Employment law

Kyenze & another v Makueni County Assembly Service Board & 3 others [2026] KEELRC 14736 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E028 of 2026
Judgment date
26 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

Open case research →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. E028 OF 2026

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

MESHACK KYENZE..................................................1ST CLAIMANT

FAUSTINE MUTUKU................................................2ND CLAIMANT

VS

MAKUENI COUNTY ASSEMBLY

SERVICE BOARD………………………………………1ST RESPONDENT

THE CLERK, MAKUENI COUNTY ASSEMBLY......2ND RESPONDENT

THE SPEAKER,MAKUENI COUNTYASSEMBLY....3RD RESPONDENT

THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY OF MAKUENI.............4TH RESPONDENT

RULING

1 Before this Court is the Claimants/Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 26th February 2025 wherein they are seeking the following orders:-

I. Spent

II. THAT Honourable Court be pleased to issue conservatory orders staying the implementation of the resolution of the 1 Respondent dated 19th February 2026 abolishing the office of Deputy Clerk (Administration) and Assistant Director (Public Communications and Media Relation) to be implemented on 2nd March 2026 pending the hearing and determination of this application;

III. THAT Honourable Court be pleased to issue conservatory orders staying the implementation of the resolution of the 1st Respondent dated 19th February 2026 abolishing the office of Deputy Clerk (Administration) and Assistant Director (Public Communications and Media Relation) to be implemented on 2nd March 2026 pending the hearing and determination of this suit;

IV. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to issue an injunction restraining the Respondents from undertaking any exercise towards removing, replacing, or interfering with the Applicants’ employment and/or declaring the Applicants redundant pending hearing and determination of this application;

V. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to issue an injunction restraining the Respondents from undertaking any exercise towards removing, replacing, or interfering with the Applicants’ employment and/or declaring the Applicants redundant pending hearing and determination of this suit;

VI. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to issue an order restraining the Respondents from implementing the said resolution, undertaking any exercise towards removing, replacing, or interfering with the Applicants’ employment and for declaring the Applicants redundant pending hearing and determination of the main suit;

VII. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to issue prohibitory orders stopping the 1st Respondent from interferir3 with the County Assembly of Makueni organizational structure, staff establishment, review and amendment of schemes of service, work distribution, staff recruitments or promotion, deployment and re-designation of staff, pending the hearing and determination of this Application and main suit;

VIII. THAT this Honourable Court do issue orders restraining the Respondents from barring the Applicants from accessing their offices or interfering with their terms of service pending the hearing of this suit;

IX. THAT an order do issue preserving the status quo pending the determination of this Application and the main suit;

X. THAT this Honourable Court do issue any other order it may deem fit and expedient in the circumstances of this case; and

XI. THAT the costs of this Application be provided for.

2 The application is supported by an undated affidavit of MESHACK KYENZE, the 1st Claimant/Applicant.

Respondent/Applicant’s Case

3 The Applicants aver that they are lawful employees of the 3rd Respondent, holding valid contracts of employment and enjoying protected tenure under the County Assembly Services Act.

4 The 1st Applicant avers that he was appointed as Assistant Director, Public Communications and Media Relations, effective 1st July 2022, while the 2nd Applicant was appointed as Deputy Clerk (Administration), effective 14th July 2022. Both were subsequently confirmed in employment on 28th March 2024.

5 The Applicants state that on 19th February 2026, the 1st Respondent passed a resolution abolishing the offices of Deputy Clerk (Legislation and Procedure), Deputy Clerk (Administration), and Assistant Director (Public Communications and Media Relations), with the decision communicated through an internal memorandum issued by the 2nd Respondent and made effective on 20th February 2026.

6 They contend that the resolution was abrupt, unilateral and made without prior notice, consultation, a hearing or an opportunity to make representations, and that its implementation was scheduled for 2nd March 2026.

7 The Applicants assert that the decision amounts to an unlawful and procedurally unfair termination of their employment disguised as restructuring and redundancy.

8 It is their case that the Respondents failed to comply with Section 40 of the Employment Act and violated their rights under the Constitution, the Fair Administrative Action Act and the County Assembly Services Act.

9 They further maintain that the decision was arbitrary, unreasonable and an abuse of statutory power, and that they were not informed of any restructuring plan, overlap of duties or financial constraints justifying the abolition of their offices.

10 The Applicants aver that they have diligently performed their duties and have never been subjected to disciplinary proceedings or poor-performance allegations.

11 It is the Applicants’ case that there was no overlap of duties or responsibilities warranting the abolition of their offices.

12 They further aver that, under Section 12(7)(b) of the County Governments Act, the 1st Respondent lacks the power or mandate to abolish an established office.

13 They assert that the impugned decision is a smokescreen intended to remove them from office without following the prescribed procedures, thereby violating their legitimate expectation and right to be heard.

14 The Applicants state that they face an imminent risk of being locked out of their offices, replaced, or deprived of their salaries and benefits, occasioning irreparable financial and professional harm.

15 They are apprehensive that the Respondents may fill the newly created or merged office of Deputy Clerk or permanently dissolve the office of Assistant Director, Public Communications and Media Relations before the determination of the suit, thereby rendering their claim nugatory.

Respondents’ Case

16 The Respondents opposed the application through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 17th April 2026 by Kevin Mutuku, the Clerk of the County Assembly of Makueni and the Secretary to the 1st Respondent.

17 The Respondents aver that the application is premature and that this Court lacks jurisdiction for failure by the Applicants to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanism under Section 77 of the County Governments Act, which grants the Public Service Commission jurisdiction to hear appeals relating to employment decisions affecting county public officers.

18 They further rely on Section 9(2) of the Fair Administrative Action Act, which requires exhaustion of available internal mechanisms before approaching the Court.

19 The Respondents aver that in January 2026, the 1st Respondent commissioned and considered a report on the rationalisation of the organisational structure and review of schemes of service. The report identified duplication of roles, functional overlaps and inefficiencies within the County Assembly, necessitating institutional restructuring.

20 They state that, following deliberations on the report during its meeting held between 19th and 22nd February 2026, the Board passed Resolution No. 09 of 2026 dated 19th February 2026, resolving to abolish certain offices to enhance efficiency, eliminate duplication and promote optimal utilization of human resources.

21 The Respondents maintain that the restructuring was undertaken in good faith, within their statutory mandate and in compliance with the law.

22 They rely on Section 24(3) of the County Assembly Services Act, which mandates the 1st Respondent to make arrangements concerning the creation, division, amalgamation or abolition of any directorate or department of the Service.

23 It is the Respondents’ case that the abolition of the offices did not amount to termination of the Applicants’ employment.

24 The Respondents state that the 1st Applicant remains an employee of the County Assembly and that administrative processes are underway to identify a suitable position for his redeployment within the revised establishment.

25 They aver that neither Applicant has been issued with a termination letter, and their salaries, benefits and contractual entitlements have not been withdrawn, suspended or terminated. They therefore describe the Applicants’ apprehension of imminent dismissal and loss of benefits as unfounded and speculative.

26 The Respondents further aver that, through Resolution No. 10 of 2026 dated 4th March 2026, the Board resolved to fill the office of Deputy Clerk through a competitive internal aptitude-based assessment.

27 They state that the 1st Applicant was not required to participate in the process because his placement was being handled under a separate redeployment framework, while the 2nd Applicant was invited to undertake the assessment on 9th March 2026 but did not attend, having notified the Board that he was on five days’ sick leave.

28 The Respondents contend that an acting officer was subsequently appointed under Resolution No. 12 of 2026 to ensure continuity of service delivery pending completion of the recruitment process.

29 They maintain that the 2nd Applicant is yet to undertake the aptitude test and may still retain his position if successful, rendering the suit premature.

30 It is the Respondents’ case that the impugned decision was an administrative and policy function rather than a disciplinary process requiring the rigors of fair administrative procedure.

31 They further rely on the doctrine of separation of powers and the County Assemblies Powers and Privileges Act, 2017, arguing that the Court ought to exercise restraint and refrain from interfering with lawful internal and procedural decisions of the 1st Respondent in the absence of demonstrable irrationality, illegality or procedural impropriety.

32 The Respondents deny violating Articles 41, 47 and 236 of the Constitution, maintaining that they acted within their statutory mandate and in accordance with the principles of fair administrative action.

33 They assert that the Applicants have demonstrated neither prejudice nor irreparable harm, as their employment remains intact, and have failed to establish a prima facie case warranting the orders sought.

Claimants/Applicants’ Submissions

34 The Applicants identified the issues for determination as whether the 2nd Claimant/Applicant has demonstrated a prima facie case with a probability of success; whether the 2nd Claimant/Applicant stands to suffer irreparable injury which would not be compensated by an award of damages; whether the balance of convenience tilts in the favour of the 2nd Claimant/Applicant; and who shall bear the costs of this Application.

35 The Applicants submitted that to obtain the orders sought, they must satisfy the conditions in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co Ltd (1973) EA 358: "First an applicant must show a prima facie case with a probability of success. Secondly, an interlocutory injunction will not normally be granted unless the applicant might otherwise suffer irreparable injury which would not adequately be compensated by an award of damages. Thirdly if the court is in doubt, it will decide an application on the balance of convenience."

36 On what amounts to a prima facie case, they relied on Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 others [2003] KECA 175 (KLR), where the Court held that it is "more than an arguable case… The evidence must show an infringement of a right and the probability of success of the applicant's case upon trial." They also relied on Rose Njeri Ndegwa v Samuel Sobi J. Misingu [2019] eKLR for the position that conservatory orders are similar to injunctions, so the applicant must show a prima facie case and irreparable loss.

37 On the prima facie case, it was submitted that the Applicants are lawful employees with valid contracts and protected tenure under the County Assembly Services Act, and that they held their respective offices until the 1st Respondent resolved on 19th February 2026 to abolish them. The 2nd Applicant was appointed on 27th June 2022 and confirmed on 28th March 2024.

38 The Applicants submitted that they have served diligently with clean records, free of any performance or disciplinary proceedings. They argued that the internal memo abolishing their offices came as a shock, since there had never been any overlap of duties to justify the abolition, and they had never been told of any restructuring plan or financial constraints.

39 It is the Applicants’ submission that the decision was made abruptly and implemented without notice, consultation or a hearing, in breach of the Constitution, the Fair Administrative Action Act, the County Assembly Services Act and the Employment Act.

40 The Applicants argued that the Board's power to restructure is not unfettered. They relied on Section 12(7) of the County Governments Act, which mandates the Board to provide services and facilities for the efficient functioning of the county assembly and to constitute offices in the county assembly service.

41 They further relied on Section 24 of the County Assembly Services Act. Section 24(3) allows the Board to make arrangements for "the creation, division, amalgamation or abolition of any directorate or department of the Service", but Section 24(4) requires that "the Board shall, for the purposes of reviewing the organizational structure under subsection (3), appoint a reputable human resource firm to advise on the effectiveness and efficiency of the intended review." They contended that without a documented report from an independent human resource firm, the abolition of their offices was procedurally flawed and illegal.

42 The Applicants further submitted that the Respondents produced no proof that the offices were superfluous, no evidence of the criteria used to abolish them, and no evidence that the proposal was submitted to the County Assembly for approval or that the affected department was given an opportunity to make representations.

43 It was submitted that even if the reasons for the abolition were valid, the Respondents were bound to follow the redundancy procedure under Section 40 of the Employment Act; which provides that an employer shall not terminate a contract of service on account of redundancy unless the employer complies with its conditions, including notifying the employee personally in writing and the labour officer, considering seniority, skill, ability and reliability in selecting employees, and paying notice, leave and severance pay.

44 They submitted that failure to notify the area labour officer renders a redundancy automatically unfair. They cited Kenya Airways v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that pre-redundancy consultations "are a crucial element of the redundancy process and must be substantive rather than merely formal and cosmetic."

45 They argued that there are no minutes or other evidence showing that they were consulted or given a chance to explore alternatives, and that implementing the abolition "effective immediately" amounts to a malicious and veiled summary dismissal and a smokescreen to remove them from office.

46 On constitutional rights, the Applicants submitted that the Respondents violated their rights to fair labour practices under Article 41 and to fair administrative action under Article 47 and Section 4(3) of the Fair Administrative Action Act, as well as the values and principles of public service under Article 232.

47 In support of their case, they relied on Kisumu County Assembly Service Board & another v Kisumu County Assembly Public Service Board & 4 others [2015] KEELRC 1474 (KLR) for the position that county assembly service boards are bound by Articles 41 and 47. They also relied on Article 236 of the Constitution, which provides that a public officer shall not be dismissed, removed from office, demoted in rank or otherwise subjected to disciplinary action without due process of law.

48 The Applicants further cited Mutuiri v Speaker, Laikipia County Assembly & another [2024] KEELRC 680 (KLR) for the proposition that labour matters are both statutory and constitutional, and County Assembly of Migori & 3 others v Ouma & 2 others [2025] KECA 6 (KLR) for the holding that a party may raise constitutional violations within a memorandum of claim. They also relied on County Government of Nyeri & another v Cecilia Wangechi Ndungu [2015] eKLR arguing that upholding the Respondents' action would render the right to fair administrative action a dead letter and set a precedent "where public offices are held at the whim of political bodies rather than the dictates of the law."

49 On jurisdiction, the Applicants submitted that the suit is not premature, as the Respondents contend. Reliance was placed on Situma v Bungoma County Assembly Service Board (CASB) & 2 others [2022] KEELRC 13285 (KLR) where the Court held that neither the Constitution nor the County Governments Act gives the Public Service Commission jurisdiction over employment claims by employees of county assembly service boards, and that no clear redress mechanism exists for appeals from such boards' decisions. The Court therefore found that it "has original jurisdiction to hear and determine claims by employees who allege services were terminated unfairly or for other grievance by employees against the County Assembly Service Boards."

50 On irreparable injury, the Applicants relied on Marsh View Limited v Benvar Estates Limited [2020] eKLR which cited Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 others [2014] eKLR, for the principle that the court must be satisfied the injury will be irreparable if the injunction is refused. They submitted that they face an imminent risk of being locked out of their offices and losing their salaries and benefits, which would cause them irreparable financial and professional damage.

51 It is the Applicants’ submission that the abolition is a sham, because someone has already been appointed to the supposedly abolished office of the 2nd Applicant in an acting capacity and is approving documents, although that person does not qualify for the role under the 4th Respondent's schemes of service.

52 They further submitted that the 2nd Applicant was invited to an aptitude test for an office he was already appointed to and qualified for. He could not attend because he was on sick leave, which he communicated to the Respondents, and despite his return to work they have not re-invited him. They contended that unless the Court intervenes, they and their families will lose their livelihoods and their claim will be rendered a mere academic exercise.

53 On the balance of convenience, the Applicants submitted that the Court ought to favour the course carrying the lower risk, and that the balance tilts in their favour since the Respondents would suffer no substantial prejudice if the application were allowed. They relied on Patriotic Guards Ltd v James Kipchirchir Sambu [2018] eKLR for the principle that judicial discretion must be exercised judiciously "upon certain legal principles and according to the circumstances of each case and the paramount need by the Court to do real and substantive justice to the parties to the suit." They also cited Lochab Bros. Limited V Peter Kaluma T/A Lumumba Mumma & Kaluma Advocates & 2 Others [2013]eKLR to the effect that the Court's main concern is to do justice to the parties.

54 On costs, the Applicants relied on Section 27(1) of the Civil Procedure Act, Cecilia Karuru Ngayu v Barclays Bank of Kenya & another [2016] eKLR and Party of Independent Candidate of Kenya v Mutula Kilonzo & 2 others, HC EP No. 6 of 2013 for the rule that costs follow the event, and submitted that there are no good grounds to depart from it.

55 It is therefore the Applicants submission that they have satisfied the three Giella principles and that the Court has jurisdiction over the dispute. They urged the Court to allow the application with costs.

Respondents’ Submissions

56 The Respondents identified three issues for determination: whether the Applicants have met the threshold for conservatory and interlocutory injunctive orders; whether the Board acted within its constitutional and statutory mandate; and whether the application is premature for failure to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanism.

57 On the first issue, the Respondents submitted that although the application also seeks injunctions, its substance is the suspension of a public body's administrative decisions, so the principles governing conservatory orders apply. They relied on Gatirau Peter Munya v Dickson Mwenda Kithinji & 2 others [2014] eKLR where the Supreme Court held that "conservatory orders bear a more decided public law connotation: for these are orders to facilitate ordered functioning within public agencies, as well as to uphold the adjudicatory authority of the Court, in the public interest," and that they "should be granted on the inherent merit of a case, bearing in mind the public interest, the constitutional values and the proportionate magnitudes and priority levels attributable to the relevant causes."

58 They also relied on Centre For Rights Education And Awareness (Creaw) & 7 Others V Attorney General [2011] eKLR for the position that the Court must balance competing public and private interests before granting such relief. The Respondents submitted that the Applicants must therefore show more than dissatisfaction with an administrative decision, and that the Court must be satisfied the public interest favours suspending the decisions of a statutory body.

59 It is the Respondents’ submission that the Applicants fall short of that threshold, as their application rests on apprehension and speculation rather than fact.

60 They submitted that the Applicants have produced no termination letter, dismissal notice, redundancy notice, revocation of appointment, stoppage of salary or withdrawal of benefits. Paragraphs 15 and 16 of the replying affidavit, they pointed out, state that the Applicants' contracts remain intact and their remuneration and benefits continue uninterrupted, and those averments have not been controverted. They contended that the application conflates the abolition of offices with the termination of contracts of employment, which are legally distinct concepts.

61 Even applying the test in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co Ltd [1973] EA 358 and the definition of a prima facie case in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 others [2003] KECA 175 (KLR), as a case where "there exists a right which has apparently been infringed by the opposite party as to call for an explanation or rebuttal from the latter," they argued that no apparent infringement of the Applicants' rights has been shown.

62 They further submitted that suspending Resolution No. 09 of 2026 at this stage would effectively restore the previous structure and grant the Applicants the principal relief in the main claim before trial, which interlocutory relief should not do.

63 On the Board's mandate, the Respondents submitted that the restructuring was carried out under powers conferred by the Constitution and statute. They argued that the Board, established under the County Assembly Services Act, 2017, is responsible for the efficient functioning of the County Assembly and is bound by Articles 10 and 232 of the Constitution. Sections 11, 12 and 24 of that Act, they submitted, give it authority over staffing, the establishment of offices, deployment, organizational structures and institutional management, and therefore the power to review and reorganize its structures, provided it acts lawfully.

64 It was submitted that the Applicants' reliance on Section 12(7)(b) of the County Governments Act rests on an unduly restrictive reading, and that the two statutes are complementary and must be read together.

65 The Respondents argued that the restructuring was neither arbitrary nor impulsive. Before implementation, the Board commissioned the January 2026 Report on the Proposal for Rationalization of the Organizational Structure and Review of Schemes of Service. The Report identified duplication of functions, fragmented reporting structures, workload imbalance, inefficient deployment of staff, over-centralization of technical functions and inefficient use of public resources. The Board deliberated on the Report at meetings held between 19th and 22nd February 2026 before passing Resolution No. 09 of 2026. It found that the offices of Deputy Clerk (Administration), Deputy Clerk (Legislation and Procedure) and Assistant Director, Public Communications and Media Relations had overlapping functions requiring rationalization. They submitted that this documented process of professional evaluation, deliberation and formal resolution negates the allegations of arbitrariness, malice and bad faith.

66 The Respondents further submitted that no public officer has a vested proprietary interest in the continued existence of a particular office, since public offices exist for the benefit of the public and not the office holder. They contended that their conduct shows an intention to preserve, rather than terminate, the Applicants' employment. Resolution No. 10 of 2026 confined recruitment into the newly established office of Deputy Clerk exclusively to the two officers who previously held the affected offices. When the 2nd Applicant informed the Board that he could not attend the aptitude assessment due to illness, the Board appointed an acting officer pending completion of the recruitment, a temporary arrangement that they argued cannot be construed as termination.

67 In support thereof, they cited Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal recognised the employer's managerial prerogative to organize and run its business as it considers best, including restructuring, provided it acts within the law. They also relied on Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei & another [2014] eKLR for the position that courts should not interfere with legitimate managerial decisions merely because employees disagree with them.

68 It is the Respondents’ submission the Applicants merely disagree with the Board's policy decision, which alone cannot justify judicial intervention at the interlocutory stage.

69 On exhaustion, the Respondents submitted that the suit was filed prematurely, without first invoking the appeal mechanism to the Public Service Commission under Section 77 of the County Governments Act. They relied on Speaker of the National Assembly v James Njenga Karume [1992] eKLR where the Court of Appeal held that "where there is a clear procedure for the redress of any particular grievance prescribed by the Constitution or an Act of Parliament, that procedure should be strictly followed."

70 They further relied on Mutanga Tea & Coffee Company Ltd v Shikara Limited & another [2015] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that an aggrieved party must first resort to a dispute resolution mechanism prescribed by the Constitution or statute before invoking the court's jurisdiction. While acknowledging that the doctrine is not absolute, they argued that the burden of showing exceptional circumstances rests on the Applicants, who have not alleged that the Commission lacked jurisdiction, was biased, or offered an unavailable or inadequate remedy. They submitted that although the Court retains jurisdiction, it ought to decline to exercise it at this interlocutory stage.

71 It is the Respondents’ submission that the Applicants have failed to establish a prima facie case, irreparable harm, or that the balance of convenience and the public interest favor the orders sought, and have shown no illegality, irrationality, procedural impropriety or constitutional violation warranting the Court's intervention.

72 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. The applicant’s contention is the unilateral abolition of offices by the respondents when they have subsisting valid contracts of employment. They contend that the decision was made abruptly and without consultation or having fair administrative action.

73 The respondents have raised serious issues on the jurisdiction of the PSC on this matter which is the appellate level on matters pending before this court and which this court cannot ignore.

74 In view of this preposition, I find that suspending the decision already made will lead to determining this cause to its finality at this interlocutory stage. I decline this invitation and order status quo be maintained pending the hearing and determination of the main cause. Costs in the cause.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 26th Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder