Employment law

Mavindu v Steelmakers Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14835 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E1081 of 2024
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

Case research

Open case research →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. E1081 OF 2024

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

PEACE MAVINDU……….....………………………………....CLAIMANT

VS

STEELMAKERS LIMITED…………………………………RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1 The Claimant filed a Memorandum of Claim dated 18th December 2019 against the Respondent, and prays for judgment against the Respondent for:

a) The Claimant’s terminal dues of Kshs. 2,039,000 as tabulated in the claim.

b) The Claimant’s P9 Form

c) Interests and Costs

d) Any other relief that the Honorable Court deems fit to grant

Claimant’s Case

2 The Claimant avers that she was employed by the Respondent employed on 5th July 2021 as a Legal Officer on a full-time basis at a monthly net salary of Kshs. 110,000. She was employed by way of an email rather than a contract of employment.

3 She states that at the time of her employment, the COVID-19 pandemic was still rife, thus, she was directed to work partly from the office and partly from home, and positive cases were reported in the office, including her own.

4 The Claimant avers that her duties included liaising with the external advocates handling the Respondent's court matters and ensuring that those matters were attended to diligently. At all material times, she reported directly to the Respondent's Director, Mr. Bobby.

5 The Claimant avers that despite the Respondent's toxic, demanding and grueling working environment, she continuously discharged her duties diligently throughout her employment.

6 She states that she underwent a lot of frustration, particularly from the Respondent's Managing Director, Bobby Johnson. She was unreasonably pressured to deliver success in all cases, harassed and spoken to rudely and unprofessionally.

7 She further avers that in June 2022 her salary was reduced to a net of Kshs. 55,000 without reason or notice to her.

8 The Claimant states that on or about 8th February 2023, at 6:52 pm, the Managing Director sent her a WhatsApp message claiming that she seemed unable to handle the Respondent's court matters.

9 It is the Claimant’s case that this came against a background of two disputes with external advocates. In the first, an external advocate raised a fee note for a concluded matter. When she submitted it for approval, the Managing Director responded by email that he had not agreed with the advocate on the fees, which required her to bargain with the advocate to amend the fee note.

10 In the second, the external advocate had negotiated an out of court settlement in another matter. The Claimant was to secure a cheque upon an undertaking that the advocates would draw, execute and file a consent in court.

11 The Claimant avers that the Respondent unreasonably refused to sign the cheque against her advice and go-ahead. This frustrated the external advocate, who wrote to the Respondent seeking to cease acting for it.

12 The Claimant states that, feeling equally frustrated, she responded to the Managing Director's WhatsApp message expressing her frustration with how the Respondent was handling the situation, and things went downhill from there.

13 She avers that the straw that broke the camel's back was when the Managing Director called her through a colleague's line and spoke to her in an unprofessional and degrading manner about the consent and the cheque. He then called her repeatedly in an effort to shout at her more. When she refused to pick up his numerous calls, he called her through the colleague's line again. She states that she could not take it anymore.

14 She further avers that after this incident, the Managing Director's attitude towards her changed for the worse and he stopped responding to her work emails, which interfered with the proper performance of her duties.

15 The Claimant avers that following these events, the Respondent refused to pay her salary for February 2023. As a result, on 15th March 2023, she unbegrudgingly resigned for the sake of her mental health. She demanded the following: Unpaid salary for February 2023 of Kshs. 110,000; Unpaid salary for 15 days worked in March 2023 of Kshs. 55,000; Underpayment of salary from May 2022 to January 2023 of Kshs. 495,000; Kshs. 77,000 for 21 leave days not afforded between July 2021 and June 2022; Kshs. 37,000 for 10 leave days not afforded between July 2022 and February 2023; and Kshs. 1,320,000 being 12 months' compensation for constructive dismissal. All these totaled at Kshs. 2,094,000.

16 She states that despite demand and notice of intention to sue, the Respondent has failed, ignored or refused to make good her demands.

17 In her reply to the Defence dated 10th June 2025, the Claimant avers that the terms of her engagement, including her place of work and leave entitlement, were never reduced into a written contract of employment as required by law, despite her repeated follow-ups with the Managing Director.

18 She states that her COVID-19 infection was confirmed by a test conducted on 13th August 2021. In line with the government guidelines at the time, those who tested positive were required to self-quarantine, and she therefore worked from home.

19 The Claimant avers that despite not receiving a written contract, she was never issued with any written communication on poor performance nor subjected to any disciplinary process.

20 It is the Claimant’s case that the Managing Director deliberately avoided issuing her with a written contract so as to retain the discretion to make unilateral decisions such as the reduction of her salary. She contends that the climate of fear he created contributed to her reluctance to demand an explanation for the reduction.

21 The Claimant urged the Court not to disregard the broader context of widespread reports by workers of toxic workplaces which, when left unaddressed, have contributed to serious mental health issues, including depression and in some cases suicide.

22 She avers that in a healthy work environment, management ordinarily communicates any delay in salary payment to employees, which the Respondent did not do.

23 The Claimant avers that the delay in paying her salary was intended to punish her for persistently questioning and challenging the Managing Director's actions.

24 She contends that despite her presenting hospital results confirming that she was positive for COVID-19, the Managing Director chose to dismiss her condition and accuse her of being fraudulent and deceitful. She describes this as a classic example of the toxic nature of the Respondent's work environment.

Respondent’s Case

25 The Respondent opposed the claim through a Defence dated 29th April 2025 in which it denies the Claimant's claim.

26 The Respondent admitted that it employed the Claimant on or about 5th July 2021 as a Legal Officer on a full-time basis, at a starting salary of Kshs. 110,000. It also admitted that her duties included liaising with the external advocates handling its court cases and ensuring those matters were attended to diligently.

27 However, the Respondent denied that the Claimant was allowed to work partly from the office and partly from home, and that any positive cases of COVID-19 were reported in the office.

28 The Respondent denied that its working environment was toxic and demanding, and that the Claimant diligently discharged her duties throughout her employment. It further denies that she underwent frustration from the Managing Director.

29 The Respondent avers that the demand for diligence and success in all cases did not amount to pressure or harassment, but was simply the performance of the duties she was employed to do.

30 It is the Respondent's case that the communications pleaded by the Claimant in relation to the fee note, the settlement cheque and the telephone calls are privileged communications made during and in the course of her duty.

31 It avers that they border on insubordination and on unethical and unprofessional conduct for failure to follow work ethics and proper working procedures, and urged that the offending paragraphs be expunged from the record.

32 Without prejudice to that, the Respondent denied that the Managing Director's attitude towards the Claimant changed for the worse or that he stopped responding to her work emails.

33 On the February 2023 salary, the Respondent denied that it refused to pay the Claimant. It states that the delay was caused by the company's cash flow problems, which affected all employees and led to the retrenchment of some workers and the closure of its Athi River and Mombasa factories, a position that subsists to date.

34 The Respondent denied that a delay of fourteen days in paying her salary was the reason for her resignation. It avers that the delay could not have affected her mental health, as it was the only time there was any delay.

35 The Respondent avers that the Claimant was insincere, fraudulent and evasive, and guilty of material non-disclosure, in that she was working in two places at the same time and earning double salaries.

36 It states that the Claimant was in particular working with H. Young Company Ltd, and avers that this may have been the reason for her poor performance and for her resignation, so as to avoid being caught. It further avers that she fraudulently deceived the company into believing that she had contracted COVID-19, so that she would be kept away from other staff and could work from home, unbeknown to the Respondent that she was deceiving both it and H. Young Ltd.

