Employment law

Issar v Prime Steel Mill Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14805 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E146 of 2019
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Respondent has filed the application dated 13th November 2026 seeking to: review, vary, vacate and or set aside the court’s judgment which was delivered on 25th October 2025; stay execution of the judgment; and to allow a change of lawyers.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The first issue for consideration is whether I should grant the advocates who have lodged the motion for review leave to come on record in place of lawyers who are on record for the Respondent in the cause. The law that governs this request is encapsulated in Order 9 rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides as follows:-

Paragraph 7 →

Reasoning passage

In any event, the court finds that the instant application, in so far as it purports to invite the court to re-evaluate various pieces of evidence in order to arrive at a different finding, does not qualify to be a motion for review.

Paragraph 25 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO E146 OF 2019

ARTI ISSAR……………………….....…………………………….CLAIMANT

VERSUS

PRIME STEEL MILL LIMITED……………………………...RESPONDENT

RULING

Background

1. The Respondent has filed the application dated 13th November 2026 seeking to: review, vary, vacate and or set aside the court’s judgment which was delivered on 25th October 2025; stay execution of the judgment; and to allow a change of lawyers.

2. The application is based on the grounds which are set out on the face thereof. It is also supported by the affidavit of one Ravi Gada.

3. The Respondent alleges that:-

a) There is an error on the face of the record which warrants review of the judgment.

b) That the court erred in holding that the Respondent was laboring under a false belief that the Claimant was still on probation when the Claimant had in fact admitted that the contract between the parties had a probationary term.

c) That the court failed to consider material evidence including internal evaluation reports, minutes and documents showing that the Claimant had persistent performance concerns in respect of which he had been issued with several warnings.

d) That the court failed to appreciate that the decision to terminate the Claimant’s employment was based on valid operational and performance concerns.

e) That the court erred in closing the Respondent’s case whilst the Respondent’s witness was waiting in the lobby to be let in.

f) That the court misconstrued the end date for the Claimant’s probationary term.

g) That the court disregarded evidence showing that the Claimant was paid terminal dues in full and that she signed a clearance certificate without protest.

h) That the court disregarded evidence showing that the Respondent held a probationary performance review meeting for the Claimant on 25th May 2018 during which her performance was discussed and she was afforded an opportunity to be heard.

i) That the court failed to appreciate that termination of the Claimant’s contract of service was lawful and in compliance with section 43 of the Employment Act.

j) That the Respondent had genuine reasons to terminate the contract between the parties.

k) That the court failed to give proper weight to the fact that the Claimant signed a ‘’no claim certificate’’ thus discharging the Respondent from liability.

l) That there was a serious threat to execute the impugned judgment thus justifying the prayer for stay of execution.

m) That the award of compensation in the judgment is excessive, punitive and not supported by evidence.

4. The Claimant has opposed the application. She contends that the application is without merit.

5. The Claimant contends that the advocates who have filed the application are not properly on record as they have not obtained leave to come on record in place of the advocates currently on record for the Respondent. Further, she contends that the court is not, in any event, entitled to grant such leave since the said advocates have not demonstrated that they served the application for leave on the lawyers who are currently on record for the Respondent.

6. The Claimant avers that the instant application for review is bad in law as it is an appeal disguised as a review motion. She asserts that what the Respondent has done is to essentially ask the court to sit on appeal judgment on its decision, a matter which the law does not permit.

Analysis

7. The first issue for consideration is whether I should grant the advocates who have lodged the motion for review leave to come on record in place of lawyers who are on record for the Respondent in the cause. The law that governs this request is encapsulated in Order 9 rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides as follows:-

‘’When there is a change of advocate, or when a party decides to act in person having previously engaged an advocate, after judgment has been passed, such change or intention to act in person shall not be effected without an order of the court:-

a) upon an application with notice to all the parties; or

b) upon a consent filed between the outgoing advocate and the proposed incoming advocate or party intending to act in person as the case may be.’’

8. That provision is clear in tenor. A change of advocates after judgment can only be validated by a court order. The order may issue either upon the application of the party seeking to change representation or upon consent of the outgoing and incoming lawyers.

9. Where the party seeking to change lawyers requests for leave to do so through an application, he must serve the application on all the parties including the outgoing lawyers. As such, the request cannot be granted without proof of service of the application on the outgoing lawyers.

10. In this case, the Claimant contends that the application for leave should not be granted because the Respondent has not tendered evidence to demonstrate that it served the application on the lawyers who are sought to be replaced. The court has scrutinized the record and noted that indeed there is no affidavit of service to confirm service of the application on the lawyers sought to be replaced.

11. Absent this evidence, the court cannot grant the impugned motion. The consequence of declining to grant leave to the new lawyers to come on record for the Respondent is that the rest of the prayers in the application inevitably fail because the law prohibits the court from granting any other prayers before the request for leave to change lawyers is granted.

12. The foregoing is self-evident from Order 9 rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules which states as follows:-

‘’An application under rule 9 may be combined with other prayers provided the question of change of advocate or party intending to act in person shall be determined first.’’

13. However, even assuming that the lawyers who have moved the court for review were properly on record, it is doubtful that the instant request for review of the court’s judgment would have succeeded on the merits. This is because the application is essentially an appeal disguised as a motion for review.

14. The issues which the Respondent raises in the application which include: whether the trial Judge erred by failing to take into account various pieces of evidence regarding the probationary term for the Claimant; whether the trial Judge erred by failing to appreciate that the Claimant voluntarily executed a ‘’no claims certificate’’ thus discharging the Respondent from liability; whether the trial Judge erred in failing to give due weight to the Respondent’s evidence; whether the trial Judge erred by failing to properly compute the probationary term for the Claimant; whether the trial Judge erred in finding that the Respondent was operating under a mistaken belief that the Claimant was still under probation when his contract was terminated; whether the trial Judge disregarded evidence which shows that the Claimant’s contract of service was properly terminated on account of poor performance; whether the trial Judge disregarded evidence which shows that the Claimant was granted an opportunity to be heard at a meeting held on 25th May 2018; and whether the award by the trial Judge is excessive, unwarranted and unsupported by evidence all question the merits of the trial Judge’s decision. They, by no stretch of imagination, can be said to disclose an error on the face of the record to warrant an application for review.

15. As such, the Respondent ought to have raised these matters in an appeal to the relevant court and not by way of an application for review to this court. To ask the court to reconsider these matters is tantamount to asking it to sit on appeal on a decision of a Judge of concurrent jurisdiction, a matter which the law does not permit.

16. Speaking to this reality in the case of Abasi Belinda vs Fredrick Kangwamu and another {1963} E.A 557, the court stated as follows:-

‘’a point which may be a good ground of appeal may not be a good ground for review and an erroneous view of evidence or law is not a ground for review though it may be a good ground for appeal.’’

17. In Adrian Kamotho Njenga v Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Information, Communication and Technology & 8 others [2017] KEHC 9246 (KLR), the learned Judge observed on the subject as follows:-

‘’ I emphasize that review proceedings are not an appeal. The review must be confined to error apparent on the face of the record and re-appraisal of the entire evidence or how the judge applied or interpreted the law would amount to exercise of Appellate Jurisdiction, which is not permissible.’’

18. In Devkan Enterprises Limited v Muthondeki [2026] KEHC 2240 (KLR), the court expressed itself on the subject as follows:-

‘’ What constitutes an error apparent on the face of the record is not novel. It has been a subject of many cases and the courts have been firm in defining the boundaries of review based on the said ground. The courts have consistently held that an error apparent on the face of the record is that which is too obvious that it does not need to attract any deep or broad legal arguments or evaluations. It may be a slip of the pen, misdescription of an obvious issue or that involving correction of a refraction to align with the court’s mind. It cannot extend to issues which go to the Judge’s interpretation of the law or the position the court has taken on a certain issue.’’ Emphasis added by underlining.

19. What I understand the Respondent to be stating is that the trial Judge misapprehended the import of the evidence on record on the various issues it has flagged. As such, it is asking this court to revisit the case with a view to re-evaluating the evidence and rendering a fresh decision. That cannot be said to be an application for review. It is an appeal disguised as a request for review which is impermissible.

20. The Respondent also alleges that the court improperly closed the defense case without hearing the defense witness. It alleges that at the time the defense case was closed, the defense witness was waiting to be admitted into the virtual court.

21. However, the court record paints a different picture. From the record, it is apparent that the Respondent was given a myriad opportunities to present the defense case but did not utilize them.

22. On the day the defense case was closed, the record shows that the court went out of its way to accommodate the defense by delaying commencement of the trial but the defense witness did not show up. And hence the decision to close the case. As such, the contention that the defense witness was denied an opportunity to present his testimony is misleading and is rejected.

Determination

23. The upshot is that the court declines to grant the request for leave to replace counsel on record for the Respondent for want of service of the application dated 13th November 2026 on the lawyers who are sought to be replaced.

24. The request for leave to replace counsel having been declined, the rest of the prayers in the application also fail.

25. In any event, the court finds that the instant application, in so far as it purports to invite the court to re-evaluate various pieces of evidence in order to arrive at a different finding, does not qualify to be a motion for review.

26. Rather, it is an appeal disguised as a motion for review.

27. In the premises, the application is bad in law and is accordingly dismissed.

28. Costs of the application are granted to the Claimant.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Claimant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder