REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E146 OF 2026
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Anna Ngibuini Mwaure)
MARTIN WAMALWA WANYONYI ……….....…........APPELLANT
VERSUS
SENECA EAST AFRICA LIMITED ……….……..........RESPONDENT
(Being an Appeal from the judgment of the Honorable E. Riany(Ms.) Principal Magistrate delivered on 8th April 2026 in Nairobi MCELRC No. E1687 OF 2021)
JUDGMENT
1. The Appellant being dissatisfied by the entire judgment and decree of the Principal Magistrate Hon. E. Riany(Ms.) delivered on 8th April 2022 filed this appeal vide a memorandum of appeal dated 24th April 2026 on the grounds that: -
1. The appeal relates to the Appellant’s dissatisfaction with the trial court’s position on his claims on statutory gratuity as per the Regulation of Wages (Protective Security Services) Order, underpayment of salary, untaken leave days and unpaid salaries for the days worked in January.
2. The appeal is to be determined by the Employment and Labour Relations Court at a date, time and place to be set by notice to the parties. The appeal is based on the following grounds:
a. The learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact by denying the Appellant’s claim for statutory gratuity as per Regulation 17 of the Regulation of Wages(Protective Security Services) Order in the amount of Kshs. 125,794.20 and instead granting the Appellant service pay in the amount of Kshs. 66,000.00, which the Appellant did not pay for.
b. The learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact by dismissing the Appellant’s statutory claim for underpayment in the amount of Kshs.126,885.60 as per Regulation of Wages(General)(Amendment) Orders for the years 2015, 2017 and 2018.
c. The learned Magistrate erred in law by declining to be guided and be bound by the jurisprudence of this Honourable Court which supports the Appellant’s right to claim underpayment of salary as a continuing injury and as a statutory right.
d. The learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law by dismissing the Appellant’s claim for untaken leave days in the year 2020.
e. The learned Magistrate misdirected herself by computing the Appellant’s unpaid salary for 8 days worked in January 2021 using the contractual wage as opposed to the minimum statutory wages as set out in the Regulation of Wages(General)(Amendment) Order 2018.
2. The Appellant prays that:
a. The appeal be allowed with costs.
b. The learned Magistrate’s judgment appealed against be set aside.
c. This Honourable Court makes such orders that it may deem fit to meet the ends of justice.
3. Parties canvassed the appeal by way of written submissions.
Appellant’s submissions
4. The Appellant submitted that the trial court erred by awarding service pay instead of statutory gratuity under Regulation 17 of the Regulation of Wages (Protective Security Services) Order, 1998, despite his 11 years of service and retirement at age 57, citing cases such as George Onyango Akuti V G4S Security Services Kenya Ltd [2013] KEELRC 727 (KLR) and Kibiru V Mars Security Guards [2025] KEELRC 184 in support of that proposition.
5. The Appellant further claims underpayment of wages between 2015 to 2020, relying on the Regulation of Wages (General) Amendment Orders and cited the cases of Ramzan V Misango [2025] KEELRC 3083 and Ng’ang’a V Christ the King Parish [2023] KECA 1100, arguing underpayment is a continuing injury under section 89 of the Employment Act.
6. The Appellant also contests dismissal of his claim for 21 untaken leave days in 2020, citing the case of Rumba Mnyika Nguta V Southern Hills Development Agency Ltd [2020] KEELRC 85 in support of that proposition, and seeks payment of Kshs.12,230.03/=.
7. Additionally, the Appellant submitted that the computation of salary for 8 days worked in January 2021, arguing the trial court wrongly applied contractual wages instead of statutory minimums, and seeks Kshs.5,812.40/=.
8. Overall, the Appellant prays that the appeal be allowed, the trial court’s awards set aside, and substituted with statutory gratuity, underpayment, leave pay, and corrected salary computation.
Respondent’s submissions’
9. The Respondent submitted that this Honourable Court to undertake a fresh and complete appraisal of the record, recognizing that the monetary claims remain the Appellant’s burden to prove. In Ramzan v Misango(Supra), the Court reaffirmed that on a first appeal, the duty is to reconsider, re‑examine, and evaluate the evidence afresh, while bearing in mind that the appellate court neither saw nor heard the witnesses, as held in Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123, Peters v Sunday Post [1958] EA, and Imanyara & 2 Others v Attorney General [2016] KECA 557 (KLR).
10. The Respondent relied on sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act place the initial burden of proof upon the party asserting facts. While sections 10(7) and 74 of the Employment Act may shift an evidential burden where the employer fails to produce statutory records, such a shift only arises after a coherent claim has been pleaded. The Court cannot reconstruct a wage ledger from a single payslip or select among inconsistent figures. In Crepach Products Ltd v Makau [2023] KEELRC 1695 (KLR), the Court cautioned against treating computational daily rates as altering the fundamental monthly character of employment. The same discipline applies here: the Appellant was a monthly‑paid employee, and a daily rate cannot be introduced merely to enlarge the award.
11. On statutory gratuity, the Respondent relied on Regulation 17 of the Regulation of Wages (Protective Security Services) Order, 1998 entitles a qualifying guard to eighteen days’ pay for each completed year of service after five years, based on the wage at termination. In George Onyango Akuti v G4S Security Services Kenya Ltd(supra), the Court applied this formula but emphasised the need for proof of completed years and the exit wage. Likewise, Kibiru v Mars Security Guards(supra) confirmed gratuity entitlement only upon proof of twelve years’ service and the exit salary. Here, the Appellant produced only one payslip from August 2019, and no record of the January 2021 exit wage. On his own dates, only eleven years were completed, yielding 198 days. The only lawful computation is Kshs.91,384.62/=, derived from the proved gross wage of Kshs.12,000/=. The Appellant cannot recover both service pay and gratuity for the same period without a pleaded and proved basis for two distinct terminal benefits.
12. On underpayment, the Respondent submitted that the earlier appellate judgment in Martin Wamalwa Wanyonyi v Seneca East Africa Ltd (ELRCA/E178 of 2023) merely held that the claim was filed within time; it did not establish underpayment or quantum. The Respondent relied on the case of Ng’ang’a v Christ the King Parish [2023] KECA 1100 (KLR) confirms that minimum wage legislation is mandatory, but requires identification of the applicable wage order, period, and classification. Unlike Ramzan v Misango(Supra), where the employer admitted continuous payment of Kshs.4,000/=, the Appellant here relies on one payslip and inconsistent. The foundational data for a lawful award was not proved.
13. On leave, the Respondent relied on section 28 of the Employment Act which guarantees annual leave, but the Respondent argued that the Appellant failed to prove a 2020 balance. In Rumba Mnyika Nguta v Southern Hills Development Agency Ltd t/a Radio Kaya(supra), the Court monetised leave only where records showed precise balances. No equivalent records exist here, and the Appellant improperly enlarged his claim on appeal by shifting from Kshs.8,400/= pleaded to Kshs.12,230.03/=.
14. On January 2021 salary, the Respondent submitted that the trial court correctly awarded Kshs.3,096.77/= based on the proved monthly wage of Kshs.12,000/=. The Appellant’s attempt to substitute a statutory daily rate of Kshs.726.55/= is unsupported.
15. In conclusion, the Respondent urged the court to dismiss the appeal with costs.
Analysis and determination
16. Being the first appeal, it is the court’s duty to reassess the evidence presented, conduct its own analysis, and reach independent conclusions in order to determine whether the trial court’s findings align with both the evidence and the applicable law. The court should, however, bear in mind that it did not see the witnesses as they testified and give due allowance as reiterated above in the case of Selle V Associated Motor Boat Co Ltd & Others(Supra) and Peters V Sunday Post Limited(Supra)
17. Having considered the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal, and the submissions of the parties, the issue for determination is whether the appeal is merited and further should the court review the awards by the trial court.
18. Section 89 of the Employment Act provides as follows:
“Notwithstanding the provisions of section 4(1) of the Limitation of Actions Act (Cap. 22), no civil action
or proceedings based or arising out of this Act or a contract of service in general shall lie or be instituted
unless it is commenced within three years next after the act, neglect or default complained or in the case
of continuing injury or damage within twelve months next after the cessation thereof.”
19. In G4S Security Services (K) Limited v Joseph Kamau & 468 others [2018] KECA 827 (KLR) the Court of Appeal held as follows:
“In the circumstances of this case we find that such ‘unpaid terminal dues’ do not constitute a continuing injury as contemplated under the proviso to Section 90 of the Employment Act. The respondents assert claims arising from the termination of their employment and dues that accrued to each of them at the end of each month. Regarding ‘a continuing injury’, the proviso to Section 90 of the Employment Act requires that the claim be made within 12 months next after the cessation thereof. The learned Judge did not determine when the continuing injury ceased, for purposes of computing the twelve-month period. In the absence of a defined period, the learned Judge erred in concluding that the claims had no limitation of time. Further, upon the claimant’s dismissal, any claim based on a continuing injury ought to have been filed within one year failing which it was time barred.”
20. In this appeal, the Appellant, through his amended memorandum of claim dated 19th January 2023, stated that he was employed as a security guard from 1st June 2009 until 8th June 2021, earning a monthly gross salary of Kshs.12,000/=. He alleged that he worked as a night watchman in Nairobi from 2015 to 2021, was denied annual leave in 2020, had Kshs.46,000/= unlawfully deducted for a uniform, and was not paid for eight days worked in January 2021. By contrast, the Respondent maintained that the Appellant retired on 5th January 2021, as reflected in the certificate of service, and had consistently taken annual leave in previous years in line with company policy. It further argued that the uniform deduction was refundable and a cheque had been prepared, but the Appellant declined to collect it. The Respondent contended that all dues were settled upon issuance of the certificate of service, and that the claim was an afterthought intended to vex the company. The trial magistrate nonetheless entered judgment in favour of the Appellant, awarding Kshs.3,096.77/= for unpaid salary, Kshs.66,000/= for gratuity, Kshs.46,000/= for uniform, Kshs.43,200/= for deducted savings, together with costs of the suit.
21. The Appellant had earlier appealed against a preliminary objection dated 20th February 2023 in Nairobi CMELRC No. E1687 of 2021, which was heard in Nairobi ELRCA No. E178 of 2023. In that appeal, Abuodha J held that claims such as unpaid leave, underpayment, and unpaid savings constitute continuous injuries and must be filed within 12 months after cessation. Since the Appellant filed his claim within 8 months of retirement, the court found it was within time and that the trial court had misinterpreted section 90 of the Employment Act. The appeal was upheld, and the ruling of Hon. Murage delivered on 28th April 2023 was set aside.
22. In this case the Appellant was awarded gratuity as per the Regulation of wages. The Court upholds the same seeing no reason to review it.
23. On underpayment, the Court upholds the trial magistrate’s finding that claims for 2015, 2017, and 2018 were time‑barred. However, the Appellant is entitled to underpayment for 2019 and 2020, calculated as follows:
(15,141.95−12,000× 24 = Kshs.75,406.80
For five months in 2021:
3,141.95 × 5 = Kshs.15,709.75
75,406+15,709.75 = Kshs.91,116.55.
Total underpayment: Kshs.91,116.55.
24. Regarding leave, the Appellant produced documentation supporting his claim for untaken leave days in 2020. In line with sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, the Court is satisfied Appellant has proved his entitlement to leave. The Court awards him Kshs.12,230.03/= for leave.
25. The Court further upholds the awards for unpaid salary, deducted savings, and uniform.
26. Flowing from the foregoing, the appeal is partially allowed, and the awards are substituted as follows:
a) Gratuity pay: - Kshs.66,000/=
b) Underpayment: - Kshs.91,116.55;
c) Untaken leave: - Kshs.12,230.03;
d) Awards for unpaid
salary at - Kshs.3,096/77,
e) Deducted savings at - Kshs.46,000/=
and
f) Uniform refunds
remain as granted by
the trial court at - Kshs.66,000/=.
27. Each party shall bear its own costs of the Appeal but Appellant will be paid costs of the trial court.
28. Interest is granted at 14% per annum from date of Judgment till full payment.
It is so ordered.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nakuru this 23rd Day of October, 2026.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE
ORDER
In view of the declaration of measures restricting Court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open Court. In permitting this course, this Court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the Court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this Court the duty of the Court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.
A signed copy will be availed to each party upon payment of Court fees.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE