Employment law

Zhensheng v Weihai Construction Group Company Limited [2026] KEELRC 14819 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 1028 of 2025
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This Ruling relates to the respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 brought under Section 1A,1B,3A & 6 of the Civil Procedure Act, Section 89 of the Employment Act and Section 12 of the ELRC Act, and it seeks the following orders: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the instant Notice of Motion, the rival Affidavit and submissions, the main issues for determination are as follows: -

Paragraph 14 →

Decision / orders

Accordingly, I allow the Respondent's Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 with costs.

Paragraph 35 →

Reasoning passage

I have perused the pleadings filed in High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025 annexed as LW-2 in the Respondent's Supporting Affidavit sworn on 25th November 2025. I have also perused the Statement of Claim filed in the present suit. Applying the above test to the facts of two suits herein, I find the instant suit clearly sub judice as regards to High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025, which was filed earlier.

Paragraph 19 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 29th October 2026)

CAUSE NO. 1028 OF 2025

LIU ZHENSHENG …….………..………..…………………………....CLAIMANT

VERSUS

WEIHAI CONSTRUCTION GROUP

COMPANY LIMITED……………………………………………...RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction

1. This Ruling relates to the respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 brought under Section 1A,1B,3A & 6 of the Civil Procedure Act, Section 89 of the Employment Act and Section 12 of the ELRC Act, and it seeks the following orders: -

a) That this suit be declared sub judice, as the issues in dispute and the parties herein are directly and substantially in issue in High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025, which is still pending determination.

b) That this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction to hear and determine the dispute herein for want of an employment relationship between the Claimant and the Respondent.

c) That in any event, any alleged employment Claim suit is statute-barred pursuant to Section 89 of the Employment Act.

d) That the Claimant's suit be struck out in its entirety.

e) That the costs of this application be provided for.

2. The Motion is supported by an Affidavit sworn by the Respondent's Managing Director, one Li Wentao, on 25th November 2025 and it is opposed by the Claimant vide his Replying Affidavit sworn on 15th December 2025. The Respondent filed a rejoinder vide a Further Affidavit sworn on 16th January 2026 by Mr. Li Wentao. The Motion was disposed of by way of written submissions.

Facts

3. Sometime on 8th March 2015, the Respondent entered into an Agency Agreement with GoldLida Limited. The Claimant was the authorized signatory and representative of GoldLida Limited. Pursuant to the terms of the Agreement, the Claimant, through GoldLida Limited, was appointed and entrusted by the Respondent to act as its duly authorized agent. The Respondent contends that the Claimant's engagement with the Respondent was therefore purely commercial and contractual, arising solely from the Agency Agreement between the Respondent and GoldLida Limited.

4. On 11th January 2024, a Special Meeting was convened by the Respondent's officials and the Claimant, whereby the claimants’ claims for reimbursement of expenses and salaries incurred on behalf of the respondent from 2018 to 2021, were discussed. The meeting culminated in written minutes that recorded the Respondent's position. The original minutes of the said meeting were prepared in Chinese language but an English translation has been provided.

5. The Claimant avers that at Item 42 of the minutes, there was an acknowledgement of his salary for the period 2018-2021, amounting to Chinese RMB 360,000 equivalent to Six Million Eight Hundred and Eighty Two Thousand Kenya Shillings (Kshs. 6,882,000). At Item 43, the minutes records salary for the period from 2018 to February 2021 in Kenya Shillings and notes that the monies were for a person called Ren Dengfeng, who was not formally employed by the company but assisted the Claimant in executing company matters. At Item 28, the minutes record Kshs. 600,000.00 paid for the Claimant's work permit and a further Twenty Thousand United States Dollars (USD 20,000.00) disbursed for his air travel to China.

6. The Claimant contends that the Respondent convened the said meeting for the specific purpose of resolving outstanding salary, and the sum owed was quantified during the meeting and a promise to settle the debt was given.

7. The Respondent contends that the Claimant has produced, and is seeking to rely on English-language minutes of the meeting allegedly held on 11th January 2024 but it categorically denies ever executing, adopting, or signing the said English version of the alleged minutes. The Respondent states that any purported signatures appearing on the English version are not the Respondent's signatures, and were not appended by or with the authority of the Respondent.

8. On 2nd April 2025, the Claimant instituted High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025, Liu Zhensheng v. Weihai Construction Group Co. Ltd., which remains active and pending determination before the High Court. The said suit seeks to recover Kshs.82,450,000 and USD 1,050,000 being expenses and salaries incurred by the claimant while working for the respondent in its various projects in Kenya between 2018 and 2021. He pleaded that he had incurred the expenses on behalf of the respondent but it failed to reimburse him.

9. On 24th October 2025, the Claimant filed the present suit, ELRC Cause No. E1028 of 2025, alleging breach of contract and general damages for breach of contract. He further prayed for Kshs.82,450,000 and Chine Yuan RMB 1,050,000 exchange rate of Ksh.18.50 to 1 Yuan. He pleaded that his claim included monthly salary, overtime and project commissions and reimbursements.

10. The Respondent contends that upon review of the pleadings filed in High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025 and those filed in the present suit, it is manifestly evident that High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025 was instituted earlier in time, thereby taking precedence over the instant proceedings.

11. It averred that the parties in both matters are the same and/or are litigating under the same title; that the subject matter in both suits is substantially identical.; that the issues raised in this suit replicate those already pending before the High Court Commercial; and that the reliefs sought herein are materially the same as those sought in the earlier suit.

12. The Respondent further contends that the dispute in question relates to the period between 2018 and 2021, and that any alleged claim founded on an employment relationship, which claim is expressly denied, is statute-barred under Section 89 of the Employment Act, for being instituted well outside the mandatory statutory limitation period of three (3) years.

13. The Respondent denies any employment relationship with claimant and contends that the Claimant has never possessed a valid Kenyan Work Permit or any other document authorizing him to work in Kenya. It further averred that even if the Claimant were to allege an employment relationship, which is denied, such a relationship would be contrary to the express provisions of the Kenya Citizenship and Immigration Act, and therefore unlawful and unenforcement before this Honourable Court.

Issues for determination and analysis

14. Having considered the instant Notice of Motion, the rival Affidavit and submissions, the main issues for determination are as follows: -

a) Whether the suit herein is sub judice.

b) Whether this Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the suit herein.

c) Whether the Claim is statute-barred.

Whether the suit is sub judice.

15. The Respondent contends that the present suit is sub judice for having been filed during the pendency of High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025. The Respondent relies on Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act (Cap. 21) which provides as follows: -

"No court shall proceed with the trial of any suit or proceeding in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit or proceeding between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, where such suit or proceeding is pending in the same or any other court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed."

16. The rationale for the doctrine was articulated by the Supreme Court in Kenya National Commission on Human Rights v Attorney General, Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 16 others (Interested Parties) [2020] KESC 54 (KLR), where the Court held that the sub judice rule exists to forestall a multiplicity of suits between the same parties over the same subject matter, thereby averting abuse of court process and the risk of competent courts issuing conflicting decisions on the same dispute.

17. The Supreme Court set out four cumulative conditions that must be satisfied for the doctrine to apply:

a) there must be more than one suit over the same subject matter;

b) one suit must have been instituted before the other;

c) both suits must be pending before courts of competent jurisdiction; and

d) the suits must be between the same parties or their representatives.

18. In Thiba Min. Hydro Co. Ltd v Josphat Karu Ndwiga [2013] KEHC 2017 (KLR), the Court held that it is not the manner in which a suit is framed that determines whether it is sub judice, but the substance of the dispute. A litigant cannot defeat the doctrine merely by relabeling a cause of action or approaching a different forum with cosmetic variations in pleading.

19. I have perused the pleadings filed in High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025 annexed as LW-2 in the Respondent's Supporting Affidavit sworn on 25th November 2025. I have also perused the Statement of Claim filed in the present suit. Applying the above test to the facts of two suits herein, I find the instant suit clearly sub judice as regards to High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025, which was filed earlier.

20. The matter in issue herein is directly and substantially the same in both suits; the parties are the same and they are litigating under the same title; the reliefs sought are the same and finally the earlier suit is still pending in a court with jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed.

21. Both suits are founded on the same breach of contract, that is, failure by the respondent to reimburse Kshs. 82,450,000 and RMB 1,050,000 being expenses and salaries incurred by the claimant while working for the respondent from 2018 to 2021. The said sums were the subject of discussion between the respondent and the claimant in a meeting held on 11th January 2024.

22. It follows that the Claimant has two suits in two superior courts of equal status seeking the same reliefs, that is, reimburse Kshs.82,450,000 and RMB 1,050,000 being expenses and salaries incurred by him while working for the respondent from 2018 to 2021. He was fully aware of the outcome of the meeting held on 11th January 2024 including the acknowledgment of his salary for two years. Considering the substance of the suit, the prominent claim is not salary and probably that is why he went to the High Court first.

23. The said sums of Kshs. 82,450,000 and RMB 1,050,000 were expenses and salaries incurred from 2018 to 2021, and according to the minutes of 11th January 2024, they included claimant’s salary and other business expenses namely, police hospitality, police cases, furniture, agent commission for various projects, forfeited guarantees, compensation for JV Partner, legal fees, office rent Air ticket, Christmas gifts, interest on loan, and project consultancy fees. The predominant claim is not salary and therefore, the high court can determine the merits of the bigger claim for reimbursement of the said business expenses alongside the smaller claim of salary.

24. The sub judice rule exists to prevent the same dispute from being litigated before two or more courts. The dispute in this suit is materially and substantially the same as the earlier suit pending before the High Court, which is competent to grant the reliefs sought. Consequently, I find that the present suit is sub judice by reason of the pendency of High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025.

Jurisdiction to entertain the suit.

25. The Respondent contends that no employment relationship exists or has ever existed between the Claimant and the Respondent. The Respondent maintains that it entered into an Agency Agreement with GoldLida Limited on 8th March 2015, pursuant to which the Claimant acted as the authorized representative of GoldLida Limited. The Respondent contends that the Claimant's engagement was, therefore, at all material times with GoldLida Limited and it was by virtue of that agency relationship that the Claimant came to perform any duties touching on the Respondent's affairs.

26. The Respondent further contends that an agent who acts on behalf of a principal, pursuant to a contract of agency with that principal, does not thereby become the employee of a third party for whose benefit the principal's services happen to be rendered. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant's contractual privity was with GoldLida Limited and there is no contractual or employment nexus between the Claimant and the Respondent directly.

27. The Claimant, on the other hand, contends that an employment relationship existed between himself and the Respondent. The Claimant relies on the definition in Section 2 of the Employment Act, 2007, which defines a contract of service as an agreement, whether oral or written, whether express or implied, to employ or to serve as an employee for any period of time. The Claimant submits that employment is not confined to formal contracts bearing signatures and stamps, but arises from the reality of how people work and how organizations treat the people who work for them.

28. The Claimant further contends that on 11th January 2024, a Special Meeting was convened by the Respondent's officials, attended by the Claimant, the Respondent's representatives and presided over by the Respondent's Deputy Managing Director, to address the Claimant's claim for project expenses and salary arrears for the period 2018 to 2021. The Claimant submits that the minutes of meeting produced before this Honourable Court as Annexure LW-5 are proof that he was employed by the respondent.

29. He pointed at item 42 in the minutes whereby the respondent acknowledged the Claimant's salary for a period of two years. I agree with the claimant to that extent save to reiterate that the sum of the acknowledged salary was not computed although in one page it was indicated as RMB 360,000 and in another RMB 720,000 out of the total sums of Kshs.82,450,000 and RMB 1,050,000 claimed and which were not acknowledged by the respondent in the said minutes for lack of supporting evidence.

30. The said sums were claimed as reimbursements for expenses and salaries incurred from 2018 to 2021, and they included claimant’s salary, police hospitality, police cases, furniture, agent commission for various projects, forfeited guarantees, compensation for JV Partner, legal fees, office rent, Air ticket, Christmas gifts, interest on loan, and project consultancy fees.

31. Suffice it to say that, by reason of the respondent’s acknowledgment of claimant’s salary for two years, I find that this court has jurisdiction to determine only a small portion of the dispute in the claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 14th October 2025 being the claim for salary for the period 2018 to 2021. The acknowledgement of salary points to employer-employee relationship between the parties herein and therefore clothes the court with jurisdiction to deal with the claim for salary for 2018 to 2021.

32. The respondent submitted that the claimant never got any work permit and therefore any contract of employment with it would be illegal and unenforceable pursuant to the Citizenship and Immigration Act. I eschew further comments on the legality of the claimant’s employment because that should be tested by the trial court. I hold the same view with respect to the question whether or not the suit is time barred by dint of section 89 of the Employment Act.

Conclusion

33. I have found that the suit herein is sub judice by reason of Case No. E251 of 2025 pending before High Court Commercial, which involves materially and substantially the same subject matter and the High Court has jurisdiction to determine.

34. I have further found that this court has a limited jurisdiction to determine only the claim for salary since the respondent acknowledged the claimant’s salary for two years. However, since the large part of the claim is not related to employment relationship between the parties, I have opted to let the High Court try the entire dispute in the High Court Commercial Case No. E251 of 2025 which was filed first.

35. Accordingly, I allow the Respondent's Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 with costs.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Maosa for Claimant

Peter for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder