Background
The Claimant is a member of the 1st Respondent. She contends that she was elected sometime in May 2021 to serve as the 1st Respondent’s National Deputy Treasurer.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Claimant is a member of the 1st Respondent. She contends that she was elected sometime in May 2021 to serve as the 1st Respondent’s National Deputy Treasurer.
Paragraph 1 →Having regard to the foregoing, the court finds that it has jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
Paragraph 22 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO E912 OF 2025
DR. ANBAR GANATRA………………………………………....CLAIMANT
VERSUS
KENYA MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS, PHARMACISTS AND DENTISTS UNION………..………………………………1ST RESPONDENT
DAVJI ATELLA...................................................................2ND RESPONDENT
RULING
Background
1. The Claimant is a member of the 1st Respondent. She contends that she was elected sometime in May 2021 to serve as the 1st Respondent’s National Deputy Treasurer.
2. The Claimant avers that the parties agreed that she will be paid Ksh. 300,000.00 per month for her services in the aforesaid position. However, she alleges that the payments were erratic.
3. The Claimant contends that she moved to Australia in 2023 but continued to serve the 1st Respondent as its National Deputy Treasurer. She alleges that before her relocation, she asked the 1st Respondent to settle her outstanding fees. However, she asserts that the 1st Respondent did not pay her the dues. Instead, she alleges that the 1st Respondent stated that she had to move back to Kenya for the dues to be paid.
4. The Claimant asserts that the 1st Respondent’s reaction was not only unreasonable but discriminatory. It is her case that she was subjected to the aforesaid treatment on account of her race. As such, she prays for the various reliefs which are set out in the Statement of Claim.
5. The Respondents have opposed the suit. They deny that the Claimant was an employee of the 1st Respondent. It is their case that the Claimant served the 1st Respondent as a volunteer and was not entitled to pay.
6. The Respondents further contend that when the Claimant relocated to Australia, she stopped discharging her duties as the 1st Respondent’s National Deputy Treasurer. They allege that she stepped down from her aforesaid role.
7. The Respondents also challenge the court’s jurisdiction to entertain the dispute. They contend that the Claimant ought to have exhausted the dispute resolution avenues provided in the 1st Respondent’s Constitution before she approached the court.
8. The Respondents have accordingly raised a preliminary objection to the suit. It is that objection which is the subject of this ruling.
Analysis
9. The court has considered the peculiar nature of this dispute in the context of section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and come to the conclusion that it has jurisdiction over the matter. The parties to the action are in agreement that the 1st Respondent is a registered trade union and that the Claimant is its (the 1st Respondent’s) member. Hence her appointment to serve as the 1st Respondent’s Deputy National Treasurer.
10. Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act grants this court jurisdiction to entertain, inter alia, disputes between a trade union and its members. Accordingly, the dispute between the Claimant and the 1st Respondent, being a dispute between a member of a trade union and the trade union, falls within the jurisdiction of the court.
11. That said, the Respondents’ objection to the court’s jurisdiction to entertain the case is anchored on an entirely different standpoint from the one considered above. The Respondents’ case is that the court lacks jurisdiction over the suit because of the Claimant’s failure to exhaust the available alternative dispute resolution mechanisms.
12. The Respondents’ objection is anchored on article VIII (B) of the 1st Respondent’s Constitution. The article sets up a Standing Committee to handle disputes between the 1st Respondent and its members.
13. In response to the objection, the Claimant asserts that because her case raises grievances which, inter alia, relate to alleged violation of her constitutional rights, it is this court and not the 1st Respondent’s Standing Committee which should hear the matter. She contends that the Standing Committee has no power to adjudicate on constitutional issues.
14. Rule 56 (5) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 contemplates a scenario where a party who is required to present his grievance to an alternative dispute resolution forum may nevertheless approach the court with the dispute. As a matter of fact, rule 56 (5) (b) thereof appears to state that a suit alleging violation of constitutional provisions may not be defeated for want of exhaustion of alternative dispute resolution processes.
15. Section 9 of the Fair Administrative Action Act recognizes that a person who has an alternative avenue for resolving a grievance may still approach the court for resolution of the grievance. However, the provision discourages courts from adjudicating on such dispute until the available dispute resolution mechanisms have been exhausted.
16. What emerges from the foregoing is that the availability of an alternative dispute resolution procedure does not extinguish a court’s jurisdiction to entertain a matter. It only postpones such jurisdiction. And hence the requirement under rule 56 (5) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules that such suit may only be stayed as opposed to being struck out.
17. This analysis should provide a conclusive answer to the Respondents’ preliminary objection. This court has jurisdiction to entertain the instant suit. The jurisdiction can only be said to be postponed as opposed to being nonexistent. As such, the court can only, where appropriate, stay the suit to enable exhaustion of the available alternative dispute resolution processes as opposed to striking it out.
18. The Claimant on the other hand has argued that because the suit raises a constitutional grievance, it cannot be referred to an alternative dispute resolution forum because only a court of law has the mandate to determine constitutional questions. The position which the Claimant expresses appears to find support in judicial precedent.
19. In Bia Tosha Distributors Limited vs Kenya Breweries Limited & 6 others SC Pet 15 of 2020, the Supreme Court appears to have expressed the view that alternative dispute resolution forums such as arbitration are not seized of jurisdiction to adjudicate on constitutional questions. The court expressed itself on the subject as follows:-
‘’Breaches, violations and infringements of the Constitution do not fall within the jurisdiction of arbitrators……The mandate of an arbitrator largely proceeds on the basis of the agreement by parties, and is mainly tasked with the resolution of a dispute as set out in the governing agreement. Where the dispute, however, transcends the commercial dispute, well into the constitutional sphere, as is the case before us, every person is free to access courts and have their day in court. As we see it, there is no tension between arbitration and enforcement of constitutional rights as distinct dispute resolution mechanisms. A court of law cannot turn a blind eye to alleged constitutional breaches in order to invoke the principle of party autonomy that binds parties to their agreements. This in itself does not mean that any person who sets out to petition the court alleging violation of fundamental rights and freedoms under the Bill of Rights must succeed, as cases are determined on their merits.’’
20. A perusal of the Statement of Claim demonstrates that the Claimant has raised grievances relating to violation of her constitutional rights to non-discrimination, human dignity, equality and fair labour practices. This is self-evident at paragraph 8 of the aforesaid pleading. It is also reflected in some of her prayers.
21. The constitutional claims need not succeed for the claim to be said to have raised constitutional grievances. As was observed by the Supreme Court in the aforesaid decision, whether or not the claim will succeed is a different matter altogether which turns on the evidence which will be presented.
Determination
22. Having regard to the foregoing, the court finds that it has jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
23. The court further finds that since the suit raises issues concerning violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights, the matter is not suitable for adjudication through the alternative dispute resolution mechanism provided in the 1st Respondent’s Constitution.
24. As such, the suit will be determined by the court.
25. The upshot is that the Respondents’ preliminary objection fails.
26. Costs of the objection shall abide the outcome of the suit.
Dated, signed and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026
B. O. M. MANANI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
…………….for the Claimant
…………….for the Respondent
ORDER
In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.
B. O. M MANANI