Employment law

Muinde v Afya Co-operative Savings and Credit Society Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14842 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E1086 of 2024
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant filed this suit to challenge the Respondent’s decision to terminate the contract of service between the parties. He contends that the Respondent first engaged his services on 2nd April 1984. He avers that he grew through the ranks until he was appointed to the position of General Manager – Human Resources and Administration with effect from 2nd January 2024.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO E1086 OF 2024

ROBERT KIMANZI MUINDE……....………………………….CLAIMANT

VERSUS

AFYA CO-OPERATIVE SAVINGS AND CREDIT SOCIETY LTD………………………………………………………………RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Background

1. The Claimant filed this suit to challenge the Respondent’s decision to terminate the contract of service between the parties. He contends that the Respondent first engaged his services on 2nd April 1984. He avers that he grew through the ranks until he was appointed to the position of General Manager – Human Resources and Administration with effect from 2nd January 2024.

2. The Claimant avers that throughout his tenure, he served the Respondent diligently and without blemish. However, he contends that the Respondent unlawfully terminated his contract on 11th September 2024 purportedly on account of early retirement after it subjected him to a conjured disciplinary process.

3. The Claimant avers that prior to the Respondent terminating his employment, it had consistently acknowledged his performance as satisfactory. He contends that it is because of his exemplary performance that the Respondent offered him promotions and issued him with certificates of recognition and long service.

4. The Claimant contends that when the Respondent promoted him to the position of General Manager – Human Resources and Administration, it undertook to issue him with a detailed Job Description. However, he contends that this was not done.

5. The Claimant contends that on 12th August 2024, the Respondent issued him with a letter of interdiction and intention of summary dismissal. He avers that the Respondent accused him of having failed to foresee the crisis that afflicted it (the Respondent) around the same time from a human resource perspective. He further asserts that the Respondent accused him of economic sabotage.

6. The Claimant contends that the Respondent gave him only one day to offer his response to the accusations against him. At the same time, he avers that the Respondent barred him from accessing the workplace or interacting with other members of staff without prior permission by it.

7. The Claimant avers that he offered his response to the charges as directed. He further contends that the Respondent thereafter invited him to a disciplinary hearing which was scheduled for 29th August 2024.

8. The Claimant avers that the Respondent did not share with him the report which it is required to prepare in respect of an employee who is to be placed on interdiction or suspension in terms of clause 12(ii) of its Management Staff Terms and Conditions of Service Manual. He further avers that the Respondent did not prove the allegations it had made against him during the disciplinary hearing.

9. The Claimant avers that in a strange twist of events, the Respondent issued him with a letter for summary dismissal from service on account of early retirement. He avers that he received the said letter under protest.

10. The Claimant contends that clause 14 of the Respondent’s Management Staff Terms and Conditions of Service Manual stipulates that an employee may voluntarily retire at the age of fifty (50) years. However, he states that the clause sets the mandatory retirement age at sixty (60) years.

11. The Claimant contends that he appealed the decision to compulsorily retire him prematurely and asked to be allowed to continue in service until he attained the mandatory retirement age of sixty (60) years as stipulated in the Management Staff Terms and Conditions of Service Manual. However, he contends that the Respondent ignored his appeal.

12. The Claimant thus states that the decision to dismiss him from service on account of early retirement breached his rights to fair labour practices and fair administrative action. As such, he avers that his services were unlawfully terminated.

13. The Claimant avers that at the point of his release from employment, he had accumulated 41 leave days. Consequently, he prays for commutation of the leave days into cash payment of Ksh. 829,205.42.

14. The Claimant further prays for:-

a) A declaration that his contract of service was unlawfully terminated.

b) A declaration that the Respondent violated his rights to fair labour practices and fair administrative action.

c) Payment of unlawfully withheld salary of Ksh. 299,400.00.

d) Payment of salary in lieu of notice to terminate his contract in the sum of Ksh. 1,394,925.00.

e) Payment of salary of Ksh. 5,579,700.00 to cover the remainder of his term of service to retirement age.

f) Compensation for unfair termination of his contract of service equivalent to his salary for twelve (12) months.

g) Certificate of Service.

h) Interest on the amounts claimed.

i) Costs of the suit.

15. During the trial, the Claimant adopted his witness statement as his evidence in chief. He also produced the various documents in his bundles and lists of documents as his exhibits.

16. The Claimant stated that the Respondent terminated his service on account of early retirement. He contended that this was unlawful.

17. The Claimant stated that the Respondent’s Management Staff Terms and Conditions of Service Manual has provision for both early and mandatory retirement. He said the manual sets voluntary retirement age at fifty (50) years and mandatory retirement age at sixty (60) years. He averred that the Respondent does not have any other policy provisions on retirement age.

18. The Claimant contended that he was forced to retire from the Respondent’s service at the age of fifty nine (59) years. He stated that he did not offer to retire early.

19. In cross examination, the Claimant acknowledged that his School Leaving Certificate indicated his date of birth as 15th August 1965. As such, he contended that he should have retired around 16th August 2025. However, he stated that he was forced to retire in September 2024.

20. The Claimant identified a string of letters through which the Respondent transferred his services to various departments. He contended that during his career, he underwent several trainings which enabled him to assume the role of Human Resource Manager with the Respondent. However, he conceded that he did not have specialized training in Human Resource management.

21. Although the Claimant averred in the Statement of Claim that he was not given a Job Description for the position of General Manager -Human Resources and Administration, he conceded during cross examination that he was given a Job Description for the position. He identified the documents at pages 32 to 35 of the Respondent’s trial bundle as the Job Description which was issued to him.

22. During cross-examination, the Claimant acknowledged that the Respondent issued him with a Certificate of Service dated 25th November 2025. However, he stated that the certificate erroneously shows that his services with the Respondent were terminated on 12th September 2024.

23. The Claimant asserted that at the time his contract was terminated, he was holding the position of substantive General Manager, Human Resources and Administration. However, he conceded that he was appointed to the position in acting capacity and that the Certificate of Service showed that at the time he was relieved of his duties, he was still serving as acting General Manager, Human Resources and Administration.

24. The Claimant stated that he is a member of the Institute of Human Resource Management. However, he conceded that he is not a registered Human Resource Practitioner. He also conceded that he did not have a Human Resource Practicing Certificate whilst he was in the Respondent’s service. Nonetheless, he stated that he was not aware that the law required him to have a practicing certificate in order to hold the position of Human Resource Manager for the Respondent.

25. The Claimant stated that he was aware that the Respondent’s Board of Directors used to invite members of the Respondent’s management to its meetings. He confirmed that he used to attend the meetings as a member of the Respondent’s management.

26. The Claimant stated that members of management were not entitled to earn sitting allowance for attending the Board meetings. He denied that he used to be paid such allowance. It was his case that the allowance used to be paid to Board members only.

27. The Claimant stated that he was not aware that the aforesaid arrangement where the Respondent’s management would be invited to Board meetings was discontinued. As a matter of fact, he stated that he was aware that such meetings were still being held.

28. The Claimant stated that one such meeting took place on 8th August 2023 when the Respondent’s Human Resource policies were to be reviewed. He contended that the Respondent engaged a consultant, one Stephen Amadalo, who attended the meeting and was tasked to fine tune the meeting’s report. He averred that by the time his contract was terminated, the process of fine tuning the report from the meeting of 8th August 2023 had not been finalized.

29. The Claimant stated that he was invited to a management meeting scheduled for 24th July 2024. He confirmed that he attended the meeting which was also attended by Mr. Stephen Amadalo. However, he denied that he was informed during the meeting that his position of General Manager – Human Resources and Administration was to be scrapped.

30. The Claimant conceded that he was aware that the Respondent had been undertaking job evaluations which was meant to yield new job structures. However, he stated that the process had not been finalized as at 24th July 2024.

31. The witness identified an Internal Memo dated 24th July 2024 which was issued by the General Manager – Investments and Estates. The Memo was addressed to the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer. He acknowledged that the document showed that the Memo was copied to him. However, he denied having received a copy of the said Memo.

32. The Claimant confirmed that there was an incident which happened within the Respondent’s premises on 6th August 2024. However, he stated that he did not have full particulars of it. He stated that he only heard that there was a disagreement and commotion at the banking hall involving members of the Respondent and some of the Respondent’s employees. He stated that the incident happened after working hours when most members of staff had left for home. He further stated that he heard about the commotion the following day.

33. The Claimant stated that by the time he was notified of the incident, the matter had already been escalated to the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer to handle. As such, he stated that he did not involve himself in the matter.

34. The Claimant contended that he was subsequently issued with a letter of interdiction on 12th August 2024. He said that he was subsequently invited for a disciplinary hearing on 26th August 2024.

35. The Claimant confirmed that he attended the disciplinary hearing. He also confirmed that he signed the minutes of the hearing.

36. The Claimant stated that the Respondent then issued him with a letter to terminate his services on account of early retirement. He confirmed that he signed the letter even though he did not agree with it.

37. The Claimant reiterated that the Respondent’s decision to terminate his services was unfair. He insisted that although he was not a registered Human Resource practitioner, he had received trainings in the area and the Respondent engaged him as such based on the trainings he had received. He further stated that he was a registered member of the Institute of Human Resource Management which entitled him to hold Human Resource positions. As such, he averred that the Respondent was not entitled to terminate his services on this account or to retire him prematurely.

38. The Claimant stated that the Respondent never questioned his qualifications whilst he was still in service. He averred that the Respondent only raised the matter during trial of the case.

39. The Claimant stated that although the Respondent alleged that his position had ceased to exist, that was not the reason which was cited in the letter of termination. He further contended that the Respondent never notified him of a redundancy at the workplace.

40. The Respondent does not admit the claim. It filed a Memorandum of Reply dated 2nd April 2025 to anchor its response to the claim.

41. The Respondent admits that the parties had an employment relationship which spanned over a period of fourty (40) years before it was brought to a close on 11th September 2024. However, it denies that the relationship was unlawfully terminated.

42. The Respondent acknowledges that the Claimant was appointed to serve as its Acting General Manager – Human Resources and Administration. However, it denies that the appointment gave him legitimate expectation to remain in service until the mandatory retirement age of sixty (60) years. Further, it contends that the Claimant was expected to offer optimum service whilst serving as its Acting General Manager – Human Resources and Administration.

43. The Respondent acknowledges that it issued the Claimant with certificates of recognition and long service during his tenure of service. However, it denies that this is evidence of his exemplary performance. On the contrary, it asserts that the Claimant failed to diligently execute his duties as Acting General Manager – Human Resources and Administration resulting in the decision to send him on early retirement.

44. The Respondent denies the Claimant’s assertion that it did not issue him with a Job Description for the position of Acting General Manager – Human Resources and Administration. Nevertheless, it contends that even if that was the case, the omission cannot justify the Claimant’s failure to execute his responsibilities in that position.

45. The Respondent asserts that the Claimant was lawfully interdicted from duty. It further avers that he was duly notified of the disciplinary case against him and the grounds therefor.

46. The Respondent avers that the Claimant was afforded a fair opportunity to respond to the accusations against him. It further asserts that he indeed proffered a detailed response to the accusations before he was taken through the disciplinary hearing.

47. The Respondent denies that it unlawfully reduced the Claimant’s salary. It contends that it only effected lawful deductions to his pay.

48. The Respondent asserts that it opted to retire the Claimant early because this was the most humane option that was available to it in contradistinction to summarily terminating his services. It avers that it opted to retire the Claimant in view of his long service and advanced age.

49. The Respondent denies that it declined to hear the Claimant’s appeal. Nevertheless, it contends that it was under no obligation in law to give the Claimant an additional opportunity to be heard through appeal.

50. The Respondent asserts that it paid the Claimant for all his unutilized leave days. As such, it denies his claim for leave days.

51. The Respondent denies that it handled the Claimant’s case in contravention of his rights to fair labour practices and fair administrative action. It reiterates that the decision to release the Claimant from service was arrived at in accordance with the law.

52. During the trial, the Respondent’s witness adopted his witness statement as the defense evidence in chief. He also tendered in evidence the documents which are attached to the lists and bundles of documents which were filed by the defense.

53. The witness stated that he serves the Respondent in the position of a consultant. He stated that the events which precipitated the decision to terminate the Claimant’s services occurred whilst he (the witness) was serving the Respondent in the aforesaid capacity.

54. The witness stated that sometime in 2024, the Respondent entrusted its General Managers, the Claimant included, with the task of coming up with a turnaround strategy for its business. However, he contended that no appropriate action was taken by the management team in this regard. He stated that in view of this lapse, the Respondent established a Task Force to undertake the process.

55. Meanwhile, he asserted that the Respondent appointed him to undertake a job evaluation exercise for senior management. He stated that following this appointment, he convened a meeting with the Heads of Divisions on 24th July 2024 to discuss the job evaluation process and review the Respondent’s Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manual.

56. The witness alleged that he informed the Heads of Division that the Respondent had resolved to do away with the position of General Manager for all the divisions with effect from end of July 2024. However, he stated that the Claimant pleaded for an extension of the period within which the decision was to be implemented.

57. The witness alleged that the Respondent’s General Managers were unhappy with the decision to scrap their positions. As a result, he contended that one of the managers, Mr. Stephen Obondi, wrote an Internal Memo dated 24th July 2024 to the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer raising various grievances. He alleged that the Internal Memo was copied to the rest of the General Managers in other divisions.

58. The witness stated that shortly after the Respondent’s managers issued the aforesaid Internal Memo, members of the Respondent congregated at the Respondent’s premises on 6th August 2024 and demanded to be paid their shares. However, he stated that there was delay in making the payment, a matter which allegedly infuriated the members thereby causing a commotion.

59. The witness stated that the ensuing commotion was publicized through social media prompting a rush by other members of the Respondent to withdraw their shares from the Respondent. He stated that the panic withdrawals that ensured exposed the Respondent to the risk of total collapse. He further stated that the incident caused the Respondent severe reputational damage, a matter which saw the immediate intervention of the Respondent’s regulator.

60. The witness stated that in view of these developments, the Respondent was forced to take immediate remedial measures in order to save itself from collapse and from being placed under statutory management by its regulator. He stated that part of the remedial steps included taking disciplinary action against members of management, including the Claimant.

61. The witness stated that members of management, including the Claimant, were issued with letters of interdiction and asked to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against them for the mayhem which was witnessed on 6th August 2024. He stated that the Respondent accused the Claimant of having failed to foresee the crisis from a human resource perspective in order to avert it. He said that the Respondent considered the Claimant’s inaction as intentional economic sabotage.

62. The witness stated that the Claimant was given an opportunity to respond to the accusations against him before he was taken through a disciplinary hearing. He contended that the Claimant conceded that he was collectively responsible for the direction which the Respondent had taken and that the Respondent’s mode of service delivery was old fashioned.

63. The witness stated that the Disciplinary Committee arrived at the conclusion that the Claimant had no appropriate training to enable him to hold the position of Human Resources Manager. He averred that the Committee was of the view that the Claimant did not understand his role in human resource.

64. The witness asserted that the Committee felt that the Claimant’s deficiencies contributed to the occurrence of the incident of 6th August 2024. He said that the Committee felt that the Claimant neither took nor was capable of taking action to prevent the incident.

65. The witness stated that in view of the findings by the Committee, it (the Committee) recommended for the Claimant’s summary dismissal from employment. However, he stated that the Respondent’s Board decided to commute the sentence to early retirement.

66. The witness stated that the Claimant appealed the decision. However, he stated that the appeal was rejected since it lacked merit.

67. The witness stated that the Respondent prepared a Certificate of Service for the Claimant. However, he stated that he could not confirm if the Claimant picked it.

68. The witness confirmed that the Internal Memo dated 24th July 2024 to the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer was authored by one Obondi, the Respondent’s General Manager – Investments and Estates. He stated that Mr. Obondi signed the Memo on 14th August 2024.

69. The witness also identified a document dated 19th June 2024 which spoke to the turnaround strategy for the Respondent. He confirmed that the document was also signed by Mr. Obondi on 14th August 2024.

70. The witness also identified a property management report dated 13th August 2024 which was prepared by Mr. Obondi. He acknowledged that Mr. Obondi, the Respondent’s General Manager – Investments and Estates, raised a complaint regarding the Respondent’s decision to appoint M/S Tysons Ltd to manage the Respondent’s assets as this overlapped with the mandate of the Investment Division of the Respondent thereby creating accountability gaps.

71. The witness confirmed that although the Disciplinary Committee recommended for the dismissal of the Claimant from the Respondent’s services, the letter of termination stated that his release from service was on account of early retirement. He was ambivalent regarding whether the letter of dismissal made reference to the proceedings before the Disciplinary Committee.

72. The witness stated that the reasons why the Respondent terminated the Claimant’s services were not mentioned in the letter of termination. He further stated that the Respondent did not warn the Claimant that it intended to terminate his services on account of the undisclosed reasons.

73. The witness stated that the Claimant had not attained the age of sixty (60) years when he was retired. He conceded that the Respondent’s policy manual does not provide for mandatory early retirement before one gets to sixty (60) years. He stated that the policy only recognizes voluntary early retirement.

74. The witness stated that the letter of termination which was issued to the Claimant compelled him to retire early. He conceded that this was contrary to the Respondent’s retirement policy.

75. The witness acknowledged that the leave computation form which was produced as part of the Respondent’s evidence was prepared after the Claimant had left employment. He also conceded that the form was prepared without the input of the Claimant and that the amount mentioned in it (the form) was not paid to the Claimant. As a matter of fact, he stated that the Claimant was yet to be paid his terminal dues.

76. Referring to his witness statement, the witness contended that the decision by the Respondent’s Board to discontinue the practice of holding joint meetings with the Respondent’s management infuriated the General Managers since it deprived them of the benefit of sitting allowance. However, he conceded that he had not tabled evidence to demonstrate that the General Managers used to earn sitting allowance for attending Board meetings.

77. The witness stated that the Respondent conducted investigations to ascertain the Claimant’s culpability for the accusations which were leveled against him. However, he stated that no investigation report was compiled.

78. The witness stated that he conducted a job evaluation for the Claimant in early 2024. However, he conceded that he had not tendered a copy of the evaluation report before court.

79. The witness confirmed that the Respondent had hired the Claimant as its Acting General Manager - Human Resources. He confirmed that this role required the Claimant to handle all human resource issues within the Respondent’s establishment.

80. However, he asserted that the Claimant was to only deal with the Respondent’s internal human resource issues whilst he (the witness) handled other human resource matters in his capacity as an external consultant. It was his case that the two roles did not conflict.

Issues for Determination

81. After evaluating the pleadings, evidence and submissions by the parties, the following issues arise for determination:-

a) Whether the Claimant’s contract of service was terminated unfairly.

b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs which he seeks in the suit.

Analysis and Determination

82. The genesis of the Respondent’s decision to terminate the Claimant’s contract of service can be traced from its (the Respondent’s) letter to the Claimant dated 12th August 2024. In the letter, the Respondent accused the Claimant of having failed to foresee the commotion which occurred at its premises on 6th August 2024 in order to stop it from happening.

83. The Respondent asserted that as a member of management, the Claimant bore collective responsibility for the mayhem since he did not foretell the incident from a human resource perspective. It asserted that the Claimant did not propose ways to balance the needs of the employees and those of the business in order to avert the crisis.

84. The Respondent asserted that the Claimant only focused on people (employee) welfare whilst forgetting that the people (employees) could only benefit if the business also thrived. It contended that the Claimant ought to have applied his personal and professional skills to de-escalate the crisis but he did not do so. As such, it accused him of having condoned the incident.

85. The Respondent alleged that the Claimant’s acts of omission amounted to economic sabotage against it warranting disciplinary action against him. As such, it demanded that he shows cause why he should not be subjected to disciplinary action.

86. The record shows that the Claimant offered his response to the accusations through his letter dated 13th August 2024. He acknowledged that as a member of management, he shared in the responsibility of shaping the direction of the Respondent. However, he denied that he had failed to advise the Respondent’s management on its (the Respondent’s) state. On the contrary he averred that he had been at the forefront in providing guidelines to facilitate the attainment of the Respondent’s mission and vision.

87. The Claimant stated that he had advocated for restructuring of the Respondent following which, it (the Respondent) undertook a job evaluation process. However, he stated that the results of the process were not implemented.

88. The Claimant further stated that he had advised the Respondent to put in place a new strategic plan for the year 2023 to 2027. He also stated that he had spearheaded a review process of the Respondent’s policies with a view to doing away with duplication of roles in the organization. He contended that this was necessitated by the need to avoid wastage of resources and streamline the Respondent’s operations.

89. The Claimant contended that the Respondent’s business model was outdated and had contributed to loss of membership and business. He stated that he had supported a systems upgrade and attended sessions intended to address this challenge.

90. The Claimant further stated that on the instructions of the Respondent’s Board of Directors, he, together with other General Managers, had formed a task force which prepared a strategic turn around brief for the Respondent. He contended that the brief showed that the main challenge which the Respondent required to address related to its liquidity.

91. The Claimant averred that the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer was briefed about these interventions and requested to escalate the matters to the Board for consideration. He stated that the interventions demonstrated his efforts to improve efficiency in the Respondent’s service delivery.

92. The Claimant contended that the aforesaid interventions demonstrated a desire on his part to facilitate the success of the Respondent. As such, he denied that he had tried to sabotage the Respondent’s business.

93. The Claimant stated that the incident on 6th August 2024 was linked to the Respondent’s Finance Department more than it was to the Human Resource Department. This is even as he acknowledged that as a team player, he had a role to play in the success or failure of the organization.

94. The Claimant averred that the incident of 6th August 2024 happened due to stagnation of county remittances. He stated that this was beyond their control.

95. The record shows that a task force comprising some of the Respondent’s General Managers had indeed prepared a turnaround brief for the Respondent dated 19th June 2024. The paper spoke to the Respondent’s liquidity challenges. The paper further suggested that these challenges were attributable to the business model which the Respondent had embraced.

96. The deficiencies in the business model included: putting in place a special clearance (SPL) facility; failure to set up an Asset – Liability Committee; failure to restructure the Finance and Banking Division; failure to fully implement the 2022 -2027 Strategic Plan; failure to separate the duties of the management team and the Board; and failure to ensure proper control of expenses.

97. The paper proposed various mechanisms to remedy the crisis. These included short term measures, mid-term measures and long term measures.

98. From the evidence on record, the incident of 6th August 2024 was triggered by the Respondent’s failure to pay its members their shares. The court is convinced that this was occasioned by the liquidity challenges which had been flagged in the task force report alluded to above. As such, the crisis evidently arose from the Respondent’s institutional challenges as opposed to the alleged incapacities of the Claimant.

99. The evidence on record shows that the Claimant gave a detailed account of why he believed that he was not to blame for the pandemonium that occurred on 6th August 2024. This notwithstanding, the Respondent terminated his services.

100. The minutes of the Disciplinary Committee do not demonstrate that the Respondent presented any material to controvert the Claimant’s defense to the accusation which had been leveled him. As such, it is unclear how and why the Respondent arrived at the conclusion that the Claimant was responsible for the events of 6th August 2024.

101. In their closing submissions, Counsel for the Respondent contend that the Respondent had genuine reasons to believe that the Claimant was guilty of the charges against him and that it was thus entitled to dismiss him from service under section 43(2) of the Employment Act. However, a perusal of the minutes of the Disciplinary Committee does not show that the Committee recommended for termination of the Claimant’s services either on account of gross misconduct or on account of any other ground.

102. Importantly, the record shows that although the Respondent had accused the Claimant of economic sabotage, it (the Respondent) terminated his services on account of early retirement. This is notwithstanding that neither the Respondent’s Human Resource Manual nor the contract between the parties contemplated termination of the Claimant’s services through forced early retirement.

103. The court notes that the Respondent sought to justify the impugned decision on account of the alleged lack of qualifications by the Claimant to hold the position of General Manager – Human Resources and Administration. This is notwithstanding that it (the Respondent) had recruited him to the impugned position presumably after it had evaluated his abilities and qualifications for the position.

104. If indeed the Claimant did not have the capacity to hold the impugned position, the Respondent ought to have invoked the grounds of poor performance or incapacity under section 41 of the Employment Act to terminate the contract between the parties. It was not open to it (the Respondent) to avoid this course by resorting to the ground of involuntary early retirement which is not provided for in either the law, the contract between the parties or the Respondent’s policies, to terminate the Claimant’s services without first seeking his concurrence to exit employment through early retirement.

105. The Respondent’s decision, in so far as it was not founded on its policies or the contract between the parties or the law, was unlawful. The decision breached the Claimant’s contract of service. It is so declared.

106. From the record, the contract between the parties was irregularly terminated on 11th September 2024. If this had not happened, the Claimant would have continued in the Respondent’s service until 16th August 2025 when he was expected to retire.

107. From the foregoing, it is apparent that the Claimant lost employment prematurely for a period of approximately eleven (11) months on account of the Respondent’s irregular decision. Accordingly and in accordance with section 49 of the Employment Act, the court awards him compensation for unfair termination of his contract which is equivalent to his salary for eleven (11) months. In making this award, the court has taken into account the long period of service by the Claimant to the Respondent which spanned over fourty (40) years.

108. According to the evidence on record, the Claimant’s exit salary was Ksh. 464,975.00. This is self-evident from his pay slip for July 2024. As such, compensation for unfair termination of his contract which is equivalent to his salary for eleven (11) months amounts to Ksh. 464,975.00 x 11 = Ksh. 5,114,725.00.

109. The Claimant has also prayed for: salary for the remainder of his term to the retirement age; salary shortfalls for the months of August and September 2024; and three months’ salary in lieu of notice to terminate his contract. However, since the court has already awarded him compensation equivalent to eleven (11) months’ salary which is equivalent to his unexpired term, it is deemed that he has been fully compensated for all of the foresaid claims. This is because the aforesaid award essentially deems him as having served his full term without loss of benefits. As such, to purport to award him: salary for the remainder of his term until retirement age; salary shortfalls for the months of August and September 2024; and three months’ salary in lieu of notice to terminate his contract will result in double compensation which the law does not permit.

110. The Claimant has prayed for leave commutation for 41 accrued leave days. During trial, the defense witness acknowledged that even though the Respondent worked out what it believed to have been the Claimant’s leave pay, the amount was not paid to him.

111. The witness further acknowledged that the leave days’ computation which the Respondent tendered in evidence was prepared after the Claimant had left employment. He further conceded that the computation was prepared without the Claimant’s input.

112. The Respondent presented workings which show that the Claimant had accrued 28.5 leave days. The computation was not signed by the Claimant.

113. Conversely, the Claimant tendered in evidence a leave schedule dated 27th March 2024 which shows that his accrued leave days stood at 41 days. The document shows that the computation was approved by the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer.

114. The Respondent did not tender evidence to demonstrate that the Claimant utilized the 41 leave days which its Chief Executive Officer had affirmed as correct before he (the Claimant) left employment. This is notwithstanding that section 74 of the Employment Act places the obligation to maintain employment records, including those on leave, on the employer. Having regard to the foresaid, the court is convinced that the Claimant had 41 accrued leave days at the point of his exit from employment (see also the Court of Appeal case of Jackson Muiruri Wathigo t/a Murtown Supermarket v Lilian Mutune [2021] KECA 388 (KLR)).

115. According to the evidence on record, the Claimant’s monthly salary was Ksh. 464,975.00. Therefore, his daily wage was Ksh. 464,975.00 x1/30 = Ksh. 15,499. As such, salary for 41 days amounts to Ksh. 15,499 x 41 = Ksh. 635,459.00. Accordingly, judgment is entered in his favour for Ksh. 635,459.00 to cover the 41 accrued leave days.

116. The Claimant further prays for a Certificate of Service. The court notes that although the Respondent issued him with the certificate, it had an error in respect of the date when the contract between the parties was closed. Accordingly, the court orders the Respondent to issue him with a corrected version of the Certificate of Service.

117. The court awards the Claimant interest on the amount awarded at court rates from the date of this decision.

118. The court awards the Claimant costs of the case.

119. The award to the Claimant is subject to the statutory deductions which were in force at the time the contract between the parties was terminated.

Summary of the Findings and Award

120. After evaluating the pleadings, evidence and submissions by the parties against the applicable law, the court makes the following findings and attendant orders:-

a) The court finds and declares that Respondent improperly and unlawfully terminated the Claimant’s contract of service.

b) The court awards the Claimant compensation for unfair termination of his contract of service in the sum of Ksh. 5,114,725.00.

c) The court awards the Claimant the sum of Ksh. 635,459.00 being commutation of accrued leave days.

d) The court declines the prayers for: salary for the remainder of the Claimant’s term; salary shortfalls for August and September 2024; and pay in lieu of notice to terminate the Claimant’s contract of service.

e) The court orders the Respondent to issue the Claimant with a corrected version of his Certificate of Service.

f) The court awards the Claimant interest on the amount awarded at court rates from the date of this decision.

g) The court awards the Claimant costs of the case.

h) The award to the Claimant is subject to the statutory deductions which were in force at the time the contract between the parties was terminated.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Claimant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder