Employment law

Likalamu v C & P Shoe Industries Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14829 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Miscellaneous Application 048 of 2026
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Notice of Motion dated 29th January 2026, the Applicant sought following orders: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the motion, affidavits and the submissions filed, the main issues for determination is whether the Court should adopt the DOSHS assessment dated 24th March 2021 as a judgment of the Court.

Paragraph 8 →

Decision / orders

Section 26(4) of WIBA requires an employer or insurer against whom a claim is lodged by the Director to settle the claim within ninety days. Section 26(6) further recognizes the seriousness of non-payment by making a criminal offence punishable by fine and imprisonment. The statutory policy plainly does not contemplate that an injured employee should remain without the benefit of an assessment where the employer has neither paid nor…

Paragraph 18 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Employment and Labour Relations Court should adopt as its judgment the DOSHS assessment in DOSH Form 4 dated 24 March 2021, awarding Ramsey Likalamu Kshs. 63,685.44, despite the Respondent’s reliance on a later assessment placing permanent…

Material facts

Ramsey Likalamu was employed by C & P Shoe Industries Limited as a machine operator. On 12 December 2020, he suffered a right-hand fracture from a machine cylinder shock while on duty. He was treated as an outpatient, with the Respondent paying Kshs. 10,280…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 29th October 2026)

MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. 048 OF 2026

RAMSEY LIKALAMU ………..………..………………………..…....CLAIMANT

VERSUS

C & P SHOE INDUSTRIES LIMITED ………………………….RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction

1. By a Notice of Motion dated 29th January 2026, the Applicant sought following orders: -

a) THAT the compensation of Ksh. 63,685.44 assessed by the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services (DOSHS) to the applicant herein be adopted as the judgment of this court.

b) THAT a decree be issued in accordance with the assessment of the Director of Occupational Health and Safety [sic] for the sum of Kenya shillings Sixty-Three Thousand, Six Hundred and Eighty-Five Shillings, Cents Four Four Only (Ksh. 63,685.44) with interest at 14% per annum from 24th March, 2021.

c) THAT costs of the application be paid by the Respondent.

2. The motion is supported by the applicant’s own affidavit sworn on 29th January 2026 and it is opposed by the Respondent through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 11th March 2026 by its director, Bhavan Premchand Shah. The applicant swore a further affidavit sworn on 2nd September 2026 to respond to the Replying Affidavit. Thereafter the motion was disposed of by written submissions.

Facts of the case

3. The Applicant was employed by the Respondent as a Machine Operator. On 12th December 2020, he sustained a fracture of the right hand caused by a machine cylinder shock. The accident occurred while the applicant was in the course of his duties, and the same was reported to DOSHS. He received outpatient treatment at Athi River Shalom Community Hospital, and the Respondent met the resulting medical expenses of Kshs. 10,280.

4. Following the injury, the Applicant’s permanent incapacity was assessed at 3.5% and vide DOSH Form 4 dated 24th March 2021, the DOSHS assessed his compensation at Kshs. 63,685.44. On the same date, the Director issued a demand to the Respondent for payment. The Respondent did not pay the assessed amount and never formally challenged the award through objection within the statutory period provided by the Work Injury Benefit Act (WIBA).

5. On 19th January 2026, the Applicant served the Respondent and its insurer, APA Insurance, with a demand for payment but it was not honoured. Subsequently, the applicant filed the present application was filed on 29th January 2026.

6. In response, the Respondent notified the applicant of a purported re-evaluation done of the applicant at the DOSH Work Injury Evaluation Clinic on 19th May 2022, which allegedly found that the applicant had fully recovered and was assessed at 0% permanent incapacity. A revised DOSH Form 4 dated 10th March 2026 was thereafter issued purporting to nullify the 2021 assessment and place the compensation at Kshs. 0.00. Therefore, it urged the Court to dismiss the application on the basis that the 2021 award was superseded by the subsequent one, as verified by the Deputy DOSH’s letter dated 19th June 2026.

7. The Applicant denied having attended the alleged re-evaluation and averred that there is no evidence before the Court that the Respondent ever lodged a formal objection to the Director’s assessment of 24th March 2021 within sixty days. He further averred that he was never notified of, participated in or ever given any hearing in relation to the alleged 19th May 2022 re-evaluation.

Determination

8. Having considered the motion, affidavits and the submissions filed, the main issues for determination is whether the Court should adopt the DOSHS assessment dated 24th March 2021 as a judgment of the Court.

9. It is now well settled that this court has the jurisdiction to adopt and enforce awards of the DOSHS by dint of Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. The foregoing position was affirmed by the court of Appeal in Thepot Patrick Charles v Joash Shisia Cheto [2025] KECA 784 (KLR). However, I must add that the said jurisdiction is only exercisable where the court is presented with a final decision from the statutory procedure.

10. In the instant case, the applicant has presented to this court a DOSHS award dated 24th March 2021 for adoption as judgment contending that the same is final as no objection was ever lodged to challenge it within the statutory period of 60 days under section 51 of the WIBA. However, the respondent has opposed the request by the applicant contending that the said award was superseded by a subsequent assessment dated 10th March 2026, that found that the applicant had suffered o% permanent incapacity and therefore entitled to zero compensation.

11. In Stephen Wangusi Nyongesa v Dot.Com Bakery Limited [2022] KEELRC 224 (KLR), the Court held found that the employer had not objected to the DOSHS award within the period prescribed by section 51 of WIBA, and rejected a reassessment that was done outside the objection procedure for challenging an award by DOSHS.

12. Section 51(1) of WIBA provides that a person aggrieved by a decision of the Director may, within sixty days of the decision, lodge an objection with the Director. Section 52 then provides that any party dissatisfied with the decision of the DOSHS on the objection to the award, may appeal to this Court.

13. The significance of that procedure cannot be understated. It provided the Respondent with a clear opportunity to challenge an assessment which it considers excessive, erroneous or otherwise unsatisfactory. The Respondent did not use the objection procedure in to formally challenge the assessment dated 24th March 2021 within sixty days from the date of receipt of the said assessment.

14. Instead, the respondent purported to invoke section 23 of the WIBA which provides that the employer can request for examination of the injured employee by a doctor of its choice. However, that right is only possible during the investigations and before the adjudication by the DOSHS. Once the DOSHS has considered the case and issued an award, any dissatisfied party can only challenge the award through objection procedure under section 51 of the WIBA and thereafter appeal to this Court procedure under section 52 of the Act.

15. Once the Director has assessed compensation and the employer fails to challenge the award by an objection under section 51 of the WIBA, the assessed sum became payable to the injured employee. Accordingly, the invocation of the employer’s right under section 23 of the Act cannot yield the same outcome as an objection under section 51 of the Act. Therefore, such a move cannot reverse or vary the final award of compensation by the DOSHS under the Act.

16. The Respondent contended that the Director had a continuing power under section 23 of WIBA to inquire further into the claim, and that the assessment of 10th March 2026 superseded the earlier assessment. However, based on the reasons highlighted above, I strongly disagree with that proposition. Section 23 does not, in my view, give an employer an alternative mechanism for reopening a concluded adjudication after the statutory objection period has expired. Once the Director has made a decision as contemplated by the Act, any aggrieved party can only challenge it first by an objection under section 51 of the Act and thereafter, file appeal to this court under section 52 of the Act.

17. There is doubt that the Respondent had the statutory opportunity to challenge the 24th March 2021 award but it slept on that right. It cannot now, benefit from its own default. It cannot also benefit from a procedure that is not contemplated in the WIBA. Therefore, DOSHS award dated 10th March 2026 is not a product of the objection procedure under section 51 of the WIBA and it cannot supersede the earlier DOSHS award of Kshs. 63,685.44 dated 24th March 2021 which remains in force against the respondent.

18. Section 26(4) of WIBA requires an employer or insurer against whom a claim is lodged by the Director to settle the claim within ninety days. Section 26(6) further recognizes the seriousness of non-payment by making a criminal offence punishable by fine and imprisonment. The statutory policy plainly does not contemplate that an injured employee should remain without the benefit of an assessment where the employer has neither paid nor lawfully challenged it. Consequently, I allow the application by accepting and adopting the DOSHS award dated 24th March 2021 as a judgment of this court for purposes of enforcement.

19. As regards the prayer for interest, at the rate of 14% per annum from 24th March 2021, it is without dispute that the Respondent was forthwith notified of the assessment but failed to either object or pay the same. The amount has remained unpaid for a prolonged period without a lawful objection having been lodged. The applicant has also not shown why he failed to move the court early enough. Consequently, he will only get interest from the date of filing the motion herein, at the rate of 14% per annum on Kshs. 63,685.44.

20. On costs, the Applicant has been compelled to come to Court to enforce an assessment which remained unpaid despite the expiry of the statutory period for objection. The costs of the application should therefore follow the event. The Applicant is awarded of the costs of the application.

Disposition

21. For the foregoing reasons, the Notice of Motion dated 29th January 2026 is allowed and the Court makes the following orders:

a) The DOSH Form 4 dated 24th March 2021 assessing the Applicant’s compensation at Kshs. 63,685.44 is hereby adopted as a judgment of this Court.

b) The Respondent shall pay the Applicant interest on the said sum at the rate of 14% per annum from the date of filing the Notice of Motion herein until payment in full.

c) A decree shall issue accordingly.

d) The Applicant is awarded the costs of the application.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Musau for Claimant

Isaboke for Ochieng for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder