Employment law

Kenya Shipping Clearing Freight Logistics and Warehouses Workers Union v Vegpro (K) Ltd & another [2026] KEELRC 14781 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause 1415 of 2018
Judgment date
28 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The prayers sought in the Application are incapable of being granted as such, it would serve no purpose to allow the application.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. 1415 OF 2018

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

KENYA SHIPPING CLEARING FREIGHT LOGISTICS

AND WAREHOUSES WORKERS UNION.........................CLAIMANT

VS

VEGPRO (K) LTD..................……………………….......RESPONDENT

AND

KENYA UNION OF COMMERCIAL

FOOD & ALLIED WORKERS……………………INTERESTED PARTY

RULING

1 In opposition to the Claimant’s Application dated 5th May, 2026, the Respondent raised a Preliminary Objection on points of law and sought the application be struck out in limine on the following grounds

1. The prayers sought in the Application are incapable of being granted as such, it would serve no purpose to allow the application.

2. THAT the proceedings herein offend the principle of Res judicata as provided for in section 7 of the Civil procedure Act Cap 21 Laws of Kenya in view of the fact that the issues raised in the present application were directly and substantially in issue in the main cause. were heard and finally determined by this Honourable Court in its judgment delivered on 22nd May, 2025 and further addressed in the Ruling delivered on 25th February 2026 and cannot be re-litigated.

3. THAT in the alternative to paragraph 2 above herein, the proceedings herein are barred by virtue of the operation of the doctrine of issue estoppel.

4. THAT this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction to hear this matter as it became functus officio upon delivery of its judgment delivered on 22nd May, 2025.Consequently this court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the present Application, which seeks to obtain a fresh monetary decree of Kshs. 20,000,000/= not awarded in the Judgment and to have the Court determine matters not adjudicated upon at trial, including the number of alleged beneficiaries and the quantum allegedly recoverable, thereby inviting the Court to sit on appeal over, vary and enlarge its own Judgment.

5. THAT the present application as taken out, drawn and filed is frivolous, vexatious, scandalous, incompetent, misconceived, fatally defective, is a blatant abuse of the court process, unsustainable, bad and a nullity in law, merely intended to frustrate the Respondent therefore is of no legal consequence or at all.

6. THAT the Claimant's Notice of Motion dated 5th May, 2026 is incompetent, misconceived, bad in law and an abuse of the process of this Honourable Court and ought to be struck out and/or dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

Respondent’s Submissions

2 The Respondent framed the issues for determination as whether there is a valid preliminary objection; whether the application is barred by res judicata and issue estoppel; whether the Court is functus officio; whether the Court has jurisdiction to enter Kshs. 20,000,000 as part of the judgment debt; and whether the application is an abuse of the court process.

3 On the first issue, the Respondent relied on Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd (1969) EA 696, as adopted by the Supreme Court in Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya v Kenya Airways Limited & 3 others [2015] eKLR , for the principle that a preliminary objection does not depend on the discretion of the court or the production of evidence.

4 It further relied on John Mugo Gachuki V New Nyamakima Co. Ltd [2012] eKLR, where Odunga J. adopted the holding of Ojwang J. in Oraro v Mbaja [2005] eKLR that a preliminary objection "is a point of law which must not be blurred with factual details liable to be contested and in any event, to be proved through the processes of evidence."

5 It is the Respondent’s submission that its objection is sound and valid, as it rests entirely on Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, issue estoppel, functus officio and the Court's jurisdiction after judgment, all of which are purely legal questions requiring no evidence.

6 On res judicata, the Respondent submitted that the Claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 5th May 2026 was barred by Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, which prohibits the re-litigation of matters directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, where those matters have been heard and finally determined by a competent court.

7 Relying on Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] eKLR, The Respondent argued that the doctrine serves to bring litigation to finality and prevent parties from being vexed twice over the same matter. It maintained that the parties, subject matter and issues in the present application were substantially the same as those previously determined by the Court.

8 The Respondent submitted that the judgment delivered on 22nd May 2025 had addressed the issue of the refund of the Kshs.1,000 medical check-up fee. Subsequently, the Claimant filed a Notice of Motion dated 13th October 2025 seeking, among other reliefs, orders relating to the refund. In its ruling delivered on 25th February 2026, the Court held at paragraph 55 that: “The only way the applicant can access the Kshs.1,000 is through an execution process and not through this application.” The Court further observed that retrying the issue would amount to changing its judgment and sitting on appeal over its own decision.

9 The Respondent argued that these findings conclusively determined the permissible avenue for pursuing the refund and precluded the Claimant from returning to Court through another post-judgment application seeking substantially similar relief.

10 Relying on John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another v Cabinet Secretary, Transport and Infrastructure & 3 others [2021] eKLR, the Respondent contended that a party cannot circumvent res judicata by reframing its pleadings or introducing further arguments concerning the same subject matter. It also relied on E.T. v Attorney General & another [2012] eKLR for the proposition that the doctrine extends to matters that ought to have been raised in the earlier proceedings.

11 It is the Respondent’s submission that the Claimant’s present attempt to have Kshs.20,000,000 entered as part of the judgment debt was, in substance, an attempt to reopen an issue already determined by the Court and was therefore barred by Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act.

12 On estoppel, the Respondent submitted that an issue judicially determined by a competent court cannot be reopened in subsequent proceedings founded on the same facts and evidence.

13 Relying on Mohamed Dado Hatu v Dhadho Gaddae Godhana & 2 others [2017] eKLR, which cited Anthony Raymond Cordiero & 2 Others v Adrian Noel Carvalho & 5 Others, Civil Suit No. 627 of 2017, it argued that a party is precluded from re-litigating an issue already decided and that permitting such proceedings would constitute an abuse of process.

14 The Respondent maintained that the Court had conclusively determined, through its judgment of 22nd May 2025 and ruling of 25th February 2026, the issue of the medical check-up fee refund and the proper procedure for pursuing it. It therefore contended that the Claimant could not avoid the effect of those determinations by changing the relief from a refund to the entry of Kshs.20,000,000 as part of the judgment debt.

15 On the doctrine of functus officio, the Respondent submitted that, having delivered judgment on 22nd May 2025 and subsequently ruled on the Claimant’s post-judgment application on 25th February 2026, the Court had exhausted its adjudicative mandate over the matters in dispute.

16 Relying on Raila Odinga & 2 others v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 3 others [2013] eKLR it argued that the doctrine gives effect to the finality of judicial decisions by preventing a court from reopening or varying a matter it has finally determined, subject to recognised exceptions and the right of appeal. It further relied on Telkom Kenya Limited v John Ochanda [2014] eKLR, in which the Court of Appeal affirmed that functus officio prevents the reopening of a matter after a final decision has been rendered.

17 The Respondent contended that the orders now sought would require the Court to determine whether 1,000 employees were beneficiaries of the judgment, adopt a list of employees that was not produced at trial, ascertain whether the relevant deductions had been made, assess the alleged aggregate sum of Kshs.20,000,000 and incorporate that amount into the decree.

18 It is the Respondent’s submission that these steps would not constitute execution of the existing judgment but a fresh adjudication of matters that had neither been pleaded and proved nor determined at trial. Consequently, the Court would be impermissibly enlarging its judgment.

19 Relying on Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1, the Respondent submitted that jurisdiction is fundamental and that, having become functus officio, the Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the application.

20 On whether the Court could enter Kshs.20,000,000 as part of the judgment debt, the Respondent submitted that the relief sought was unknown to law. It argued that neither the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, 2011, the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, nor the Civil Procedure Act and Civil Procedure Rules conferred jurisdiction on the Court to convert an unquantified finding into a fresh monetary decree after judgment.

21 Relying on Samuel Kamau Macharia & another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited & 2 others [2012] eKLR wherein the Supreme Court held: “A Court’s jurisdiction flows from either the Constitution or legislation” It contended that the Judgment merely found that the Kshs. 1,000 medical check-up fee was refundable, and that once judgment is delivered the Court’s powers are limited to correcting clerical or arithmetical mistakes under Section 99 of the Civil Procedure Act, review in prescribed circumstances, or interpretation incidental to execution, none of which permits creating a fresh monetary decree.

22 It was submitted that the Court did not identify the employees entitled to a refund, determine the number of beneficiaries, adopt any list, compute an aggregate sum or enter judgment for Kshs. 20,000,000, and that no decree contains that sum. It pointed out that the extracted decree provides only for a “refund of Kshs. 1,000 per each employee for medical check-up” with “no order as to costs,” and cannot be expanded beyond its express terms.

23 The Respondent relied on Lakhamshi Brothers Ltd v Raja & Sons [1966] EA 313 for the principle that execution must strictly conform to the decree and cannot create rights never adjudicated. It further argued that the list of one thousand employees is fresh evidence that never formed part of the trial record or was tested in cross-examination, and that relying on it to enlarge the Judgment would offend finality, procedural fairness and due process. The Claimant’s remedy, it submitted, lies strictly within the decree as issued.

24 On abuse of the court process, the Respondent submitted that the application was frivolous, vexatious, misconceived and legally untenable because it sought to reopen matters already determined by the Court.

25 Relying on Twin Buffalo Safaris Limited v Business Partners International Limited [2015] eKLR, where a vexatious pleading was described as one that “lacks bonafides and is hopeless or offensive and tends to cause the opposite party unnecessary anxiety, trouble or expenses”. It further relied on Muchanga Investments Ltd V Safaris Unlimited (Africa) Ltd & 2 others [2009] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that abuse of process includes instituting a multiplicity of proceedings over the same subject matter and seeking to relitigate matters already determined.

26 It is the Respondent’s submission that the Court process exists to facilitate the fair and final determination of disputes. It is not intended to afford litigants multiple opportunities to re-open issues that have already been conclusively determined merely because they remain dissatisfied with the outcome.

27 The Respondent argued that, rather than pursue execution within the terms of the decree or avail itself of any appellate remedies, the Claimant had returned to the same Court seeking to have Kshs.20,000,000 entered as part of the judgment debt, although that amount had neither been awarded nor incorporated into the decree. It contended that the application sought indirectly to achieve what the Court had already declined to permit directly and ought therefore to be struck out.

28 On costs, the Respondent submitted that costs follow the event and urged the Court to award it the costs of the Preliminary Objection.

Claimant’s Submissions

29 The Claimant submitted that the Respondent’s Preliminary Objection is a procedural gimmick calculated to delay justice, frustrate the Claimant and deny 1,000 workers their lawfully refundable medical check-up fees.

30 It is the Claimant’s submission that the Court has already determined that Kshs. 1,000 per employee is refundable, and that the only outstanding matter is quantifying the total sum and entering it into the decree to facilitate execution. It contended that the Respondent does not dispute the legality of the refund, but merely seeks to obstruct execution through technical objections.

31 On the validity of the objection, the Claimant relied on Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696 for the principle that a preliminary objection must be based on pure points of law capable of disposing of the matter without evidence. It argued that the Respondent's objection is not a pure point of law, since it invites the Court to make factual determinations on the number of affected employees, the authenticity of the annexed list and whether the sum of Kshs. 20,000,000 is properly computed. These, it submitted, can only be determined through evidence or execution proceedings, so the objection is misconceived and incompetent ab initio.

32 On res judicata, the Claimant submitted that Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act bars re-litigation only of issues directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties and finally determined. It maintained that the sum of Kshs. 20,000,000 has never been pleaded, litigated or determined in any prior proceedings, and that the application seeks only to quantify the refund and enter the quantified sum into the decree for execution.

33 The Claimant submitted that this is a post-judgment execution step, not a re-litigation of the substantive dispute. It pointed out that the ruling of 25th February 2026 expressly stated that the Claimant could access the refund through execution proceedings, and argued that the application is precisely that.

34 The Claimant thus submitted that res judicata does not bar a party from taking the steps necessary to enforce a judgment, including quantifying an award.

35 On issue estoppel, the Claimant submitted that the doctrine applies only where the same issue has been finally determined in prior proceedings. It argued that the main suit determined only liability for the refund, and that the quantum of Kshs. 20,000,000 was never in issue. Quantification, it contended, is a new issue arising from the Judgment and expressly permitted by the Court's Ruling.

36 It further argued that the Respondent cannot invoke issue estoppel to prevent the execution of a judgment that it admits remains valid and enforceable.

37 On functus officio, the Claimant submitted that the doctrine prevents a court from revisiting its final decision on the merits, but does not bar it from performing the ministerial or ancillary functions needed to give effect to its judgment. It relied on Raila Odinga v IEBC [2013] eKLR, where it submitted the Supreme Court acknowledged that courts retain jurisdiction to correct clerical errors, interpret their judgments and issue consequential orders necessary to give effect to them.

38 It is the Respondent’s submission that the application falls squarely within the Court's residual jurisdiction to facilitate execution of its own decree, since the Court is not being asked to revisit the merits but to complete the execution process. It described the Respondent's position as erroneous and contrary to established practice, pointing out that courts routinely entertain post-judgment applications for execution, taxation and quantification.

39 On jurisdiction to enter the sum, the Claimant submitted that under Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, this Court has unlimited original jurisdiction to determine employment disputes, grant remedies including monetary relief, and issue orders to enforce its judgments.

40 It further relied on Orders 21 and 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which it argued empower the Court to assess the amount due under a judgment, enter the quantified sum into the decree and issue warrants of attachment and sale. It contended that the Court cannot be functus officio where execution is incomplete, since a judgment without execution is a futile exercise.

41 The Claimant submitted that the application is not frivolous or vexatious, as it simply follows the Court's direction in the ruling of 25th February 2026 that execution is the only lawful avenue, and it would be ironic and unjust to label such an application vexatious.

42 It submitted that the Respondent did not deny the medical check-up deduction, did not challenge its pleading that 1,000 employees were affected, and did not file its own list of employees. Having thereby implicitly admitted the facts pleaded, it argued, the Respondent cannot now dispute the number of beneficiaries or the quantum. It added that the Interested Party filed a list of employees in 2019 confirming that the affected employees were in the Respondent's employment, which corroborates its position.

43 The Claimant contended that it is the Respondent that is abusing the court process, having filed a preliminary objection in 2018, another in November 2025, the present one in June 2026 and multiple applications in between. It argued that this pattern shows a systematic effort to frustrate execution of a valid judgment and deny workers their dues, contrary to the overriding objective under Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act of just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of disputes.

44 It further submitted that under Article 27 of the Constitution, its members are entitled to equal protection and equal benefit of the law, including the fruits of the Judgment, and that denying the workers their refundable money violates their right to fair remuneration and reasonable working conditions under Article 41(1) and (2). It urged the Court to guard its own dignity and ensure that its judgments are not rendered hollow by technical objections.

45 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. The preliminary objection raised by the respondent herein is to the effect that the prayers being sought by the claimant applicants cannot be granted by reason of being res judicata having been litigated upon and a judgement delivered by this court on 22/5/2025.

46 I have looked at the application by the applicants respondents dated 5/5/2026 where they seek inclusion of Kshs 20,000,000/- as part of the judgement of the court.

47 In the judgment of this court dated 25/5/25, this court at para 78 made a finding that kshs 1,000/- deducted from each employee is refundable.

48 In a subsequent ruling of 25/2/26, at para 55, this court also made a similar position that the kshs 1,000/- is payable and the applicants can only access it through an execution process. This is not a matter to be retried. The claimants are advised to follow the correct process of execution in order to access the amount of kshs 1,000/-per employee.

49 The preliminary objection raises serious issues of retrying similar issue which issue is already res judicata. I find the preliminary objection has merit and I allow it and strike out the application dated 5/5/26 accordingly.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 28th Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder