Background
Spent
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Spent
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC MISC. APPLICATION NO. E273 OF 2025
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)
J.A. GUSERWA & COMPANY ADVOCATES…………………………………ADVOCATE/RESPONDENT
VS
JAMES M. NJIIRI………........................................CLIENT/APPLICANT
RULING
1 The Client/Applicant filed a Chamber Summons dated 17th June 2026 under Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, Sections 1A, 1B, 3 and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and all other enabling provisions of the law, seeking the following orders:
1. Spent
2. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to grant a stay of execution of the ruling dated 22nd May 2026 and the Certificate of Taxation issued herein for the sum of Kshs. 308,189.90/- and any subsequent enforcement proceedings pending the hearing and determination of this Application inter-partes.
3. THAT this Honorable Court be pleased to review and vary the Taxing Officer’s ruling dated 22nd May 2026 by ordering a set-off of the taxed costs of Kshs.308,1 89.90/- against the
4. sum of Kshs.1,428,229/- unlawfully withheld ond retained by the Respondent Advocate.
5. THAT upon such set-off, this Honorable Court be pleased to order the Respondent Advocate to immediately refund and pay over the net balance of Kshs.1,1 20,039.10/- to the Applicant client, together with interest at court rates from the date the funds were withheld until payment in full.
6. THAT the costs of this application be in the cause.
2 The Application is premised on the grounds on its face and is supported by the Affidavit of James Mwangi Njiiri, the Client/Applicant, sworn on 17th June 2026.
Client/Applicant’s Case
3 The Applicant avers that the dispute arose from a complaint he lodged with the Advocates Complaints Commission against the Respondent Advocate for unlawfully and without just cause withholding Kshs. 1,428,229, being part of the decretal amount and costs received on his behalf from the Respondent in Nairobi ELRC No. 809 of 2020 (formerly HCCC No. 205 of 1998) James Mwangi Njiiri v National Bank of Kenya.
4 He avers that following the complaint, the Commission required the Respondent Advocate to account for the monies or, in the alternative, to file an Advocate-Client Bill of Costs and have it taxed, and that the Advocate opted to file an Advocate-Client Bill of Costs dated 31st July 2025, which particularised the withheld funds at item No. 112.
5 It is the Applicant's case that the Taxing Officer, by a ruling delivered on 13th November 2025, taxed the said Bill of Costs at Kshs. 2,950,500, which he contends was almost half of the judgment sum of Kshs. 6,103,543. Being aggrieved, he filed a reference by way of Chamber Summons dated 17th December 2025, which was determined by this Court (Wasilwa J.) on 20th April 2026.
6 He avers that the Court remitted the Bill of Costs for re-taxation before a different Taxing Officer and issued a mandatory directive that the new Taxing Officer must factor in and credit the funds already withheld and retained by the Respondent Advocate.
7 The Applicant avers that upon re-taxation, the Taxing Officer delivered a ruling on 22nd May 2026 taxing the Bill of Costs at Kshs. 308,189.90 but failed, ignored and/or omitted to credit him with the withheld sum of Kshs. 1,428,229 as particularised in item No. 112 and as directed by the Court.
8 He states that upon realizing this error, he instructed his advocates to lodge a Letter of Objection dated 2nd June 2026 addressed to the Taxing Officer drawing attention to the non-compliance with the Court's order, but that the Taxing Officer has failed to reply, give reasons or address the anomaly.
9 He further avers that the registry has since extracted a Certificate of Taxation for the full sum of Kshs. 308,189.90, and that the Respondent Advocate, by a demand letter dated 28th May 2026, has demanded immediate payment of that sum and threatened execution.
10 He contends that he is in imminent danger of execution through auctioneers on what he terms an illegal, double-counted sum, which would occasion him massive financial loss, public embarrassment and psychological distress.
11 He therefore seeks that the taxed costs be set off against the withheld funds and that the Respondent Advocate be ordered to refund the net balance of Kshs. 1,120,039.10 together with interest at court rates from the date the funds were withheld until payment in full.
12 In response to the Replying Affidavit dated 24th June 2026, the Applicant filed a Supplementary Affidavit sworn in July 2026.
13 He avers therein that upon receipt of the ruling of 22nd May 2026, he forwarded a copy to the Advocates Complaints Commission by a letter dated 26th May 2026, and that the Commission thereafter issued a formal demand letter dated 12th June 2026 to the Respondent Advocate directing it to deduct the final taxed amount of Kshs. 308,189.90 from the withheld funds and immediately remit the net balance of Kshs. 1,120,039.10 to him.
14 He avers that the Respondent Advocate has withheld funds which this Court ordered to be paid to him in ELRC No. 809 of 2020 for more than one year, causing him untold suffering as he requires the funds to access urgent medical care which has been put on hold.
Respondent/Advocate’s Case
15 The Respondent/Advocate opposed the Application through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 24th June 2026 by Judith A. Guserwa, the proprietor of the firm of J.A. Guserwa & Company Advocates.
16 The Respondent avers that the orders sought are baseless, lack merit and are intended to delay the recovery of the fees owed to her firm by the Applicant.
17 It is its position that the ruling of the Taxing Master of 22nd May 2026 is not available for review or variation, as it was made after the Applicant had already filed a reference against the original taxed costs.
18 The Respondent avers that the question of any sums withheld by the firm on account of its fees was adequately addressed by the Taxing Master, who concluded that it is the Applicant who owes the firm Kshs. 308,189.90, a sum which she contends the Applicant is attempting to avoid paying through the present Application, which in any event does not lie.
19 It further avers that this Court's ruling of 20th April 2026 was duly complied with, in that upon re-taxation the originally taxed sum of Kshs. 2,950,500 was reduced to Kshs. 1,258,689.90 payable by the Applicant to the firm.
20 The Respondent denies that the firm is withholding any monies due to the Applicant, stating that the sums held form part of its fees.
21 The Respondent avers that the complaint lodged by the Applicant before the Advocates Complaints Commission is what led to the filing of the Advocate-Client Bill of Costs, which went through taxation as well as the hearing of the reference filed against the first taxation.
22 It is therefore the Respondent’s case that there is no mathematical error in the re-taxation of the Bill by the Taxing Master, and that the Application is misplaced and lacking in substance and ought to be dismissed with costs to pave way for execution for the balance of the taxed costs.
Client/Applicant’s Submissions
23 The Client/Applicant identified three issues: whether the Taxing Officer committed an error of principle by failing to comply with an express order of this Honourable Court to offset the withheld funds; whether the Respondent/Advocate’s Demand Letter represents a clear threat of double enrichment and an abuse of the court process that warrants this Court's immediate intervention; and whether this Honourable Court should interfere with the Taxing Officer’s Re- taxation Ruling.
24 On the first issue, the Applicant relied on Premchand Raichand Ltd v Quarry Services of East Africa Ltd [1972] EA 162 for the proposition that the Court will interfere with a Taxing Officer's discretion where the officer has acted on an erroneous principle or ignored material facts. He argued that the Taxing Officer blindfolded himself to the very genesis of the matter, being a complaint before the Advocates Complaints Commission over withheld funds.
25 It was submitted that this Court, in remitting the Bill for re-taxation, explicitly directed the Taxing Officer to address all issues raised in the Chamber Summons dated 17th December 2025, which included the withheld funds, and that by failing to record the sum of Kshs. 1,428,229 in the final assessment, the Taxing Officer went outside his mandate and acted in direct contravention of the remittal instructions.
26 It is the Client/Applicant submissions that the result is a dangerous absurdity in which the Advocate can lawfully execute the certificate of taxation to recover fees while simultaneously sitting on the client's substantial funds.
27 On the second issue, the Applicant submitted that the demand letter of 28th May 2026 exposes the exact mischief he sought to prevent, as the Advocate now seeks to use the machinery of the Court to extract fresh payment while holding his funds.
28 He submitted that the Court cannot stand by and watch its processes be used to facilitate illegality and unjust enrichment, and argued that taxation certificates must reflect the true and equitable financial position between the parties so as to prevent advocates from executing for sums they have effectively already recovered or covered through client funds in their possession.
29 It was his submission that unless the certificate is urgently varied or set aside, he faces imminent and unlawful execution based on a flawed accounting process, and that the true position is that Kshs. 1,428,229 less Kshs. 308,189.90 leaves Kshs. 1,120,039.10 payable to him.
30 On the third issue, the Applicant acknowledged that the Court is generally hesitant to interfere with the exercise of a Taxing Officer's discretion but submitted that the rule is subject to clear exceptions. He relied on the Court of Appeal decision in First American Bank of Kenya v Shah [2002] 1 EA 64, which he described as the locus classicus, where it was held that the Court will not interfere with the decision of the Taxing Officer "unless it is shown that he has acted on a wrong principle, or that he has left out of consideration matters which he ought to have considered, or that the amount allowed is so manifestly excessive or inadequate as to be an error of principle."
31 He further relied on Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board [2005] eKLR, where the Court reiterated that intervention is warranted where the Taxing Officer misapprehends the evidence or the law in a manner amounting to an injustice.
32 It is therefore the Claimant/Applicant’s submission that the impugned ruling falls squarely within these exceptions, since the Taxing Officer left out of consideration the critical fact that the Advocate was already in possession of funds withheld from the Applicant, and by ignoring that financial reality arrived at a figure representing double recovery and unjust enrichment.
33 In conclusion, the Applicant argued that the Advocate's demand letter underscores the urgency of the application and reveals an intent to bypass the orders of both this Court and the Advocates Complaints Commission.
Advocate/Respondent’s Submissions
34 The Advocate/Client submitted on two issues: whether the Reference Application is time barred; and whether the Reference Application has merit.
35 On the first issue, the Respondent urged the Court to find that the reference was filed out of time and that the Court is therefore without jurisdiction to entertain it.
36 The Respondent placed reliance on Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors [1969] EA 696 to contend that limitation is a pure point of law capable of disposing of the matter, the Court having held that a preliminary objection "consists of a point of law which has been pleaded, or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit. Examples are an objection to the jurisdiction of the court or a plea of limitation..."
37 The Respondent anchored its objection on Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, which provides in part that "(1) Should any party object to the decision of the taxing officer, he may within fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation to which he objects. (2) The taxing officer shall forthwith record and forward to the objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a judge by chamber summons..." and under subparagraph (4) empowers the Court, in its discretion, to enlarge the time fixed under subparagraphs (1) and (2) "notwithstanding that the time sought to be enlarged may have already expired."
38 It is the Respondent’s submission that the fourteen days ran from delivery of the ruling of 22nd May 2026, and that since the reasons for the Taxing Officer's award were contained in the ruling itself, which the Applicant had in hand, there was no need to call for reasons, a step the Respondent termed absurd.
39 The Respondent therefore submitted that the Applicant's letter of 2nd June 2026 could not stop time running, and that by filing the reference on 17th June 2026, some 27 days after the ruling, without ever seeking enlargement of time under Paragraph 11(4), the Applicant was out of time and his application is an abuse of the court process.
40 To fortify this position, the Respondent relied on Chaudhri & Associates v Lady Lori (Kenya) Limited [2025] KEELRC 1490 (KLR), where the Court, citing Vincent Kibiwott Rono v Abraham Kiprotich Chebet & another [2022] eKLR, held that "where a ruling by a Taxing Officer contains adequate reasons for taxation on contested items, there is no need to seek for further reasons."
41 The Respondent further drawing on Agarwal v Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd [2019] eKLR and Republic v The Taxing Master of the High Court of Kenya [2018] eKLR, affirmed that the time limits for references are mandatory and late references ought to be dismissed unless exceptional reasons for the delay are shown. It also relied on Mauwa & Co Advocates v JRS Group Limited, ELRC Misc. Civil Application No. E075 of 2021, where a reference was dismissed because "It was filed after the lapse of the 14 days without any leave." The Respondent argued that, like in those cases, no reason has been advanced for the delay herein.
42 On the second issue, it is the Respondent's submission that the application, being one for review, must meet the threshold in Rule 33(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Rules, which permits review "(a) if there is discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the knowledge of that person or could not be produced by that person at the time when the decree was passed or the order made; (b) on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; (c) if the judgment or ruling requires clarification; or (d) for any other sufficient reason."
43 It argued that the Applicant has shown neither new evidence, nor an error apparent on the face of the record, nor any sufficient reason touching on specific aspects of the ruling, and that the application therefore fails on every limb of the Rule.
44 The Respondent further argued that the very complaint at the heart of the application, the withheld funds, was adequately addressed by the Taxing Officer, who credited the sum held and found that it is the Applicant who owes the firm Kshs. 308,189.90.
45 It submitted that this Court's ruling of 20th April 2026 was fully complied with, as demonstrated by the reduction of the taxed costs from Kshs. 2,950,500 to Kshs. 1,258,689.90, and that the firm is not withholding any money due to the Applicant since what it holds forms part of the fees owed.
46 It is the Respondent’s submission that the Applicant has failed to show that the Taxing Officer erred in principle, which demonstrates that the application is brought in bad faith to deny the Respondent its fees.
47 Reliance was placed on Bruce Odeny & Co. Advocate v Scottish Tartan Hotel Ltd & another [2023] KEELRC 564 (KLR), where a reference was dismissed because the respondents "have not demonstrated that in exercising her discretion while taxing-off each of the items, the Taxing Officer did not apply her mind correctly to the applicable principles."
48 In conclusion, the Respondent urged the Court to dismiss the application with costs on the grounds that it is time barred and the Court is consequently bereft of jurisdiction, and that in any event the Taxing Officer gave reasons in his ruling for arriving at the taxed sum of Kshs. 1,258,689.90, so as to pave the way for execution for the balance of the taxed costs.
49 I have examined all the averments and submission of the parties herein. The applicant seeks orders for review and variation of taxing officer’s ruling dated 22/5/26 by ordering a set off of the taxed costs of kshs 308,189.90/- against the sum of kshs 1,428,229/- unlawfuly withheld by the respondent’s counsel. They also seek that upon set off that the respondent’s counsel be ordered to immediately refund the net balance of kshs 1,120,039.10 to the applicant herein.
50 It is indeed trite law that courts will generally be hesitant to interfere with the exercise of a taxing officer’s discretion unless it is shown that he acted on wrong principles and left out of consideration matters which he ought to have considered….”
51 The respondents urged court to ignore this reference since it is time barred and is not merited. The respondents put reliance on para 11 of the Advocates remuneration order which is cited within this ruling and which envisages that an objection to a decision of taxing officer should be made within 14 days to the taxing officer and the taxing officer is then required to record and forward to the objector reasons for the decision on these items. Reference to the judgment is made after the above process is done.
52 The respondents submitted that the time runs from the time the decision was rendered on 22/5/2026 and that the reference was filed late 27 days later without seeking enlargement of time. They contend that this reference was filed late and should not be considered. They also aver that the disputed account was considered by the taxing officer.
53 It is indeed true that the applicant approached this court with this application on 17/6/2026 after a ruling of the taxing master on 22/5/2026 which was late in time given the provisions of para 11 of the advocates Remuneration order.
54 That notwithstanding, I do not consider the delay inordinate and which would be fatal to the application. It is however important that this reference be remitted once more to the taxing master to consider any omissions if any and consider the issues raised by the applicant herein.
55 I therefore refer this mater Hon. Nyamora DR to review his own ruling upon considering the sentiments of the parties. There shall be stay orders of execution in the meantime pending further directions from the taxing master.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 29th Day of October 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE