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 34 and 38 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 22 Rules 1, 6, 7, 31, 32 and 33, and Order 51 Rules 1 and 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Claimant/Applicant seeks orders that: -

1. THAT for the reasons to be recorded, this Application be certified as urgent, service be dispensed with in the first instance and the matter be heard on a priority basis.

2. THAT this Court issues summons to Khalid bin Abdullah Al-Salman to show cause why he should not be punished by this Court for Contempt of Court.

3. THAT Khalid bin Abdullah Al-Salman, the Ambassador of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to the Republic of Kenya, the above-named Contemnor be cited for contempt of this Honourable Court for wilfully disobeying the Orders issued by Honourable Justice Byram Ongaya on 19th July, 2019 and the resultant Decree served upon his office on 28th October, 2020.

4. THAT Khalid bin Abdullah Al-Salman, Ambassador of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to the Republic of Kenya, the above-named Contemnor be detained in prison for a period of Six (6) months or for such period as this Honourable Court shall deem necessary for being in disobedience of the Orders of this Honourable Court given 19th July, 2019.

5. THAT in addition to or in lieu of such committal, this Honourable Court be pleased to order the sequestration of the properties of the Royal Saudi Arabia Embassy, the Contemnor herein for disobedience and/or non-observance of the Orders of this Honourable Court given on 19th July, 2019.

6. THAT costs of this Application be borne by Khalid bin Abdullah Al-Salman, the Contemnor herein.

2 The application is premised on the grounds on its face and on the Supporting Affidavit of Abdikadir Mohamed Abdullahi sworn on 26th September 2025.

Claimant/Applicant’s Case

3 The Applicant avers that the Respondent unlawfully terminated his employment in 2014 without due process, prompting him to file the suit by a Memorandum of Claim dated 2nd February 2015.

4 He avers that by its judgment of 19th July 2019, the Court found the termination unfair, having been predicated on his grievance over salary arrears, which the Respondent acknowledged in the course of the proceedings. The Court then ordered the Respondent to pay him USD 310,282 plus SAR 54,000 by 19th September 2019, failing which interest at 14% per annum would accrue from the date of filing suit on 5th February 2015 until payment in full, together with the costs of the suit.

5 He further avers that the party and party costs were taxed at Kshs. 1,042,540.70, and that the judgment has not been varied or set aside and remains valid and binding.

6 The Applicant depones that his advocates extracted the Decree dated 14th August 2020 and served it, together with the judgment, on the Respondent through the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on 28th October 2020.

7 He states that the Principal Secretary, Ministry of Foreign and Diaspora Affairs, confirmed by a letter dated 13th March 2023 that the Decree had been forwarded to the Respondent. Despite this, the Respondent has refused to pay his dues for more than five years.

8 He avers that the Ambassador has knowledge of the orders but has chosen to disobey them, and that the Respondent is bent on delaying and obstructing execution, his advocates having been unable to attach its property despite warrants having been issued.

9 The Applicant contends that the Court does not issue its judgments in vain, and that unless the Contemnor is punished he will continue to disregard its orders with impunity, lowering the dignity of the Court and depriving the Applicant of the fruits of his judgment. He thus urged the Court to direct the Ambassador to personally appear and explain his disobedience, and to take stern action so as to uphold the authority of the Court, ensure observance of due process, and maintain public confidence in the administration of justice.

10 In his Further Affidavit dated 12th June 2026, sworn in response to the Respondent's replying affidavit dated 2nd March 2026, the Applicant contends that the replying affidavit was improperly filed and ought to be struck out.

11 He avers that contempt proceedings threaten personal liberty and are therefore quasi-criminal, so that due process requires that only the individual cited respond to, defend against, or purge the contempt.

12 The Applicant argued that since the proceedings are directed against the Ambassador, the response sworn by Khalid M. H. Al-Arishi, the Embassy's Head of Finance, who has neither been cited nor joined, is improper.

13 He further contends that the Replying Affidavit is diversionary and intended to mislead the Court.

14 On immunity, the Applicant avers that he is advised that this Court has jurisdiction over a suit against an embassy founded on a commercial contract such as one of employment, since any private person may enter into such a contract.

15 He contends that persons enjoying diplomatic immunity must respect the laws of the receiving state, including the Employment Act. Further, the Respondent relied on Kenyan employment law to compute his final dues and thereby waived its immunity.

16 The Applicant further avers that even if the Respondent considered the judgment and decree illegal or incapable of execution, defiance was not open to it. Its remedy was to apply to vary or set aside the orders, or to appeal, neither of which it did.

17 He states that the Respondent has not denied knowledge of the judgment or of the obligations it imposes, so that its continued disobedience is deliberate and willful.

18 He therefore urged the Court to cite and punish the Contemnor and to strike out the Replying Affidavit as frivolous and vexatious.

Respondent’s Case

19 The Respondent opposed the application through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 2nd March 2026 by Khalid M. H. Al-Arishi, the Head of Finance at the Royal Embassy of Saudi Arabia in Nairobi, who depones that he is duly authorized to swear it.

20 It is the Respondent's case that the application seeks to execute a null and void judgment, delivered on 19th July 2019, by summoning and ultimately committing to civil jail the Ambassador of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to the Republic of Kenya.

21 The Respondent avers that there is an error of law apparent on the face of the record which calls for the Court's urgent intervention, failing which it is poised to precipitate an unwarranted and avoidable diplomatic row.

22 It contends that the Ambassador, as the accredited representative and agent of the Monarch of Saudi Arabia, is the personification of the sending State.

23 It is the Respondent’s case that the application is in effect an attempt to summon and commit the Monarch to civil jail, an act wholly repugnant to international law and the law of diplomatic immunities.

24 The Respondent avers that should the Court proceed with the application, an immediate diplomatic rupture between the Republic of Kenya and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia would inevitably follow.

25 The Respondent further avers that the proceedings commenced by the Memorandum of Claim dated 5th February 2015 were irregular, unlawful and wholly incompetent. Therefore, the resulting judgment of 19th July 2019 is equally void, having been rendered in violation of Article 22 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, 1961 and of the Privileges and Immunities Act, Cap. 179.

26 It is the Respondent’s case that under these provisions it enjoys absolute immunity from the jurisdiction of Kenyan courts and is incapable of suing or being sued. In support, it relies on Kingsley Construction Limited v Embassy of the Federal Republic of Somalia to the Republic of Kenya [2020] eKLR.

27 The Respondent further avers that the Royal Embassy of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is not a juristic person, and that an agent of a disclosed principal, including a foreign mission acting on behalf of a sovereign State, cannot be sued.

28 It clarifies that it does not suggest that the Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the claim, but rather that the proper party to the proceedings ought to have been the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

29 It therefore contends that the suit is incurably defective and liable to be struck out with costs, and that the judgment, founded on proceedings undertaken without jurisdiction and in violation of international law, ought to be set aside or declared null and void ab initio.

30 In the overriding interests of justice, comity and international harmony, and to forestall an unnecessary diplomatic crisis, the Respondent urges the Court to dismiss the application and to set aside or vacate the judgment.

Claimant/Applicant’s Case

31 The Respondent submitted that the application raises issues beyond the ordinary execution of a decree, touching on Kenya's constitutional order, its obligations under international law, diplomatic immunity and the inviolability of diplomatic missions. In its view, the Court is confronted with a threshold jurisdictional question: whether execution can lawfully proceed on a judgment rendered against an entity which lacked capacity to be sued from the inception of the proceedings.

32 It identified as the issues for determination as: whether the Royal Saudi Arabia Embassy is a legal person capable of suing or being sued; whether the proceedings against it were incompetent ab initio, whether the judgment of 19th July 2019 is a nullity; whether the intended execution violates diplomatic immunity; and whether the Court should permit execution founded on a void judgment.

33 The Respondent submitted that Article 2(5) and (6) of the Constitution make the general rules of international law and ratified treaties part of the law of Kenya. The Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations is part of Kenyan law, domesticated through the Privileges and Immunities Act.

34 It argued that once a dispute touches on diplomatic missions or foreign sovereigns, the Court is constitutionally obliged to interpret domestic law consistently with Kenya's treaty obligations.

35 It is the Respondent’s submission that any interpretation permitting coercive process against a diplomatic mission or an accredited Ambassador would place Kenya in breach of both its Constitution and its international obligations.

36 The Respondent characterized its objection as jurisdictional, arguing that without jurisdiction there are no valid proceedings, judgment, decree or execution, and that the application wrongly assumes that execution must follow simply because a judgment exists.

37 The Respondent's primary submission was that the proceedings were incompetent from inception, having been instituted against the Embassy rather than the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

38 It is the Respondent’s submission that an embassy is merely the diplomatic representation through which a sovereign State conducts its relations with another. It is not a corporation, statutory body, natural person or artificial legal person, and has no juridical identity apart from the State that established it.

39 It was submitted that where proceedings are brought against an embassy, it contended, no competent defendant is before the Court.

40 The Respondent placed reliance on Ministry of Defence of the Government of the United Kingdom v Ndegwa[1983] eKLR and on Kingsley Construction Limited v Embassy of the Federal Republic of Somalia to the Republic of Kenya [2020] eKLR, where the High Court held: "In my view the Embassy is incapable of suing or being sued. Rather it was open for Kingsley to sue the state of Federal Republic of Somalia, but not its embassy in Kenya… It fails because there was no service of the summons upon the Federal Republic of Somalia and because leave was not sought to effect service out of the jurisdiction of this court."

41 It is the Respondent’s submission that the law cannot yield contradictory answers to identical questions, thus, if the embassy lacked capacity in Kingsley Construction, it equally lacked capacity here.

42 The Respondent submitted that independent of immunity, the Embassy is the agent of a disclosed principal, so that rights and liabilities attach to the Kingdom rather than to the Embassy.

43 It is the Respondent’s submission that courts have no authority to create a legal personality where Parliament has not done so.

44 The Respondent submitted that it does not contend that foreign States can never be sued, its complaint being narrower: the wrong legal entity was sued. Had the Claimant wished to sue the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, he was required to comply with the Vienna Convention, the Privileges and Immunities Act and the rules governing service outside Kenya, none of which were invoked.

45 It further submitted that jurisdiction cannot be acquired through mistake, acquiescence, consent, estoppel, passage of time or execution proceedings. If absent when the suit was filed, it remains absent today, so that the age of the judgment is legally irrelevant.

46 It is the Respondent's further submission that the judgment of 19th July 2019 is void ab initio. It drew a distinction between an irregular judgment, which is effective until set aside, and a void judgment, which has no legal existence.

47 Relying on Lord Denning's statement in Macfoy v United Africa Co. Ltd [1961] 3 All ER 1169 that a void act is "incurably bad", needing no order of the court to set it aside, and that every proceeding founded on it is equally void. It argued that the decree, execution, attachment and committal proceedings therefore all fall with the judgment, since a valid superstructure cannot be erected on a void foundation.

48 The Respondent further submitted that, even if the judgment were valid, the mode of execution sought is prohibited by international law. It relied on Article 29 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which provides:"The person of a diplomatic agent shall be inviolable. He shall not be liable to any form of arrest or detention."

49 It is the Respondent’s submission that this protection is absolute, and is neither qualified by the existence of a judgment nor displaced by execution proceedings. It relied on Article 22, which declares the premises of a mission inviolable and prohibits coercive measures against them without consent.

50 It was therefore submitted that the application fails on two independent grounds: the judgment is void, and the proposed execution against an accredited Ambassador is prohibited.

51 The Respondent submitted that execution is not an independent cause of action but derives its legitimacy from the decree, so that a void decree cannot found valid execution.

52 It further submitted that the Court possesses inherent jurisdiction to set aside a void judgment ex debito justitiae. Such an inquiry, it argued, requires no demonstration of sufficient cause, mistake or excusable error, the sole question being whether jurisdiction existed.

53 On public policy, it submitted that Kenya hosts numerous diplomatic missions whose operation depends on reciprocal observance of immunities. It maintained that disregarding them would invite reciprocal treatment of Kenyan missions abroad and expose the Republic to an avoidable diplomatic dispute with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

54 It further contended that the application is an abuse of the Court's process, since it invokes coercive powers without confronting the jurisdictional defect and would require a diplomatic representative to answer proceedings prohibited by treaty.

55 The Respondent therefore urged the Court to uphold its jurisdictional objection, to dismiss the application with costs, and to grant such further orders as are necessary to preserve the integrity of the Court's process and safeguard the inviolability of diplomatic missions and accredited diplomatic agents.

56 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. The applicant has sought orders to summon the ambassador of Saudi Arabia in Kenya to answer to the decree pending before court.

57 The respondents are opposed to this application on the ground of diplomatic immunity. It is worth noting that the applicant seeks to execute a valid judgment of this court that has not been appealed against and thus the argument that the judgment is null and void ab initio cannot stand.

58 The issue then is about how to execute this judgment. Summoning an Ambassador to be placed in civil jail is out of the question and the issue of contempt cannot lie against the ambassador in person. The respondents know who is responsible to make good the decree and so it would have been reasonable to summon the respondent to show cause why execution should not issue as opposed to issuance of a warrant of arrest.

59 I decline this application accordingly noting my sentiments above. There shall be no order of costs.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 22nd Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder