Employment law

Kenya Building Construction Timber and Furniture Industries Employees Union v Superfit Steelcon Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14813 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E861 of 2024
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant is a trade union which is registered and has its operations in the Republic of Kenya. It avers that it has both a Recognition Agreement (RA) and Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) with the Respondent which were signed by the Respondent’s umbrella body, the Kenya Association of Building and Civil Engineering Contractors (KABCEC). As such, it contends that it represents unionisable employees working for the Respondent.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

I am satisfied that these lapses alone vitiated the disciplinary process against the grievants rendering the subsequent decisions to terminate their contracts of service unlawful. It is so declared.

Paragraph 73 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the union could be denied standing through an objection first raised in closing submissions; whether the grievants’ dismissals complied with procedural fairness requirements; and whether they proved claims for compensation, notice pay, underpayment…

Material facts

The union sued for Shadrack Milton Orwa, Isaac Oduor Awande and Sylvester Kyungu Kala, alleging that they were shop-floor union representatives dismissed after pursuing workplace grievances. The respondent maintained that it dismissed them for refusing lawful…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO E861 OF 2024

KENYA BUILDING CONSTRUCTION TIMBER AND FURNITURE INDUSTRIES EMPLOYEES UNION………………..………….CLAIMANT

VERSUS

SUPERFIT STEELCON LTD............................................…....RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Background

1. The Claimant is a trade union which is registered and has its operations in the Republic of Kenya. It avers that it has both a Recognition Agreement (RA) and Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) with the Respondent which were signed by the Respondent’s umbrella body, the Kenya Association of Building and Civil Engineering Contractors (KABCEC). As such, it contends that it represents unionisable employees working for the Respondent.

2. The Claimant avers that it has instituted the instant suit on behalf of three of its members: Shadrack Milton Orwa, Isaack Oduor Awande and Sylvester Kyungu Kala (the grievants). It alleges that the grievants were employees of the Respondent and were also serving as the shop-floor trade union representatives at the workplace.

3. The Claimant alleges that in or about April 2023, employees of the Respondent raised various grievances relating to their conditions of work. It contends that the aggrieved employees held a meeting with the Respondent on 13th April 2023 to raise their concerns.

4. The Claimant asserts that the grievances related to the tools of work which were in a less than satisfactory state. It further avers that the Respondent was also underpaying some of the workers.

5. The Claimant alleges that despite the meeting of 13th April 2023, the Respondent did not address the workers’ grievances. It alleges that the position remained the same despite several other meetings which were held to address the grievances.

6. The Claimant alleges that sometime in the month of July 2023, the grievants sought to pursue the grievances which had been flagged by employees. In reaction, the Claimant alleges that the Respondent assigned them (the grievants) other duties and accused them of having engaged in a go slow.

7. The Claimant asserts that the Respondent issued the grievants and other employees show cause letters dated 17th July 2023. It asserts that the employees, including the grievants, were subsequently subjected to a disciplinary hearing held on 20th July 2023.

8. The Claimant asserts that after the disciplinary process, the Respondent pardoned some employees. However, it (the Claimant) avers that the contracts of service for the grievants were terminated.

9. The Claimant asserts that the decision to relieve the grievants of their employment was motivated by the fact that they were also serving as shop floor union representatives. As such, it contends that the decision was unlawful.

10. The Claimant asserts that the Respondent did not pay the grievants their terminal dues. It also alleges that the three were victims of underpayment as particularized in the Statement of Claim.

11. The Claimant contends that after the Respondent dismissed the grievants from service, it (the Claimant) tried to have the dispute amicably resolved but to no avail. It contends that the matter was first reported to the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection which appointed a conciliator to assist the parties to settle the case. However, it (the Claimant) avers that there was no settlement reached prompting the filing of this suit. As such, it (the Claimant) prays for the various reliefs set out in the Statement of Claim.

12. During trial, the Claimant called the three grievants as witnesses in support of their case. They gave their testimonies in chief and were cross examined.

13. Isaac Awande adopted his witness statement and presented the list and bundle of documents filed by the Claimant as exhibits.

14. He averred that the Respondent had engaged his services as a fitter. He asserted that he also served as a shop steward on behalf of the Claimant.

15. The grievant stated that he had a card which was issued to him in 2021 which shows that he was a fitter. He averred that although the card was issued to him in 2021, the Respondent engaged him as a fitter from inception.

16. He stated that the work of a fitter is to identify material for work to be done. After this, he stated that he was required to prepare, fit and fabricate the material before it is handed over to the Wielder.

17. The witness stated that the Respondent terminated his services without giving him the reason for the decision. He contends that he only came to learn about the reason for the decision much later when he got the letter of termination of his services.

18. The witness stated that the grievants reported the matter to the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection. However, he asserted that the Ministry did not offer them any assistance.

19. The witness asserted that he believes that the decision to terminate his services was because of his involvement in trade union activities. However, he conceded that the Respondent informed him that his services were terminated because he refused to execute his duties.

20. The witness conceded that he was invited for a disciplinary hearing where he was granted the opportunity to offer his explanation. He confirmed that he indeed gave his version of the story during the hearing.

21. The witness averred that the charges against him and his colleagues were fabricated. However, he acknowledged that they (the charges) were issued to each of the grievants individually based on their respective Job Description.

22. In re-examination, the witness stated that the Respondent did not issue him with a formal contract when it engaged his services. He averred that he was issued with a one year contract much later. He further alleged that he continued to work for the Respondent even after the one year contract had lapsed.

23. He confirmed that the one year contract shows that he was engaged as a Wielding Assistant. He however insisted that he was hired as a fitter.

24. The witness stated that he was issued with an accreditation card which showed he was a fitter after the Respondent applied for it in 2021. He stated that the Respondent applied for the cards because one of its clients wanted to be sure that the Respondent had qualified fitters.

25. Shadrack Orwa also adopted his written witness statement. He stated that the Respondent hired his services as a Wielder. He said the Respondent obtained an accreditation for him which shows he was a Wielder.

26. The witness stated that the Respondent terminated his services in 2023. He said that the letter of dismissal indicated that he was relieved of his duties after he refused to take lawful instructions.

27. In cross examination, he stated that when the Respondent hired him in 2015, it did not issue him with a letter of appointment. However, he maintained that he was recruited as a Wielder.

28. When shown the one year contract which was issued to him, he conceded that it (the contract) indicated that he was engaged as an Erector Assistant. However, he maintained that he was hired as a Wielder as evidenced in the accreditation card which was issued to him in 2021. He stated that it is the Respondent who sought the accreditation in order to demonstrate to its clients that he was a qualified Wielder.

29. The witness acknowledged that he was subjected to a disciplinary hearing. However, he alleged that he was not allowed to get representation during the hearing because his colleagues were not admitted into the session.

30. The witness stated that the Respondent did not inform him why he was dismissed from service. He alleged that the reason for his dismissal from employment were not even clear from the letter of suspension. He averred that he had reason to believe that his contract was terminated because of his involvement in trade union activities.

31. When asked about the allegation that he had defied work instructions, he appeared to concede that he was given this as the reason for his dismissal from employment. However, he denied that he had refused to work as alleged.

32. Sylvester Kyungu Kala also adopted his written witness statement as his evidence in chief. He averred that the Respondent hired his services as an Electrician. He asserted that he was issued with an accreditation in 2021 to affirm his position.

33. The witness stated that he was also serving as the Claimant’s shop steward at the Respondent’s shop floor. He said that he held this position together with the other two grievants.

34. The witness stated that as shop stewards, the grievants held several meetings with the Respondent’s management regarding various workplace grievances. He contended that the Respondent subsequently issued him with a letter in which it accused him of having refused to execute some of his duties.

35. The witness stated that although the letter did not call for his response, he nevertheless responded to it. He stated that he explained the reason why he had did not execute the task of repairing the grinder at the workplace. He said that despite asking for tools to execute the works, they were not given to him and hence the failure to repair the grinder.

36. The witness stated that despite his explanation, the Respondent terminated his services. He alleged that the Respondent did not supply him with the testimonies of the various witnesses whose evidence it relied on to arrive at the decision to terminate his services.

37. During cross-examination, the witness stated that although his entry salary was Ksh.17,000.00, he was subsequently given some increments. However, he maintained that despite the increments, he was underpaid.

38. The witness stated that the Respondent hired him as an Electrician and that he remained in this position until his contract was terminated. He contended that the accreditation card he was issued with shows he was an Electrician.

39. The witness confirmed that the Respondent invited him for a disciplinary hearing. He further confirmed that he was given an opportunity to ventilate his case during the disciplinary hearing. Unlike the other grievants, he conceded that the Respondent allowed him to attend the hearing in the company of a witness. However, he averred that the witness did not accompany him to the hearing out of fear of victimization.

40. The witness conceded that he was not relieved of his duties because of his engagement in trade union activities. He stated that his dismissal from employment was due to other work issues.

41. In response, the Respondent admitted that the grievants were indeed its employees. However, it denied that they were engaged in the positions which the Claimant has pleaded. According to the Respondent, the three were engaged as Electrician, Wielding Assistant and Erector Assistant.

42. The Respondent denied that the contracts of service for the grievants were terminated because of their involvement in trade union activities. It contended that their contracts were terminated after they refused to comply with lawful instructions at the workplace.

43. The Respondent averred that it was not the first time the three were engaged in workplace infractions. It averred that they had in fact been previously issued with warnings. As such, it contended that the grievants’ contracts of service were lawfully terminated.

44. The Respondent acknowledged that the Claimant reported the dispute to the Ministry of Labour and Social Services which appointed a conciliator. It contended that after the conciliator heard the parties, he upheld the decision to terminate the grievants’ respective contracts as the dispute had nothing to do with their involvement in trade union activities.

45. The Respondent averred that the grievants’ contracts were summarily terminated because of gross misconduct. It contended that the contracts were terminated for lawful reasons and in accordance with fair procedure.

46. During the trial, RW1, the Respondent’s Human Resource Officer, adopted her witness statement as part of her evidence. She also produced the Respondent’s bundle of documents as defense exhibits.

47. The witness stated that the grievants were hired as Electrician, Wielding Assistant and Erector Assistant respectively. However, she conceded that they had accreditation cards which showed they were qualified as Electrician and Wielders.

48. The witness confirmed that the Claimant had written to the Respondent regarding alleged underpayment of the grievants. She stated that the Respondent responded to the letter describing the three employees as general workers. She contended that the positions of fitter, wielder and erector, all fell in the category of general labourers.

49. When shown the CBA between the parties, she conceded that the categorization she gave did not match the categorization in the CBA. She confirmed that under the CBA, general labourers were placed under category one (1), wielders were under category seven (7) and fitters were under category six (6).

50. The witness however alleged that despite the categorization in the CBA, the Respondent’s staff were not yet categorized. As such, she stated that they were all treated as general labourers.

51. The witness stated that the grievants were dismissed from service because of refusal to take lawful instructions. She stated that they were issued with letters of suspension which also served as notice to show cause letters and invitations to the disciplinary hearing.

52. The witness stated that the letters required the grievants to offer their response to the accusations against them within three days. She averred that they all offered their responses.

53. The witness stated that the Claimant wrote to the Respondent on 21st July 2023 asking for further and better particulars of the charges against the grievants. However, she contended that the letter by the Claimant was received after the disciplinary hearings had been processed.

54. The witness stated that the Respondent’s witnesses did not record their statements before the disciplinary hearing. She averred that the witnesses, just like the grievants, testified orally during the disciplinary hearing.

55. The witness stated that the grievants were aware of the charges against them since details thereof had been set out in the letters of suspension. However, she conceded that the suspension letters only made reference to failure to perform ‘’certain duties’’ without further details.

56. The witness acknowledged that a CCTV footage was played during the disciplinary hearing. However, she stated that she could not confirm if the grievants had been shown the footage beforehand even though she believed that they had seen it.

57. The witness stated that the grievants were notified of their right to bring their witnesses to the hearing. She further stated that they were allowed a free hand to ask the Respondent’s witnesses the questions they wished to ask. She however conceded that the minutes of the disciplinary session had not been presented to court.

58. The witness stated that the show cause letters accused the grievants of failure to perform ‘’certain duties’’. However, she stated that the particulars of the infractions were set out in the letters of dismissal.

59. The witness stated that the grievants had been issued with earlier warnings. She said that although the CBA required warnings to employees to be in writing, the warnings to the grievants were oral.

60. The witness stated that the grievants did not demonstrate their remorse for the offenses they committed. She averred that although this was not the reason why their contracts were terminated, it was considered as an aggravating factor. She said other employees who were subjected to the disciplinary process showed remorse and hence the decision not to terminate their contracts of service.

61. The witness stated that the Respondent computed the terminal dues for the grievants. However, she said that they refused to collect them.

Analysis

62. Before the court considers the merits of the case, it is necessary to address one matter which the Respondent has raised through its closing submissions. It contends that because the Claimant filed the instant proceedings on behalf of its members using its name, the suit is improperly before the court. The Respondent asserts that the Claimant had no locus standi to file suit as it did.

63. The issue which the Respondent seeks to raise on locus standi was neither pleaded in the Statement of Defense nor raised during the trial. It was raised for the first time through its (the Respondent’s) closing submissions.

64. The law is now settled that a party to a cause is not entitled to advance a case or defense which is not founded on his pleadings. He is bound by his pleadings. As such, any case or defense which is not anchored on the filed pleadings must be rejected (see Daniel Otieno Migore v South Nyanza Sugar Co. Ltd [2018] eKLR).

65. Having regard to the foregoing, it was not open to the Respondent to raise the defense of locus standi for the first time through its closing submissions without having pleaded it. As such, the court declines to interrogate the defense.

66. The evidence on record shows that the Respondent issued the three grievants with letters dated 17th July 2023 suspending them from duty. The letters are worded in the same way. They all accused the grievants of refusal to undertake ‘’certain tasks’’ which had allegedly been allocated to them on the morning of the letters.

67. The letters gave the grievants 48 hours to offer their defense to the accusation against them. They (the letters) meanwhile suspended the grievants from duty and also set 20th July 2023 as the date their disciplinary cases were to be heard.

68. Measured against the requirements of section 41 of the Employment Act and section 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act, the letters had glaring deficiencies. Section 41 of the Employment Act requires the employer to inform the employee of the reasons why his contract is being considered for termination. On the other hand, section 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act, inter alia, provides that information, materials and evidence that is to be relied on in making a decision which is likely to affect a person should be supplied to him.

69. I understand these provisions to obligate an employer to provide an employee with clear particulars of the charge against him (the employee). It cannot be said, by any stretch of imagination, that reference to ‘’certain tasks’’ in the letters of suspension which were issued to the grievants satisfied the requirement to furnish them (the grievants) with clear and specific particulars of the charges against them.

70. It has also emerged from the evidence which was tendered in court that during the disciplinary hearing, the Respondent relied on recordings from a CCTV footage to prove the charges against the grievants. However, the grievants contend that these recordings were not shared with them beforehand.

71. Whilst the Respondent’s witness alleged that the footage was given to the grievants, she could not support this assertion. As a matter of fact, she eventually conceded that she was not in a position to confirm if the grievants were indeed given this evidence beforehand.

72. The failure to share the CCTV footage with the grievants also breached section 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act. As such, it affected the validity of the disciplinary process.

73. I am satisfied that these lapses alone vitiated the disciplinary process against the grievants rendering the subsequent decisions to terminate their contracts of service unlawful. It is so declared.

74. The Respondent may have had valid grounds to consider terminating the contracts of the grievants. However, the presence of valid reasons is not sufficient to validate a decision to terminate an employee’s contract of service. Beyond the presence of a valid reason to terminate the contract, the employer must accord the affected employee fair procedure whilst processing his release from service. Absent this, the entire process collapses (see Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] KEELRC 386 (KLR)).

75. Having arrived at the conclusion that the grievants’ contracts of service were improperly terminated, the court awards each one of them compensation for unfair termination of their respective contracts which is equivalent to their respective monthly salaries for four months per grievant. According to the pay slips tendered in evidence by the Claimant, the grievants’ last known salary was: Shadrack Milton Orwa – Ksh. 25,278 (see page 41 of Claimant’s trial bundle); Isaac Oduor Awande – Ksh. 25,484 (see page 44 of Claimant’s trial bundle); and Sylvester Kyungu Kala – Ksh. 21,825 (see page 46 of Claimant’s trial bundle). As such, compensation for unfair termination works out as follows for each of the grievants:-

a) Shadrack Milton Orwa Ksh. 25,278 x 4 = Ksh. 101,112.00

b) Isaac Oduor Awande Ksh. 25,484 x 4 = Ksh. 101,936.00

c) Sylvester Kyungu Kala Ksh. 21,825 x 4 Ksh. 87,300.00

76. The grievants assert that during the currency of their service the Respondent underpaid them. They assert that whilst they were to be remunerated as holders of positions of Electrician and Wielder/Fitter, the Respondent remunerated them as General Labourers. It is their case that this not only breached the terms of the CBA between the parties but also resulted in their underpayment.

77. The evidence on record shows that Shadrack Milton Orwa was first engaged by the Respondent on 31st December 2015 in the position of Erector Assistant. Under the one year contract which was issued to him, he was to receive gross salary of Ksh. 18,092.

78. The evidence also shows that Isaac Oduor Awande was first engaged by the Respondent as a Wielding Assistant with effect 3rd January 2017. His gross salary was agreed at Ksh. 20,423.00. This was a one year contract.

79. Although there is not contract for Sylvester Kyungu Kala, he avers that he was engaged around September 2018 in the position of Electrician. He stated that his starting salary was Ksh.17,000.00.

80. The Respondent avers that the three individuals were employed in the aforesaid positions. On the other hand, the grievants contend that they were hired in the following positions:-

a) Shadrack Milton Orwa Wielder.

b) Isaac Oduor Awande Steel Fixer/Wielder.

c) Sylvester Kyungu Kala Electrician.

81. The grievants rely on the accreditation cards which were issued to them by the National Construction Authority, the regulator of the sector where the Respondent operates, to anchor their contention. The cards indeed show that the grievants were licensed in the above positions.

82. The cards were issued to the grievants before June 2022. This is because they show that their expiry date was June 2022 implying that they were issued earlier. As a matter of fact, the parties to the action appear to confirm that the accreditations were done in 2021, during the currency of the grievants’ employment with the Respondent.

83. The grievants assert that after their fixed term contracts with the Respondent lapsed, they continued in its (the Respondent’s) service but in the positions which are set out in the accreditation cards. Although the Respondent disputes this fact, it has not presented cogent evidence to controvert the position and evidence by the grievants on the matter. In the premises, the court is convinced on a balance of probabilities that the grievants were serving the Respondent in the following positions at the time their contracts were terminated:-

a) Shadrack Milton Orwa Wielder.

b) Isaac Oduor Awande Steel Fixer/Wielder.

c) Sylvester Kyungu Kala Electrician.

84. The court is further convinced that the grievants were respectively serving the Respondent in the aforesaid positions at least from the date they were issued with the aforesaid accreditations, which according to the evidence on record, was in June 2021.

85. The Claimant alleges that the Respondent was underpaying the grievants their salaries. However, apart from Isaac Oduor Awande’s pay slip for June 2023, the Claimant did not provide pay slips for June or July 2023 for the other grievants to assist the court to determine what they were being paid at the time their contracts were terminated. As a matter of fact, the latest pay slips for the two are the pay slip for Shadrack Milton Orwa for April 2022 and for Sylvester Kyungu Kala for July 2022.

86. Further, the Claimant relies on the CBA dated 28th July 2023 to anchor its contention that the grievants suffered salary underpayments. The CBA has a schedule which backdated salary increments to 1st January 2023. As such, the grievants can only claim the differences in their salaries and what the CBA provided with effect from 1st January 2023 to the date their contracts were terminate. Again, this must be based on proof that the Respondent paid them less than what the CBA proposed.

87. Having regard to the foregoing, only Isaac Oduor Awande would possibly have sustained a claim for underpayment of salary. However, this again has to fail because the CBA granted Wielders and Fitters differentiated salary depending on their grades. No evidence was presented to show under which grade Shadrack Milton Orwa and Isaac Oduor Awande were accredited as Wielders. This information is not contained in the accreditation cards either.

88. In effect, it is self-evident that there is paucity of evidence to support the claim for salary underpayments by the grievants. For this reason, the court declines this claim.

89. The grievants also pray for pay in lieu of notice to terminate their contracts of service. Having regard to the fact that the decision to terminate their contracts of service has been nullified, the court awards each one of them an amount which is equivalent to salary for one month in lieu of notice to terminate their contracts of service in terms of sections 35 and 36 of the Employment Act, that is to say:-

a) Shadrack Milton Orwa Ksh. 25,278.

b) Isaac Oduor Awande Ksh. 25,484.

c) Sylvester Kyungu Kala Ksh. 21,825.

90. I note that the Claimant has prayed for notice pay equivalent to the grievants’ salary for two months in line with the CBA dated 28th July 2023. However, the grievants’ contracts were terminated on 17th July 2023. Although the CBA proclaims its effective date to be 1st January 2023, there is no indication in it that it was to apply to and or cover persons who left office before it was signed on 28th July 2023. In my view, the CBA applied retroactively only in respect of persons who were in employment on 28th July 2023, the date it was signed.

91. The grievants have claimed for service pay for the duration they were in the Respondent’s service. Under section 35 (5) of the Employment Act, an employee who leaves employment after one year of service is entitled to service pay for every year worked. However, section 35 (6) (d) of the Act disqualifies employees who are members of the National Social Security Fund from claiming this benefit.

92. A perusal of the pay slips tendered in evidence by the Claimant shows that each of the three grievants was a contributor to the National Social Security Fund. As such, they are not entitled to claim service pay.

93. The amount awarded to the grievants is subject to the statutory deductions which were in force at the time their contract were terminated.

94. The grievants are awarded interest on the amount awarded at court rates from the date of this judgment.

95. Since the suit was not litigated through an advocate, I will not award costs as these are normally computed under the Advocates (Remuneration) Order which presupposes that the services being billed for were rendered by an advocate. However, the Claimant is allowed to recover the actual expenses it incurred in pursuing the claim which must be supported by receipts.

Summary of the Findings and Orders

96. After evaluating the evidence on record against the applicable law, the court makes the following findings and attendant orders:-

a) The court finds that the Respondent irregularly terminated the grievants’ contracts of service.

b) Consequently, the decision to terminate the contracts is declared unlawful.

c) The court awards each of the grievants compensation for unfair termination of their contracts to wit:-

i) Shadrack Milton Orwa Ksh. 25,278 x 4 = Ksh. 101,112.00

ii) Isaac Oduor Awande Ksh. 25,484 x 4 = Ksh. 101,936.00

iii) Sylvester Kyungu Kala Ksh. 21,825 x 4 = Ksh. 87,300.00

d) The court declines to grant the prayer for underpayment of salaries for want of proof.

e) The court awards each of the grievants an amount which is equivalent to their salary for one month in lieu of notice to terminate their contracts of service in terms of sections 35 and 36 of the Employment Act, that is to say:-

i) Shadrack Milton Orwa Ksh. 25,278.

ii) Isaac Oduor Awande Ksh. 25,484.

iii) Sylvester Kyungu Kala Ksh. 21,825.

f) The court declines the claim for service pay.

g) The amount awarded to the grievants is subject to the statutory deductions which were in force at the time their contracts of service were terminated.

h) The grievants are awarded interest on the amount awarded at court rates from the date of this judgment.

i) Since the suit was not litigated through an advocate, I will not award costs.

j) However, the Claimant is allowed to recover the actual expenses it incurred in pursuing the claim which must be supported by receipts.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Claimant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder