Employment law

Sirere & 6 others v Nesco Services Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14804 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 75 of 2016
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the Claimants/Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 19th May, 2026, made pursuant to Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, and Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules,2010. The Applicants seek the following reliefs: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The issues for determination are firstly, whether the firm of Ochieng’ Makokha & Company Advocates should be granted leave to come on record for the Claimants after judgment, and secondly, whether the pleadings and applications previously filed by the firm should be validated.

Paragraph 24 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances, I find that the application dated 19th May, 2026 is merited. Accordingly, I make the following orders: -

Paragraph 35 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. 75 OF 2016.

 

GEORGE ODUOR SIRERE…………...….............................1ST CLAIMANT

JACKONIA OMONDI OGEGO……………………………..2ND CLAIMANT

CHRISTINE NYAMORAMAMBO MAANGI……………….3RD CLAIMANT

GLADYS LUKENDO AMBUCHI…………………………..…4TH CLAIMANT

JAMES SANGANI MONAYO….……………………………5TH CLAIMANT

PAMELA NANGUNI NAIBENI………………………………6TH CLAIMANT

WINFRED MWIVA……………………………………..…….7TH CLAIMANT

VERSUS

NESCO SERVICES LIMITED………………………….………..RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling relates to the Claimants/Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 19th May, 2026, made pursuant to Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, and Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules,2010. The Applicants seek the following reliefs: -

i. THAT leave be granted to the firm of OCHIENG MAKOKHA & COMPANY ADVOCATES to come on record for the Decree-Holders/Applicants in place of WANGIRA OKOBA & COMPANY ADVOCATES post-judgment.

ii. THAT all pleadings, applications and affidavits already filed by the said firm be deemed duly filed and properly on record.

iii. THAT costs of this application be in the cause.

2. The application is supported by grounds on the face thereof and the affidavit sworn by FESTUS OCHIENG MAKOKHA, on 19th May, 2026.

3. The Claimants/Applicants aver that judgment in this matter was delivered on 24th September, 2024, and that execution proceedings are ongoing. The deponent contends that the Claimants/Decree Holders appointed Ochieng Makokha & Company Advocates to represent them post judgment.

4. They contend that although Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules requires leave of court or consent of the outgoing advocates for a change of representation after judgment, the outgoing advocates have participated in taxation and execution proceedings without objecting to their new advocates.

5. They further argue that their outgoing advocates have thereby acquiesced to the change of representation and are estopped from raising a technical objection. They therefore seek recognition of their current advocates on record and validation of the applications already filed to avoid duplication and delay.

6. The Motion is opposed vide a replying affidavit sworn by ALEX KING’ORI on 20th July, 2026.

7. The deponent contends that the motion herein is made in bad faith, is frivolous, vexatious, an abuse of the court process, and has been overtaken by events. The Advocate further argues that the matter is already closed and that the Applicant should instead seek instructions to represent the Claimants in the pending appeal.

8. It is further averred that an appeal has already been filed at the Court of Appeal in Nairobi, with the Record of Appeal available at the registry, as evidenced by their annexed excerpt marked “AK-1.”

9. The Advocate further contends that the Applicants should pursue the pending appeal to avoid duplicity of court decisions, arguing that granting the application would render the appeal nugatory.

10. It states that the Appellant has already furnished security for costs, and for this reason, they seek dismissal of the application dated 19th May, 2026, with costs against Ochieng’ Makokha & Company Advocates or personally against Advocate Festus Ochieng’ Makokha.

11. The Advocate also states that on 18th May, 2026, Justice Jemimah Wanza Keli dismissed an earlier application dated 17th April, 2026 seeking to vacate the stay of execution orders issued on 14th May, 2025 and reviewed on 16th June, 2025.

12. The Advocate states that the Court ordered Ochieng’ Makokha & Co. Advocates to bear the costs of an application dismissed as illegally filed and fatally defective, and which he interprets as wasted costs, arguing that the firm should pay those costs before being granted further audience before the Court.

13. It avers that following the judgment delivered on 24th September, 2024, Ochieng’ Makokha & Co. Advocates filed a Notice of Change of Advocates dated 4th July, 2025 and undertook post judgment proceedings without leave of Court, contrary to Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Advocate contends that the firm sought to undermine Wangira Okoba & Co. Advocates’ entitlement to fees earned in prosecuting the matter to judgment.

14. Counsel argues that the irregular actions include filing submissions on the party-and-party Bill of Costs dated 27th November, 2024, requesting a certificate of costs, applying to adopt the certificate dated 12th March, 2026, requesting warrants of attachment, and filing an application dated 17th April, 2026 to set aside the stay orders.

15. The Advocate maintains that these steps were taken without leave of Court and that the relevant documents were not served on their firm, contrary to the Applicant’s assertions.

16. The Advocate states that Wangira Okoba & Co. Advocates were not served with the application dated 17th April, 2026 seeking to set aside the stay orders issued on 14th May, 2025, or with any other post-judgment documents, and that they only became aware of the proceedings upon noticing a mention date of 18th May, 2026 on the Judiciary’s CTS. He avers that upon appearing in Court on that date, they objected to Ochieng’ Makokha & Co. Advocates being improperly on record, following which the Court terminated the latter’s application.

17. The Advocate contends that Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules requires an incoming advocate to obtain leave of Court or file a consent between the incoming and outgoing advocates before coming on record after judgment. He avers that the Applicant misrepresented the law and falsely suggested that the former advocates had participated in the post-judgment proceedings or had failed to object to the change of representation.

18. The Advocate further maintains that the objection was raised at the earliest opportunity after discovering the proceedings.

19. It is his assertion that Ochieng’ Makokha & Co. Advocates acted unjustifiably and with an ulterior motive of depriving Wangira Okoba & Co. Advocates of their lawfully earned fees.

20. The Court is finally urged to dismiss the application dated 19th May, 2026 and order the costs to be paid by the firm or personally by Advocate Festus Ochieng’ Makokha before being granted further audience.

21. Both Counsels urged the motion orally on 6th October, 2026, where counsel intending to come on record for the Applicants told court that the outgoing advocate has already filed an advocate-client bill of costs which has since been taxed and a certificate of taxation issued, hence they no longer represent the Claimants/Applicants.

22. He argues further that the Claimants have an absolute right to legal representation, and since their former advocate’s financial interest is already secured, there is no prejudice to the application being allowed.

23. On his part, Mr. Kingori argues that the Claimants/Applicants having already filed an appeal before the Court of Appeal through Mr. Makokha, this motion is overtaken by events and should be dismissed with costs.

Analysis and Determination.

24. The issues for determination are firstly, whether the firm of Ochieng’ Makokha & Company Advocates should be granted leave to come on record for the Claimants after judgment, and secondly, whether the pleadings and applications previously filed by the firm should be validated.

25. Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, provides that a change of advocates after judgment must be effected either through an order of the Court upon an application served on all parties or through a consent filed between the outgoing and incoming advocates. Rule 10 of the same Order further permits the application for change of advocates to be combined with other prayers, provided the question of representation is determined first.

26. On the first issue herein, it is evident that judgment was delivered on 24th September, 2024, and that the firm of Ochieng’ Makokha & Company Advocates subsequently filed a Notice of Change of Advocates dated 4th July 2025. It is also not disputed that this firm undertook several post-judgment steps, including applications touching on execution and the existing stay orders.

27. The Applicants argue that the Respondent acquiesced in the change as no objection was raised during the earlier taxation and execution proceedings. The opposing counsel disputes service and asserts that they became aware of the post-judgment proceedings only when they saw the mention date of 18th May, 2026 on the Judiciary’s Case Tracking System.

28. In the circumstances, the alleged acquiescence cannot, without evidence of proper service and knowledge, be treated as a waiver of the requirements of Order 9 Rule 9, nor does the fact that the new firm has already filed documents cure the failure to obtain leave or file the requisite consent.

29. It is, however, not lost on the court that the Applicants’ right to legal representation is a constitutional guarantee, and must be considered alongside the procedural safeguards protecting the outgoing advocate. In Waithanji v Absa Bank Kenya PLC [2024] KEHC 969 (KLR), the Court considered the protective purpose of Order 9 Rule 9 and the absence of an objection by the outgoing advocates after service.

30. The foregoing decision supports the consideration of the actual prejudice to the outgoing advocate, but it does not dispense with the mandatory procedure prescribed by the Rule.

31. The outgoing counsel argues that the application is overtaken by events because an appeal has already been filed in the Court of Appeal.

32. In my considered view, the filing of an appeal does not, by itself, render the present application spent. The Applicants seek recognition of their advocates in the original proceedings, where they have filed execution and stay-related applications.

33. The outgoing counsel further contends that the firm should not be granted audience until it pays the costs awarded following the dismissal of its application dated 17th April 2026.

34. An order directing a party to pay costs does not, without more, necessarily amount to an order barring the advocate from further audience.

35. In the circumstances, I find that the application dated 19th May, 2026 is merited. Accordingly, I make the following orders: -

a) That Leave be and is hereby granted to Ochieng’ Makokha & Company Advocates to come on record for the Claimants/Applicants in place of Wangira Okoba & Company Advocates.

b) That each party shall bear their own costs of this application.

36. It is so ordered.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Makokha present for the Claimants/Applicants

Mr. Wangira present for the outgoing advocate

N/A for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S- C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder