Employment law

Maloba & Amalemba Advocates v Ngamu Limited t/aNational Oil Chania & another [2026] KEELRC 14815 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Miscellaneous Application E012 of 2022
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Applicant filed an Advocate–Client Bill of Costs against the Respondents herein which was taxed on 30th November 2022 in the sum of Ksh. 273,305.00. Accordingly, the Taxing Officer of the court issued a Certificate of Taxation dated 21st December 2022 for the aforesaid amount.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Having regard to the foregoing, the court finds that this is a proper case to lift the corporate veil of the 1st Respondent and hold its surviving director and shareholder, one Esther Muthoni Ngaru, personally liable to satisfy the decree herein. It is so ordered.

Paragraph 23 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the corporate veil of Ngamu Limited t/a National Oil Chania should be lifted so that its surviving director and shareholder, Esther Muthoni Ngaru, would personally satisfy the unpaid decree for advocate-client costs; and whether costs of the…

Material facts

Maloba & Amalemba Advocates obtained taxation of its Advocate–Client Bill of Costs on 30 November 2022 at Ksh. 273,305.00, followed by a certificate of taxation dated 21 December 2022. Judgment was entered on 14 November 2024 and a decree issued for that sum,…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. E012 OF 2022

MALOBA & AMALEMBA ADVOCATES…………….………APPLICANT

VERSUS

NGAMU LIMITED T/A NATIONAL OIL CHANIA....1ST RESPONDENT

DR. FRANCIS JOEL NGARU….......................................2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

Background

1. The Applicant filed an Advocate–Client Bill of Costs against the Respondents herein which was taxed on 30th November 2022 in the sum of Ksh. 273,305.00. Accordingly, the Taxing Officer of the court issued a Certificate of Taxation dated 21st December 2022 for the aforesaid amount.

2. The applicant subsequently moved the court for entry of judgment in its favour in terms of the Certificate of Taxation. On 14th November 2024, the court granted the aforesaid request. Accordingly, a decree was issued for the aforesaid sum of Ksh. 273,305.00 together with interest and costs.

3. It would appear that efforts by the Applicant to have the Respondents settle the decree have not been fruitful. According to the Applicant, the Respondents have evaded to settle the decretal sum for no cogent reason. The Applicant contends that the directors and shareholders of the 1st Respondent have hidden behind its corporate veil to defeat enforcement of the decree.

4. The Applicant aver that the directors of the 1st Respondent closed the business of the 1st Respondent and have refused to settle its liabilities. It (the Applicant) has thus filed the instant application dated 18th June 2025 seeking, inter alia, an order to lift the corporate veil of the 1st Respondent so that its (the 1st Respondent’s) directors are held personally liable to settle the amount in the decree.

5. The application was served on the 1st Respondent’s directors. In response, one of the directors swore an affidavit to object to the request.

6. The court record shows that when the application was placed before the court on 9th July 2025, the court issued an order directing the 1st Respondent’s directors to personally appear before it (the court) on 29th September 2025 for oral examination on the properties and assets of the 1st Respondent and for them to produce the 1st Respondent’s bank statements and books of accounts or other documents to ascertain the 1st Respondent’s means and capacity to satisfy the decree dated 21st November 2024 for Ksh. 273,305 plus interest from the date of taxation till payment in full.

7. The court record shows that despite this order, the directors of the 1st Respondent did not attend court on the appointed date or subsequently thereafter in order to be examined on the capacity of the 1st Respondent to settle the decree in the cause. Similarly, the directors did not present to court the books of accounts and bank statements for the 1st Respondent. This is despite them being aware of the order and requesting through counsel on 20th November 2025 for time to present the aforesaid documents.

8. On 23rd February 2026, counsel representing one of the directors informed the court that her client and the 1st Respondent were willing to make payments. Counsel stated that her client had instructed her that she had made partial payment of the decretal sum but was disputing some amounts. She asked for time to settle the matter.

9. Based on the aforesaid representation, the court adjourned the proceedings to 25th February 2026 to give parties room to amicably resolve the dispute between them. However, on 25th February 2026, the parties reported to court that they had not been able to agree on a settlement. Hence their decision to have the court determine the dispute. This history, as will be noted later, is part of the considerations the court will take into account in determining the instant application for lifting of the 1st Respondent’s corporate veil.

10. In the affidavit filed in opposition to the application, the director of the 1st Respondent does not speak to the ability or inability of the 1st Respondent to pay the decretal amount. She does not account for the assets of the 1st Respondent. She does not share information regarding the balances on the bank accounts held by the 1st Respondent, if any. This is notwithstanding that the purpose of the instant application is for her to disclose the aforesaid information in order to assist the court to determine the 1st Respondent’s ability to pay the decretal sum.

11. All that the said director has sought to address is the fact that she is a minority shareholder in the 1st Respondent and that she was not actively involved in the day to day running of its activities at the material time to this action. She avers that the individual who was the majority shareholder of the 1st Respondent at the time was one Francis Joel Ngaru and is now deceased.

12. The director contends that the 1st Respondent is a body corporate with a life of its own. As such, she contends that its directors are not personally liable for its liabilities.

13. The director avers that it will be unjust to lift the 1st Respondent’s corporate veil and condemn her to shoulder liability for the decree when her shareholding in the 1st Respondent is only 25%. As such, she asks the court to decline the application.

Analysis

14. It is an accepted legal principle that a company is a legal person with a life of its own. It (the company) is considered as distinct and separate from its directors and shareholders. As such, all factors remaining constant, directors and shareholders of a company cannot be called upon to assume personal responsibility for the company’s liabilities (see Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd (1897) AC 22]).

15. Notwithstanding the foresaid, there are times when the law permits the lifting of the corporate veil of a company so that the directors and shareholders of the company are called upon to shoulder its liabilities personally. This happens when it is established that the persons behind the company are using it as shield to commit fraud and other illegalities.

16. Restating this point as captured in the Halsbury’s Laws of England, the Court of Appeal in the case of Githunguri Dairy Farmers Co-operative Society v Ernie Campbell & Co. Ltd & another [2018] KECA 721 (KLR) stated as follows:-

‘’Notwithstanding the effect of a company’s incorporation, in some cases the court will ‘pierce the corporate veil’ in order to enable it to do justice by treating a particular company, for the purpose of the litigation before it, as identical with the person or persons who control that company. This will be done not only where there is fraud or improper conduct but in all cases where the character of the company, or the nature of the persons who control it, is a relevant feature. In such case the court will go behind the mere status of the company as a separate legal entity distinct from its shareholders, and will consider who are the persons, as shareholders or even as agents, directing and controlling the activities of the company.’’

17. In the case before me, it is apparent that the Applicant has a lawful decree which was issued by the court. It is also evident that the decree remains unpaid.

18. As has been seen earlier, one of the directors of the 1st Respondent, Esther Muthoni Ngaru, through her lawyers on record, made representations to the court that they were ready to settle the decree. Her only grievance was that she was disputing some of the amount which had been granted to the Applicant. This does not suggest inability by the 1st Respondent to settle the decree under consideration. Rather, it demonstrates a deliberate choice by the directors of the 1st Respondent to resist paying the decree because they hold the view that the amount is not due.

19. The 1st Respondent’s directors’ attempts to challenge the quantum of the decree at this stage of the proceedings is misguided. As the record shows, the decree emanated from taxation of Advocate-Client costs. As such and by virtue of section 51(2) of the Advocates Act, it represents the final figure of what is due to the Applicants as it was not challenged through a reference. Consequently, the directors’ attempts to resist payment on this account is not only belated but legally unsound.

20. The correspondence between the parties demonstrates that the reason why the 1st Respondent’s directors have resisted settling the decree is their disagreement with the quantum of fees. It has nothing to do with the inability of the 1st Respondent to settle the decree.

21. The record shows that the 1st Respondent’s directors have deliberately evaded to present to court the books of accounts and bank statements for the 1st Respondent. At the same time, they have shut down the 1st Respondent’s operations without disclosing where they have placed its assets. This is clear evidence of an attempt to use the corporate veil of the 1st Respondent to avoid settling the Applicant’s decree, a matter which the law does not allow (see Superfit Steelcom Limited v Anmol Limited [2025] KEHC 6765 (KLR)).

22. The 1st Respondent’s directors cannot seek to shield themselves behind the 1st Respondent’s corporate veil whilst at the same time declining to provide information which will aid in ensuring that the 1st Respondent discharges its lawful debts. That is contrary to the tenets of equity and good conscience (see Robert Kinaga Waweru v Northcorr Enterprises Ltd [2021] KEHC 6093 (KLR)). It amounts to using the corporate veil of the 1st Respondent for unlawful purposes.

Determination

23. Having regard to the foregoing, the court finds that this is a proper case to lift the corporate veil of the 1st Respondent and hold its surviving director and shareholder, one Esther Muthoni Ngaru, personally liable to satisfy the decree herein. It is so ordered.

24. Costs of the application are granted to the Applicant.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Applicant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder