Background
For determination is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 29th February, 2024, in which the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
For determination is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 29th February, 2024, in which the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →In light of the foregoing, I find and hold that the Respondent has not discharged its burden under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act; hence, the Claimant’s summary dismissal is unfair and unlawful.
Paragraph 71 →Whether Richard Mutuku’s summary dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair; whether the respondent violated his constitutional rights through discrimination and alleged publication of his image, family image and telephone number; and whether he was…
Mutuku was employed by the respondent, latterly as Travel/Fleet Supervisor under a 14 August 2020 contract. Suspicious payments totalling Kshs.761,554 were linked to an M-Pesa number registered with his identity particulars. He denied registering or operating…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E161 OF 2024.
RICHARD MUTUKU……………………………………….……..CLAIMANT
VERSUS
THE CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST OF
LATTER DAY SAINTS, TRUSTEES REGISTERED…………… RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. For determination is the Claimant’s Statement of Claim dated 29th February, 2024, in which the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
a) An order of declaration that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair and wrongful.
b) Reinstatement of the Claimant to the position he held prior to the said dismissal without any loss of rank/insignia, salary and allowances and benefits.
c) Payment of damages for the unfair dismissal from employment, equivalent to 12 Months’ salary.
d) General damages for the infringement and violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights and freedoms, including the freedom from discrimination, the right to human dignity, the right to privacy and right to fair labour practices.
e) Interest on (c) and (d) above from the date of filing this suit until payment in full.
f) Costs of the Claim.
2. The Respondent entered appearance on 28th March, 2024 and filed a response to the claim dated 16th April, 2024, and a list and bundle of documents dated 3rd May, 2024.
3. The Claimant subsequently filed a reply to the response dated 2nd July, 2024, further witness statement of even date, Claimant’s further list of documents of even date and a supplementary list of documents dated 5th May, 2025.
4. The Claimant’s case was heard on 11th June, 2025 when CW1, Richard Sila Mutuku, testified in support of his case. He adopted both his witness statements dated 29th February, 2024 and 2nd July, 2024 as his evidence in chief, and produced his list and bundle of documents dated 29th February, 2024, a further list and bundle dated 2nd July, 2024, and a supplementary list and bundle dated 5th May, 2025, which the Court admitted as his exhibits Nos. 1-34, 32-37 and 38-45, respectively.
5. The Respondent’s case was heard on 17th March, 2026 and 22nd June, 2026 through two witnesses. RW1, Peter Kirima, the Respondent’s Regional Human Resource Manager, adopted his witness statement dated 29th April, 2024 and further witness statement dated 27th March, 2025 as his evidence in chief and produced the Respondent’s list and bundle of documents dated 3rd May, 2024 and supplementary bundle dated 28th March, 2025, which were admitted as the Respondent’s Exhibits Nos. 1-10.
6. RW2 Jadmaire Ndivo, the Respondent’s Area Member and Statistical Records Manager, also testified and adopted his witness statement dated 26th July, 2024.
7. Both parties filed their submissions in the matter.
The Claimant’s Case.
8. The Claimant’s case is that he was associated with the Respondent since 1994, when he served as a volunteer missionary before being employed as a Distribution Store Supervisor under an employment contract dated 26th July, 2012.
9. It is his case that in August 2020, he was appointed Travel/Fleet Supervisor under a fresh contract dated 14th August, 2020. He maintains that he diligently performed his duties, managed substantial funds and assets belonging to the Respondent without misappropriation, and received commendations for his work.
10. The Claimant further avers that the dispute herein arose from fraudulent transactions involving Kshs.761,554/= allegedly siphoned from the Respondent’s local unit disbursement account through M-Pesa accounts associated with church members and employees.
11. He states that one of the accounts was linked to telephone number 0742386535, registered using his identity particulars and associated with a fictitious beneficiary named Tetteh Fountain Richard. He maintains that the transactions occurred at the Respondent’s Dandora Branch, where he neither worked nor controlled the financial disbursement system, as he worked in the Temporal Affairs Department at Galleria Business Park.
12. The Claimant contends that the Respondent’s investigations implicated Philip Wafula, who had access to the Dandora Branch’s financial system and who admitted involvement in the theft and undertook to refund the money. He states that the M-Pesa statement for telephone number 0742386535 showed that funds received through the line were transferred to telephone number 0792177572, which is associated with Wafula.
13. The Claimant denies registering or operating the impugned line and maintains that he gave Wafula a copy of his identity card in the course of his earlier ecclesiastical duties, without knowing that his particulars would subsequently be misused.
14. The Claimant further states that upon learning of the fraudulent use of his identity, he obtained the M-Pesa statement, took steps to have the unauthorized account frozen, reported the matter to Lang’ata Police Station under OB No. 64/15/09/2020, and notified the Respondent.
15. It is his case that he was subsequently arrested and charged in Milimani Criminal Case No. E113 of 2021 in connection with the alleged theft. He maintains that the Respondent treated him differently from other persons whose details were linked to the transactions, particularly Wafula, who was subjected to the Respondent’s ecclesiastical disciplinary process.
16. The Claimant further avers that he was suspended and issued with a notice to show cause on 21st January, 2021. He avers that he responded to the allegations and attended the disciplinary hearing, but contends that the process was predetermined and that his explanation concerning the misuse of his identity and the absence of evidence showing that he benefited from the funds was disregarded.
17. It is his case that by a notice dated 1st March, 2021, the Respondent summarily dismissed him from service on grounds that included loss of trust and confidence. He avers that his appeal against the dismissal was unsuccessful, and the decision was upheld on 24th March, 2021.
18. The Claimant states that he was subsequently acquitted of the criminal charges on 27th October, 2023.
19. The Claimant also states that the Respondent violated his constitutional rights by selectively subjecting him to disciplinary and criminal proceedings while failing to take equivalent action against other persons implicated in the transactions.
20. He further contends that the Respondent published his photograph and that of his family in its General Handbook without his consent and continued to display his personal telephone number on its public contact information, exposing him to unwanted calls and messages.
21. It is his case that these actions infringed on his rights to privacy, dignity, equality and freedom from discrimination, and fair labour practices.
22. On cross-examination, the Claimant confirmed that the Temporal Affairs Department was his employer, and that ecclesiastical positions including that of Bishop were voluntary rather than employment positions. He acknowledged that he previously faced disciplinary proceedings in 2017 relating to fraud, and that the conclusion at the time referred to potential misappropriation.
23. He maintains that he was cleared for lack of evidence and was subsequently appointed to a new grade in 2020. He stated that he had no document showing that he continued working in the distribution clerk department after 2017.
24. The Claimant further admitted that telephone number 0742386535 was registered using his identity particulars on 12th July, 2019, and that money from the Respondent’s Dandora Branch account was transferred to that number. He confirmed that he gave Wafula a photocopy of his identity card in 2014 or 2015, although he did not have control over its subsequent use.
25. He also acknowledged that Wafula’s letter did not expressly admit to stealing the entire Kshs. 761,554/= or mention the telephone number registered in the Claimant’s name. He confirmed that he reported the matter to the police, was suspended, received the charges against him, responded within the stipulated period, attended the disciplinary hearing with a representative and appealed against the dismissal, but the appeal was unsuccessful.
26. He further acknowledged that lack of trust and confidence was among the grounds for his dismissal.
27. On re-examination, the Claimant clarified that the total alleged loss was Kshs. 761,554/=, while the amount associated with the telephone line registered in his name was approximately Kshs. 245,049/=. He testified that the M-Pesa statement showed that the funds received through that line were transferred to telephone number 0792177572, which was registered to Wafula, and that other persons had also received money through the same line.
28. He stated that Wafula admitted using members’ accounts and passwords and acknowledged stealing Kshs. 318,854/=. The Claimant maintains that he was dismissed over the loss associated with the line registered in his name, which last received money in April 2020, and reiterated that he neither participated in nor benefited from the transactions.
The Claimant’s Submissions.
29. It is the Claimant's submission that his termination was procedurally and substantively unfair, contrary to Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution and Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, 2007.
30. He submits that the Respondent combined the show cause notice with the invitation to a disciplinary hearing, thereby denying him adequate time to respond and prepare, and that the absence of the disciplinary hearing recording or minutes undermined the fairness of the process. He relied on Jefwa v Ecu Worldwide [K] Limited [2024] KEELRC 13633 (KLR) and Kimonge & another v Eastern Produce Kenya Ltd [2024] KEELRC 459 (KLR) on procedural fairness.
31. On the validity of the reason for termination, he submits that the Respondent failed to establish a sufficient evidential link between him and the fraudulent transactions. He maintains that registering an M-Pesa line using his identity particulars did not establish his participation in or benefit from the fraud, and that the Respondent’s investigation and transaction records pointed to other individuals.
32. He further relies on his report of the suspected identity theft and his acquittal in Milimani Criminal Case No. E113 of 2021. He further cites Jadiah M. Mwarania v Kenya Reinsurance Corporation Limited [2018] KEELRC 1443 (KLR), on the burden of proving a valid reason for termination and the requirement for reasonable and sufficient grounds to suspect an employee of misconduct.
33. The Claimant further submits that the Respondent violated his right to privacy under Article 31 of the Constitution by publishing his personal telephone number without consent and violated his rights to privacy and human dignity under Articles 31 and 28, respectively, by publishing his image and that of his family in its General Handbook after termination of his employment. He relied on Muthama v Hornbill Pub Limited [2024] KEHC 15945 (KLR) on the unauthorized publication of a person’s image.
34. On the allegation of discrimination and unequal treatment, the Claimant submits that the Respondent singled him out for dismissal and criminal prosecution while other employees implicated in initiating, approving and processing the transactions were not subjected to comparable disciplinary action. He relied on Article 27 of the Constitution, Section 5 of the Employment Act, and Gichuru v Package Insurance Brokers Ltd [2021] KESC 12 (KLR) on fair labour practices, the right to be heard, and protection against discrimination.
35. The Claimant urged the court to find that his termination was unfair and that his constitutional rights were violated.
The Respondent’s case.
36. The Respondent denies the allegations of unfair and wrongful termination and violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights. It maintains that the Respondent terminated the Claimant’s employment due to a loss of trust and confidence arising from the Claimant's suspected involvement in fraudulent transactions involving the Respondent’s funds.
37. The Respondent maintains further that the Claimant’s termination is lawful and seeks dismissal of the Claim with costs.
38. The Respondent states that the Claimant initially served in various ecclesiastical capacities before being employed as a Distribution Supervisor on 26th July, 2012. It avers that his employment terms were subsequently revised by a contract dated 14th August, 2020, under which he assumed the position of Travel/Fleet Supervisor.
39. The Respondent states that his ecclesiastical service was distinct from his contractual employment.
40. The Respondent states that suspicious transactions were detected in April 2020, involving payments to a person recorded as Tetteh Fountain Richard through telephone number 0742386535.
41. It avers that following investigations, the Respondent discovered that the telephone number was registered in the Claimant’s name, and avers that the Claimant failed to satisfactorily explain the circumstances surrounding the use of his identification details and the disputed transactions.
42. It is the Respondent’s case that Philip Ongore Wafula admitted responsibility for part of the missing funds and undertook to repay the money. It states that it reported the matter to the police, who independently investigated and subsequently arrested and charged the Claimant.
43. The Respondent maintains that the dismissal was not based solely on the arrest, but on the totality of the circumstances and the resulting loss of trust and confidence.
44. The Respondent further maintains that the Claimant was issued with a notice to show cause dated 21st January, 2021, that he responded to it on 27th January, 2021, attended a disciplinary hearing, and was subsequently summarily dismissed by a letter dated 1st March, 2021.
45. It is the Respondent’s case that his appeal was considered and dismissed by a letter dated 24th March, 2021. The Respondent denies malicious prosecution, discrimination and violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights.
46. The Respondent’s witness RW1 reiterated that the Respondent discovered suspicious transactions involving the telephone number registered in the Claimant’s name, and that internal investigations were undertaken before disciplinary proceedings commenced. He maintains that the Claimant’s explanation concerning the use of his national identity card was unsatisfactory and that the Respondent had reasonable grounds to lose confidence in him.
47. On cross-examination, RW1 admitted that the Respondent has not filed its investigation report in court and that the disciplinary hearing minutes were not produced or supplied to the Claimant despite his request. He explained that he recorded the minutes through Microsoft Teams, but they were lost after a laptop crash. He further acknowledged that he had no evidence that the Claimant had initiated or approved the disputed financial assistance requests.
48. RW1 also confirmed that the transaction records reflected the involvement of Philip Wafula and Nathan Ohanga in initiating and approving requests. He acknowledged that Wafula admitted responsibility for approximately Kshs. 220,000, while the total amount remaining unaccounted for was estimated at Kshs. 761,554. However, he maintains that the Respondent has not established who was responsible for the entire loss.
49. On re-examination, RW1 explained that the Claimant had access to Church membership and financial assistance records by virtue of his ecclesiastical position, but did not have authority to approve financial assistance requests. He maintains that the fraudulent transactions continued even after Wafula’s excommunication and that the Respondent could not identify all the persons involved.
50. RW2, Jadmaire Ndivo, explained the distinction between Church membership records and employee records and maintained that the Respondent was unable to establish who entered the disputed telephone number into its membership system.
51. On cross-examination, RW2 confirmed that the Claimant reported the matter to the police and froze the relevant account on 15th September, 2020. He further acknowledged that the payment records reflect the involvement of other persons in initiating and approving the disputed transactions, and that the Respondent has not established who entered the telephone number into its system.
52. He further confirmed that the Respondent could not produce statements for the disputed telephone number because it was not the registered owner of the line.
53. On re-examination, RW2 clarified that the telephone statements in the Respondent’s bundle did not establish the date on which the number was registered and might not cover the entire period under investigation.
54. On the validity of the termination, it submits that the employment relationship was founded on trust and confidence and that an employer could take disciplinary action where there were reasonable grounds to suspect an employee of misconduct involving the employer’s property without necessarily awaiting the outcome of criminal proceedings.
55. The Respondent maintains that the telephone number registered in the Claimant’s name, the unexplained transactions, his explanation concerning his identification card and his previous disciplinary history provided sufficient grounds for the loss of trust and confidence.
56. On procedural fairness, the Respondent relied on Section 41(1) and (2) of the Employment Act, 2007, and the decisions in Agricultural Finance Corporation v Jillo [2025] KECA 2068 (KLR), to submit that the Claimant was issued with a notice to show cause, afforded an opportunity to respond to the allegations, attended a disciplinary hearing accompanied by an employee of his choice and exercised his right of appeal.
57. It consequently urged the Court to find that the termination was procedurally fair.
58. On the alleged violation of constitutional rights, the Respondent submits that the Claimant failed to plead and demonstrate with sufficient precision the constitutional provisions allegedly infringed and the manner of their infringement. It denied discriminating against the Claimant or unlawfully publishing his personal information.
59. On remedies, the Respondent relied on Section 12(3)(vii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act to argue that reinstatement was unavailable because more than three years had lapsed since the dismissal.
60. It also opposed the claims for compensation and general damages, maintaining that the termination was justified and that the Claimant has not established entitlement to the reliefs sought.
61. The Respondent therefore urged the Court to find that the Claimant’s employment was terminated for valid reasons and through a fair procedure, and to dismiss the Claim with costs.
Analysis and Determination
62. The issues that present for determination are:
i. Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair;
ii. Whether his constitutional rights were violated; and
iii. Whether he is entitled to the remedies sought.
Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair
63. A termination of employment is fair and lawful where the employer adheres to the twin tenets of fair process and the substantive justification for the termination espoused under Sections 41, 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007.
64. Under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, 2007, the employer/Respondent bears the burden of proving the reason for the termination, and further demonstrating that it was valid, fair and related to the Claimant’s conduct, capacity or compatibility. (See Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited [2014] KEIC 121 (KLR).
65. The Respondent relied on the registration of a telephone number in the Claimant’s name and its association with disputed/fraudulent transactions involving Kshs.761,554 as the reason for his summary dismissal, phrased as loss of trust and confidence.
66. The Respondent’s witnesses admitted that they did not produce the investigation report and/or the disciplinary hearing minutes, and that no evidence showed that the Claimant initiated or approved the disputed payments.
67. The witnesses further confirmed that the evidence from their investigation implicated other persons in initiating and approving the subject transactions, and that the Claimant reported the suspected misuse of his identity and took steps to freeze the account.
68. These circumstances, in my view, weaken the evidential basis for attributing the misconduct to the Claimant. Loss of trust and confidence, without reasonable evidential grounds, cannot by itself justify a summary dismissal.
69. The Claimant’s assertion that he was acquitted in the criminal proceedings does not, by itself, render the dismissal unfair, since administrative disciplinary action is distinct from criminal proceedings and applies a different standard of proof. The acquittal therefore does not inform the fairness or otherwise of his summary dismissal.
70. Having said that, the Respondent remained duty bound to establish, on a balance of probabilities, that it genuinely and reasonably believed that the Claimant committed the alleged misconduct. As I stated earlier in this judgment, the absence of the investigation report, coupled with the admission that the Claimant did not initiate or approve the transactions, leaves the reason for dismissal insufficiently substantiated.
71. In light of the foregoing, I find and hold that the Respondent has not discharged its burden under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act; hence, the Claimant’s summary dismissal is unfair and unlawful.
72. On procedural fairness, Section 41 of the Employment Act requires that the employer explains the allegations to the employee, in a language the employee understands, and affords him an opportunity to respond in the presence of a fellow employee or shop-floor union representative of his choice. (See Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR).
73. The evidence before the court shows that the Claimant received the allegations leveled against him in the form of a show cause letter, he admitted that he responded to the show cause, attended the disciplinary hearing with a representative, and that he appealed against the Respondent’s decision to summarily dismiss his services.
74. Further, although the failure to produce the disciplinary minutes is a serious evidential deficiency, it does not conclusively establish that the hearing was not fair. The evidence produced shows that the Claimant was afforded an opportunity to be heard in response to the allegations.
75. I therefore reach the conclusion that the Claimant’s dismissal was procedurally fair and lawful.
Whether his constitutional rights were violated
76. On discrimination, Article 27 of the Constitution and Section 5 of the Employment Act prohibit discrimination in employment. In Gichuru v Package Insurance Brokers Ltd [2021] KESC 12 (KLR), the Supreme Court explained the principles governing proof of employment discrimination.
77. Although the Claimant alleges that other persons implicated in the transactions were treated differently, the evidence does not sufficiently establish that the differential treatment was based on a prohibited ground of discrimination.
78. The claim of discrimination therefore fails.
79. Regarding the alleged violation of privacy and dignity, Articles 28 and 31 of the Constitution protect human dignity and privacy. The Claimant was bound to establish the alleged infringement and connect it to the Respondent’s conduct.
80. Further, the allegations concerning publication of his photograph, his family’s image and his telephone number do not, on the material presented, sufficiently establish the circumstances of publication, the absence of lawful justification or the resulting infringement if at all.
81. The claim for separate constitutional damages has therefore not been sufficiently proved, and it fails.
Whether he is entitled to the remedies sought
Reinstatement
82. On reinstatement, Section 12(3)(vii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act limits the Court’s power to order reinstatement to cases in which the order is made within three years of dismissal.
83. The Claimant was dismissed on 1st March, 2021, and the Court is determining the claim after the expiry of that period.
84. Reinstatement is therefore unavailable, and this claim fails.
Damages for unfair dismissal
85. Under Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act, an employee whose termination/dismissal is found to be unfair may be awarded compensation of up to twelve months’ gross wages, subject to the considerations in Section 49(4).
86. I have held the Claimant’s dismissal unfair on account of the Respondent’s failure to justify the validity and fairness of the reasons for the dismissal, hence finding the dismissal substantively unfair. This finding thus entitles the Claimant to compensation pursuant to Section 49 of the Act.
87. Considering the Claimant’s length of service, the circumstances of his dismissal and the parties’ evidence, I deem an award of five months’ gross salary sufficient compensation for the unfair and unlawful dismissal.
88. In the final analysis, the Claimant’s Claim succeeds in terms of the following orders:-
a) A declaration that the Claimant’s dismissal is substantively unfair and unlawful.
b) That the Respondent shall pay the Claimant five months’ salary as compensation for the unfair dismissal.
c) The prayer for reinstatement is declined.
d) The claims for general damages for violation of constitutional rights are dismissed.
e) The compensation awarded herein shall attract interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full.
f) The Respondent shall bear the costs of the claim.
89. Orders accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Mutua present for the Claimant
Mr. Andiwo & Ms. Akech present for the Respondent
Ms. Esther - C/A