REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E847 OF 2023
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Anna Ngibuini Mwaure)
CECILIA MUKOYA……………………..………..……CLAIMANT
VERSUS
ANKOLE GRILL LIMITED………………………… RESPONDENT
RULING
1. Before this Honourable Court for determination is the question of whether the Notice to Produce should be enforced in respect of two original employment contracts, namely: the contract executed on 9th September 2021 and the contract allegedly executed on 28th August 2022.
2. The Claimant’s Notice to produce is dated 29th May 2026.
3. On 3rd June 2026 the court directed that both contracts be availed.
Respondent’s affidavit
4. The Respondent filed an affidavit dated 23rd June 2026 sworn by June Kinyua, the Respondent’s General Manager.
5. The deponent affirms her awareness of the directions issued by this Honourable Court on 3rd June 2026, which required the Respondent to produce the Claimant’s original employment contracts dated 4th June 2021 and 1st June 2022.
6. The deponent explains that despite conducting a diligent and extensive search of personnel files, archived records, and storage locations, the Respondent was unable to trace the Claimant’s personnel file, which appears to be missing in its entirety.
7. The deponent emphasizes that the Respondent has no intention of withholding evidence and continues internal inquiries to locate the originals, while noting that scanned copies of the contracts are available and had been relied upon in pleadings.
8. On advice of Counsel, the deponent invokes section 68(1)(c) of the Evidence Act, Cap 80, which permits reliance on secondary evidence where originals are lost without fault or neglect, and accordingly seeks leave of the Court to admit the scanned copies in place of the originals.
9. The Court directed the parties to file their submissions.
Claimant’s submissions
10. The Claimant identified three issues for determination: first, whether the Respondent is obligated to produce the original employment contracts dated 9th September 2021 and 28th August 2022, arguing that under section 67 of the Evidence Act and the best evidence rule, primary evidence must be produced unless statutory exceptions apply. The Claimant relied on cases such as Midrock Water Drilling Co Limited v National Water Conservation and Pipeline Corporation [2020] KEHC 10187 (KLR), In re the Estate of Charles Ndegwa Kiragu alias Ndegwa Kiragu – Deceased [2016] KEHC 6987 (KLR), and Jane Wambui V Stephen Mutembei & Another [2006] KEHC 2098 (KLR), all affirming the primacy of original documents. The Claimant also relied on section 2 of the Employment Act, 2007, which designates the employer as custodian of contracts.
11. Second, the Claimant submitted that the originals are material and necessary to resolve the authenticity of the alleged 2022 contract, invoking section 70 of the Evidence Act, which requires proof of handwriting and signatures, and cited the case of Oracle Productions Ltd v Decapture Ltd & 3 Others [2022] KEHC 16146 (KLR) on the purpose of discovery. The Claimant argued that forensic examination cannot be done on scanned copies, and that reliance on secondary evidence would frustrate their statutory right to proof.
12. Third, the Claimant contended that the Respondent has not met the threshold under section 68(1)(c) of the Evidence Act, which permits secondary evidence only where originals are lost without fault or neglect, criticizing the affidavit of June Kinyua for failing to explain how the personnel file vanished while digital scans survived. The Claimant further relied on sections 10 and 74 of the Employment Act, 2007, which obligate employers to keep accurate employee records, arguing that the Respondent’s failure amounts to professional neglect.
13. In conclusion, the Claimant urges the Court to compel production of the originals within seven days, failing which adverse inference should be drawn against the Respondent.
14. At the time of writing this ruling, the Respondent had not filed their respective submissions by filing a hard copy or on the CTS system.
Analysis and determination
15. Having considered the notice to produce, the affidavit and the submissions on record, the issue for determination is whether the Respondent should be compelled to produce the contracts in question dated 9th September 2021 and 28th August 2022.
16. Sections 10 and 74 of the Employment Act establish that the employer is the statutory custodian of employment records and must maintain accurate documentation of contracts of service. Complementing this, Section 67 of the Evidence Act provides that documents must ordinarily be proved by primary evidence, subject only to the exceptions outlined in Section 68 of the said Evidence Act which permits secondary evidence in narrowly defined circumstances. These include situations where the original is in the possession of an adverse party who fails to produce it after notice under Section 69 of Evidence Act, where its contents are admitted in writing, where the original has been destroyed or lost without fault of the party relying on it, where the original is immovable, where it is a public document under Section 79 of Evidence Act and where a certified copy is permitted by law, or where the original consists of numerous records such that only the general result is required. Subsection (2) further clarifies the admissibility of different forms of secondary evidence depending on the situation: any secondary evidence where originals are lost or withheld, written admissions where applicable, certified copies for public or legally permitted documents, and expert summaries for voluminous records. In essence, the statutory framework prioritizes primary evidence while allowing secondary evidence only under strict and limited exceptions, thereby safeguarding the integrity of judicial proceedings.
17. In case of the Estate of Charles Ndegwa Kiragu alias Ndegwa Kiragu – Deceased(supra), Mativo J stated as follows:
“My interpretation the above provisions of the Evidence Act is that secondary evidence as a general rule is admissible only in the absence of primary evidence and when a proper explanation of its absence is given. Such secondary evidence cannot be admitted without the non-production of the original being first accounted for in a permissible manner and only after satisfying the conditions provided for under Section 68 of the Act.
In other words, there must be proper justification to allow a party to adduce secondary evidence.”
18. In this instant case, the Claimant filed a Notice to Produce seeking the original employment contracts dated 9th September 2021 and the contract allegedly executed on 28th August 2022. The Respondent, however, contends that it is unable to trace the originals, stating that the Claimant’s entire employment file appears to be missing. The Respondent’s General Manager JUNE KINYUA depones they conducted a diligent and extensive search and yet could not trace the Claimant’s original file. The court having no reason to doubt the Respondent’s evidence will accept their explanation instead. The Respondent however maintains that it holds scanned copies of the contracts, which had previously been preserved in its records and relied upon in its pleadings before the Court.
19. The Court, having considered the Respondent’s explanation regarding its inability to trace the original employment contracts, is satisfied that the loss of the Claimant’s personnel file has been sufficiently accounted for. Consequently, the Court holds that the only documents available for reliance are the scanned copies previously maintained in the Respondent’s records and forming part of its pleadings. In light of the circumstances presented, the Court accepts the production of the scanned copies as the operative evidence.
20. The Claimant has not proved the scanned copies are not true copies of the original.
21. In the circumstances the scanned copies are admitted and case will proceed.
It is so ordered.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nakuru this 23rd Day of October, 2026.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE
ORDER
In view of the declaration of measures restricting Court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open Court. In permitting this course, this Court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the Court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this Court the duty of the Court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.
A signed copy will be availed to each party upon payment of Court fees.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE