Background
By a Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 sought the following orders: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The Notice of Motion seeking leave for the Court to assume jurisdiction before exhaustion of internal mechanisms was dismissed. The Memorandum of Claim was struck out as prematurely filed. The claimant may invoke and exhaust the proper internal appeal procedure before returning to Court, and costs were awarded to the respondent.
33. Having carefully considered the facts of the case, I find no merits in the claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 and decline to assume jurisdiction prematurely. Accordingly, I make the following orders:
Paragraph 33 →
(a) The Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 is dismissed.
Passage 80 →
(b) The Memorandum of Claim dated 13th April 2026 is struck out for being prematurely filed.
Passage 81 →
Held. Decided. The Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya were properly joined as a necessary party. Its joinder was not invalid merely because other necessary parties might also not have been joined.
Ratio. The respondent was necessary because, as the legally recognized holder of Church property, an effective and enforceable judgment against the Church could not otherwise be obtained. The possibility that additional necessary parties existed did not invalidate this respondent's joinder.
Issue
a) Whether the Respondent is a proper party to this suit.
Passage 30 →
Held
15. I have considered the facts of the case and the Constitution of the Anglican Church of Kenya (ACK) Mt. Kenya South Diocese, 2023. The Provincial Constitution was the same in force in 2016 when the case of JMM, JNG & PMW Vs Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya [2016] eKLR supra was decided. Therefore, I adopt the said decision in this case that the respondent is properly joined in the suit because it is a necessary party without which judgments of the court may be unenforceable. There may be other necessary parties not joined as respondents to the suit but that does render the joinder of the respondent herein invalid.
Paragraph 15 →
Ratio
"The court has considered the material on record and there is no doubt that within the statutes of the Anglican Church of Kenya, the Respondent is the only recognized person in law that is responsible for the funds of the Church and the court returns that it is the proper party in a suit like the present suits where the Claimants are seeking pecuniary reliefs and which can only be satisfied by the Respondent on behalf of the Church... the Respondent is the proper party to the suit in this matter where the claimants are seeking a remedy against the Anglican Church of Kenya which otherwise is an unincorporated association. Article XVII of the Constitution of the Anglican Church of Kenya vests all property of the church in the respondent and the court returns that there would be no effective decree or order passed by the court in the present proceedings binding upon the church except against the named respondent. The respondent is therefore the proper party to have been sued in the present proceedings".
Passage 35 →
15. I have considered the facts of the case and the Constitution of the Anglican Church of Kenya (ACK) Mt. Kenya South Diocese, 2023. The Provincial Constitution was the same in force in 2016 when the case of JMM, JNG & PMW Vs Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya [2016] eKLR supra was decided. Therefore, I adopt the said decision in this case that the respondent is properly joined in the suit because it is a necessary party without which judgments of the court may be unenforceable. There may be other necessary parties not joined as respondents to the suit but that does render the joinder of the respondent herein invalid.
Paragraph 15 →
Held. Decided. The Court declined to assume jurisdiction prematurely. The claimant had not demonstrated grounds to bypass exhaustion: the proper appeal was to the Provincial Tribunal under Canon XXI, rather than to the Archbishop. The motion was dismissed and the claim struck out as premature, with liberty to exhaust that proper appeal procedure first.
Ratio. Where a prescribed internal procedure exists for redress, it should be followed before recourse to the Court. The claimant did not use the applicable Provincial Tribunal appeal mechanism and did not establish exceptional circumstances warranting the Court's intervention before exhaustion.
Issue
b) Whether the court should assume jurisdiction over the dispute and permit the Applicant to institute and maintain the proceedings herein before exhausting the respondent’s internal dispute resolution mechanism.
Passage 31 →
Held
31. However, he did not do so and for second time he has come to court. I regret to say that he has not demonstrated why the court should assume jurisdiction over the matter before he exhausts the internal appeal mechanism.
Paragraph 31 →
33. Having carefully considered the facts of the case, I find no merits in the claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 and decline to assume jurisdiction prematurely. Accordingly, I make the following orders:
Paragraph 33 →
(b) The Memorandum of Claim dated 13th April 2026 is struck out for being prematurely filed.
Passage 81 →
Ratio
29. The Claimant did not comply with the above procedure and instead appealed to the Archbishop of the Church. Such appeal procedure is not provided for in the Articles or Canons of both Provincial Constitution and the Diocesan Constitutions of the Church. He appears to have been misled by the Bishop of the Mt. Kenya South Diocese in his letter dated 10th December 2024, which communicated his decision after the hearing of the claimant by the Pastoral Care Committee on 1st November 2024.
Paragraph 29 →
31. However, he did not do so and for second time he has come to court. I regret to say that he has not demonstrated why the court should assume jurisdiction over the matter before he exhausts the internal appeal mechanism.
Paragraph 31 →
“In our view, there is merit in the submission that where there is a clear procedure for redress of any particular grievance prescribed by the Constitution or an Act of Parliament, that procedure should be strictly followed.”
Passage 78 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 sought the following orders: -
Paragraph 1 →The motion was disposed of by written submissions. Having considered the pleadings, Notice of Motion, Affidavits and Written Submissions, the main issues for determination are:
Paragraph 12 →Having carefully considered the facts of the case, I find no merits in the claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 and decline to assume jurisdiction prematurely. Accordingly, I make the following orders:
Paragraph 33 →The court considered whether the Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya was properly joined as respondent, and whether it should assume jurisdiction and allow James Muigai Muthungu to maintain the claim before exhaustion of the Church’s internal…
Muthungu was an ordained minister in the Diocese of Mt. Kenya South for over 22 years. After being required to step aside and later interdicted in 2024, he elected to appear before the Diocesan Pastoral Care Committee. He attended its 1 November 2024 hearing,…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT
NAIROBI
(O N Makau J on 29th October 2026)
CAUSE NO. E377 OF 2026
JAMES MUIGAI MUTHUNGU….…..…………………………..…….. CLAIMANT
VERSUS
THE REGISTERED TRUSTEES OF
THE ANGLICAN CHURCH OF KENYA ………………………..…..RESPONDENT
RULING
Introduction
1. By a Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 sought the following orders: -
a) That, this Honourable Court be pleased to grant leave to the Applicant to institute and maintain these proceedings notwithstanding the non-finalization of internal dispute resolution mechanisms.
b) That, this Honourable Court be pleased to assume jurisdiction over the matter on the basis of the existence of exceptional circumstances as demonstrated by the Applicant.
c) That, this Application be placed for directions and further determination before the Learned Judge on a priority basis.
d) That, any other or further orders and/or directions as this Honourable Court deems just and expedient in the circumstances.
e) That, the costs of this Application be provided for.
2. The Motion was brought under Article 41,47 & 50 (1) of Constitution, section 9(4) of the Fair Administrative Actions Act, order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and Section 1A,1B &3A of the Civil Procedure Act. It was supported by a Supporting Affidavit sworn by the Applicant, on 13th April 2026, and was opposed by the Respondent through Grounds of Opposition dated 20th May 2026. It was then disposed of by way of written submissions.
Facts
3. The Applicant was a long-serving ordained minister who served the Anglican Church of Kenya under the Diocese of Mt. Kenya South for over twenty-two (22) years, firstly as an evangelist from the year 2002 and eventually as a clergy upon promotion in the year 2011. His net monthly salary was Kshs. 90,000 and he was posted to various parishes within the Diocese of Mt. Kenya South.
4. On 7th May 2024, the Applicant received a letter requiring him to step aside indefinitely pending investigations into an alleged misconduct. By another letter dated 20th May 2024, he was interdicted on half salary for three months from 1st June 2024 to 31st August 2024. By a letter dated 3rd September 2024, he was given four options to choose one, and by his letter 9th September 2024, he chose the option of “facing the Diocesan Pastoral Care Committee established under Article X of the Diocese of Mt Kenya South 2023 to defend himself, and whose decision is binding and final.” He also requested to be supplied with the evidence to be relied on during the hearing at least seven days prior. He further requested to be accompanied by a representative in line with the established law.
5. By a letter dated 8th October 2024, the Bishop of Mt. Kenya South Diocese invoked the provisions of Canon XVI of the Constitution and Canon XIV of the constitution of the Diocese of the Mt. Kenya South and invited the claimant to appear before the diocesan Pastoral Care Committee on 1st November 2024. The claimant protested the failure to be provided with the requested evidence vide various letters and none was provided and instead he was told that the meeting was not a Tribunal. The claimant attended the hearing with his counsel who raised objection but the same was not allowed and he was told to leave the meeting.
6. Subsequently, the claimant received a letter dated 10th December 2024 notifying of Intention to withdraw his licence as a priest based on his admission that 40% of the allegations made against him. The letter also gave him a right of appeal to the Archbishop of the Anglican Church of Kenya within 30 days. He lodged his appeal on 9th January 2025 pursuant to the internal dispute resolution mechanisms established under the applicable Canons of the Church seeking, inter alia, review of the disciplinary process, reinstatement of his ministerial privileges and a fair hearing in accordance with Church law and the Constitution of Kenya.
7. Receipt of the appeal was acknowledged by the Provincial Chancellor, vide an email dated 17th January 2025, which noted that the matter was purely a diocesan matter and wondered what was the legal basis upon which the appeal was lodged. The claimant respondent vide letter dated 21st January 2025 indicating that the right of appeal was granted vide the notice of intention to withdrawal of his priestly license.
8. Subsequently, the claimant filed suit before this court, Cause E090 of 2025 but the respondent raised a preliminary objection to the same contending that the claimant had not exhausted internal mechanism. By a ruling delivered on 23rd October 2025, the court upheld the objection and directed the parties to exhaust the internal procedure before approaching the court.
9. Following the said Court ruling, it became incumbent upon the Respondent to activate the prescribed internal process under the relevant Church Canons. However, despite follow-ups including a letter dated 13th November 2025 requesting the commencement of the internal appeal, the Respondent remained silent and failed to act for a period exceeding five (5) months since the delivery of the ruling on 23rd October 2025.
10. As a result, the claimant brought this suit and the instant motion on 13th April 2026. Upto date, no response has been given to the Applicant's appeal and no explanation has been provided for the prolonged delay.
11. The Respondent entered appearance in this case on 20th May 2026 and filed Grounds of Opposition dated the same date. It contended that it is not the Applicant's employer and as such it is improperly joined to these proceedings; that the disciplinary proceedings, administrative actions, and decisions complained of were undertaken by the Anglican Church of Kenya Diocese of Mt. Kenya South and not by the Respondent; and that it lacks the mandate, authority and institutional capacity to convene, supervise, or conclude the internal dispute resolution mechanism contemplated under the applicable Canons of the Anglican Church of Kenya.
12. The motion was disposed of by written submissions. Having considered the pleadings, Notice of Motion, Affidavits and Written Submissions, the main issues for determination are:
a) Whether the Respondent is a proper party to this suit.
b) Whether the court should assume jurisdiction over the dispute and permit the Applicant to institute and maintain the proceedings herein before exhausting the respondent’s internal dispute resolution mechanism.
Whether the Respondent is a proper party in this suit
13. The Respondent contended that it is not the Applicant's employer and as such it is improperly joined to these proceedings. It argued that the Applicant has failed to establish any contractual, statutory or legal relationship between himself and the Respondent capable of grounding the reliefs sought herein. The Respondent further contended that the disciplinary proceedings, administrative actions, and decisions complained of were undertaken by the Anglican Church of Kenya Diocese of Mt. Kenya South and not by the Respondent.
14. The Applicant on the other hand submitted that the Respondent is the proper party to be sued in the instant suit, since it is incorporated under the provisions of Article XVII of the Constitution of the Anglican Church of Kenya. For emphasis he relied on the case of J M M, J N G & P M W Vs. Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya [2016] eKLR, where Ongaya, J, held as follows:
"The court has considered the material on record and there is no doubt that within the statutes of the Anglican Church of Kenya, the Respondent is the only recognized person in law that is responsible for the funds of the Church and the court returns that it is the proper party in a suit like the present suits where the Claimants are seeking pecuniary reliefs and which can only be satisfied by the Respondent on behalf of the Church... the Respondent is the proper party to the suit in this matter where the claimants are seeking a remedy against the Anglican Church of Kenya which otherwise is an unincorporated association. Article XVII of the Constitution of the Anglican Church of Kenya vests all property of the church in the respondent and the court returns that there would be no effective decree or order passed by the court in the present proceedings binding upon the church except against the named respondent. The respondent is therefore the proper party to have been sued in the present proceedings".
15. I have considered the facts of the case and the Constitution of the Anglican Church of Kenya (ACK) Mt. Kenya South Diocese, 2023. The Provincial Constitution was the same in force in 2016 when the case of JMM, JNG & PMW Vs Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya [2016] eKLR supra was decided. Therefore, I adopt the said decision in this case that the respondent is properly joined in the suit because it is a necessary party without which judgments of the court may be unenforceable. There may be other necessary parties not joined as respondents to the suit but that does render the joinder of the respondent herein invalid.
Where the Court should assume jurisdiction before internal procedure is exhausted
16. The claimant urged the court to assume jurisdiction because the respondent has failed to hear his appeal even after the court ordered it to do so. However, the respondent averred that it has no mandate, authority or even institutional capacity to convene, supervise or conclude the internal dispute resolution mechanism contemplated under the applicable Canons of the Anglican Church of Kenya.
17. There is no doubt that impugned proceedings were before the Pastoral Care Committee of Mt. Kenya South Diocese. I have perused the Constitution of Anglican Church of Kenya Mt. Kenya South Diocese to see what powers the Diocesan Pastoral Care Committee enjoys. The Committee is established under Article X of the Constitution and its composition and its functions are as follows:
(a) Membership
i. The Bishop or his nominee who shall be the Chairperson;
ii. The Administrative Secretary who shall be the Secretary;
iii. The Vicar General;
iv. Other Bishops serving in the Diocese;
v. The active clerical and lay Canons of the Diocese;
vi. Tw (2) Archdeacons appointed by the Standing Committee of the Synod;
vii. The Provost;
viii. The Clerical Secretary of Synod;
ix. Three (3) laypersons appointed by the Standing Committee of Synod.
(b) Functions
i. To exercise a general watchfulness over the pastoral work of the Diocese and to ensure that as far as possible the flock of Christ is cared for and spiritually fed.
ii. To reach out to errant clergy and other Church workers with the aim of rehabilitating, supporting and winning them back to the flock.
iii. To examine the candidates for commissioning as Lay Readers and advise the Bishop on their suitability prior to licensing.
iv. To receive from the Bishop advance information as to any disciplinary action he may feel himself compelled to take against any Clergyman or lay person in the Diocese.
v. Upon referral from the Bishop, grant a fair hearing to persons under any form of accusation in accordance to the rules of natural justice and make recommendations to the Bishop accordingly, without prejudice to the exercise of the powers granted to the Bishop under this constitution.
vi. To inform the Bishop of any irregularities in the life of the clergy or congregations that may have come to their notice.
vii. To advise the Bishop with regards to formation of new Parishes, Deaneries, or Archdeaconries or modification of boundaries between parishes, Deaneries or Archdeaconries.
viii. To advise the Bishop concerning contemplated transfer and posting of clergy and other licensed workers in the Diocese prior to the effectuating of such transfer and posting.
18. The summary of the above mandate of Committee is oversight on the Clergy in the Diocese and where necessary rehabilitate them. The other main role is advisory to the Bishop on disciplinary matters referred to it by the Bishop. It is not a Tribunal for conducting disciplinary proceedings against the Clergy.
19. The Tribunal of the diocese is established under Canon XIII of the Anglican Church of Kenya Mt. Kenya South Diocese and it is presided over by the Vicar General of the Diocese as the Chairperson, three priests of five years standing and above, plus three laymen, one of who must be a lawyer appointed by the Diocesan Synod. In addition, the Bishop may in any desirable case appoint one Clergyman and a layman from his own or another Diocese in the Church as Assessors to assist the Tribunal in purely advisory capacity. The Diocesan Chancellor also sits in the tribunal in an advisory capacity and is not a member of the Tribunal. The Diocesan Tribunal is the Trial Court for Priests and Deacons under Canon XVIII of the Provincial Constitution while the Tribunal created under Canon XXI of the Provincial Constitution is the Court of Appeal.
20. Canon XIV, XV, XVI, XVII and XVIII of the Anglican Church of Kenya Mt. Kenya South Diocesan Constitution then sets out the charges or accusation which may be presented against a Bishop, Priest, Deacon or Layperson of the Church; the procedure to be followed and the sentences that can be meted out upon conviction. Canon XXI then provides for appeal against the decision of Diocesan Tribunal to the Provincial Tribunal.
21. In the instant case, it is clear that the proceedings before the Anglican Church of Kenya Mt. Kenya South Diocesan pastoral Care Committee were not disciplinary proceedings before a Diocesan Tribunal highlighted above. The Committee admitted as such in its letter dated 24th October 2024 whereby it responded to a demand letter by the Claimant’s advocate dated 9th September 2024.
22. As I have indicated above, the mandate of the Diocesan Pastoral Care Committee is not disciplinary per se but oversight and advisory on pastoral work in the Diocese. However, upon referral by the Bishop, it can grant a hearing to persons for any accusation and make recommendations to the Bishop.
23. In exercise of the foregoing mandate, the Diocesan Pastoral Care Committee summoned the claimant to appear before it upon referral by the Bishop. The summons was vide letter dated 8th October 2024 to a meeting on 1st November 2024. The decision to summon the claimant was informed by the claimant’s own choice exercised vide his letter dated 9th September 2024 which was in response to a communique from the Bishop dated 3rd September 2024.
24. The Communique gave options (a) to (d) and he chose option (c) which provided as follows:
“(c). You may choose to face the Diocesan Pastoral Care Committee established under Article X of the Constitution of the Diocese of Mt. Kenya South 2023 and make your case before them. The decision of this constitutional committee will be binding and final.”
25. It is without dispute that the claimant attended the hearing before the Pastoral Care Committee with his Lawyer on 1st November 2024 and by a letter dated 10th December 2024, the Bishop of Mt. Kenya South Diocese communicated his decision after the Pastoral Care Committee proceedings. The decision was the intention to withdraw his Priestly licence. Accordingly, he was ordered to surrender all his Ordination documents and Black Stole to the Diocesan Office before 20th December 2024. He was given the right of appeal to the Archbishop of the Anglican Church of Kenya within one month.
26. The claimant appealed to the Archbishop but the appeal was never heard as the Arch Bishop wrote back to him to indicate the legal basis upon which he was appealing to the Archbishop when there must be a procedure for appeal so in the Constitution of the Church.
27. The claimant filed suit but the Court declined jurisdiction and directed him to exhaust the internal mechanism first. The claimant has come back to the same court seeking leave to institute suit before exhausting the internal procedure.
28. From the foregoing background, it is clear that the claimant was accorded a hearing by the Pastoral Care Committee on 1st November 2024 and it made its recommendation to the Bishop who then made a decision of intention to withdraw the claimant’s licence. The Bishop further ordered the claimant to surrender his Ordination Documents and the Black Stole. In my view, the said decision was appealable to the Provincial
Tribunal under Canon XXI of the Provincial Constitution. Canon XXI provides that:
“1. There shall, subject as is hereinafter otherwise provided, be a right of appeal to the Provincial Tribunal from any judgment or sentence of the diocesan Tribunal or (as the case may be) the judgment or sentence of the Bishop:-
(a) By presenters in cases…
(b) By persons against whom judgment shall have been given…”
29. The Claimant did not comply with the above procedure and instead appealed to the Archbishop of the Church. Such appeal procedure is not provided for in the Articles or Canons of both Provincial Constitution and the Diocesan Constitutions of the Church. He appears to have been misled by the Bishop of the Mt. Kenya South Diocese in his letter dated 10th December 2024, which communicated his decision after the hearing of the claimant by the Pastoral Care Committee on 1st November 2024.
30. I would not wish to blame the claimant for complying with the orders of the person who passed judgment and against him. However, I believe the claimant had served in the church long enough to know the disciplinary procedure that applied to him. Besides, he was represented by Counsel who vide email dated 17th January 2025 was given an opportunity by the Archbishop to consider the Constitution of the Church and verify the proper appeal procedure.
31. However, he did not do so and for second time he has come to court. I regret to say that he has not demonstrated why the court should assume jurisdiction over the matter before he exhausts the internal appeal mechanism.
32. Courts in the country have consistently upheld the doctrine of exhaustion and the constitutional duty to encourage Alternative Disputes Resolution (ADR). In the case of Speaker of National Assembly –vs- James Njenga Karume [1992] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that:-
“In our view, there is merit in the submission that where there is a clear procedure for redress of any particular grievance prescribed by the Constitution or an Act of Parliament, that procedure should be strictly followed.”
33. Having carefully considered the facts of the case, I find no merits in the claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 and decline to assume jurisdiction prematurely. Accordingly, I make the following orders:
(a) The Notice of Motion dated 13th April 2026 is dismissed.
(b) The Memorandum of Claim dated 13th April 2026 is struck out for being prematurely filed.
(c) The Claimant is at liberty to invoke and exhaust the proper internal appeal procedure before coming to court.
(d) Costs of the suit to respondent.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
ONESMUS MAKAU
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mugane for Claimant
Okiring for Respondent