37 On the salary reduction, the Respondent states that the reduction from Kshs. 110,000 to Kshs. 55,000 was mutually agreed when it became evident that the Claimant could not come to the office physically, the Respondent believing this was because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

38 It avers that the Claimant took a salary of Kshs. 55,000 per month for ten months, from 8th May 2022 to March 2023, without complaint, and that her claim touching on her salary is therefore an afterthought.

39 The Respondent states that by her emails of 15th and 16th March 2023, the Claimant tendered her resignation with effect from 15th March 2023. She demanded Kshs. 82,500 as salary for February and 15 days of March 2023, being Kshs. 55,000 for February and Kshs. 27,500 for March.

40 It is the Respondent’s case that it accepted the Claimant’s case and prepared a cheque of Kshs. 82,500, but that the Claimant refused to collect it unless it was first banked and cleared. It maintains that she was entitled to nothing further upon resigning without notice.

41 The Respondent denied that the Claimant is owed Kshs. 2,094,000 for unpaid salary, underpayments, leave days and compensation for constructive dismissal. It avers that she was never terminated or constructively dismissed, but resigned voluntarily with effect from 15th March 2023 and served notice on the Respondent.

42 It further avers that she never worked full time because of the alleged fraud and deceit that caused her to work from home, and so she cannot claim leave days, having not worked consistently. It admits the jurisdiction of the Court.

Evidence in Court

43 The Claimant, Peace Mavindu, (CW1), adopted her witness statement dated 18th December 2024 as her evidence in chief and produced her documents as Claimant's Exhibits 1 to 17.

44 CW1 testified that she resigned because her salary had been withheld and she had been put through unbearable circumstances. She stated that she was under pressure to win all cases and had to give daily updates. She relied on Exhibit 5a, an email from the Managing Director asking her to ensure she won all cases, including cases she had inherited.

45 On cross-examination, CW1 maintained that she worked from the office and only worked from home when she contracted COVID-19 and was quarantined, after which she resumed working from the office.

46 CW1 denied that she worked from home for two years, and stated that it was in fact the Managing Director who was not coming to the office.

47 She testified that she had no meeting with the Managing Director and never agreed to the reduction of her salary to Kshs. 55,000, although she conceded that she stayed on after the reduction and did not complain about it in her emails.

48 CW1 testified that in February 2023 she was not informed that her salary would be delayed, and that all other employees were paid except her. She admitted that she worked for H. Young as a company secretary handling board matters, but stated that she never received any demand to explain this.

49 On re-examination, she testified that the Respondent was aware that she worked for H. Young and that she was never served with any contract prohibiting her from working elsewhere.

50 CW1 confirmed that her COVID-19 test results are on record.

51 On the cheque of Kshs. 82,500, CW1 stated that she went to collect it but was asked to sign a discharge voucher, which she declined to do, and asked that the cheque be deposited into her account instead.

52 The Respondent's Director, Bobby Johnson, testified as RW1. He adopted his witness statement dated 27th April 2025 as his evidence in chief and produced the Respondent's documents as Respondent's Exhibits 1 to 7.

53 It was RW1's testimony that he was not aware that the Claimant was working for H. Young, and that as a full-time employee she was not allowed to work anywhere else.

54 On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that he asked the Claimant by email to ensure the company won all cases, and that the email at Exhibit 5b was sent at about 10:34 pm, outside working hours. He confirmed that in the WhatsApp correspondence the Claimant complained of frustration, and that her resignation email stated she was resigning because of frustration.

55 Although his witness statement alleges that the Claimant's work had diminished, RW1 conceded that he never issued her with any warning letter, explaining that she was not in the office and so no action could be taken against her. He conceded that the call logs produced show only missed calls.

56 RW1 further conceded that he had no proof that he notified the Claimant before reducing her salary, and testified that it was a verbal communication.

57 He also conceded that he filed no evidence of the cash flow challenges said to have caused the delay in paying her February and March salary, and that he did not communicate those challenges to her.

58 On re-examination, RW1 maintained that the reduction of the Claimant's salary was done mutually against the backdrop of her performance, and that the call logs and her WhatsApp complaints show her unavailability and diminished performance.

59 On his email asking her to make a watertight case, RW1 testified that the remark was general and that her response, "sounds good, ok," shows she was under no pressure.

Claimant’s Submissions

60 The Claimant identified the following issues for determination: whether she was constructively dismissed and whether the Respondent’s defence was tenable in law.

61 On the first issue, the Claimant relied on Sophie Muthoni Njagi v Rift Valley Railways (Kenya) Limited [2020] KEELRC 1506 (KLR) wherein the Court adopted the Black's Law Dictionary(9th Edition) definition of constructive dismissal as a termination brought about by the employer "making the employee's working conditions so intolerable that the employee feels compelled to leave." It also cited Nathan Ogada Atiagaga v David Engineering Limited [2015] KEELRC 75 (KLR): “Constructive dismissal occurs when an employee resigns because their employer’s behaviour has become so intolerable or made life so difficult that the employee has no choice but to resign. Since the resignation was not truly voluntary, it is in effect a termination.”

62 She further relied on Cause Number 611 [N] of 2009 between Maria Kagai Ligaga v. Coca Cola East and Central Africa Limited [unreported], which sets out the basic ingredients in constructive dismissal are: the employer must be in breach of the contract of employment; the breach must be fundamental as to be considered a repudiatory breach; the employee must resign in response to that breach; and the employee must not delay in resigning after the breach has taken place, otherwise the Court may find the breach waived.

63 She also cited Milton M Isanya v Aga Khan Hospital Kisumu [2017] eKLR, where the Court held: “In constructive dismissal the desire to resign is from the employee as a result of hostile working environment or treatment by the employer. A constructive dismissal occurs where the employer does not express the threat or desire to terminate employment but frustrates the employee to the extent that the employee tender’s resignation.”.

64 Finally, she relied on Kenya Union of Sugarcane Plantation and Allied Workers v Othira [2024] KEELRC 843 (KLR), where Baari J. held: “For a constructive dismissal to be construed, there must be resignation. Resignation is viewed as communication of the intolerability of the employer’s conduct. In the absence of resignation, it is safe to draw an inference that the employee has acquiesced to the employer’s intolerable conduct.”

65 Applying these principles, the Claimant submitted that she was subjected to several unbearable circumstances.

66 On frustration, she submitted that the Managing Director frustrated her by refusing to approve cheques for the consent settlement and the external advocates' fee notes. As a result, the external advocates refused to attend court and she had to attend court herself. She contended that RW1's explanation that there was no fee agreement with the external advocate is untrue and an attempt to cover his tracks.

67 It is the Claimant’s submission that the real problem was the undue and unexplained delay in approvals and payment, which left her managing external advocates who were equally frustrated by non-payment. She argued that any fee agreement ought in any event to have been negotiated when the suit began in 2015, long before she joined the Respondent in 2021.

68 On the consent, she submitted that she complied with the company's policy by providing the consent agreement, which expressly provided that the Respondent would draw a cheque in favour of the external advocate, to be held in trust pending execution and filing of the consent.

69 The Claimant further submitted that insisting on further documentation was unreasonable and served only to delay and frustrate the process, particularly since the Managing Director was copied in all the correspondence and was fully aware of the agreed position. She argued, that the delay caused the external advocate to cease acting, and she maintained that the Managing Director maliciously withheld approvals in a bid to frustrate her into quitting.

70 On unprofessional language, the Claimant submitted that following this incident, the Managing Director called her numerous times, yelling and insulting her until she stopped picking his calls. He then resorted to calling her through other employees' phones. She pointed to the call logs, to RW1's own email confirming that she was not picking his calls, and to her resignation email, in which she called him out for being abusive.

71 Reliance was placed on Benjamin Biko Mongatte v Rubycut Enterprises Limited also trading as Rubycut Gardens [2021] eKLR: “In this case the Claimant’s unrebutted evidence is that the Respondent’s director conducted herself in an abusive and violent manner against him that the working environment became harsh and intolerable forcing him to resign on 22.12.2015. Consequently, I am satisfied that the Claimant has proved on a balance of probability that he was constructively dismissed by the Respondent.”

72 On withholding salary, the Claimant submitted that the Respondent maliciously withheld her February 2023 salary without explanation, simply to punish her.

73 She submitted that RW1's admission that he neither informed her of the reason for the delay nor filed proof of the alleged cash flow challenges is a clear indication that her salary was simply withheld. She cited Mokaya v Christ the King Parish & another [2024] KEELRC 28 (KLR), where Nderitu J. held that "Non-payment of salary to an employee who is working as expected and directed is such a fundamental breach of the contract of employment as it subjects an employee to unfair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution…….. It is therefore the finding and holding of this court that the resignation of the claimant was neither voluntary nor of free-will but was occasioned by the unbearable working environment that was created by the respondents through nonpayment of the monthly salary for three consecutive months as alluded to above.”

74 She also relied on Mutai v Kisa & another [2022] KEELRC 1543 (KLR), where the Court held that withholding an employee's salary without any excuse is a fundamental breach, so that "on that ground alone the Claimant was justified to resign and sue." She further cited Mbaya v Murban Movers Limited [2024] KEELRC 1350 (KLR), where a resignation prompted by non-payment of salary was described as "a classic case of constructive dismissal."

75 On unreasonable pressure to perform, the Claimant submitted that the Respondent placed unreasonable pressure on her by demanding that she ensure the company won every case and lost none. She cited Patrick Omutia v Telkom Kenya Limited [2016] eKLR, where Nduma J. held that: “………everyone would agree that the resignation of an employee due to unreasonable and excessive pressure by his employer is not a voluntary resignation or termination of services, but a situation akin to a dismissal”.

76 It is the Claimant’s submission that it is unfair and illogical to expect a Legal Officer to win every case. Such an expectation, coupled with non-cooperation, unprofessional language, work outside office hours and the withholding of salary, is bound to frustrate an employee into resigning.

77 On working outside office hours, the Claimant submitted that in February 2023 the Managing Director messaged her as late as 10 pm and 11 pm, and called her numerous times at almost 7 pm. She relied on Mwalimu Plus Limited v Cheruto [2022] KEELRC 13417 (KLR), where Onyango J. upheld a finding of constructive dismissal partly on account of the employer engaging the employee on work outside working hours, and held: "an employee can only be required to work overtime with her consent and with payment to compensate for the extra time."

78 On cutting the Claimant’s salary into half, she relied on Kabucho v Kamuthi Housing Co-operative Society Ltd [2024] KEELRC 536 (KLR), where Manani J. held: “Under Part IV of the Employment Act, an employee’s wage is a protected entitlement. The employer has no right to make deductions from it except as authorized by the law or with the consent of the employee. The Respondent did not provide evidence to demonstrate that the Claimant acceded to the reduction of her salary by half. Further, there was no evidence that she waived her right to claim the half salary that had been withheld. Therefore, this amount remained a debt due from the Respondent to the Claimant.” She argued that, similarly, the Respondent provided no proof that she agreed to, was notified of, acceded to or waived her claim to the halved salary.

79 On the second issue, the Claimant argued that the Respondent's defence is untenable. She pointed out that RW1's witness statement alleges that her results diminished because she held two jobs, "a fact we discovered too late," yet in his evidence in chief he testified that he only learnt of her employment with H. Young after she resigned. She described this as a contradiction.

80 It is the Claimant’s submission that if the Respondent knew of the other employment during her tenure, it evidently had no issue with it, since it neither raised it nor produced any proof of having demanded accountability. If, on the other hand, it only learnt of it after she resigned, then the issue has no probative value and is an afterthought.

81 She thus submitted that what broke the camel's back was not any failure on her part to do her job, but the delay in paying the external advocate. She relied on Githu v PCEA Kikuyu Hospital [2024] KEELRC 252 (KLR): “The respondent raised the issue of double employment in two distinct hospitals by the claimant. That however can only be regarded as an afterthought as it was not part of the reasons given during the disciplinary process and was not raised in the pleadings.”

82 The Claimant further submitted that the Respondent never particularized the alleged diminished performance in its pleadings, never issued her with a warning letter and never took her through any disciplinary process. She argued that the Respondent never gave her a written contract containing a term prohibiting her from working elsewhere.

83 It is the Claimant’s submission that RW1's witness statement admits she worked from home as and when there was work, which, she contended, means she was not working for the Respondent full-time and was free to work elsewhere part-time. She urged the Court to disregard the defence as an attempt to hoodwink the Court into believing she was at fault and so deserved the treatment she received.

Respondent’s Submissions

84 The Respondent submitted on three issues: whether the Claimant voluntarily resigned from employment; whether the Claimant has proved constructive dismissal; and whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

85 On the first issue, the Respondent submitted that it is not disputed that the Claimant resigned by her email of 15th March 2023. It argued that her email does not indicate that she was being dismissed, but clearly communicates her own decision to end the relationship. The Respondent merely accepted the resignation on 16th March 2023 and started the normal clearance process.

86 It submitted that her request for her P9 forms immediately after resigning is consistent with an employee who had already decided to leave voluntarily. Most importantly, it maintained that the Claimant demanded Kshs. 82,500 as her terminal salary, a figure computed on the very salary of Kshs. 55,000 that she now claims was unlawfully reduced. Had she genuinely considered the reduction unlawful, she would have computed her dues on Kshs. 110,000.

87 It was submitted that contracts of employment may be varied by the conduct of the parties. The Claimant, being an advocate who worked under the revised salary for about ten months without objection, accepted the variation by conduct. She cannot approbate and reprobate by accepting the benefits of the revised arrangement throughout her employment and only challenging it after resigning.

88 On the second issue, the Respondent submitted that the burden of proving constructive dismissal lies on the Claimant under Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, which provides that "for any complaint of unfair termination of employment or wrongful dismissal the burden of proving that an unfair termination of employment or wrongful dismissal has occurred shall rest on the employee, while the burden of justifying the grounds of the termination of employment or wrongful dismissal shall rest on the employer."

89 Reliance was placed on Max Masoud Roshankar & another v Sky Aero Limited [2015] KEELRC 1556 (KLR), wherein the Court adopted the holding of the South African case Pretoria Society for the Care of the Retarded v Loots [1997] 6 BLLR 721 (LAC) that the first test is whether, in resigning, the employee had no other motive, and would have continued the relationship indefinitely but for the employer's unacceptable conduct. The Court further held that "it is not for the employer… to show that he did not introduce any intolerable condition; it is for the employee to show that indeed there were intolerable conditions."

90 The Respondent also relied on Maria Kagai Ligaga v Coca Cola East and Central Africa Limited, where the Court held that "constructive dismissal demands the employee demonstrates that his resignation was justified." In that case, the Court required the employee to show a fundamental and unilateral breach by the employer, a working environment so intolerable that he could not continue, that the resignation was caused by that breach, and that he would have continued working had the employer not created the intolerable conditions.

91 It is the Respondent’s submission that the Claimant failed to prove any of these requirements, and that her six complaints, whether taken individually or collectively, do not meet the threshold.

92 On the delay in salary, the Respondent argued that the delay in paying the February 2023 salary arose from temporary cash flow challenges affecting the company, was neither permanent nor targeted at the Claimant, and was only about fifteen days long by the time she resigned.

93 It submitted that she did not contradict RW1's evidence that the cash flow challenge affected all employees and that they were notified by internal memo. Further, the failure to produce financial records does not negate the reason for the delay.

94 The Respondent submitted that the Claimant produced no evidence that she was the only unpaid employee and did not prove that the delay was deliberate, discriminatory or intended to force her out. It relied on Saro v Evans Sunrise Centre [2024] KEELRC 977 (KLR), where the Court held that an employer's delay in paying salaries during the COVID-19 period in itself would not be a reason for the employee to claim constructive termination. The Court found in that case that the employee had resigned of his own volition upon getting another job.

95 The Respondent distinguished Mokaya v Christ the King Parish, Mutai v Kisa and Mbaya v Murban Movers Ltd. It argued that those cases involved prolonged and repeated non-payment of salary over several months, whereas here there was only a temporary delay of about two weeks, and arrangements had already been made to pay the Claimant.

96 On the alleged abusive language and harassment, the Respondent submitted that the Claimant's resignation email merely refers to phone calls characterized by unprofessional language. It contended that there is no evidence of such language in the emails, no independent evidence, and no specific particulars of what was said, even from the Claimant herself. It contended that the call logs and WhatsApp messages do not show abusive content, and that mere disagreements and criticism of work between an employer and employee do not amount to constructive dismissal.

97 On the alleged frustration over payments to external advocates, it submitted that RW1 explained that company policy and proper accounting practice required fee notes, invoices, decrees, filed consents or other supporting documents before funds could be released. These were ordinary financial controls not directed at the Claimant, and an employer cannot be said to have fundamentally breached the contract merely by insisting on accountability and compliance with internal procedures.

98 On the alleged unreasonable pressure, the Respondent submitted that the Managing Director's email asking the Claimant to ensure the company had a watertight case and won all cases was not pressure to attain a result. It maintained that the email was advice and a reminder to furnish the external advocates with all documents and information needed to mount a good defence. It pointed out that the Claimant replied, "Sounds good. Ok. Sounds good to me." It further submitted that this was a one-time communication in an undated email with no other instance of pressure, and that it does not show what would have happened had she not complied. In its view, this cannot amount to intolerable pressure beyond ordinary professional duty.

99 On work outside office hours, the Respondent argued that, as the Legal Officer responsible for litigation, occasional communication on urgent legal matters cannot amount to harassment. It submitted that the Claimant did not show that she was required to work excessive hours without compensation, or that her terms had fundamentally changed.

100 It is the Respondent’s submission that the call logs do not show any request to work late, and that the email she relies on, enquiring about a meeting, dates from February 2022, more than a year before her resignation, and so could not have made her resign in a huff.

101 It distinguished Mwalimu Plus Limited v Cheruto [2022] KEELRC 13417 (KLR), where the employee was required to take Skype calls after hours and sometimes work up to 3 am. In the present case, the Respondent argued, the Claimant refers only to a WhatsApp message at 10 pm, which she responded to and closed. It urged the Court to find that she never worked overtime and that a one-off call cannot have forced her to resign.

102 On the reduction of salary, the Respondent submitted that in or about June 2022 the Claimant and the Managing Director sat down and mutually agreed to reduce her salary to Kshs. 55,000 net because of the change in circumstances, following her request to work from home.

103 It is the Respondent’s submission that the Claimant raised no complaint for ten months and even computed her final dues on the reduced salary. It also pointed out that her resignation email does not mention the reduction, citing instead the delayed salary and the alleged unprofessional calls. Therefore, the claim for the underpaid balance should therefore be declined, and the Claimant's authorities on unilateral salary reduction are distinguishable because she accepted and acted on the revised remuneration throughout her employment.

104 On her employment with H. Young & Company, the Respondent submitted that whether it learnt of this during or after her employment does not alter the central issue, and that it does not rely on the allegation as a ground for termination. It argued instead that the other employment offers a plausible alternative explanation for the deterioration of the relationship and for her decision to resign. It contended that since she resigned voluntarily, there was no obligation to commence disciplinary proceedings or issue warning letters. It maintained, however, that the issue shows the Claimant was dishonest in working for another employer without its knowledge and remains unapologetic, and that she has not come to Court with clean hands. It urged the Court to find that she resigned deliberately to concentrate on her work with H. Young.

105 The Respondent further submitted that despite alleging unbearable conditions, the Claimant never lodged a formal complaint against the Managing Director or invoked any internal grievance mechanism, and resigned almost immediately after the salary delay. It argued that this conduct is inconsistent with an employee whose environment had become so intolerable that resignation was the only option.

106 It is the Respondent’s submission that the evidence shows nothing more than an ordinary employment relationship in which the employer exercised supervision, required accountability, insisted on proper documentation and experienced temporary financial constraints. This falls far below the threshold for constructive dismissal, and that the Claimant has failed to discharge her burden under Section 47(5) of the Employment Act.

107 On reliefs, the Respondent submitted that having failed to prove constructive dismissal, the Claimant is not entitled to compensation. It argued that the claim for underpayments fails because she accepted the revised salary and only challenged it after resigning.

108 On accrued leave, it submitted that she did not place sufficient evidence before the Court to show that any leave days remained outstanding or that she was entitled to payment in lieu. It argued that the burden of proof rested on her under Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act, and that she failed to discharge it.

109 I have examined all the evidence and submissions of the parties herein. From the evidence on record the claimant is said to have resigned from work citing frustration. The issue of the claimant being put under pressure is also evident from the email sent to her by the respondent’s MD demanding that she must win all cases.

110 There is also evidence that the claimant’s salary was reduced from kshs 110,000/- to ksh 55,000/- from June 2022 for 8 months. The respondents attribute this to a mutual agreement and due to cash flow problems. There is no evidence that the parties agreed to this and the respondent who is alleging is expected to prove this fact which the respondents did not. The respondent also failed to pay the claimant’s salary for February 2023 and this is what led the claimant to resign on 15th March 2023.

111 In her resignation email the claimant states that she resigned because of delay in payment of her salary but for which no explanation was given to her. The respondents aver that this affected the entire office but the respondents did not produce any evidence that they had communicated that there would be any delay to the claimant. The email the claimant sent shows frustration at work due to constant phone calls characterized with unprofessional language.

112 Her resignation was promptly accepted by the respondents MD. My take from the above analysis of evidence is that the claimant’s work environment was toxic. It is also true that her salary was reduced unilaterally as there is no evidence that there was prior discussion on the issue and it was reduced in writing. This is as envisaged under section 10(5) of the Employment Act 2007 which states as follows:

Where any matter stipulated in subsection (1) changes, the employer shall, in consultation with the employee, revise the contract to reflect the change and notify the employee of the change in writing.

113 The respondents having thus reduced the claimant’s salary as stated, I find for claimant and order that:

(1) She be paid the unpaid salary for 8 months from June 2022 to January 2023= 55,000x8= kshs 440,000/-.

(2) I also order that she be paid her unpaid February 2023 salary which is conceded = kshs 110,000.

(3) She is also entitled to salary for 15 days worked up to 15/3/2023 at the time she resigned= kshs 55,000/-.

(4) In addition to this and given the circumstances under which the clamant resigned and which was due to the toxic work environment with pressure to win all cases, it is my finding that the claimant was terminated constructively. In the circumstance, I award her 6 month’s compensation for the unfair constructive termination= 6x110,000= kshs 660,000/-.

(5) The claimant is also entitled to her leave of days not taken as pleaded = kshs 114,000/-.

TOTAL AWARDED = KSHS 1,379,000/- less statutory deductions.

(6) I also direct that the respondent issues the claimant her form P9 as requested by her and not delivered.

(7) The respondent’s will pay costs of this case plus interest at court rates with effect from the date of this judgment.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 29th Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder