Background
Through Khalwale & Company Advocates, the Claimant commenced these proceedings by way of a memorandum of claim dated 7th December 2017, seeking for the following reliefs –
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Through Khalwale & Company Advocates, the Claimant commenced these proceedings by way of a memorandum of claim dated 7th December 2017, seeking for the following reliefs –
Paragraph 1 →In the absence of any evidence to the contrary from the Respondent, the Court will accept the Claimant's narrative as the truthful account of what transpired. A demand from an employer or its agent directing and commanding an employee to resign is not a voluntary resignation; it amounts to dismissal. Since the Respondent failed to appear to prove a fair reason for the dismissal under Section 43(1) or demonstrate compliance with the…
Paragraph 23 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CLAIM NO. 507 OF 2018
EDWIN OMONDI OKUMU………………..….……. CLAIMANT
-VERSUS -
GYTO SUCCESS COMPANY LIMITED……......RESPONDENT
(BEFORE HON. JUSTICE DAVID NDERITU)
JUDGMENT
I. INTRODUCTION
1. Through Khalwale & Company Advocates, the Claimant commenced these proceedings by way of a memorandum of claim dated 7th December 2017, seeking for the following reliefs –
a) A declaration that the claimant dismissal was wrongful and unfair.
b) The claimant be and is hereby paid Ksh.224,188.30/= as terminal benefits calculated as follows –
1. One (1) month's salary in lieu of notice - 9,000/=
2. Leave allowance (3 years x 26 days x 9,000 / 26 days)- 27,000/=
3. House allowance unpaid (9,000 x 41 months x 15%) / 100- 55,000/=
4. Offs missed (4 weeks x 9,000 x 2 hrs x 12 hrs) / 225 hours
-3,840/=
5. Service pay / Gratuity (3 years x 18 days x 9,000) / 26 days-18,692/=
6. Refund of unlawful salary deduction- 3,000/=
7. Compensation for wrongful dismissal (12 months x 9,000)- 108,000/=
c) Costs.
2. The memorandum of claim was accompanied with a verifying affidavit sworn by the Claimant, a list of witnesses dated 7th December 2017, the Claimant’s written statement, a list of documents, and copies of the listed documents attached.
3. The Respondent entered appearance through Wambua syokwaa & Company Advocates and filed a statement of response dated 12th May 2023. The response was accompanied with a list of witnesses, the written statement of Ayub Sitati, a list of documents of even date, and copies of the listed documents attached.
4. The cause came up in court for hearing on 11th March 2026 when the Claimant (CW1) testified and closed his case. Despite having filed a response and witness statement, the Respondent failed to attend the trial hearing and hence no evidence was offered in defence of the claim.
5. Counsel for the Claimant Mr. Khalwale filed written submissions dated 3rd August 2026.
II. THE CLAIMANT’S CASE
6. The Claimant’s case is expressed in the memorandum of claim, the Claimant’s witness statement, the documents filed, the oral testimony by the Claimant in court, and the written submissions by his Counsel.
7. In the Memorandum of Claim, it was pleaded that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent on or about 9th September 2012 as a security guard (specifically designated as a night guard in the pleadings). The Claimant's initial monthly salary was Kshs8,500/=, which was subsequently reviewed upwards to Kshs9,000/= per month. The Claimant stated that he worked diligently and honestly for a period of 41 months.
8. The Claimant averred that during his employment, his working hours were strictly scheduled from 6:00 pm to 6:00 am daily, including weekends and public holidays, without any provision for overtime pay. He further pleaded that the Respondent neither provided him with housing, nor did the Respondent pay him a house allowance as required by law. He further alleged that he did not proceed on annual leave for the entire period of his service and that the Respondent failed to remit the statutory contributions to the National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) and the National Social Security Fund (NSSF), notwithstanding that the same were deducted from his monthly salary.
9. The Claimant further pleaded that on or about 1st February 2016 he
requested for four (4) days off duty, which was duly approved and granted by his supervisor. The Claimant further pleaded that when he reported back to work upon the expiry of his off-days, the supervisor abruptly instructed him to return home and wait “until further notice.” The Claimant pleaded that he was unlawfully deducted Kshs3,000/= from his salary for allegedly staying away from work.
10. The Claimant was not called back to work and hence he instructed his advocates, Khalwale & Company Advocates, who dispatched a formal demand letter dated 15th September 2016 to the Respondent, seeking immediate settlement of his outstanding dues. Having received no positive response, the Claimant sued for the aforementioned reliefs.
11. In his testimony in Court, CW1 reiterated the contents of the foregoing pleadings and his written statement dated 7th December 2017. He produced and adopted the documents in his list of documents as exhibits 1 and 2.
12. He testified that the he worked for the Respondent as a night guard from 9th September 2012 to 1st February 2016 and was terminated on 1st February 2016 while on a duly approved off duty. He testified that he was not notified or given a hearing before termination. He was not issued with a written contract. He testified further that during his entire period of employment he was denied leave and the Respondent failed to provide him with housing or pay house allowance. He further stated that he resigned under coercion from the director of the Respondent.
III. SUBMISSIONS
13. The Claimant’s counsel filed written submissions dated 4th May 2026. Counsel reiterated the factual assertions and advanced arguments on the issues of termination, the reliefs sought for, and costs.
14. It was submitted that the Claimant’s resignation was forced and involuntary. It was argued that the Respondent's act of deducting Kshs3,000/= from the Claimant’s salary upon his return from authorized four-day off-duty, coupled with accusations of absconding duty, poisoned the work environment and constituted a fundamental breach of the contract. Counsel cited Coca-Cola East and Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga (2015) [eKLR] arguing that the employer’s conduct amounted to a fundamental breach of the contract, rendering the resignation to amount to constructive dismissal.
15. It was further submitted that the termination was procedurally unfair and unlawful. Counsel cited Kenya Union of Commercial, Food and Allied Workers v Meru North Farmers Sacco Limited (Cause No. 74 of 2013) in asserting that Section 41 of the Employment Act demands for fair hearing before termination. Counsel further argued that the Respondent violated Sections
43(1), 44(4), & 45(1) of the Employment Act.
16. Counsel further contended that under Section 27 & 28 of the Employment Act the Claimant was entitled to leave allowance yet the Respondent denied him annual leave over his 41-month service. It was further submitted that the Claimant was entitled to one month's salary in lieu of notice under Section 35 of the Employment Act for the constructive dismissal.
17. On compensation, the Claimant prayed for 12 months' salary citing Alfred Muthomi & Others v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2018] eKLR alongside Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act. It was submitted that the Claimant had unblemished service for 41 months yet he was condemned to financial embarrassment and justified the maximum award. Lastly, the Claimant sought a certificate of service under Section 51 of Employment the Act.
18. On costs Counsel cited Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 others [2014] eKLR in support of the proposition that costs must follow the event to indemnify the successful party.
IV. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
19. The Court has carefully and dutifully gone through the pleadings filed, the documentary and oral evidence tendered, and the written submissions by counsel for the Claimant. The following issues are for determination –
a) Whether the Claimant was unfairly and unlawfully
terminated/dismissed.
b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
c) Costs.
V. ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
20. On the first issue, under Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, the Claimant bears the burden of presenting a prima facie case of unfair dismissal. Once this was established, the statutory burden shifts to the employer under Section 43(1) to justify the reason for the termination and under Section 45(2) to prove that the termination was substantively and procedurally fair.
21. Due to the lack of evidence, specifically the Respondent's total failure to attend the hearing to tender its documents or offer oral testimony on oath, the Court is only left with the evidence as tendered by the Claimant on the circumstances surrounding the separation on 1st February 2016.
22. However, a party who chooses to default on attending a court hearing must bear the legal consequences. The Respondent opted not to attend the hearing to formally adduce its evidence or cross-examine the Claimant, and hence the Claimant's oral and documentary case stands uncontroverted. The Claimant testified on oath that he was ordered to resign by the Respondent's Director, who allegedly forced him to execute a letter of resignation against his will. A sum of Kshs3,000/= was deducted
from his pay. This testimony was unchallenged and unrebutted.
23. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary from the Respondent, the Court will accept the Claimant's narrative as the truthful account of what transpired. A demand from an employer or its agent directing and commanding an employee to resign is not a voluntary resignation; it amounts to dismissal. Since the Respondent failed to appear to prove a fair reason for the dismissal under Section 43(1) or demonstrate compliance with the procedural requirements in Section 41, the Court finds and holds that the Claimant was wrongfully and unfairly dismissed from employment.
VI. RELIEFS
24. Having established that the Claimant's dismissal was unfair, wrongful, and unlawful, the Court shall evaluate his specific reliefs.
25. Prayer (i) is for (one) Month's Salary in lieu of notice in the sum of Kshs9,000/=. Section 35(1)(c) of the Employment Act guarantees an employee a notice or salary in lieu of notice upon termination. The Claimant's testimony is that he was ordered to resign with immediate effect stands uncontroverted and he is thus entitled to this relief in the sum of Kshs9,000/= as prayed.
26. Prayer (ii) is for unpaid leave allowance of Kshs27,000/=. Section 28 of the Employment Act guarantees an employee 21 days of fully paid annual leave for every 12 months of service. The Claimant deposes that he worked for the Respondent for over three years without taking annual leave. His claim of Kshs27,000/= has merits and is hereby allowed.
27. Prayer (iii) is for unpaid house allowance in the sum of Kshs55,000/=. Section 31(1) of the Employment Act imposes a mandatory obligation on an employer to provide reasonable housing or pay a house allowance to every employee. The Respondent pleaded that the Claimant's monthly salary of Kshs9,000/= was an 'all-inclusive' consolidated incorporating house allowance. However, the burden of proving that a salary is consolidated rests entirely with the employer. The Respondent did not avail a written employment contract of service containing an “all-inclusive” clause, nor did it provide any other document showing that house allowance was factored into the basic pay. In the absence of such evidence, the Claimant's basic salary is deemed exclusive of house allowance. Calculating house allowance at the standard rate of 15% of basic salary yields Kshs1,350/= per month. For 41 months, the total entitlement is Kshs55,350/=. The Court hereby awards the claimed sum of Kshs55,350/=.
28. Prayer (iv) is for unpaid weekly rest days of Kshs3,840/=. This prayer is ambiguous as there was no explanation of the variables used by the Claimant or missed rest days or the period covered. While Sections 10, 30, & 74 of the Employment Act, place the evidentiary burden to the employer to show compliance with labour standards by presenting working registers and records, this statutory burden does not relieve the Claimant of his primary legal duty to plead and establish intelligible prima facie basis for his claim. A court of law cannot rubber-stamp an ambiguous claim simply because a suit is undefended. Awarding an arbitrary claim on the basis of an unexplained formula would violate the core tenets of justice. Consequently, for want of specificity, ambiguity in pleading, and failure of strict proof, the claim for weekly rest days (offs missed) of Kshs3,840/= is hereby disallowed and dismissed.
29. Prayer (v) is for service pay in the sum of Kshs18,692.30. Under Section 35(5) & (6) of the Employment Act, service pay is payable upon termination where an employer has failed to make statutory or pension contributions. The Claimant testified that the Respondent failed to remit the deductions made to NSSF and NHIF. However, the Court must calculate the award in strict compliance with the statutory minimum of fifteen (15) days' wages for each completed year of service. A month is deemed to have twenty-six (26) working days (excluding Sundays). Therefore, the Claimant's daily rate was calculated as Kshs9,000/= /26 days = Kshs346.15/=. Consequently, fifteen (15) days' wages equal to Kshs346.15/= x 15 = Kshs5,192.31/= per year. For the Claimant's three (3) completed years of service, the statutory entitlement is calculated as Kshs5,192.31/= x 3 years = Kshs15,576.92. The Court awards the sum of Kshs15,576.92 under this head.
30. Prayer (vi) is for refund of Kshs3,000/= that was unlawfully deducted from his salary. The Claimant testified that the Respondent unilaterally deducted Kshs3,000/= from his last salary. Under Section 19 of the Employment Act, unilateral and unauthorized deductions are strictly prohibited. This claim remains unctroverted and thus, the Court orders full refund of the Kshs3,000/= to the Claimant.
31. Prayer (vii) is for compensation for unfair dismissal in the sum of Kshs108,000/=. Under Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act, the Court has the discretion to award at most compensation equivalent to up to gross 12 months' salary for unfair dismissal. In exercising this discretion, the Court considers the Claimant's length of service (41 months), his unblemished record and, the fact that he was forced to resign under duress from the Director. The Court must exercise its discretion reasonably. Given the circumstances of the forced resignation, the Court holds that an award equivalent to six (6) months' gross salary is fair and reasonable compensation under this head. The Court therefore awards Kshs9,000/= x 6 months totaling to Kshs54,000/=.
32. While the Claimant did not plead for award of a Certificate of Service, Section 51 of the Employment Act commands that an employer shall issue a certificate of service to an employee upon
termination, unconditionally.
X. COSTS
33. The Claimant is awarded costs of the cause.
XI. DISPOSAL/ORDERS
70. The court issues the following orders –
a) The Claimant is awarded as follows –
(i) One month’s salary in lieu of notice Kshs9,000/=
(ii) Leave allowance Kshs27,000/=
(iii) House Allowance Kshs55,000/=
(iv) Service pay Kshs15,576.92/=
(v) Salary deduction refund Kshs3,000/=
(vi) Compensation for wrongful, unfair, and
Unlawful dismissal Kshs54,000/=
Total Gross Award Kshs163,576.92
b) The Respondent shall issue the Claimant with a certificate if service within 30 days of this judgment.
c) The Respondent shall bear the costs of this suit.
DELIVERED VIRTUALLY, DATED, AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
……………………
DAVID NDERITU
JUDGE